Full Order Text
Interim Order 14 · 22 Aug 2026 · CNR DLNT020109582024
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: 1 IN THE COURT OF SH. SAHIL GUPTA JUDICIAL MAGISTRATE FIRST CLASS-07,NORTH,ROHINI, DELHI. Ct. Cases 1099/2024 Sahab Singh Vs. Murslim Bashir etc PS Swaroop Nagar Present:- Ld. Counsel for the complainant. Arguments on the application u/s. 175 (3) Cr.PC & 223 CrPC have already been heard and matter is fixed for clarifications/orders, however, no clarifications are required. The entire case file including the ATR has been perused carefully. 1. In brief the facts of the case as mentioned in the applicant/ complaint are that the complainant used to work with the accused persons at M-3 builder and developers as an employee for a sum of ₹15,000/- p.m. & 1% commission on the sale of plots, but whenever the complainant demanded his dues, the accused persons would seek more time for some reason or the other. That in the year 2020, the complainant demanded the money for her daughter's marriage on 30.11.20 and the accused persons promised to gift Alto car in the marriage of the daughter of the complainant, but refused later and complainant had to take loan for the purchase of the car. That the accused persons had given many signed cheques of the complainant to the other parties who have filed cases u/s 138 NIA against the complainant, which are still pending adjudication. That at the instance of the accused persons, an amount of ₹8,50,000 was transferred by some other party in the account of the complainant on 13.01.22 and an amount of ₹8,00,000 was transferred in the account of accused no.6 on 14.01.22 from the account of the complainant and ₹50,000 were taken in cash from the complainant by accused no.3. That the accused persons have committed fraud with the complainant and other persons. The complainant filed complaint in this regard to the concerned PS and to higher police authorities, however, no action has been taken. In this matter, ATR was called from the concerned PS as per judgment of Hon'ble High Court of Delhi in matter of “Subhkaran Luharuka & Anr. Vs. State (Government of NCT of Delhi) & Anr.”, 170 (2010) which is on record. -- 1 of 3 -- 2 2. Status report filed by IO wherein it is submitted that during course of inquiry, it is found out that the complainant was working with the accused persons for almost 3 years after which they fell apart and the accused had not paid the salaries of the complainant attracting the civil court jurisdiction and the allegations related to confinement and threatening pertain to the jurisdiction of Uttar Pradesh. That as for the allegations of cheating by the accused with other persons are concerned, the allegations are general in nature. Further, that the incident mentioned in the complaint is of July 2020, but the complaint is filed after a delay of two years. 3. Perusal of the complaint and status report of the IO shows that the dispute between the parties seem to be civil in nature and the plaintiff has an alternative and appropriate civil remedy against the accused persons who have allegedly failed to make the payment to the complainant towards the salary and the commission. Further, the complainant has levelled allegations of illegal confinement and threatening, which pertains to the jurisdiction of Uttar Pradesh. Further, the component has alleged that an amount of ₹8,50,000 was transferred in the account of the complainant in the year 2022 which was later transferred in the account of the other accused person, but no complaint regarding such receipt/transfer was made by the complainant for the past two years. With this background, the filing of present application/complaint with ulterior motive cannot be ruled out and in considered opinion of this Court, no scientific investigation is required to be done by the police in the present matter, when the evidence to prove the allegations leveled by the complainant is within her reach and control. Reliance is placed by this court on the judgment delivered in case titled as “ M/s Skipper Beverages P. Ltd. vs. State”, 2002 Cr.L.J. NOC 333 (Delhi) wherein Hon’ble Delhi High Court held that Section 156 (3) Cr.P.C. empowers a Magistrate to direct police to register case and initiate investigation but this power has to be exercised judiciously and not in a mechanical manner. Those cases where allegations are not very serious and complainant herself in possession of evidence to prove allegation, there should be no need to pass order u/sec.156(3) Cr.P.C. But cases where the -- 2 of 3 -- 3 Magistrate is of the view that nature of allegation is such that complainant himself may not be in position to collect and produce evidence before court, and interest of justice demand that police should step in to help complainant, police assistant can be taken. 4. Thus, prima facie, it seems that the dispute is purely civil in nature and nothing has been brought on record which shows that alleged person has committed any cognizable offence. It seems that allegations are made to convert a civil dispute into a criminal one. Thus, application under Section 175(3) Cr. P.C. does not discloses commission of cognizable offence. In view of the above-said reasons, the application under Section 175 (3) of The Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 is hereby dismissed. A complaint under Section 223 Cr.P.C. is also filed along-with application. Complaint of complainant perused. I take cognizance of offence. Put up the matter for PSE on 06.11.2026. (SAHIL GUPTA) JMFC-07, NORTH DISTRICT, ROHINI COURT, DELHI 22.08.2026 -- 3 of 3 --
