Full Order Text
Interim Order 12 · 18 Jul 2025 · CNR DLNT030008152023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: EX NO. 216/23 BABITA DEVI VS. REGIONAL DIRECTOR & ANR. 18.07.2025. ORDER ON OBJECTIONS FILED BY JD-1 1. Vide this order, this court shall adjudicate the objections filed on behalf of JD-1 i.e. ESIC. I have heard the submissions at length from all the parties and also gone through the record carefully. 2. As per the Decree sheet, the JD-2/Rajesh Kumar Gupta has been directed to give compensation of Rs. 5 Lakh to the DH. The JD-2 has been directed to complete all the formalities for the compensation as well as pension and other debt benefits under the ESI Act to the DH, if any remaining. The JD-1/ESIC has been directed to fix the compensation amount as well as pension amount and to pay the same to the DH, as per rules. 3. To this execution petition, the JD-1/ESIC filed objections on 18.04.2024, almost one year after the institution of the petition. JD-1/ESIC has taken the following objections:- 1) The decree is not executable as the same is barred under Section 75 (3) of The ESIC Act; 2) The awarded amount of Rs. 5 Lakhs is against the JD-2; 3) The deceased has not died due to employment injuries; 4) The formalities for release of pension has not been completed by JD-2; ________________________________________________________________ EX No. 216-23 Babita Devi Vs. Regional Director & Anr. Page 1 of 3 -- 1 of 3 -- 4. The JD-1/ESIC participated in the trial and also filed the written statement and advanced arguments. The objection regarding the Section 5(3) of ESIC Act was never taken before the trial court. Section 21 of CPC squarely covers the situation and provides that no objection regarding jurisdiction or competence of court, shall be allowed until and unless such objection was taken in the court of first instance. Accordingly, this objection is not sustainable in the eyes of law. 5. It is settled law that the executing court cannot go beyond the decree and it has to enforce the decree as it is. As per Section 47 of The CPC, the other objections raised by JD-1/ESIC go beyond the decree, passed by the court. In the case Sanwar Lal Aggarwal & Ors. Vs. Ashok Kumar Kothari & Ors., CA No(S) 1312-1313 of 2023, decided on 21.02.2023, the Hon'ble Scupreme Court held that the executing court has to execute the decree as it is. 6. In view of the detailed discussion above, the objections filed by JD-1/ESIC are held to be devoid of merits and are dismissed with costs of Rs. 3000/- to be paid by JD-1/ESIC to the DH within two weeks from today. 7. JD-2 is also not complying with the decree. Issue warrants of attachment against JD-1 & JD-2 Warrants of attachment of movable property be issued afresh against the JD as per list attached on filing of PF, as per rules. DH is directed to appear for appointment of Bailiff on 29.08.2025 before Ld. ACJ and to Report before this Court on 31.10.2025. ________________________________________________________________ EX No. 216-23 Babita Devi Vs. Regional Director & Anr. Page 2 of 3 -- 2 of 3 -- 8. DH is also directed to file an affidavit stating therein that there is no stay on the execution petition alongwith the PF, if not filed earlier. The affidavit be filed one week prior to the issuance of warrant of attachment. (Himanshu Raman Singh) SCJ/RC/North Rohini Court/18.07.2025 ________________________________________________________________ EX No. 216-23 Babita Devi Vs. Regional Director & Anr. Page 3 of 3 -- 3 of 3 --
