Full Order Text
Final Order 11 · 21 Jul 2025 · CNR DLNT020069172023
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: IN THE COURT SH. ROHIT KUMAR JUDICIAL MAGISTRATE FIRST CLASS– 04 NORTH: ROHINI COURT : NEW DELHI Cr. Case 3857/2023 STATE Vs. Vishal Agagrwal FIR No. 42/2023 PS Prashant Vihar U/s 279/338 IPC JUDGMENT A Registration Number 3857/2023 B Name of the complainant Sita Ram Sharma C Name of the accused & his parentage and address Vishal Aggarwal S/o Sh. Suresh Kumar R/o E-1/60, Sector-7, Rohini, Delhi. D Offence Complained of 279/338 IPC E Date of commission of offence. 19.01.2023 F Date of Institution 20.04.2023 G Offence Charged 279/338 IPC H Plea of the accused person Pleaded not guilty. I Order Reserved on 20.05.2025 J Date of Pronouncement 21.07.2025 K Final Order Accused Vishal Aggarwal is acquitted for the offence u/s 279/338 IPC. Vide this judgment, the accused Vishal Aggarwal is acquitted of the offence punishable under Section 279/338 of Indian Penal Code (hereinafter referred to as “the IPC”) in this case FIR No. 42/2023 Police Station Prashant Vihar for the reasons mentioned below: 1. PROSECUTION'S CASE: It is the case of the prosecution that on after Holidays and prior to 19.01.2023 at around 10:30 am on road, in front of Rose Apartment Sector-14, Rohini, Delhi within jurisdiction of PS Prashant Vihar, Delhi, accused herein was found driving the offending vehicle i.e. Maruti Ciaz bearing registration RC No. DL-11CB-1194 in a rash and Cr. Case 3857/2023 STATE Vs. Vishal Aggarwal FIR No. 42/2023 Page 1/7 -- 1 of 7 -- negligent manner and to endanger the human life and public safety of the others and hit against the one motor-cycle bearing no. DL-11SR- 2259 and thus thereby caused grievous injury to the complainant/victim namely Sita ram Sharma and had committed an offence u/s 279/338 IPC. That based on these facts, it is the case of the prosecution that the accused Vishal Aggarwal is stated to have committed an offence u/s. 279/338 1IPC, which led to registration of FIR No. 42/2023 at PS Prashant Vihar. 2. CHARGE: In compliance of the procedural mandate u/s. 173 Criminal Procedure Code (hereinafter referred to as “CrPC”), charge-sheet against the accused Vishal Aggarwal was filed in the present matter, upon completion of investigation. Accused was summoned to face trial and was supplied with the copy of the charge-sheet as per s. 207 CrPC to accused. Based on the charge-sheet, a charge for the offences punishable u/s. 279/338 IPC was framed against the accused, to which he pleaded not guilty and claimed trial. 3. PROSECUTION EVIDENCE: - 3(a). PW-1 Sita Ram Sharma deposed that he is advocate by profession and on 19.01.2023, he was going to Rohini court on his motor-cycle bearing no. DL-11SR2259 and at around 10:30 am, when he reached to the Rose apartment, one car hit him. Further deposed that other than this, he does not want to say anything else and he can not identify the accused. Ld. APP for the State sought permission to cross-examine the witness as he was resiling from his complaint and previous statement. During the cross-examination by the Ld. APP for the State, witness was shown complaint dated 23.01.2023 and asked if the same was given by him to the police. To which, witness stated that it only bears his signature at point A. However, contents from point X to X1 Cr. Case 3857/2023 STATE Vs. Vishal Aggarwal FIR No. 42/2023 Page 2/7 -- 2 of 7 -- were not stated by him and the complaint is Ex. PW-1/A. Vol. Further deposed that the contents of the complaint are false and wrong. Further deposed that that he has not given any such complaint. Further he denied that the complaint Ex. PW-1/A was given by him to the police station and contents are true and correct. Further denied that car bearing no DL11CB1194 Maruti Ciaz hit his motor-cycle and the same was being driven in a rash and negligent manner. Further denied that due to the collision of the offending car with his motor-cycle and he sustained injury. Further denied that after the accident he went to Jaipur Golden Hospital, he got myself medically treated and obtained MLC. During cross-examination by the Ld. APP for the State, witness was pointed out towards accused and asked to identify him and after seeing the accused, witness failed to identify him. Further denied that accused present in the court was the same person who caused accident and due to which he suffered injury. Further denied that site plan was prepared at his instance. Vol. his signatures were obtained on blank papers and it bears his signature at point A on Ex. PW-1/B. PW1 admitted that his brother had handed over the motor-cycle to the IO. Further admitted that he handed over the medical documents to the IO which are already on record. During further cross-examination by the Ld. APP for the State, witness was asked if he can identify the offending vehicle as well as his motor-cycle. However, Ld. counsel for accused stated that he is not disputing the identity of the offending vehicle and motor-cycle of the complainant. Accordingly, identification of the case property was dispensed with) 3(b). It is pertinent to mention that as the star witness/injured/complainant has turned hostile completely in this matter, accordingly, remaining witnesses were not called for examination before the court and PE was closed vide order dt. 20.05.2025 and statement of accused was dispensed with. Vide same order, final arguments were also heard and matter was fixed for Cr. Case 3857/2023 STATE Vs. Vishal Aggarwal FIR No. 42/2023 Page 3/7 -- 3 of 7 -- Judgment at 4:00 pm. 4. APPRECIATION OF EVIDENCE AND MARSHALLING OF THE FACTS: This being the factual, evidentiary and the legal position of the present case, let us analyze whether the prosecution has been able to successfully prove the guilt of the accused person on the touchstone of “beyond reasonable doubt”. 5. APPLICABLE LEGAL PROVISIONS: 5 (a) Section 279 IPC: Rash driving or riding on a public way.— Whoever drives any vehicle, or rides, on any public way in a manner so rash or negligent as to endanger human life, or to be likely to cause hurt or injury to any other person, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to six months, or with fine which may extend to one thousand rupees, or with both. The essential ingredients to constitute an offence under this section are: - 1. The accused was the driver of the vehicle in question. 2. The accused had driven the vehicle in a manner so rash or negligent, to endanger human life, or to be likely to cause hurt or injury to any other person. 5(b). Act being Rash or Negligent: To adjudicate upon the culpability of the accused, it must be seen from the evidence brought on record whether the act of the accused would fall under the ambit of “rash or negligent”. It would be expedient to lay bare the legal threshold in this regard. Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Rathnashalvan vs. State of Karnataka (2007) 3 SCC 474 has observed, inter alia, as under-: "7. .... Culpable negligence lies in the failure to exercise reasonable and proper care and the extent of its reasonableness will always depend upon the Cr. Case 3857/2023 STATE Vs. Vishal Aggarwal FIR No. 42/2023 Page 4/7 -- 4 of 7 -- circumstances of each case. Rashness means doing an act with the consciousness of a risk that evil consequences will follow but with the hope that it will not. Negligence is a breach of duty imposed by law. In criminal cases, the amount and degree of negligence are determining factors. A question whether the accused's conduct amounted to culpable rashness or negligence depends directly on the question as to what the amount of care and circumspection is which a prudent and reasonable man would consider it to be sufficient considering all the circumstances of the case. Criminal rashness means hazarding a dangerous or wanton act with the knowledge that it is dangerous or wanton and the further knowledge that it may cause injury but done without any intention to cause injury or knowledge that it would probably be caused. 8. As noted above, "rashness" consists in hazarding a dangerous or wanton act with the knowledge that it is so, and that it may cause injury. The criminality lies in such a case in running the risk of doing such an act with recklessness or indifference as to the consequences. Criminal negligence on the other hand, is the gross and culpable neglect or failure to exercise that reasonable and proper care and precaution to guard against injury either to the public generally or to an individual in particular, which, having regard to all the circumstances out of which the charge has arisen it was the imperative duty of the accused person to have adopted." 6. Now, in the present factual matrix prosecution has examined the PW-1 only before the court. 7. The witness/PW1 examined by the prosecution has failed to link the alleged actus reus to the accused person. PW-1 has completely turned hostile before the court and has not supported the story of prosecution and his statement recorded before the police. The court is conscious of the fact that the injured/complainant has turned hostile, and it is a settled law that mere turning of the witness’s hostile would not discard his deposition in entirety and the same can be relied upon if it is materially corroborated. (Attar Singh vs. State of Maharashtra (See: 2013 (11) SCC 719)). Now, the other witnesses have come into picture only after the occurrence of the incident. But the same would not suffice to bring home the charge u/s. 279 IPC. The way the vehicle Cr. Case 3857/2023 STATE Vs. Vishal Aggarwal FIR No. 42/2023 Page 5/7 -- 5 of 7 -- was driven is the prime consideration for culpability under the said provision. Further, it is also required that vehicle was being driven by the accused in rash and negligent manner. In the present facts the prosecution has failed to demonstrate that the vehicle was being driven by the accused himself in a rash and negligent manner because injured/PW1 himself has turned hostile. It is pertinent to mention that in this matter, the PW1 has not supported the story of the prosecution and has also denied the suggestions regarding the rash and negligent act by the accused person. Further PW1 has also failed to identify the accused person before the court. Perusal of testimony of PW1 reflects that his deposition has failed to link any incriminating fact with the accused person. In this eventuality, benefit of doubt must be given to the accused person. It is also pertinent to mention that in this matter, charge against the accused person was framed u/s 279 and 338 of IPC, however, vide statement dt. 20.05.2025 complainant has compounded the offence u/s 338 of IPC with the accused with due permission of the court for the sum of Rs. 10,000/-. Accordingly, trial was conducted only for the offence 279 IPC. 8. CONCLUSION: The onus and duty to prove the case against the accused is upon the prosecution and the prosecution must establish the charge beyond reasonable doubt. It is also a cardinal principle of criminal jurisprudence that if there is a reasonable doubt regarding the guilt of the accused, the accused is entitled to benefit of doubt resulting in acquittal of the accused. Considering the above discussion, the unequivocal conclusion that comes forth is that the prosecution has failed to prove the case against the accused on the touchstone of “beyond reasonable doubt”. To bring home the charge under s. 279 IPC, the onus was on the prosecution to establish the fact that accused was driving the car in rash and negligent manner. However, due to being hostile of PW1, same has not been proved. Accordingly, the accused is entitled for benefit of reasonable doubt and is hereby found Cr. Case 3857/2023 STATE Vs. Vishal Aggarwal FIR No. 42/2023 Page 6/7 -- 6 of 7 -- not guilty u/s 279 of IPC. Moreover, offence 338 of the IPC has been compounded by the complainant. Accordingly, accused Vishal Aggawal S/o Sh. Suresh Kumar is hereby acquitted of the offences under Section 279/338 IPC. Announced in open court. On 21.07.2025 (ROHIT KUMAR) JMFC-04 (North) Rohini Courts Delhi/21.07.2025 Certified that this judgment contains 07 pages, and each page bears my signature. (ROHIT KUMAR) JMFC-04 (North) Rohini Courts Delhi/21.07.2025 Cr. Case 3857/2023 STATE Vs. Vishal Aggarwal FIR No. 42/2023 Page 7/7 -- 7 of 7 --
