Full Order Text
Order 16 · 07 Aug 2025 · CNR DLNT020108652023
Order Details: COPY OF JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS Pdf Text: 40Ct. Cases 1028/2023 NITIN CHOPRA Vs. PUNIT SINGHCHAUHAN00/2023 (PrashantVihar) 07.08.2025 Present: Ld. counsel for the complainant (through VC) ORDER ON SUMMONING ON THE COMPLAINT U/s 200 Cr.P.C Brief facts of the case are that accused no.1 Puneet Singh Chauhan is the resident of H No. 1210/V-786, Gali No. 8A, Vijay Park, Maujpur, Promotor Director of Sh. Radhey Techbuild Pvt Ltd. and accused no 2 Mr. Manoj Singh R/o 501, Alankar Apartment, Golf Course Road, Sector-56 Gurgaon, Haryana-122011 and the dealing person for and on behalf of the said company. That accused no.3 is the promoter and Ex- Director of said company. That they are engaged in the business of buying, selling and developing of Real Estate. That accused person approached the complainant through one person namely Mr. Parvesh for selling a big land parcel comprising of Khasra No. 2711, 2712, 2938, 2887, 2713, 637, 638, 640, 641 and 641/2 at Village Raja Khasa and Village Jhang Rada Teshil Indora District Kangra Himachal Pradesh. That complainant partnership firm namely M/s. Neelkanth Developers entered into an agreement dated 25.11.2019 for a consideration of Rs. 16,38,65,750/- with the accused persons through their said company in buying the property to develop food park in Himachal Pradesh. That accused persons did not disclose the complainant that a big portion of above-mentioned property was already covered under forest land. That an agreement dated 23.11.2019 was executed between the accused and the previous land owner for a consideration amount of Rs. 13,60,00,000/- and relying upon the same, complainant made a total payment of Rs. 10,50,00,000/- till date against the above-mentioned agreement dated 25.11.2019 by way of bank transaction. That even after making the substantial part of payment, accused did not perform their part of -- 1 of 4 -- -2- the transaction as per the above-mentioned duties. That when complainant raised the issue then accused person started sending their henchmen to threaten him. Complainant has also registered one FIR against the accused person and said henchmen bearing no. 530/2022 at PS Punjabi Bagh PS Prashant Vihar, Delhi. The accused persons as per the above-mentioned agreement issued a cheque to Mr. Parvesh in lieu of his services but when said cheque was got dishonored and accordingly, Mr. Parvesh had filed the case against the accused person u/s 138 NI Act. That during framing the notice u/s 251 Cr.P.C, accused had stated that “one namely Mr. Nitin Chopra has criminal acts against the accused such as threatening to life, extortion, trespass and attempt of looting and Mr. Nitin Chopra is a gangster”. Further, complainant through his counsel on 27.09.2022 had sent a legal demand notice to the accused persons requesting them to complete their part of the agreement. However, instead of fulfilling of their obligations, they sent a reply dated 23.10.2022 to the said legal notice thereby using harsh sentencing blaming/accusing the complainant of situations. That in the said reply, accused alleged that “It is pointed out, at the outset, that your client has committed the criminal acts of threatening to life, extortion, trespass and attempt of looting against my client, in association with kartar Singh who happens to be gangster of Bahadugrah, Haryana”. Before entering into the said agreement and MOU yoru client did not disclose that gangster happens to be your client’s working partner in whose plot of land at Bahadurgarh your client’s factory is planted”. Further accused persons also alleged that “Nitin Chopra employed the gangster Kartar Singh, who was asking my client of her mobile phone to quit from the project and execute agreement in favour of Neelkanth developers. It turned out clear that Nitin hopra had employed the gangster Kartar Singh for extortion of money from my client. Nituin Chopra and Karta Singh with their 15-20 criminal associates again appeared at his residence, Yamuna Vihar Delhi on 11.05.2022. Unfortunately, at his time, police arrived in time and arrested both Kartar Singh and Nitin Chopra. -- 2 of 4 -- -3- Further, even after making such harsh allegations against the complainant, accused persons were not satisfied and consequently when they filed reply dated 03.01.2023 to the application Mr. Parvesh u/s 143 A NI Act in the said case, they again made some false, baseless allegations against the complainant. Accused person alleged that “Nitin Chopra has an association with Kartar Singh who is a gangster by profession in Bahadurgarh, Haryana and that he has a long list of criminal cases against him. Further, accused persons have also mentioned that “complainant employed Kartar Singh to extort the accused over the phone and to quit the project and the execute an agreement in favour company and when the accused refused to comply, he demanded money amounting to Rs. 4 Crore. It is further alleged that “Complainant paid to Kartar Singh sum of Rs. 22 Lac through bank account via cheque leaf sent through whatsapp by complainant”. Complainant has examined two other witness on his behalf namely Mr Parvesh CW2 (through whom accused persons had approached the complainant) and CW3 Sabhya Chopra in support of the present case. Perusal of the testimony of CW2 and CW3 is reflecting that they have also deposed the same story on same line. Therefore, for the sake of brevity, contents of testimony of witnesses CW2 and CW3 are not being repeated in the order. Arguments are already heard and considered. Record are perused. Testimony of all witnesses are corroborating in nature prima-facie and same are reflecting that some serious allegations were levelled against the complainant and it was alleged against the complainant that he is the associate of gangster Kartar Singh and used to do the criminal acts of threatening to life, extortion, trespass and attempt to looting. This is not a case of mere testimony of witnesses, complainant has placed on -- 3 of 4 -- -4- record also some documents which are reflecting that said allegations were mentioned in the legal demand notice and other documents. It is pertinent to mention that in the reply dated 23.10.2022 sent by the accused persons, placed on record before this Court, also reflecting that in number of paragraphs serious allegations were mentioned and same was sent to the Ld. counsel for the complainant. After perusal of the said reply, Court is of the view that it is prima-facie proving the case in favour of the complainant and against the accused persons. Sending of legal demand notice or reply to the Ld. counsel for the complainant with serious imputation is satisfying the ingredients of Section 499 of IPC. Court is of the view that it was the publication at the end of the accused persons of the defamatory contents. In view of the observation, Court is inclined to take the cognizance against the accused persons namely Puneet Singh Chauhan, Manoj Singh and Toyaj Chauhan for the offence u/s 500 IPC for doing the criminal defamation against the accused persons. Let summons be issued to the accused persons on filing of PF within 03 days, returnable on 23.12.2025. ROHIT KUMAR JMFC(North) Rohini Courts Delhi/07.08.2025 -- 4 of 4 --
