Full Order Text
Interim Order 18 · 23 Feb 2024 · CNR DLNT010059052023
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: SC No. 322/2023 State Vs. Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit etc IN THE COURT OF MS. SEEMA MAINI PRINCIPAL DISTRICT & SESSIONS JUDGE NORTH DISTRICT: ROHINI COURTS: DELHI In the matter of: (Sessions Case No. 322/2023) CNR No. DLNT010059052023 FIR No. 46/2023 Police Station S.P. Badli Charge sheet filed Under Section 394/397/34 IPC Charges framed Under Section 392/394/34 IPC 397 IPC State V/s 1. Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit S/o Sh. Dayanand R/o C98, Near Masjid, Badli, Delhi. 2. Saloni (since deceased & proceedings abated) D/o Krishan H.No. 250, Gali No. 11, A Block, Ambedkar Nagar, Haiderpur, Delhi. …. Accused Date of institution of case before the Ld. MM 12.04.2023 FIR No. 46/2023 : PS S.P. Badli page 1 of 31 -- 1 of 31 -- SC No. 322/2023 State Vs. Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit etc Date of committal of case to Sessions Court 01.06.2023 Date of arguments 14.02.2024 Judgment Pronounced on 23.02.2024 Decision Convicted J U D G M E N T 1. The accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit is facing trial in the present case on allegations that he along with coaccused Saloni (since deceased and proceedings against her already abated), in furtherance of their common intention, committed robbery of Rs.2800/ from the possession of the complainant, and while committing the robbery, voluntarily caused injuries to the complainant, by using a knife i.e. a deadly weapon. 2. On the complaint of Krishan Pal (complainant / injured), the instant case FIR bearing no. 46/2023, was registered by the police of Police Station S.P. Badli, under Section 394/397/34 IPC, which after requisite investigation, culminated into the charge sheet, which the SHO of Police Station S.P. Badli, filed against accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit and against Saloni, in the Court of Ld. MM, North District, Rohini, Courts, Delhi. After compliance of provisions of Section 207 CrPC, Ld. MM committed the case to the Court of FIR No. 46/2023 : PS S.P. Badli page 2 of 31 -- 2 of 31 -- SC No. 322/2023 State Vs. Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit etc Sessions under provisions of Section 209 CrPC for trial, being a session triable case. During trial, the accused Saloni was murdered and proceedings against her stood abated, vide order dated 19.10.2023. 3. The facts in brief, which are borne out from the record / chargesheet are that on 09.01.2023 at about 9.00 pm, when the complainant, who runs his shop, under the name & style of Mother Dairy, was present at his shop bearing no. 17525, A8/14, Sector 18, Rohini, Delhi, one motorcycle, having two riders i.e. one boy, aged about 2530 years and one girl (pillion rider) aged about 2025 years, crossed his shop and after taking a U turn, came back and the boy stopped his said motorcycle, in front of the shop of the complainant. The said boy asked the complainant for two cups of curd, which he gave to the said boy, who in turn, showed him a currency note of Rs. 500/, and made the said currency note fall on the ground. When the complainant bent down to pick the said currency note, the said boy, stole Rs. 2800/ from the Galla / money box of the complainant. On being raised an objection by the complainant, the said boy took out a knife from the pocket, of the pant which he was wearing, and attacked the complainant on his right thigh, and ran away from there on his motorcycle, along with the said girl. 4. The complainant called the police at 100 number, and the FIR No. 46/2023 : PS S.P. Badli page 3 of 31 -- 3 of 31 -- SC No. 322/2023 State Vs. Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit etc information was recorded vide GD No. 118 A, which was assigned to ASI Narender Dhama, who reached at the spot and came to know that the injured has already been removed to BJRM Hospital by the PCR van. IO ASI Narender Dhama reached at BJRM Hospital and met the complainant, who was under medical treatment, and the IO collected his MLC bearing no. 219741/23. On being discharged from the hospital, the complainant visited the police station, where IO SI Narender Dhama recorded his statement, on the basis of which, he prepared the rukka, and got the case FIR registered through Duty Officer. Efforts were made to trace out the accused persons, and during investigation it was revealed that both the said accused, whose name was revealed as Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit and Saloni, have been arrested in another case bearing FIR No. 19/2023 dated 10.01.2023, u/s 379/356/411/34 IPC & 25/54/59 Arms Act, pursuant whereto on 13.01.2023, IO ASI Narender along with W/Ct. Deepika reached at Rohini Court Complex, and after taking requisite permission from the court concerned, they interrogated and arrested the accused persons in the present case bearing FIR No. 46/2023, PS S.P. Badli, and their disclosure statements were recorded. IO obtained the requisite permission from the court concerned to get the TIP conducted, whereafter the TIP proceedings were conducted. In the TIP, the complainant correctly identify the accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit, but he could not correctly identity the accused Saloni. Since nothing incriminating against the accused Saloni could be surfaced, her name FIR No. 46/2023 : PS S.P. Badli page 4 of 31 -- 4 of 31 -- SC No. 322/2023 State Vs. Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit etc was mentioned in column no. 12 of the Chargesheet, which was filed before the court of Ld. MM. 5. Ld. MM took the cognizance of the offence committed, and finding that there is sufficient material available on record, summoned both the accused including Saloni also. On appearance in the court of Ld. MM, both the accused persons were supplied with the copies of the chargesheet and other documents, whereafter the matter was committed to the Court of Sessions, as the accused persons had been chargesheeted for the offence punishable u/s 394/397/34 IPC. After hearing the counsel for the accused and Ld. Addl. P.P. for the State, vide order dated 21.07.2023 framed the charges against the accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit and Saloni, for the offence punishable u/s 392/394/34 IPC, to which they pleaded not guilty and claimed trial. The accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit was also charged for the offence punishable u/s 397 IPC, to which they pleaded not guilty and claimed trial. 6. To substantiate its case, the prosecution examined eight witnesses in all, out of which PW 1, PW 3, PW 4, PW 6 and PW 7 are formal witnesses, PW 5 and PW 8 are witnesses of investigation, while PW 2 Krishan Pal (complainant / injured) is the material witness. FIR No. 46/2023 : PS S.P. Badli page 5 of 31 -- 5 of 31 -- SC No. 322/2023 State Vs. Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit etc 7. During the course of trial, the accused vide his statement dated 03.01.2024, admitted the TIP proceedings conducted qua him and qua accused Saloni, both dated 19.01.2023, Ex. PW 2/B and PW 2/C, pursuant whereto PW Ms. Neha Pandey, Ld. MM06, North District, Rohini Courts, Delhi, who had conducted the said TIP proceedings, was dropped from the list of witnesses. FORMAL WITNESSES 8. PW1 ASI Lalit Pradhan deposed that on 09.01.2023, while he was posted at PS S.P. Badli, Delhi, at about 11:17 pm, an information was from the control room to the effect that “A8/14, ABlock, Sector 18, Rohini, Delhi, bike par ek ladka aur ek ladki thi Pulsar bike par caller se 2800 rupay chheen kar le gaye hain, pair mein chaaku maara hai, red light Sector18, Rohini, ki side bhaag gaye, dono jeans pehene huyen hain, ladki pair mein chappal M juraab pehene huyen hai. Mobile No. 8368250512”, and the same was reduced into writing vide DD Entry No. 118A dated 09.01.2023 Ex. PW1/A, which was assigned to ASI Narender Dhama, who went to the spot along with HC Rajender for taking necessary action. He proved on record the attested copy of the DD Entry No. 118A dated 09.01.2023 as Ex. PW1/B. FIR No. 46/2023 : PS S.P. Badli page 6 of 31 -- 6 of 31 -- SC No. 322/2023 State Vs. Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit etc 9. PW3 Dr. Mohd. Asif, Officiating Casualty Medical Officer, BJRM Hospital, Jahangir Puri, Delhi deposed that on 09.01.2023, while he was posted at BJRM Hospital, Delhi, as CMO, injured Krishan Pal Singh was brought to the Casualty of the said hospital, by the police with the history of stab injury, as told by the patient himself. PW3 further deposed that he medically examined the patient and found injury on his person, as mentioned in the MLC Ex. PW3/A, prepared by Dr. Mitul, JR (Casualty), under his supervision. He furthe deposed that the injury sustained by Krishan Pal Singh, was found to be ‘simple’ in nature, as is mentioned at point C in the MLC. 10. In his crossexamination at the hands of the Ld. Counsel for the accused, PW 3 admitted it to be correct that the injury as mentioned in the MLC Ex. PW3/A, could be occured with a sharp object/pointed object. 11. PW4 ASI Santosh Kumar, No. 521/NorthWest, PS Maurya Enclave, Delhi, deposed that on 09.01.2023, while he was posted at PS Maurya Enclave, on receipt of DD No. 86A dated 09.01.2023, along with W/Ct. Anju and Ct. Giri Raj reached District Park, Pitampura, Delhi, where the complainant Mahi (in case FIR No. 19/2023 PS Maurya Enclave) along with police staff HC Vijay FIR No. 46/2023 : PS S.P. Badli page 7 of 31 -- 7 of 31 -- SC No. 322/2023 State Vs. Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit etc and HC Sadhu Ram met them, and produced before him the robbed mobile phone of the complainant and the knife recovered from accused Punit @ Arjun @ Vinit. PW 4 further deposed that he seized the knife and recorded the statement of the complainant, who identified both accused Saloni and accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit, who had committed robbery of her mobile phone, and at that time the accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit was riding Bajaj Pulsar NS200 motorcycle bearing registration no. DL11SL8523 and accused Saloni was pillion rider, and that the accused Saloni had snatched the mobile phone from the complainant and both the accused persons were apprehended by the patrolling police staff with the motorcycle. 12. PW 4 further deposed that on the complaint of the complainant against both the accused persons, an FIR No. 19/2023 at PS Maurya Enclave was got registered, which he proved as Ex. PW4/A. He further testified that the documents including seizure memo of the motorcycle, arrest memos of both the accused persons, disclosure statements of both the accused persons, the previous involvement of accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit and their conviction slip prepared by him, in case FIR No. 19/2023 PS Maurya Enclave, which he proved as collectively Ex. PW4/B. He correctly identified both the accused persons i.e. Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit and Saloni are present in the Court. FIR No. 46/2023 : PS S.P. Badli page 8 of 31 -- 8 of 31 -- SC No. 322/2023 State Vs. Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit etc 13. In his crossexamination at the hands of the Ld. Counsel for the accused he denied the suggestion that the knife was planted on the accused in case FIR No. 19/2023. He further denied that both the accused persons were not involved in case FIR No. 19/2023, nor was any recovery effected from them. He further denied that the accused persons had not made any disclosure statement. 14. PW 5 W/Ct. Deepika deposed that on 13.01.2023, while she was posted at PS S.P. Badli, she joined the investigation of the present case along with ASI Narender Dhana and they reached at Rohini Courts, and after taking the requisite permission from the court concerned, they arrested the accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit (correctly identified) and accused Saloni (proceedings against her already abated), vide appropriate arrest memo Ex. PW 5/A and Ex. PW 5/B respectively. She further deposed that both the said accused made their respective disclosure statements Ex. PW 5/C and Ex. PW 5/D respectively. 15. In her crossexamination at the hands of the Ld. Counsel for the accused, PW 5 denied the suggestion that the accused persons had not made any disclosure statements. 16. PW6 Sh. Ashutosh, JJA/Asstt. Ahlmad from the Court of FIR No. 46/2023 : PS S.P. Badli page 9 of 31 -- 9 of 31 -- SC No. 322/2023 State Vs. Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit etc Ms. Vasundhara Chhaunkar, Ld. ACMM, NorthWest District, Rohini Courts, Delhi, brought the original case file of case FIR No. 19/2023 PS Maurya Enclave recorded u/s 356/379/411/34 IPC and 25/54/59 Arms Act, qua accused persons Punit @ Arjun @ Vinit S/o Sh. Dayanand and Saloni D/o Sh. Krishan, which is pending trial in the said court, containing the original documents related to the case FIR No. 19/2023 (OSR), the copy of which is already Ex. PW4/A, seizure memo of motorcycle bearing registration no. DL11SL8573 with its key (OSR), the copy of which is already Ex. PW4/B, arrest memos of accused Punit @ Arjun and accused Saloni (OSR), copies of which, he proved as Exs. PW6/A and PW6/B respectively, disclosure statements (OSR) of accused Punit @ Arjun @ Vinit and accused Saloni have been proved as as Exs. PW6/C and PW6/D respectively. Previous conviction/involvement report (OSR) of accused Vinit @ Arjun @ Lala s/o Sh. Dayachand have been proved on record as Ex. PW6/E and the conviction slips of accused Punit @ Arjun and accused Saloni are have been proved on record exhibited as Exs. PW6/F and PW6/G respectively. 17. PW7 SI Mahender Pal deposed that in the intervening night of 09/10.01.2023, while he was posted at PS S.P. Badli, at about 00:02 am, ASI Narender Dhama handed over to him a rukka, on the basis of which, he got present case FIR registered, on computer FIR No. 46/2023 : PS S.P. Badli page 10 of 31 -- 10 of 31 -- SC No. 322/2023 State Vs. Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit etc through Computer Operator, copy of which has been proved on record by him Ex. PW7/A. He made his endorsement on the rukka, Ex. PW7/B and also issued a certificate u/s 65B of the Evidence Act Ex. PW7/C. He further deposed that after registration of FIR, he handed over the copy of the FIR and the original rukka to ASI Narender Dhama for further investigation. WITNESSES OF INVESTIGATION 18. PW8 ASI Narender Dhama deposed that on 09.01.2023, on receipt of DD No. 118A, he reached at A8/14, Sector18, Rohini, Delhi and came to know that the injured has already been shifted to BJRM Hospital by PCR vehicle, whereafter he also reached there and found that the injured Krishan Pal Singh was under treatment, and on his MLC, the opinion regarding the nature of injuries was given as ‘simple’. PW 8 further deposed that the injured could not make any statement, at that time in the hospital, and later on, he came to the police station and met him and made his complaint already Ex. PW2/A, on the basis of which, he (PW8) prepared the rukka, Ex. PW8/A and handed over the same to the Duty Officer, and got the present case FIR registered. PW 8 further deposed that he prepared the site plan Ex. PW8/B, at the instance of the complainant. He correctly identified the accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit. FIR No. 46/2023 : PS S.P. Badli page 11 of 31 -- 11 of 31 -- SC No. 322/2023 State Vs. Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit etc 19. PW 8 further deposed that on 13.01.2023, he along with W/Ct. Deepika reached at Rohini Courts and after taking permission from the concerned Court, vide his application Ex. PW8/C, he arrested the accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit and accused Saloni, vide arrest memos already exhibited as Ex. PW5/A and Ex. PW5/B respectively, and also recorded their disclosure statements already exhibited as Ex. PW5/C and Ex. PW5/D respectively. He further testified that he moved an application Ex. PW8/D, for getting conducted the TIP proceedings of both the accused persons, which was got fixed for [date withheld] at Rohini Jail, vide Order dated 13.01.2023 Ex. PW8/E. He further deposed that on 19.01.2023, TIP proceedings of accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit and accused Saloni, were conducted, vide TIP proceedings already Exs. PW2/B and PW2/C respectively, wherein the complainant correctly identified the accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit. 20. In his crossexamination at the hands of the Ld. Counsel for the accused, PW 8 deposed that he made inquiries from the public persons, who were present near the spot, but no public person had joined the investigation. He further deposed that the complainant came at the police station on 09.01.2023 between 11 pm to 12 midnight. He further deposed that the complainant had accompanied FIR No. 46/2023 : PS S.P. Badli page 12 of 31 -- 12 of 31 -- SC No. 322/2023 State Vs. Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit etc him to the spot, where he prepared the site plan. No public person was present at the spot, at that time. He denied the suggestion that the site plan was not prepared at the instance of the complainant or that due to this reason, the same has not been signed by the complainant. He further denied the suggestion that no investigation in the present case, was carried out at the instance of the complainant, at the spot. PW 8 also denied the suggestion that prior to TIP proceedings of the accused persons, their photographs were shown to the complainant. MATERIAL WITNESSES 21. PW 2 Sh. Krishan Pal deposed that on 09.01.2023 at about 9:00 pm, when he was present alone at his shop bearing no. 17525, Mother Dairy, A8/14, Sector 18, Rohini, Delhi, one boy, aged about with a girl, who was sitting as a pillion rider and had wrapped her face with a chunni type cloth, on a Pulsar motorcycle, came from the side of Green Value Apartments and crossed from, in front of his shop. They took a turn, after going ahead a little bit, and stopped the motorcycle in front of his shop, and got down from the motorcycle and came to his shop. On being asked by the said boy for two cups of curd, the complainant had given him. When the complainant asked for the money from the said boy, he (said boy) had shown him FIR No. 46/2023 : PS S.P. Badli page 13 of 31 -- 13 of 31 -- SC No. 322/2023 State Vs. Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit etc a currency note of Rs. 500/, which he made fall, by the side of the counter, and when he bent down to lift the said currency note of Rs.500/, the said boy put his hand in his cash box and lifted the cash of Rs. 2800/. On seeing this, the complainant raised a noise and pushed the said boy, due to which, he disbalanced, and took out a knife from the pocket of his pant and stabbed the complainant on his left thigh, due to which he sustained injuries and the blood started oozing. PW 2 further deposed that both the said boy and girl fled away from the spot, on their motorcycle. Thereafter, he called the police at 100 number, pursuant whereto the PCR personnel took him to BJRM Hospital, Delhi, where he was medically treated. He further deposed that the Police of PS S.P. Badli met him in BJRM Hospital, but since he was in pain, he told the police that he would later visit the police station to make his statement. Accordingly, on the same day, between 11 pm to 12 midnight, he reached at PS S.P. Badli and made gave his complaint Ex. PW2/A. On being shown, the accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit, who was present in the Court, PW2 identified the said accused, as the same boy who had committed robbery with him and had stabbed him, at the time of robbery. However, he could not identify the girl who had accompanied the accused Puneet @ Arjun at the time of incident, as he had not seen her face. The attention of the witness was drawn towards accused Saloni, who was also present in the Court, but the said witness FIR No. 46/2023 : PS S.P. Badli page 14 of 31 -- 14 of 31 -- SC No. 322/2023 State Vs. Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit etc deposed that he could not say as to whether the accused Saloni was the same girl, who had accompanied the accused Puneet @ Arjun at the time of robbery, with him. 22. PW 2 further deposed that the police prepared the site plan of the spot, at his instance. He could not note down the registration number of the said motorcycle, nor was he able to identify the said motorcycle even if it is shown to him. He further deposed that on 19.01.2023, he visited Tihar Jail, Delhi, and joined the TIP proceedings in respect of the present case and identified the accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit, but he could not identify the girl accused in the said TIP proceedings. On being shown, PW2 identified his signatures on the TIP proceedings of accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit, which he proved as Ex. PW2/B. He also identified his signatures on the TIP proceedings of accused Saloni, which he proved as Ex. PW2/C. 23. On the request of the Ld. Addl. PP for the State, PW 2 was allowed to be cross examined on behalf of the State. In his cross examination at the hands of the Ld. Addl. PP for the State, PW 2 admitted that in his complaint Ex. PW2/A, he had mentioned the age of the said girl accused as about 2025 years. PW 2 further deposed that he had stated to the police that the girl had wrapped her face with FIR No. 46/2023 : PS S.P. Badli page 15 of 31 -- 15 of 31 -- SC No. 322/2023 State Vs. Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit etc a chunni type cloth at the time of robbery (confronted with complaint Ex. PW2/A where it is not so recorded). He denied the suggestion that he was not identifying the accused Saloni in the Court and also during the judicial TIP Ex. PW2/C, in order to save the accused Saloni. PW 2 deposed that he had not stated to the police in his complaint that the colour of the said Pulsar bike was black. He volunteered that the colour of the said Pulsar motorcycle was just like black, which he had stated in his complaint (confronted with complaint Ex. PW2/A where the word ‘black’ is specifically mentioned). He denied the suggestion that he was refusing to identify the said motorcycle, in order to save the accused persons. 24. PW 2 further admitted that his supplementary statement was recorded by the police on 10.01.2023, but he had not stated to the police in his supplementary statement that he could identify the said girl accused, if shown to him (confronted with supplementary statement Ex. PW2/PX where it is so recorded). He denied the suggestion that he has compromised the matter with the accused Saloni and / or in order to save her, he was deposing falsely. 25. In his crossexamination at the hands of the Ld. Counsel for the accused, PW 2 deposed that the operating time of his said milk shop, is from 5:30 am to 1:00 pm and from 4:00 pm to 10:00 FIR No. 46/2023 : PS S.P. Badli page 16 of 31 -- 16 of 31 -- SC No. 322/2023 State Vs. Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit etc pm. He further deposed that no other shop was/is attached with his said dairy and that the said milk booth is situated in between the residential DDA Flats colony. He denied the suggestion that accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit, whom he had identified, was already shown to him, in the police station. He had visited the police station only once during investigation of the present case. He himself had called the police at 100 number, but he did not remember the time when he was taken to the hospital. He denied the suggestion that before conducting the TIP proceedings of accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit, the photograph of accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit was shown to him or that the photograph having his face was shown to him. He had mentioned, in his complaint, the amount of robbed money i.e. Rs.2800/, but he had not shown to the police any register/record to show that the cash amount of Rs. 2800/ was lying in his cash box, at the time of incident. PW 2 further deposed that the police had not inquired from the residents of the locality, in his presence, nor was he aware if any residents of the locality were made witness in the present case. He had not told the registration number of the said motorcycle used by the accused, to the police, nor had he mentioned the description of the accused persons, except their age to the police. PW 2 further testified that he does not know if any CCTV camera was installed in the nearby area of his shop, but no CCTV camera was installed in his shop. Police had not seized his clothes in the present case. He admitted that the police had not shown any FIR No. 46/2023 : PS S.P. Badli page 17 of 31 -- 17 of 31 -- SC No. 322/2023 State Vs. Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit etc motorcycle to him during investigation of the present case. He denied the suggestion that he had identified the accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit in the court as well as during TIP proceedings, only at the instance of the IO. He further denied the suggestion that the accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit never stabbed him. He further denied the suggestion that the accused persons had never committed robbery with him. 26. After close of PE, the statement of accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit u/s 313 CrPC was recorded, wherein he pleaded his innocence and stated that he has been falsely implicated in the present case. He further deposed that though he had been named in another FIR bearing no. 19/2023, but the said case is also a false one, and that police had obtained his signatures on some blank papers, which have been used against him in this case. He further deposed that he is innocent and has been falsely implicated in the present case, by the IO in connivance with the injured, with ulterior motive. He opted not to lead defence evidence. 27. Final arguments were extended by Ms. Neeta Gupta, Ld. Chief PP for the State and Mr. D.K. Pandey, Ld. Counsel for the accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit, at length. 28. Ld. Counsel for the accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit has FIR No. 46/2023 : PS S.P. Badli page 18 of 31 -- 18 of 31 -- SC No. 322/2023 State Vs. Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit etc contended that the accused has been falsely implicated in the instant case, and even his identification as perpetrator of the crime, during the TIP proceedings, was because the complainant had been shown the photograph of the accused. Further more, it is pointed out that no public witness has been joined in the investigation by the IO and that adverse inference be drawn that the investigation was not a fair one. The accused persons Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit and Soloni (since deceased) allegedly came to the shop of the complainant on a bike, but the said alleged bike has not been recovered by the IO. Further more, there is no document to show that the complainant did actually have Rs.2800/ in his galla, which were robbed. It is stated that the complainant is not a reliable witness, since he has been declared hostile by the Ld. Addl. PP for the State and was cross examined, therefore his testimony is to be discarded, and owing to various inconsistencies in the prosecution case, acquittal of accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit is prayed for. 29. Per contra, Ld. Chief PP for the State has argued that the complainant has duly identified the accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit, in the TIP proceedings as well as in the court, to be the person, who had robbed him of Rs. 2800/, at his shop, after threatening him with a knife and thereafter also stabbed him with the knife, on his thigh. It is contended that qua accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit, the testimony of the complainant is totally reliable. Qua accused Saloni FIR No. 46/2023 : PS S.P. Badli page 19 of 31 -- 19 of 31 -- SC No. 322/2023 State Vs. Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit etc (since deceased), no doubt, the complainant did not identify her during TIP proceedings firmly and unambiguously, and thereafter even in the court, he did not identify her, but this part of his testimony can be totally segregated, from the part of his testimony, which supports the prosecution case qua involvement of accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit in the present case, and this part of his testimony, is sufficient to base the conviction of accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit. As regards, recovery of motorcycle, it is contended that the both the accused persons were arrested in another case bearing FIR No. 19/2023, PS Maurya Enclave, and during interrogation, both the accused persons Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit and Saloni (since deceased) made their disclosure statements regarding their involvement in the present incident, pursuant whereto they were arrested in the present case, by the IO concerned. The motorcycle bearing registration no. DL11SL8573, which was presumably used in the commission of the crime in the instant case also, was seized along with its key, by the IO of case FIR No. 19/2023, PS Maurya Enclave, in that case. The motorcycle was not produced in this case, since the complainant had already stated that he had not noted the number of the same and therefore he would not have been able to identify the same. It is stated that the MLC of the complainant Krishan Pal Singh corroborates his testimony that he was attacked with a knife on his thigh. Conviction of accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit for the offences u/s 392/394/397 IPC is prayed for. FIR No. 46/2023 : PS S.P. Badli page 20 of 31 -- 20 of 31 -- SC No. 322/2023 State Vs. Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit etc 30. I have given my thoughtful consideration to the rival contentions put forth by both the parties, have gone through the relevant case law and have scrutinized the evidence adduced by the prosecution. 31. The star witness of the prosecution in this case, is the complainant Krishan Pal Singh himself, examined as PW 2. The complainant is the victim and the injured in the instant case, and he is also a partly hostile witness (qua involvement of coaccused Saloni, who has since expired). The complainant, in his testimony as PW 2 in the court, has narrated the incident, as he had narrated the same to the IO, on the fateful day, when he lodged a complaint against the accused persons, who were unknown to him. There is no dispute that the complainant was present at his milk shop on 09.01.2023 at about 9.00 PM, while his MLC corroborates his version that he was stabbed on his thigh with a knife, which was used by the accused persons, to commit the robbery. 32. The appreciation of the testimony of an injured person, has been discussed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court as follows : In Shivalingappa Kallayanappa v. State of Karnataka 1994 Supp (3) SCC 235, this Court has held that the FIR No. 46/2023 : PS S.P. Badli page 21 of 31 -- 21 of 31 -- SC No. 322/2023 State Vs. Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit etc deposition of the injured witness should be relied upon unless there are strong grounds for rejection of his evidence on the basis of major contradictions and discrepancies, for the reason that his presence on the scene stands established in case, it is proved that he suffered the injury during the said incident. 33. In Raja v. State of Karnataka (Supra), Hon’ble Supreme Court has held as under: “That the evidence of a hostile witness in all eventualities ought not stand effaced altogether and that the same can be accepted to the extent found dependable on a careful scrutiny.” 34. In Koli Lakhman Bhai Chanabhai v. State of Gujarat (1999) 8 SCC 624, Hon’ble Supreme Court has held as under: “It is settled law that evidence of hostile witness also can be relied upon to the extent to which it supports the prosecution version. Evidence of such witness cannot be treated as washed off the record. It remains admissible in the trial and there is no legal bar to base his conviction upon his testimony if corroborated by other reliable evidence.” 35. Guided by the judgments, the part of the testimony of the complainant, which narrates the incident as well as the perpetrators of the crime, being one boy and one girl, coming on a Pulser bike, the girl being the pillion rider and having covered her face with a FIR No. 46/2023 : PS S.P. Badli page 22 of 31 -- 22 of 31 -- SC No. 322/2023 State Vs. Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit etc Chunni, not being disputed at all, brings about the truthfulness of the witness. The complainant identified the accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit, in his testimony as PW 2, but did not identify the coaccused Saloni (since deceased), on which note, he was declared hostile. 36. In the case in hand too, the consistent testimony of the complainant can be segregated from the part of his testimony, which does not support the prosecution case, and therefore it is trite to mention that qua accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit, testimony of complainant, is totally reliable. So much so, accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit was not known to the complainant, due to which, after their arrest, TIP proceedings of both the accused persons were conducted. The complainant duly identified the accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit, in a queue of 10 boys, who were almost of the same built and age, and the said TIP proceeding, conducted by the Ld. MM, has been duly admitted by the accused. Due identification of the accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit in the TIP, was followed by his identification in the court. As regards, coaccused Saloni (since deceased), during TIP proceedings, the complainant Krishan Pal Singh had stated before the Ld. MM that “he cannot exactly identify the girl, who committed the offence. She might be at 2nd or 5th position from right to left”. The coaccused Saloni was actually standing at S.No. 5 in the said queue, and therefore TIP qua co FIR No. 46/2023 : PS S.P. Badli page 23 of 31 -- 23 of 31 -- SC No. 322/2023 State Vs. Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit etc accused Saloni, cannot be said to be an outright 'non identification', but it was rather a case of confusion, which perpetuated due to which coaccused Saloni was not identified by the complainant in the court. 37. It needs to be kept in mind that the time of the incident was during a cold winter night at about 9 PM, and coaccused Saloni was the pillion rider on the motorcycle, and had wrapped her face in her Chunni. Therefore, the identification of coaccused Saloni was actually a difficult task, and the confusion and the subsequent non identification of coaccused Saloni, is definitely not willful but was because of the confusion, not having had a proper look, at the face of coaccused Saloni. 38. At this juncture, relevant is the contention of the Ld. Counsel for the accused that accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit was identified in the TIP proceedings, because his photograph had been shown to the complainant. However, this contention is not convincing, because, if the photographs of accused had to be shown to the complainant, the IO would also have shown the photographs of both the accused persons, and in that eventuality, coaccused Saloni, would also have been identified by the complainant firmly. Therefore, I am of the opinion that the identity of the accused Puneet FIR No. 46/2023 : PS S.P. Badli page 24 of 31 -- 24 of 31 -- SC No. 322/2023 State Vs. Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit etc @ Arjun @ Vinit is very well established, by the convincing identification of the said accused, by the complainant, both during TIP proceedings as well as in the court. 39. The complainant having been declared hostile only qua identification of accused Saloni, is a part of his testimony, which can be totally segregated and in fact, the nonidentification of coaccused Saloni, is proof of the truthfulness of the complainant. The portion of the testimony of the complainant, which is favourable to the prosecution case qua delineation of the entire incident and identification of accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit, being the perpetrator of the crime, is found convincing and totally reliable. 40. As regards, the recovery of the motorcycle, PW 6 Sh. Ashutosh, JJA / Asstt. Ahlmad from the court of Ld. ACMM, North West, Rohini Courts, Delhi, has produced the case file of case bearing FIR No. 19/2023, PS Maurya Enclave, which shows the seizure of a Pulser motorcycle. The seizure of the said motorcycle has been proved by PW 4 and PW 6. Since the complainant was the only person, who had seen the motorcycle, at the relevant time, but had not noted any other particular of the motorcycle, it would have been a futile exercise to call for the motorcycle and put it to the FIR No. 46/2023 : PS S.P. Badli page 25 of 31 -- 25 of 31 -- SC No. 322/2023 State Vs. Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit etc complainant. From the fact that the motorcycle, which was seized by the police personnels of PS Maurya Encalve, was a Bajaj Puler motorcycle, is a strong pointer that it was the same motorcycle, which was used by the accused persons, in commission of the crime in the present matter. 41. Ld. Counsel for the accused has contended that the case of the prosecution is not reliable, as no public person had been joined in the investigation. However, noteworthy it is, that the incident is dated 09.01.2023 around 9 PM, and the complainant reached the hospital around 9.42 PM, and after preparation of his MLC and requisite medical aid, he went to the police station for lodging his complaint, around 11 PM. It was between 11 PM to 12 midnight that the IO inspected the spot and prepared the site plan, and the FIR came to be lodged in the intervening night of 09.01.2023 and 10.01.2023. At this time, in the winter night of the month of January, people are not present on the roads, even scarcely, leave alone, in abundance. Therefore, the deposition of the IO PW 8 ASI Narender Dhama in his crossexamination that no public persons were present at the spot at that time, is totally believable. 42. The site plan Ex. PW 8/B, no doubt, does not bear the FIR No. 46/2023 : PS S.P. Badli page 26 of 31 -- 26 of 31 -- SC No. 322/2023 State Vs. Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit etc signature of the complainant, but the site plan, in itself, is so exhaustive that absence of the signatures of the complainant on the same, do not make the authenticity of the site plan, come under scanner. The place of the incident is not disputed and it is shown in the site plan very clearly, and it is also not in dispute that the incident did not take place at the relevant place i.e. milk shop of the complainant. Therefore, there is no doubting the truthfulness of the IO and I find the testimony of the police personnels, who conducted the investigation, reliable, without a shadow of doubt hovering in the periphery. 43. Ld. Counsel for the accused has also contended that no document was produced by the prosecution / complainant that the complainant actually had Rs. 2800/ in his galla, which was robbed. It is to be noted that the complainant was plying his milk shop, from where he was selling milk, curd, paneer and such other milk products. In this area of Sector 18, Rohini, Delhi, people generally use cash for their sale / purchase transactions of petty items like milk, curd, vegetables etc, and for such cash transactions, generally no receipts are issued, to show the earning of the day. Even as on date, small shopkeepers, do their business by way of cash or digital payments through googlepay, PayTM or PhonePe etc. Therefore, an amount of Rs. 2800/ being present in the galla, is not such an FIR No. 46/2023 : PS S.P. Badli page 27 of 31 -- 27 of 31 -- SC No. 322/2023 State Vs. Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit etc amount, which would not be believable. Rather, such a small amount, having been mentioned by the complainant, again goes a long way to show the truthfulness of the witness, who could easily have exaggerated the amount, if he had so wanted. 44. Accordingly, I find that the prosecution has been able to prove its case qua accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit, beyond a shadow of reasonable doubt. OFFENCE U/S 392/394/34 IPC and U/S 397 IPC 45. The accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit has been charge sheeted for the offence punishable u/s 392/394/34 IPC and u/s 397 IPC, and for ready reference the relevant provisions of law are being reproduced herein below : Section 392 Punishment for robbery : Whoever commits robbery shall be punished with rigorous imprisonment for a term which may extend to ten years, and shall also be liable to fine; and, if the robbery be committed on the highway between sunset and sunrise, the imprisonment may be extended to fourteen years. Section 394 Voluntarily causing hurt in committing robbery : If any person, in committing or in attempting to commit robbery, voluntarily causes hurt, such person, FIR No. 46/2023 : PS S.P. Badli page 28 of 31 -- 28 of 31 -- SC No. 322/2023 State Vs. Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit etc and any other person jointly concerned in committing or attempting to commit such robbery, shall be punished with 1 [imprisonment for life], or with rigorous imprisonment for a term which may extend to ten years, and shall also be liable to fine. Section 397 Robbery or dacoity, with attempt to cause death or grievous hurt : If, at the time of committing robbery or dacoity, the offender uses any deadly weapon, or causes grievous hurt to any person, so attempts to cause death or grievous hurt to any person, the imprisonment with which such offender shall be punished shall not be less than seven years. Section 34 IPC 46. Proceeding further, as to the offences, which have been made out, the perusal of the record reveals that accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit, and for that matter, accused Saloni, have been charged for the offences punishable u/s 392/394/34 IPC. It is clear that Section 34 IPC is not a penal section in itself. It defines the common intention when more than one person commit a crime who share intention qua the offence committed. In such cases, this section is applied alongwith the substantive offence. The offence in the present case was committed, with common intention as per the allegations, which manifest in the acts attributed to the accused persons, therefore, Section 34 IPC was applied accordingly. The accused persons are charged for the offence punishable under Section FIR No. 46/2023 : PS S.P. Badli page 29 of 31 -- 29 of 31 -- SC No. 322/2023 State Vs. Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit etc 392/394 IPC which is the penal provision describing the offence too, therefore, the constitution of offence and punishment would be in terms of Section 392/394 IPC. 47. Since the accused Saloni has not been identified by the complainant, firstly during TIP and thereafter in the court, and the identity of the second accused i.e. the girl sitting on the motorcycle of the accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit, as pillion rider, at the relevant time could not been established, and further since the accused Saloni has now expired and proceedings against her have already been abated, section 34 IPC dies a natural death. Therefore, for all purposes, the charge u/s 392/394 IPC and u/s 397 IPC against accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit, now requires to be dealt with. 48. The unflinching testimony of the complainant clearly shows, that after putting him under threat of his life or injury on his body, the accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit committed theft of Rs. 2800/ from his galla. He also stabbed the complainant on his thigh and the injury sustained by the injured as reflected in his MLC, clearly corroborates his version that the theft of Rs. 2800/, actually falls within the ambit of robbery, as envisaged u/s 392 IPC. The very fact that the knife was used for committing the said robbery, makes the offence u/s 394 IPC complete. FIR No. 46/2023 : PS S.P. Badli page 30 of 31 -- 30 of 31 -- SC No. 322/2023 State Vs. Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit etc 49. The complainant sustained the injuries on his thigh with the knife, used by the accused, as is clear from his MLC Ex. PW 3/A, and the said injury was caused voluntarily and intentionally by the accused, making the offence u/s 397 IPC complete. Accordingly, accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit is convicted for the offences punishable u/s 392/394/397 IPC. Accused Saloni has already expired and proceedings against her have already been abated. Announced in the open court today i.e. 23rd February, 2024 (SEEMA MAINI) Principal District & Sessions Judge (North) Rohini Courts, Delhi FIR No. 46/2023 : PS S.P. Badli page 31 of 31 -- 31 of 31 --
