Full Order Text
Order 4 · 24 Apr 2025 · CNR DLNT030005272025
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: CS SCJ 347/25 NARESH KUMAR Vs. ANAND AND OTHERS 24.04.2025 1. Vide present order I shall dispose off application moved by plaintiff for temporary injunction against defendants. 2. It is submitted by Ld. Counsel for plaintiff that plaintiff is owner of 1/3rd share in property bearing khasra no. 507, Rukva (4-03), 460 (7-8) village Mo- hammadpur, Ramzanpur, Delhi. It is submitted that defendants are doing illegal construction over the suit property by raising a wall by which they are trying to close the passage leading from property of plaintiff to main gali. It is submitted that the area of passage belongs to plaintiff and is more than 30 years old. It is submitted that defendants did not stop construction despite request from plain- tiff, in fact defendants threatened the plaintiff. It is submitted that plaintiff has filed police complaint also. The plaintiff has sought temporary injunction against defendants thereby restraining them be from raising construction and re- moval of illegal construction. 3. Per contra Ld. Counsel for defendant no. 1 and 2 has argued that plaint is silent regarding title and possession of suit property i.e., area of passage. It is ar- gued that for the purpose of injunction the plaintiff must show his possession, however, plaintiff has not placed on record any documents to this effect. It is ar- gued that area of passage is not actually a passage, this alleged passage is part of the area under occupation of defendant no. 1 and 2. It is argued that no new con- CS SCJ 347/25 NARESH KUMAR Vs. ANAND AND OTHERS Page 1 of 4 -- 1 of 4 -- struction has been done or going on, on the alleged passage. Ld. Counsel has placed on record photographs of the alleged passage. It is argued that upon oral partition between plaintiff and fathers of defendant no. 1, 2 and 3, all the parties came in possession of their respective share and the alleged passage fell in share of father of defendant no. 1 and 2. It is argued that present application may be dismissed as the same is not disclosing any cause of action. 4. In the case of Gujrat Bottling Co. Ltd. v. Coca Cola Co., 5 SCC 545, the Hon’ble Supreme Court, while discussing the factors to be considered by the Courts in exercise of the discretion under Order 39 Rule 1 & 2 CPC, has ob- served as follows: “The grant of an interlocutory injunction during the pendency of legal proceedings is a matter requiring the exercise of discretion of the Court. While exercising the discretion the Court applies the following tests: (i) Whether the plaintiff has a prima facie case; (ii) Whether the balance of convenience is in favour of the plaintiff; (iii) Whether the plaintiff would suffer an irreparable injury if his prayer for in- terlocutory is disallowed.” Explaining the ambit and scope of the connotation "prima facie" case, in Martin Burn Ltd. v. R.N. Banerjee, AIR 1958 SC 79, the Supreme Court observed: "A prima facie case does not mean a case proved to the hilt but a case which can be said to be established if the evidence which is led in support of the same were believed while determining whether a case is prima facie one or not, the relevant consideration is whether on the evidence led it was possible to arrive at the con- clusion in question and not whether that was the only conclusion which could be arrived at on that evidence.” In other words, the Court must be satisfied that CS SCJ 347/25 NARESH KUMAR Vs. ANAND AND OTHERS Page 2 of 4 -- 2 of 4 -- there is a bona fide dispute raised by the applicant and on the facts before it there is a probability of the applicant being entitled to the relief claimed by him. 5. The plaintiff has relied upon the order of SDM vide which the proceed- ings initiated by Gram Sabha against plaintiff for recovery of possession were dismissed, however from this order alone it can not be ascertained whether the alleged passage was in occupation and possession of plaintiff. It is submitted by Ld. Counsel for plaintiff that as per the oral partition the alleged passage was given to plaintiff, however this claim is denied by defendants. The plaintiff has no document to show the possession of alleged passage. Ld. Counsel for defen- dants has filed photographs of the suit property which are not controverted by plaintiff. In the photographs, the place of alleged gate is also shown. It can be seen that at the alleged place of gate there is a stack of bricks and one small tree in the area of plaintiff and on the same place there are bricks and other stuff ly- ing in the area under possession of defendants no.1 and 2. This court is unable to understand as to why the plaintiff has stacked bricks and is having a small tree where the gate is supposed to be as per the site plan. It is apparent that no construction is going on and the wall shown in the photographs appears to be old. The plaintiff has also filed two photographs alleging that defendants were given passage from this area, however the photographs do not show any passage or area starting from the property of plaintiff. It only shows some constructed wall and passage starting from gali outside the gate from which it can not be as- certained whether the same is part of suit property. 6. Clearly the plaintiff has failed to show a prima facie case in his favour hence there is no need to delve into other two conditions of temporary injunc- CS SCJ 347/25 NARESH KUMAR Vs. ANAND AND OTHERS Page 3 of 4 -- 3 of 4 -- tion. For the reasons stated above this court is of the opinion that plaintiff has failed to show prima facie case, hence present application stands dismissed. It is needless to say that observation made in present order shall not be viewed as ex- pression upon merits of the case. Announced in the open court on 24.04.2025. (Ajay Singh Parihar) ACJ-cum-ARC/North Rohini Court/24.04.2025 CS SCJ 347/25 NARESH KUMAR Vs. ANAND AND OTHERS Page 4 of 4 -- 4 of 4 --
