Skip to main content
Court Order

Final Order 1

CNR DLNT01012540202308 Nov 2023
Back to Case

Full Order Text

Final Order 1 · 08 Nov 2023 · CNR DLNT010125402023

Order Details: COPY OF JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS
Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SH KISHOR KUMAR, ADJ-04
NORTH, ROHINI COURTS, DELHI.
ARBTN No.2476/23
M/S ECO STAR SECURITIES AND CREDIT LTD.
C/o 2199/63, Naiwala Karol Bagh, New Delhi.
Through Its AR,
Sh Amod Kumar.
VERSUS
INDER PAL
s/o Ram Nand
R/o 376, Baprola Village, West Delhi-110043.
08.11.2023
O R D E R
Fresh petition u/s 9 of the A & C Act, 1996 received.
It be checked and registered.
1. ld counsel for petitioner.
2. The present petition has been filed under Section 9 of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 seeking appointment of
receiver to take possession of Vehicle make TATA MOTORS LTD
TATA ACE bearing Registration No.DL1LAB5852, Engine
No.70910 and Chassis No.9856 which stood hypothecated with the
petitioner.
3. Case of the petitioner is that the petitioner is a company,
carrying on business of hire-purchase of vehicle and Sh Amod
Kumar constituted attorney is duly authorized to sign, verify and
institute the petition on behalf of the petitioner company. The
respondent approached the petitioner for purchase of Vehicle make
TATA MOTORS LTD TATA ACE bearing Registration
No.DL1LAB5852, Engine No.70910 and Chassis No.9856 and the
petitioner financed the same to respondent. An agreement of loan-
cum-hypothecation dated 25.09.2022 was executed between the
Arbtn No. 2476/23 Eco Star Securities and credit P Ltd v Inder Pal 1/6
-- 1 of 6 --
petitioner and the respondent. Under the agreement, it was agreed that
the respondent would hypothecate and create first charge over the said
vehicle in favour of the petitioner company, as such, the vehicle stood
surety for due performance of the agreement. Under the agreement,
petitioner disbursed a sum of Rs.2,50,000/- to the respondent, which
was to be repaid by the respondent in 24 equal monthly installments of
Rs.13,500/- each. It is claimed that the respondent failed/avoided to
make the payment, as per schedule and after lapse of months/years,
respondent has paid only 9 installment(s). It is also claimed that the
recall notice dated 23.10.2023 has also been issued to the
borrower/respondent. It is stated that as on date, respondent is liable to
pay a sum of Rs.74,500/-. The petitioner is having apprehension that
respondent is contemplating to shift the vehicle elswhere. The
agreement entered into between the parties contains arbitration clause/
(s), which the petitioner intends to invoke. The petitioner has prayed
for appointment of Sh Shyam as ‘RECEIVER’ to take possession of
Vehicle make TATA MOTORS LTD TATA ACE bearing
Registration No.DL1LAB5852, Engine No.70910 and Chassis
No.9856.
4. It has been argued by the ld counsel for the petitioner that the
balance of convenience lies in favour of the petitioner and if the
‘RECEIVER’ is not appointed, irreparable loss would be caused to it,
as there is apprehension that the respondent may dispose of the
vehicle. It is further argued that there is no necessity to issue notice to
the respondent, at this stage, and ex-parte order, regarding
appointment of ‘RECEIVER’ can be straightway passed. In support of
arguments advanced, judgment in case of GE Capital Transportation
Financial Services Ltd v Raj Tours Private Ltd. Reported as 159(2009)
Arbtn No. 2476/23 Eco Star Securities and credit P Ltd v Inder Pal 2/6
-- 2 of 6 --
DLT 440 has been relied, in which, the Hon’ble High Court had
appointed the RECEIVER to take the possession of the vehicle, as the
respondent had failed to make the payment of the installments.
Another judgment relied is in this case of Jai Singh v Indusind Bank
Ltd., reported as MANU/DE/4655/2009, in which the order of Ld.
Trial Court for appointment of ‘RECEIVER’ was upheld. Another
judgment relied upon is in the case of Sundaram Finance Ltd v NEPC
India Ltd., reported as (1992) 2 SCC 479 wherein it has been held that
interim order can be sought from the Court, even before
commencement of the proceedings. It was further held that Court is
not debarred from dealing with the application under Section 9 of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, merely, because no notice has been
issued. Next, judgment is in the case of Citicorp Finance (India) Ltd.
V Neeraj Jain & Anr., (FAO 283/205, DOD: 20.09.2005, by Hon’ble
High Court of Delhi), in which, it was held that delay occasioned due
to issuance of notice, thereby, preponement of interim protection, to
which, the appellant appears entitled, is likely to defeat the object of
filing of the petition. It was held that the ld Trial Court ought to have
passed an ex-parte order, appointing a receiver to secure possession of
the vehicle.
5. perusal of agreement shows that the vehicle in question can be
repossessed by the petitioner, in case of default by the respondent. As
per Judgment Sundaram Finance, (Supra), and Citicorp Finance
(India) Ltd., (Supra), there is no requirement of issuance of notice to
the respondent before passing an ex-parte order. An ex-parte for
appointment of ‘RECEIVER’ can be passed without issuance of such
notice to the respondent.
Arbtn No. 2476/23 Eco Star Securities and credit P Ltd v Inder Pal 3/6
-- 3 of 6 --
6. Accordingly, in view of the aforesaid judgments and facts and
circumstances of the case, a balance of convenience lies in favour of
the petitioner and in case ex-parte order, regarding appointment of
‘RECEIVER’ is not passed, it would cause irreparable loss to the
petitioner. In case exparte ‘RECEIVER’ is not appointed, there is
likelihood of disposal of hypothecated vehicle by the respondent and
that its value may depreciate day by day. Consequently, I, hereby
appoint Sh Shyam employer of the petitioner, as ‘RECEIVER’ with
directions to take possession of the Vehicle make TATA MOTORS
LTD TATA ACE bearing Registration No.DL1LAB5852, Engine
No.70910 and Chassis No.9856 from the respondent of any other
person found in possession thereof. RECEIVER is authorized to take
appropriate police assistance, if required. However, the vehicle shall
not be sold till further order of this Court.
7. The petitioner is directed to refer the matter to the Arbitrator
within three weeks. The petitioner is further directed not to transfer
the possession as well as title of the vehicle in question. Compliance
report regarding status of vehicle and appointment of Arbitrator be
filed in due course. In case, vehicle is repossessed, compliance report
be filed immediately after its repossession, failing which interim order
shall stand vacated.
8. In case, vehicle is repossessed, ‘RECEIVER’ shall report to the
local police station and shall submit the compliance report before this
Court within three days of the repossession of the vehicle in question.
The copy of the order be given to the ‘RECEIVER’ on his furnishing
complete details of his residence, contact number, etc, alongwith
proof.
Arbtn No. 2476/23 Eco Star Securities and credit P Ltd v Inder Pal 4/6
-- 4 of 6 --
9. The receiver shall take over the possession of the vehicle from
the respondent at the address(es) given in the loan application. If the
vehicle is not available at the said address(es), the receiver shall be at
liberty to recover the vehicle wherever found. However, the receiver
shall not stop a running vehicle on the road to forcibly take out the
driver to take the possession of the vehicle. The receiver shall also not
make any attempt to block the passage of a vehicle to bring it to a halt
to take its possession.
10. The receiver shall avoid taking the possession of the vehicle if
the vehicle is occupied by a woman who is not accompanied by a
male member or an elderly infirm or physically/mentally challenged
person. In such cases, the receiver shall take the possession of the
vehicle from the borrower's residence.
11. The receiver shall be at liberty to take the assistance of the local
police, if required, for taking over possession of the vehicle. The
concerned SHO shall provide assistance to the receiver as and when
requested.
12. The receiver shall also ensure theat the repossession of the
vehicle does not result in any breach of peace. In the event of any
breach of peace, the receicver shall not proceed without assistance of
police.
13. At the time of taking the custody of the vehicle, the receiver
shall deliver a copy of this order to the person from whom the
possession it is taken.
14. At the time of taking the custody of the vehicle, the receiver
shall take the photographs of the vehicle from different angles
alongwith the person(s) occupying the vehicle as well as place of
taking over the possession.
Arbtn No. 2476/23 Eco Star Securities and credit P Ltd v Inder Pal 5/6
-- 5 of 6 --
15. The receiver shall remain personally present at the time of
seizure of the vehicle and shall prepare an inventory of the
articles/accessories found in the vehicle and shall furnish the copy of
the inventory to the person from whom the possession is taken. The
exact date and time of the seizure shall also be noted down and copy
of the seizure memo shall be supplied to the respondent or his
representative at the spot itself. Before taking possession of the
vehicle, the respondent shall be permitted to recmove his belongings,
if any from the vehicle.
16. After taking the vehicle in possession, the receiver shall keep
the vehicle in safe custody for which the petitioner shall make
appropriate arrangements at his own cost, risk and responsibility.
17. The maximum period for which this order shall remain effective
is 90 days i.e. Maximum time granted by this Court to the
applicant/petitioner under Section 9(2) of the Arbitration &
Conciliation (Amendment) Act, 2015.
18. The Reciever shall not repossess the vehicle if the respondent
pays Rs.74,500/- (Rupees Seventy Four Thousand Five Hundred
Only) out of the total outstanding dues as on the date of the petition
filed in the Court and shall also duly issue a proper receipt for
receiving the amount with the apparent authority of the petitioner
being reflected on the receipt itself.
19. Compliance report be filed in due course.
20. File be consigned to record room.
PRONOUNCED IN THE OPEN COURT ON THIS 8th DAY OF
NOVEMBER, 2023.
(Kishor Kumar)
ADJ-04, North, Rohini Courts,
Delhi/08.11.2023
Arbtn No. 2476/23 Eco Star Securities and credit P Ltd v Inder Pal 6/6
-- 6 of 6 --

TrustJury presents public court-record information for legal discovery and reference. Record availability and detail can vary by source and case.