Full Order Text
Final Order 9 · 17 Jan 2025 · CNR DLNT010124992024
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: MCA DJ 13/24 NIRMAL BANSAL VS. YOGENDER PAL SINGH 17.01.2025 Present: Ms. Kritika Bajaj, counsel for appellant (through VC). Sh. Ujjwal Parti, counsel for R-1 to R-3. None for R-4. Counsel for R-5/MCD. Further arguments on present appeal heard. Appellant has filed present appeal against order dated 03.08.2024, passed by Ld. JSCC/ASCJ/Guardian Judge, North, Rohini Courts, Delhi. Vide impugned order dated 03.08.2024, passed by Ld. JSCC/ASCJ/Guardian Judge, North, Rohini Courts, Delhi, an application filed by appellant herein/plaintiff before Ld. Trial Court, was dismissed and disposed of. The relevant operative portion of order dated 03.08.2024 is being reproduced herein for sake of convenience and ready reference :- “1. Vide present order, court will decide application filed on behalf of plaintiff u/o 39 Rule 1 and 2 CPC. 2. After going through averment mentioned in the plaint as well as WS filed on behalf of Defendants, particularly going through WS filed on behalf of defendant No.6/MCD court is of the view that no prima-facie case is made out infavour of plaintiff as it is stated in in WS of defendant No.6 that after following due process of law and as per policy for installtion of lift permission for installation of lift was granted. Contd../- -- 1 of 3 -- -2- 2. In the view of court balance of convenience also lies in favour of defendants as defendants would suffer more inconvenience then plaintiff if construction of lift is stayed as in the view of court stay of installation of lift would cause more inconvenience to defendants. Considering the above facts and circumstances the application U/o 39 rule 1 and 2 CPC filed on behalf of plaintiff stands dismissed.” A careful perusal of order dated 03.08.2024 shows that the said order is a non-speaking order and in said order there is no mention/discussion about the contentions of the parties and more particularly the appellant herein/plaintiff therein. Ld. Trial Court dismissed the application u/o 39 rule 1 & 2 CPC merely relying upon the WS of defendant no-6/MCD. In impugned order dated 03.08.2024, no discussion was made regarding the plaint and as to on what grounds the contentions of plaintiff therein were rejected. Passing of a speaking order is a sine-qua-non for deciding an issue. Speaking order is not only essential for the parties to a proceeding but is also essential for upholding/reversal of an impugned order by appellate courts, while hearing an appeal/revision. An order must reflect the thought process of the court on the basis of which a court reaches its conclusion. Since, the impugned order dated 03.08.2024 is a non-speaking order, the same is liable to be set aside and the same is hereby set aside. Contd../- -- 2 of 3 -- -3- Ld. Trial Court is directed to hear arguments on said application u/o 39 rule 1 & 2 CPC again and is further directed to dispose of said application vide a speaking order. Present appeal stands disposed of accordingly. Appeal file be consigned to record room after necessary compliance. TCR be sent back to court concerned alongwith copy of present order for information and compliance. Parties are directed to appear before Ld. Trial Court on 20.01.2025 at 2.00 PM for further proceedings, as per law. Ahlmad is directed to comply. (Deepak Dabas) DJ-1(North)/Rohini Courts Delhi/17.01.2025 -- 3 of 3 --
