Full Order Text
Interim Order 9 · 07 Sept 2024 · CNR DLNT010098702023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF DISTRICT JUDGE-02: NORTH ROHINI COURTS COMPLEX: DELHI IN THE MATTER OF:- CS DJ No. 650 - 2023 Dhanraj Jain vs. Mukesh Garg & Ors. 07.09.2024 ORDER ON APPLICATION 1. Counsel for the defendant no. 3 and 4 presses an application under order 1 Rule 10 CPC dated 04.04.2024 for deletion of name of defendant no. 4 from array of parties. 2. It is argued by counsel for the defendant no. 3 and 4 that present suit has been filed seeking possession, permanent and mandatory injunction as also declaration. 3. Counsel for the defendant no. 3 and 4 further argues that the prayer for possession is directed against defendant no. 1 qua suit property bearing plot no. 12 A, Kewal Park Extension, Azadpur, Delhi, prayer for permanent injunction and mandatory injunction is directed against defendants and defendants will be duty bound by the judgment and decree passed by this court. Prayer for occupational charges is directed against defendant no. 1 and 2. prayer for declaration declaring documents in favour of defendant no. 1 and 2 concerns only defendant no. 1 and 2 and not the defendant no. 4. Defendant no. 4 is only custodian of revenue records. Relevant records can be summoned from the department through concerned witness. Defendant no.4 is not necessary party. CS DJ No. 650 – 2023 Dhanraj Jan vs. Mukesh Garg & Ors. Page no. 1 of 4 -- 1 of 4 -- 4. Per contra counsel for the plaintiff argues that specific averments they have been made in para 2 that defendant no. 4 is responsible for stopping unauthorized and illegal construction. Defendant no. 4 is necessary party. 5. It is also argued that there is connivance of defendant no. 3 and 4 with the defendant no. 1 and 2. 6. It is further argued by counsel for defendant no. 3 and 4 that the village Azadpur has since been urbanized, the Delhi Land Revenue Act has seized to apply. SDM has no control or power the suit property. Defendant no. 3 MCD is the concerned authority which has control over the illegal construction. 7. Per contra counsel for the plaintiff states that for mutating the property, for identification of the suit property, the SDM is necessary party. Heard. File perused. 8. Perusal of the record shows that present suit has been filed seeking possession, permanent and mandatory injunction as also declaration. 9. Perusal of the record shows that prayer for possession is directed against defendant no. 1 qua suit property bearing plot no. 12 A, Kewal Park Extension, Azadpur, Delhi. Further prayer for permanent injunction and mandatory injunction is directed against defendants. But the defendants will be duty bound by the judgment and decree passed by this court. Further Prayer for occupational charges is directed against defendant no. 1 and 2. Further prayer for declaration declaring documents in favour of defendant no. 1 and 2 concerns only defendant no. 1 and 2 and not the defendant no. 4. 10. It is rightly argued by counsel for Defendant no. 4 that defendant no. 4 is only custodian of revenue records. Relevant records can be summoned from the department through concerned witness at the time of trial. Defendant CS DJ No. 650 – 2023 Dhanraj Jan vs. Mukesh Garg & Ors. Page no. 2 of 4 -- 2 of 4 -- no.4 is not necessary party. If any decree and directions are passed in the suit the defendant no. 4 will be duty bound to comply with the same. His presence as a party is not necessary for just adjudication of the case. 11. The contention by counsel for the plaintiff that specific averments have been made in para 2 that defendant no. 4 is responsible for stopping unauthorized and illegal construction. Defendant no. 4 is necessary party is rejected. Defendant no. 4 will be duty bound to carry out the directions and decree passed by the court. Same does not make defendant no. 4 as a necessary party. 12. The contention by counsel for the plaintiff that there is connivance of defendant no. 3 and 4 with the defendant no. 1 and 2 is mainly directed against the defendant no. 1 and 2. Order 6 Rule 4 CPC provides that specific particulars of fraud must be given. No dates or details of alleged connivance of defendant no. 4 are on record. It is correct that at this stage the averments of the plaint are to be taken as true. However, even if the plaintiff succeeds in proving role of defendants and alleged connivance, all the reliefs as prayed for can be granted. Defendant no. 4 for the grant of reliefs is not a necessary party. Presence of defendant no. 4 is not necessary for settling the questions involved in the suit. 13. It is further rightly argued by counsel for defendant no. 3 and 4 that the village Azadpur has since been urbanized, the Delhi Land Revenue Act has seized to apply. SDM has no control or power the suit property. Defendant no. 3 MCD is the concerned authority which has control over the alleged illegal construction. CS DJ No. 650 – 2023 Dhanraj Jan vs. Mukesh Garg & Ors. Page no. 3 of 4 -- 3 of 4 -- 14. The submission by counsel for the plaintiff that for mutating the property, for identification of the suit property, the SDM is necessary party is rejected. Plaintiff will be at liberty to summon concerned witness with relevant record. No relief is prayed for against the SDM defendant no. 4. Defendant no. 4 is accordingly deleted from the array of parties. Let amended memo of parties be filed by the plaintiff. 15. Application under order 1 Rule 10 CPC dated 04.04.2024 for deletion of name of defendant no. 4 from array of parties is allowed. (VIKRAM BALI) DISTRICT JUDGE-2/NORTH/ ROHINI COURT/DELHI/07.09.2024 CS DJ No. 650 – 2023 Dhanraj Jan vs. Mukesh Garg & Ors. Page no. 4 of 4 -- 4 of 4 --
