Full Order Text
Order 3 · 05 May 2026 · CNR DLNT030007542026
Order Details: COPY OF JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS Pdf Text: 12 CS SCJ 509/26 ANAND PRAKASH NAGPAL Vs. AJAY BHARDWAJ 05.05.2026 Present: Sh. Rajiv Tehlan Ld. Counsel for plaintiff with plaintiff in person. Sh. Rahul Sharma Ld. Counsel for defendant no.1. Sh. Kapil Jain Ld. Counsel for defendant no.2 and 3. Sh. Sunil Kumar Ld. Counsel for defendant no.4/ MCD. Today, it has been apprised that the matter is pending before the mediation center for tomorrow. However, it is stated that chances of settlement are bleak. An application U/o 10 rule 2 CPC has been made on behalf of plaintiff. On being inquired, as to how the said application is maintainable as the said rule pertains to the power/discretion of the court to examine any party, Ld. Counsel for the plaintiff has sought permission to withdraw the same. The said application is accordingly dismissed as withdrawn. Another application U/s 151 CPC has been made by plaintiff seeking stay of unauthorised construction of the entire property of defendant no.1. This application, in the considered opinion of this court, seeks to remedy a cause which should be done by way of a separate suit. The application is seeking to redress something beyond the scope of the suit and is accordingly dismissed. -- 1 of 3 -- At this stage, the plaintiff seeks a direction for maintaining status quo. Essentially, it is sought that defendant No. 1 be restrained from opening a door towards the gali in question till the next date of hearing, as it is asserted that the said gali is being exclusively used by the plaintiff. It is pertinent to mention that the plaintiff has relied upon a mutual agreement dated 23.12.2012. Prima facie, the said document is unregistered and no material has been placed on record to establish any exclusive right of the plaintiff over the gali which has been left out for the access by the predecessor of defendant no.2 and 3. It is also not in dispute that both parties have alternate access to their respective properties. Even if the said agreement dated 23.12.2012 is taken into consideration, stipulating that upon sale of the property by defendant no.2 and3, the door shall be closed and the gali shall be for the exclusive use of the plaintiff, the same, being unregistered, does not prima facie confer any enforceable right in immovable property. Further, an easement by prescription requires clear proof of open, continuous, peaceful and as-of-right user for a period of 20 years. It is suffice to state that the alleged agreement is of the year 2012 and the statutory period is not even shown to have elapsed. As regards the contention that in the absence of interim protection the suit would be rendered infructuous, the same is not persuasive, as the mere opening of a door would not extinguish any alleged right of the plaintiff and can be suitably addressed at the stage of final adjudication. -- 2 of 3 -- Thus, the prayer of the plaintiff for restraining the defendant no.1 from opening gate or window in the said gali is rejected. However, it is deemed necessary and fit in the circumstances of the case that directions given on the last date of hearing should remain in force till NDOH. For the sake of clarity, it is re-affirmed that the defendant no.1 has been directed to not raise any construction in the passage as shown in red colour in the site plan and to not install any gate on the entrance of the said passage till NDOH. Defendant no.1 is further directed not to store any construction material in the said passage till the NDOH. In the event of no settlement, the case shall be heard on the interim application u/o 39 rule 1 and 2 CPC on 14.05.2026. (Nitish Kumar Sharma) JSCC/ASCJ/GUDN. JUDGE North, Rohini Courts,Delhi/05.05.2026 -- 3 of 3 --
