Full Order Text
Order 4 · 07 May 2026 · CNR DLNT010073922025
Order Details: COPY OF JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS Pdf Text: 26 CS (COMM.) 412-25 ANJU JAIN Vs. HARJINDER SINGH OBEROI 07.05.2026 Present: Mr. Sharad Malhotra, Ld. Counsel for plaintiff through VC. Defendant along with Mr. NK Saifi, Ld. Counsel for defendant through VC. Matter is listed for disposal of the application moved on behalf of defendant U/o 8 Rule 1 CPC seeking condonation of delay in filing of WS. It appears from the record that defendant was duly served with the summons on 27.08.2025. WS was e-filed on 15.10.2025 and hard copy was filed on 17.10.2025. It is stated in the application that defendant received copy of the plaint and documents and Ld. Counsel for defendant put appearance on 08.12.2025. However, in between, on account that defendant was under medical treatment from 20.09.2025 to 06.10.2025, Ld. Counsel for defendant, without instructions from the defendant, could not prepare WS. As such, it is stated that there is a delay of around 23 days in filing of the WS. Ld. Counsel for the plaintiff opposed the application stating that there is a delay of around 50 days in filing of WS and there is no explanation of each day delay. It is further argued that even the medical documents annexed with the application is only a prescriptions of dated 02.04.2025, 12.08.2025 and 19.08.2025 which are of the period even prior to the service of summons. -- 1 of 2 -- Having heard the submissions and carefully perused the record, admittedly there is a delay in filing of WS, however, this Court is of the opinion that the matter should be decided on merits rather than technicalities but at the same time, it is also settled law that defendant is required to show plausible reasons by explaining the delay of each day in filing of WS. The mandate of law cannot be dispensed with without there is no sufficient plausible explanation given in the application, though it is mentioned in para 3 of the application that on account of medical treatment with effect from 20.09.2025 to 06.10.2025, Ld. Counsel for defendant could not take instructions from the defendant to file WS whereas the documents filed with the application is not in consonance with the reasons mentioned in the application. Having so obsered, the delay of 50 days needs to be condoned so that matter can be decided on merits. Accordingly the delay of 50 days in filing of WS is hereby condoned subject to cost of Rs.20,000/- to be payable to the plaintiff within four weeks from today. Subject to filing of receipt of payment of cost of Rs.20,000/-, WS be taken on record. Put up for filing of replication, admission/denial of documents and framing of issues 04.08.2026. (Shailender Malik ) District Judge (Commercial)-02 North District, Rohini Courts, Delhi/07.05.2026 -- 2 of 2 --
