Full Order Text
Final Order 4 · 10 Feb 2026 · CNR DLNT010097882025
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF MS. VANDANA, ADDITIONAL SESSIONS JUDGE-02, NORTH DISTRICT, ROHINI COURTS, DELHI In the matter of: Criminal Revision No. 170/2025 Mr. Hari Om S/o late Sh. Jug Lal, R/o A-42, Gali No. 2, Amrit Vihar, Burari, Delhi-110084 ....Revisionist Versus Mr. Rajeev S/o late Sh. Jug Lal, R/o A-3, 25 Futta Road, Amrit Vihar, Burari, Delhi-110084 ...Respondent Date of Institution : 23.07.2025 Conclusion of arguments : 10.02.2026 Date of Order : 10.02.2026 ORDER 1. Present revision petition is preferred by the revisionist under section 440 BNSS against the order dated 15.05.2025 (hereinafter referred to as impugned order) passed by Ld. JMFC, North. 2. Brief facts required for the disposal of the present revision petition are as under:- 2.1 The revisionist filed the complaint case bearing no. 6520/2017 stating that his father has purchased a property bearing no. A-3, 25 futta road, Amrit Vihar, Burari, Delhi -84 New CR No. 170/2025 Hari Om Vs. Rajeev page no. 1/6 -- 1 of 6 -- (hereinafter referred to as “the property”) after selling ancestral property. His father constructed four shops for his four sons including the complainant on the property. From past nine years, complainant had been running a confectionery shop on the property. The complainant’s father got expired in the year 2015. In the year 2017, his mother told him to vacate the shop, subsequent to which, he demanded partition and his share in the property, but the same was refused by his mother and brother Rajeev. Complainant also served a legal notice to all the Lrs of his father on 28.09.2017. After that, they started creating hindrance on the way leading to his shop by parking motorcycle and placing pots. 2.2 It has been further stated that on 20.10.2017, complainant’s mother alongwith brother Rajeev filed a complaint against the complainant and his brothers Sanjay and Vijay Bahadur. On 23.10.2017, complainant gave written complaint against his mother and brother Rajeev. Thereafter, complainant filed partition suit qua the property before Ld. ADJ, Rohini. That in the night of 15.11.2017 his mother and brother Rajeev forcibly broke the lock of his shop and put their lock through chain and took possession of goods lying in the shop. After that complainant made a written complaint to PS Swaroop Nagar. 3. The revisionist herein led pre summoning evidence and got examined himself as CW1 and his brother Sanjay Kumar as CW-2, who deposed on similar lines to that of the revisionist. 4. Thereafter, on hearing arguments on the point of summoning, the Ld. Trial Court dismissed the complaint New CR No. 170/2025 Hari Om Vs. Rajeev page no. 2/6 -- 2 of 6 -- observing that the matter is in the nature of civil dispute and no criminal offence is made out. 5. The above said impugned order has been challenged on the ground that the Ld. Trial Court mechanically passed the above said order and failed to appreciate the evidence in its proper legal prospective. Hence, he prayed to set aside the impugned order. 6. Notice was issued to the respondent. Instead of filing any reply, Ld. Counsel for the respondent argued the same straightway. It was argued by the Ld. Counsel for the respondent that Ld. Trial court has rightly passed order dated 15.05.2025 and there is no infirmity in the impugned order, therefore, it needs no interference. It was further argued by the counsel for the respondent that Ld. Trial Court after considering all the material available on record has rightly passed the order. 7. As regards the powers of Revision U/s 397 Cr.P.C the Ho'ble Supre Court in the latest judgment dated 17.02.2022 in the case of Directorate of enforcement Vs. Gagandeep Singh 2022 SCC online Delhi 514 has reiterated the law that: “the provision of revision in Cr.P.C. suggests that the court shall limit itself to the findings sentence or order pass by the subordinate court, against which the revisionists is seeking relief before the court concerned and shall not go beyond the analysis and observations made by the subordinate court.” Section 397 Cr.P.C. unequivocally states that the High Court and Sessions Courts which is exercising its revisional New CR No. 170/2025 Hari Om Vs. Rajeev page no. 3/6 -- 3 of 6 -- jurisdiction shall apprise itself solely of the question of correctness, legality and properity of the order of the subordinate court. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in Directorate of enforcement Vs. Gagandeep Singh (supra) again emphasised that “ in its revisional jurisdiction court will not proceed into the enquiry of the records, documents and other evidence in consideration before the Trial Court but shall constrain itself to the findings of the lower court in the impugned order and to the question whether there is any patent, illegality, error apparent on record or incorrectness.” 8. The Ld. Trial Court vide impugned order dismissed the complaint observing that the matter is in the nature of civil dispute and no criminal offence is made out. 9. With respect to summoning of accused, in G. Sagar Suri and Amr. Vs. State of UP and Ors. (2000) 2SCC 636, hon’ble Supreme Court observed that, “it is the duty and obligation of the court to exercise a great deal of caution in issuing process, particularly, if the matter is essentially is of civil nature.” 10. The summoning order has to be passed when the complaint or chargesheet discloses an offence and when there is material that supports and constitutes essential ingredients of the offence. The summoning order should not be passed lightly or as a matter of course. Reliance placed upon Thermax Ltd. And anr. Vs. K.M. Johny and Ors. (2011) 13 SCC 412.” New CR No. 170/2025 Hari Om Vs. Rajeev page no. 4/6 -- 4 of 6 -- 11. In the case in hand, during the course of the arguments, it was admitted by the counsel for revisionist that he has already filed a suit for partition of the property in question which is still subjudice. Apart from the same, he further admitted that he has filed one more suit for injunction against his mother and brother. 12. The whole case of the revisionist rest upon the fact that the respondent has illegally dispossessed him from the shop occupied by the revisionist and committed theft by taking the goods lying in the shop run by the revisionist in his possession. So far as dispossession of the revisionist is concerned, undoubtedly, the given facts clearly indicate that the dispute is completely of civil nature. The Ld. Trial court rightly observed that CW-2 is the interested witness being brother of the revisionist and through the criminal complaint case under section 200 Cr.P.C, an attempt has been made by the revisionist herein to give criminal colour to a civil dispute. Merely filing of telephone bills, invoices, MCD Challan Etc. is not sufficient to show exclusive possession of the revisionist over the property. 13. With respect to the alleged theft, the photograph of shop from outside, and the list of goods does not attract the alleged offence of theft against respondent. 14. As Ld. Counsel for the revisionist has remained failed to point out any error apparent on record or incorrectness in the impugned order, therefore, the revision petition is hereby stands dismissed as the impugned order does not need any interference, hence, the same is hereby stands upheld. New CR No. 170/2025 Hari Om Vs. Rajeev page no. 5/6 -- 5 of 6 -- 15. It is clarified that the above said observation has been made only with respect to the allegation of criminal offence and this court has not been commented any observation on the civil rights of the revisionist. 16. Revision petition is disposed of accordingly. 17. Nothing stated herein shall tantamount to an expression of opinion on the merits of the case. 18. TCR, be sent back to the concerned court with copy of this order. 19. Revision file be consigned to record room after due compliance. Pronounced in open (VANDANA) Court on 10.02.2026 ADDITIONAL SESSIONS JUDGE-02, NORTH DISTRICT, ROHINI COURTS, DELHI New CR No. 170/2025 Hari Om Vs. Rajeev page no. 6/6 -- 6 of 6 --
