Full Order Text
Interim Order 8 · 07 Sept 2024 · CNR DLNT010098702023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF DISTRICT JUDGE-02: NORTH ROHINI COURTS COMPLEX: DELHI IN THE MATTER OF:- CS DJ No. 650 – 2023 Dhanraj Jain vs. Mukesh Garg & Ors. 07.09.2024 ORDER ON APPLICATION 1. Counsel for the plaintiff presses his application under order 1 Rule 10 CPC dated 04.04.2024 for impleading Ms. Deepika Singhal as defendant no. 5. 2. It is argued by counsel for the plaintiff that there is a specific prayer for possession of suit property i.e. plot no. 12 A,Kewal Park Extension, Azadpur, Delhi which falls in khasra no. 429/61/1/2/2 in revenue Estate of Village Azadpur. 3. It is argued by counsel for the plaintiff that in the written statement of defendant no. 1 and 2 in para 10 of additional pleas at page 8 of the written statement a specific plea is taken that vide sale deed dated 09.02.2023 Geeta Rani the previous owner had sold the property in favour of Smt. Deepika Singhal and she is owner to the extent of 67%. CS DJ No. 650 – 2023 Dhanraj Jan vs. Mukesh Garg & Ors. Page no. 1 of 3 -- 1 of 3 -- 4. It is argued that without presence of Deepika Singhal, decree, if passed, cannot be executed effectively. 5. Per contra counsel for the proposed defendant no. 5 Deepika Singhal states that she has not trespassed the property of the plaintiff. No cause of action has arisen against defendant no. 5. He argues that the application be dismissed. 6. Heard. File perused. 7. Perusal of the record shows that in the suit plaintiff has made a specific prayer for possession of suit property i.e. plot no. 12 A,Kewal Park Extension, Azadpur, Delhi which falls in khasra no. 429/61/1/2/2 in revenue Estate of Village Azadpur. 8. Perusal of the record shows that in the written statement of defendant no. 1 and 2 in para 10 of additional pleas at page 8 of the written statement a specific plea is taken that vide sale deed dated 09.02.2023 Geeta Rani the previous owner had sold the property in favour of Smt. Deepika Singhal and she is owner to the extent of 67%. 9. It is rightly argued by counsel for the plaintiff that without presence of Deepika Singhal, decree, if passed, cannot be executed effectively. Further it is in interest of Smt. Deepika Singhal as well to file her defence & contest the present case. CS DJ No. 650 – 2023 Dhanraj Jan vs. Mukesh Garg & Ors. Page no. 2 of 3 -- 2 of 3 -- 10. The contention by counsel for the proposed defendant no. 5 Deepika Singhal states that she has not trespassed the property of the plaintiff. No cause of action has arisen against defendant no. 5 is rejected. At this stage, the court is satisfied that presence of proposed defendant no. 5 Ms. Deepika Singshal is necessary to enable the court to effectually and completely adjudicate the questions involved in the suit. Identification of suit property is involved. Smt. Deepika Singhal has a sale deed in her favour, her interests, right and title is involved. The application under order 1 Rule 10 CPC dated 04.04.2024 for impleading proposed defendant no. 5 Ms. Deepika Singhal is accordingly allowed. (VIKRAM BALI) DISTRICT JUDGE-2/NORTH/ ROHINI COURT/DELHI/07.09.2024 CS DJ No. 650 – 2023 Dhanraj Jan vs. Mukesh Garg & Ors. Page no. 3 of 3 -- 3 of 3 --
