Full Order Text
Order 4 · 01 Feb 2025 · CNR DLNT010071242024
Order Details: COPY OF JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS Pdf Text: CS DJ 381/24 PARVEEN PAL Vs. JAGRESH PAL 01.02.2025 Present: Sh. Virag Kumar Aggarwal, counsel for the plaintiff. Sh. Rakesh Kumar, Counsel for the defendant through VC not clearly audible). Sh. Sumit who states that he is nephew of the defendant is present. Counsel for the plaintiff has filed on record reply top application u/o 8 rule 1 CPC. Copy supplied to Sh. Sumit in the court. Counsel for the defendant presses his application u/o 8 rule 1 CPC which is supported by an affidavit dated 25.09.2024. It is argued that defendant is resident of UP and is a Heart patient. It is argued that delay of 88 days in filing the written statement, may be condoned as opportunity to raise defence in suit for Specific Performance, filed by purchaser plaintiff, may be granted. Per contra, counsel for the plaintiff contends that no proper explanation for condonation of delay, is mentioned. It is argued that the medical documents are of Eye treatment and pertain to February, 2024. Reliance is placed on case titled Atcom Technologies ltd. vs. Y.A. Chunawala and Co. and Ors., decided on 07.05.2018 by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India to contend that delay in filing the written statement outght not to be condoned wihtout cogent reasons. Heard. Filed. Perusal of the file shows that there is a delay of approximately 126 days in filing the written statement. It has been mentioned in application seeking condonation of delay in filing the written statement that defendant had undergone treatment of Contd….2 -- 1 of 2 -- -2- CS DJ 381/24 PARVEEN PAL Vs. JAGRESH PAL his Eyes. Same is supported by medical certificate showing date of discharge as 01.02.2024. Admittedly, summons were received by the defendant on May, 2024. He contacted his counsel only on 20.09.2024. Thus, for delay, the plaintiff ought to be compensated with costs There is no dispute with the law laid down in case titled Atcom Technologies ltd. vs. Y.A. Chunawala and Co. and Ors., decided on 07.05.2018 by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, however, same is distinguishable on facts as in the facts before the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, there was a delay of more than 5 years. Present suit is for Specific Performance. Plaintiff is the purchaser. Defendant is the seller. Defendant must be given full opportunity to defend the case. Plaintiff is compensated with costs of Rs. 2,500/- to be paid by the defendant to the plaintiff. Subject to payment of abovesaid costs of Rs.2,500/-, written statement is taken on record. Application u/o 8 rule 1 CPC is disposed off in above terms. Now, to come up on 25.04.2025 for arguments on the application u/o 39 rule 1 and 2 CPC. Interim order dated 26.09.2024 is continued till the next date of hearing. (VIKRAM BALI) DISTRICT JUDGE-2/NORTH/ ROHINI COURT/DELHI/01.02.2025 -- 2 of 2 --
