Full Order Text
Final Order 5 · 06 Jun 2026 · CNR DLNT010073302025
Order Details: COPY OF JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS Pdf Text: 26 OMP (COMM.) 14/25 AMIT GUPTA AND ANR Vs. M/S HDB FINANCIAL SERVICES LIMITED 06.06.2026 Present: Ld. counsel for petitioner. Ms.Priya, ld. counsel for respondent (through VC). Matter is listed for arguments on the present petition filed u/s 34 of Arbitration and Conciliation Act. I have heard the submissions. It appears from the record that petitioner herein had taken a loan on 26.08.2022 for purchase of vehicle Maruti Suzuki bearing registration no. DL9CAZ 2939, from respondent company of Rs.7,51,737/-. The amount was to be repaid under the loan agreement dated 26.08.2022 by way of equated EMIs. As per the case of respondent the loan was not completely repaid, therefore since the loan agreement contained an arbitration clause, arbitration proceedings were initiated by appointment of Sole Arbitrator Sh.Sanjay Aggarwal. It appears that Sole Arbitrator passed an ex parte award dated 20.03.2025 against the petitioner herein. Hence the present petition challenging the award on following grounds : (i) It is stated in the petition that award is liable to be set aside as no notice for appointment of ld. Arbitrator was received by the petitioner, no consent for appointment of Arbitrator was taken. (ii) The terms of arbitration clause indicate that the interested party i.e. respondent HDB Financial had been given liberty to appoint Arbitrator of their own -- 1 of 5 -- choice. As such the process involving appointment of Arbitrator unilaterally was against the law. (iii) The Sole Arbitrator decided the claim on the basis of presumption and without taking into consideration the relevant evidence, documents and passed the award against the principle of natural justice. Reply Reply to the present petition has been filed by respondent company taking an objection that present petition is not maintainable as petitioner has not approached the court with clean hands rather distorted the facts. It is stated that petition is not maintainable in terms of Section 34 of Arbitration and Conciliation Act and therefore liable to be dismissed on this score. It is stated that petitioner had taken loan of Rs.7,51,737/- under a loan agreement dated 26.08.2022, wherein he after understanding all the terms and conditions signed the same including agreeing for condition regarding appointment of arbitrator. It is stated that when the loan account of the petitioner was not proper and regular, a legal notice dated 12.06.2024 was served calling upon him to pay the outstanding amount. It is stated that vide surrender letter dated 20.06.2024 permission was given to respondent no.1 for selling the vehicle in question. It is stated that as per arbitration clause the venue of the arbitration was at Chennai, to which petitioner herein had agreed. Mother of the petitioner herein had appeared before ld. Arbitrator and sought adjournment. Thereafter two effective dates were given for appearance of the petitioner who failed to appear to contest the claim. It is stated that petitioner has failed to raise -- 2 of 5 -- any of the grounds contemplated u/s 34 of Arbitration and Conciliation Act. Moreover the petition is barred by limitation. Submissions I have heard Ld. Counsel for the petitioner as well as ld. counsel for respondent and perused the record. Analysis and conclusion Before examining the grounds taken in the petition, it be noted that jurisdiction of the court under Section 34 of Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 to set aside the arbitral award is very limited as while examining the arbitral award u/s 34 of the Act of 1996, court does not assume any jurisdiction of appeal over the arbitral award. Arbitral award can be interfered with on very limited grounds as provided under Section 34(2)(b) (ii) of the Act i.e. the award is against the public policy of India. It is well established legal proposition that bare reading of Section 34 of the Act of 1996 indicates highly constricted power of civil court to interfere with arbitral award. Reason is obvious that the scheme of Arbitration and Conciliation Act is such that there should be least interference from the court in the arbitral proceedings. No doubt an arbitral award can be set aside under Section 34 of the Act only when the arbitral tribunal’s view/conclusion is patently perverse and arbitrary. Expression “arbitral award is in conflict with public policy of India” though is not defined but to be construed when the core principle of Indian law has been violated or where the award is so perverse that it is not in consonance with judicial conscience or principles. (See : MMTC Limited vs. Vedanta Limited (2019) 4 SCC 163, K. Sugumar vs. Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Limited (2020) 12 SCC 539, Dyna Technology Pvt. Ltd. vs. Crompton -- 3 of 5 -- Greaves Limited (2019) 20 SCC 1, UHL Power Company Limited vs. State of HP (2022) 1 SCR 1, Konkan Railway Corporation Limited vs. Chenab Bridge Project Undertaking (2023) 11 SCR 215). It is evident from the reading of the arbitration clause that it stipulates that sole arbitrator would be appointed by respondent company who granted the loan facility to petitioner. It be noted in this context that efficacy of arbitration as an alternate dispute resolution mechanism rests on the foundation that the disputes would be adjudicated by independent and impartial arbitrators. The decision of supreme Court of India in Perkins Eastman Architects DPC and Anr. v. HSCC (India) Limited AIR 2020 SC 59, recognizes the importance of ensuring that Arbitrators not be appointed by persons who are otherwise interested in the matter so as to obviate any doubt as to the impartiality and independence of the Arbitral Tribunal. Apex court reiterated the legal position in highlighting the observation as : “….Since the principles of impartiality and independence cannot be discarded at any stage of the proceedings, specifically at the stage of constitution of the Arbitral Tribunal, it would be incongruous to say that party autonomy can be exercised in complete disregard of these principles - even if the same has been agreed prior to the disputes having arisen between the parties. There are certain minimum levels of independence and impartiality that should be required of the arbitral process regardless of the parties' apparent agreement. ….” Above judgment was followed by Apex Court in M/s. Glock Asia-Pacific Ltd. vs. Union of India AIR 2023 SC 2777, as in facts of that case, arbitration clause authorized Secretary, Ministry of Home Affairs, whose relationship with Union of India was that of an employee, to nominate an officer of the -- 4 of 5 -- Ministry of Law and Justice to act as Sole Arbitrator. It was held that arbitration clause would fall within the expressly ineligible category provided in Paragraph 1 of Schedule VII, read with Section 12(5) of the Act and the appointment under said clause, of officer of Ministry of Law and Justice as Arbitrator could not be given effect to. In the present case the arbitration clause stipulates unilateral appointment of arbitrator by one of the party of loan transaction i.e. lender company/respondent herein. Thus such arbitration clause is not strictly in accordance with the law and cannot be given legal affect. On this score itself the consequential arbitral proceedings get vitiated. Examining of arbitral award in question would further indicates that Ld. Sole Arbitrator has not taken into account any concrete evidence, rather went on to accept the statement of claim filed by the respondent herein as gospal truth, without even examining the very vital aspect of the fact that vehicle in question was sold and sale consideration was to be adjusted while awarding the amount. That aspect was not at all taken into consideration. Thus, it can safely be concluded that the arbitration award in question was patently illegal and against the public policy. For the reasons as noted above, the award is liable to be set aside. Accordingly, petition stands allowed. File be consigned to record room. (Shailender Malik ) District Judge (Commercial)-02 North District, Rohini Courts, Delhi/06.06.2026 -- 5 of 5 --
