Full Order Text
Interim Order 6 · 29 Jan 2026 · CNR DLNT030011492025
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: CS SCJ No.731/2025 Rajender Prasad Gupta Vs. Poonam Page No. 1 of 7 IN THE COURT OF SH. NITISH KUMAR SHARMA, JSCC/ASCJ/GUDN. JUDGE, NORTH DISTRICT, ROHINI COURTS, DELHI CNR NO.DLNT030011492025 CS SCJ No. 731/2025 RAJENDER PRASAD GUPTA ….........Plaintiff Versus POONAM ............Defendant ORDER 29.01.2026 By this order, the court shall dispose off application U/o 12 Rule 6 CPC moved on behalf of plaintiff. 1. By virtue of present application, the plaintiff has stated that the present suit has been filed against the defendant in respect of tenanted suit property i.e. House No. G-23, Second Floor, Mahendra Park, Village Sarai Peepal Thala, Delhi- 33 which was let out to defendant on monthly rent of Rs. 16,000/- for a period of eleven months starting from 25.04.2023 which was again let out for eleven months on 26.06.2024 for a period of eleven months. 2. It is further stated that defendant has admitted in the written statement as well as in the statement recorded before the court u/section 168 BSA, 2023 that she was the tenant of the plaintiff in the suit property and was paying monthly rent Rs. 16,250/- per month exclusive of electricity -- 1 of 7 -- CS SCJ No.731/2025 Rajender Prasad Gupta Vs. Poonam Page No. 2 of 7 and water charges and has also admitted that the notice of the court was received by her on 24.07.2025. It is stated that defendant has taken the stand in the written statement that the plaintiff has not filed the sale deed of suit property on the record and the documents in favour of plaintiff, do not confer any title on the suit property and further taken the stand that an amount of Rs. 20 lacs was given to the plaintiff without interest in cash which was to be returned by the plaintiff within a period of twelve months but the plaintiff has not returned the same. 3. By way of present application, the plaintiff has prayed that the suit of the plaintiff be decreed. 4. Reply has been filed on behalf of defendant, wherein it is stated that the defendant has not made any admission in the pleadings or otherwise which would entitle the plaintiff to a judgment on admission. 5. It is further stated that the plaintiff has not shown his ownership over the suit property and is not entitled to any relief. 6. Prayer is made for dismissal of application. 7. I have heard arguments advanced by Ld. counsels for parties and perused the record carefully. 8. At the outset, it is to be seen that it is not in dispute that rent agreement was executed between plaintiff and -- 2 of 7 -- CS SCJ No.731/2025 Rajender Prasad Gupta Vs. Poonam Page No. 3 of 7 the defendant. The defendant has taken a plea that an amount of Rs. 20 lacs was given in cash to plaintiff in April, 2023 by way of loan and which has not been returned by the plaintiff. It is further pleaded that the plaintiff has not filed on record his ownership documents regarding the suit property. 9. It is not the case of the defendant that no rent deed was executed rather it is argued that the plaintiff could not have executed the same as he was not the owner of the same. It is settled position of law that a person need not be owner of a property for being a landlord of the same. 10. Further, Section 116 of the Indian Evidence Act provides that : “ No tenant of immovable property, or person claiming through such tenant, shall during the continuance of the tenancy be permitted to deny that the landlord of such tenant had, at the beginning of the tenancy, a title to such immovable property, and no person who came upon any immovable property by the licensee of the person in possession thereof, shall be permitted to deny that such person had a title to such possession at the time when such licensee was given.” 11. As per Section 108 (q) of TPA, a lessee is under obligation to vacate the tenanted property and hand over the possession to landlord/lessor on termination of tenancy. -- 3 of 7 -- CS SCJ No.731/2025 Rajender Prasad Gupta Vs. Poonam Page No. 4 of 7 12. While referring to provisions u/o XII Rule 6 CPC, it has been held by Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case titled as Kapahi and Others vs. Lal Chand Public Charitable Trust and Another, (2010) 4 SCC 753 that :- “In the 54th Law Commission Report, an amendment was suggested to enable the Court to give a judgment not only on the application of a party but on its own motion. It is thus clear that the amendment was brought about to further the ends of justice and give these provisions a wider sweep by empowering judges to use it `ex debito justitiae, a Latin term, meaning a debt of justice. In our opinion the thrust of the amendment is that in an appropriate case, a party, on the admission of the other party, can press for judgment, as a matter of legal right. However, the Court always retains its discretion in the matter of pronouncing judgment. 13. It has been further held by Hon'ble Delhi High Court in the case titled as Delhi Jal Board vs Surendra P. Malik 104 (2003) DLT 151 (DB) that the only pre requisite for passing a decree under Order 12 Rule 6 CPC is that there must be admission of fact arising in the suit, be that in the pleadings or otherwise or orally or in writing and that the admissions must be clear and unequivocal, unconditional and unambiguous. Further, the admissions need not be made specifically or expressly and could be a constructive admission as well. So it is not required in law that admission only has to be in the pleadings. 14. Furthermore in a recent case titled as Keshav Chander Thakur & Anr. Vs. Krishan Chander & Ors. 211 -- 4 of 7 -- CS SCJ No.731/2025 Rajender Prasad Gupta Vs. Poonam Page No. 5 of 7 (2014) DLT 149 (DB), it was similarly held by Hon'ble Delhi High Court that :- "However, in our view given the nature of pleadings and admitted documents on record and the extensive arguments advanced by the parties on the issues discussed herein, this was a fit case for the Court to exercise powers under Order XII Rule 6 CPC where the Court has powers to suo moto pass a judgment. There is no requirement in Order XII Rule 6 CPC for filing of a formal application. The Court can on its own motion without any application by a party proceed to pass a decree on admissions as stated in Order XII Rule 6 CPC." 15. The major issue in the present application is that the defendant's claim is that the plaintiff was not the owner of the property and that the defendant had given a loan of Rs. 20 lacs in cash to the plaintiff which has not been returned by plaintiff. 16. In the facts and circumstances of this case, I am of the considered opinion that the stance taken by the defendant does not help him for the reasons that the claim of the defendant is that there is no unequivocal admission on her part, however, the said contention is without any merits, as defendant in her examination u/section 168 BSA, 2023, has categorically stated that the plaintiff was the landlord qua the suit property and that a rent agreement was executed for a period of eleven months on 26.06.2024. As regards advancing of loan by the defendant to the plaintiff, it is no gainsay that the defendant can avail her remedies to recover the same as per law but can not insist to stay in the suit property till the time the -- 5 of 7 -- CS SCJ No.731/2025 Rajender Prasad Gupta Vs. Poonam Page No. 6 of 7 said amount is re-paid. Reliance placed on H.S. Bedi Vs. National Highway Authority of India, 220 (2015) DLT 179. 17. Thus, in the present scenario the defendant cannot deny that the plaintiff was his landlord. The argument of the Ld. Counsel for defendant that the legal notice did not terminate the tenancy is also not tenable. In this regard, I am keeping in view the amendment brought about to Section 106 of TPA by Act 3 of 2003 and as per which amendment no objection with regard to termination of tenancy is permitted on the ground that legal notice did not validly terminate the tenancy, as long as a period of 15 days was otherwise given to the tenant to vacate. The intention of the legislature is therefore clear that technical objections should not be permitted to defeat substantial justice. 18. Thus, considering the matter from overall perspective it has to be held that defendant was a tenant of plaintiff in the suit property on a monthly rent of Rs 16,000/- and the said tenancy has been duly terminated. 19. Accordingly, the application of plaintiffs stands partly allowed qua the relief of possession & injunction. The plaintiff has also sought relief of mesne profits at the rate of Rs. 26,000/- per month from 25.05.2025 and the said relief can not be granted without any evidence qua the same. 20. The suit of the plaintiff is thus partly decreed in the following terms: -- 6 of 7 -- CS SCJ No.731/2025 Rajender Prasad Gupta Vs. Poonam Page No. 7 of 7 (a) Defendant is hereby directed to vacate the suit property i.e. House No. G-23, Second Floor, Mahendra Park, Village Sarai Peepal Thala, Delhi- 33 within fifteen days from today. (b) The defendant is also restrained from creating any third party interest or assigning the possession to any third person, of the suit property i.e. House No. G-23, Second Floor, Mahendra Park, Village Sarai Peepal Thala, Delhi- 33. 21. Decree sheet be prepared accordingly. 22. As regards the other reliefs, the following issue(s) are framed for trial : (a) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to recover Rs. 26,000/- per month as mesne profits from the defendant for the period starting from 25.05.2025 till handing over of possession of suit property? OPP. (b) Whether the defendant had granted any loan of Rs. 20 lacs to the plaintiff and which amount was agreed to be adjusted against the overstay of defendant in the suit property? OPD. (c) Relief. Parties are directed to file list of witnesses within fifteen days from today. The plaintiff is directed to file affidavit of its witnesses with advance copy to the opposite party. Be put up for PE on 14.05.2026. Pronounced in the open court today on 29.01.2026 (Nitish Kumar Sharma) JSCC/ASCJ/GUDN. JUDGE North Rohini, Courts,Delhi/29.01.2026 -- 7 of 7 --
