Full Order Text
Final Order 23 · 08 Apr 2024 · CNR DLNT010059052023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: SC No. 322/2023 State Vs. Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit etc IN THE COURT OF MS. SEEMA MAINI PRINCIPAL DISTRICT & SESSIONS JUDGE NORTH DISTRICT: ROHINI COURTS: DELHI In the matter of: (Sessions Case No. 322/2023) CNR No. DLNT010059052023 FIR No. 46/2023 Police Station S.P. Badli Charge sheet filed Under Section 394/397/34 IPC Charges framed Under Section 392/394/34 IPC 397 IPC Convicted Under Section 392/394/397 IPC State V/s 1. Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit S/o Sh. Dayanand R/o C98, Near Masjid, Badli, Delhi. (Convict) 2. Saloni (since deceased & proceedings abated) D/o Krishan H.No. 250, Gali No. 11, A Block, Ambedkar Nagar, Haiderpur, Delhi. Order on Sentence : FIR No. 46/2023 page 1 of 7 PS S.P. Badli -- 1 of 7 -- SC No. 322/2023 State Vs. Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit etc 08.04.2024 ORDER ON SENTENCE 1. Accused Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit has been convicted for the offence punishable u/s 392/394/397 IPC, vide judgment dated 23.02.2024. During trial, the accused Saloni was murdered and proceedings against her stood abated, vide order dated 19.10.2023. I have heard arguments on the point of sentence, advanced at Bar by Ms. Yogita Kaushik, Ld. Addl. Public Prosecutor for the State and Mr. D.K. Pandey, Ld. Counsel for convict Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit. 2. Learned Addl. Public Prosecutor for the State has vehemently argued that the offence committed by the convict in this matter is highly derogatory in nature. It is contended that the convict along with his coaccused Saloni (since deceased), not just robbed the complainant but caused him injuries on his thigh, with a deadly weapon i.e. a knife. It is further contended that the convict was having a clear cut plan for committing robbery, due to which firstly he crossed the shop of the complainant, and after looking around, the convict executed his plan to commit the robbery. It is further contended that soon after committing the robbery upon the complainant in the present case, the convict along with his associate / accused Saloni, committed another crime, wherein they were Order on Sentence : FIR No. 46/2023 page 2 of 7 PS S.P. Badli -- 2 of 7 -- SC No. 322/2023 State Vs. Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit etc apprehended and arrested. It is submitted that the convict is a habitual offender and is involved in many other criminal cases, including the murder case of his coaccused Saloni, he allegedly having committed her murder, after he was released on bail in the present case, and is now in JC in case FIR No. 871/2023, PS. S.P. Badli. Learned Addl. PP has prayed for the maximum punishment prescribed under Section 392/394/397 IPC for the convict, so that the same may act as deterrent for other impending offenders. 3. Per contra, the learned defence counsel for the convict Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit has submitted that convict Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit, is young boy, aged about 24 years, and is unmarried. He has his aged father to look after in his family, as his mother has since expired. It is further stated that he was working as a labour and was able to earn Rs. 5000/ per month. It is further stated that the convict is the sole bread earner in his family. It is prayed that a lenient view be taken. 4. On query from the convict Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit as regards his financial status, he has stated that he is 8th class pass, and belongs to a poor family and is living in a small jhuggi. In his family, he has only his father. He further stated that be belongs to a poor family and would not be able to pay any compensation to the victim / Order on Sentence : FIR No. 46/2023 page 3 of 7 PS S.P. Badli -- 3 of 7 -- SC No. 322/2023 State Vs. Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit etc injured or any fine. 5. Convict Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit has also filed his affidavit of Assets and Incomes, in terms of the judgment in case Karan Vs. State of Delhi, as directed by this court, wherein he has stated that he is 8th class pass and that he does not have any movable or immovable property in his name. 6. Victim Impact Report (VIR) has also been received from Delhi Legal Services Authority (North), Rohini, Delhi, wherein it is reported that the contents as mentioned by the convict in his affidavit, were found correct. Convict has no movable or immovable property in his name and that the father of the convict is living in a jhuggi. 7. As regards, victim / injured, it is reported in the VIR, that the victim does not wish to take any compensation, nor has he ever been granted any compensation by any government agency. 8. As per the mandate of Hon'ble High Court, in case titled Karan Vs. State of NCT Delhi, CRL A 352/2020 dated 17.12.2020, Ld. Chief Prosecutor, NorthDistrict on behalf of the State, has also filed an affidavit, disclosing that a total expense of Rs. 2640/ has been incurred, on prosecution of the present case. Order on Sentence : FIR No. 46/2023 page 4 of 7 PS S.P. Badli -- 4 of 7 -- SC No. 322/2023 State Vs. Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit etc 9. I have given my thoughtful consideration to the arguments advanced at Bar by the Ld. Addl. PP for the State and Ld. Counsel for the convict, considered the submissions made by the convict, and have also considered the facts and circumstances of the case in totality. 10. No doubt the convict is a young person, with his entire life ahead, but his mindset even at this early age, seems to be of a hardened criminal. The leniency of the court wherein he was granted the benefit of bail, was misused by the convict, as he allegedly committed a graver offence than the present one i.e. murder of his associate Saloni, during that time. Every convict, just because of his tender years and less fortunate means, does not deserve leniency in perpetuity. Punishment should be commensurate to the offence committed, so that in future, it may prove as a deterrent to the convict, to commit further crime. 11. Keeping in view the totality of the facts and circumstances in mind, I am of the opinion that ends of justice would be met by sentencing the convicts as under : Order on Sentence : FIR No. 46/2023 page 5 of 7 PS S.P. Badli -- 5 of 7 -- SC No. 322/2023 State Vs. Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit etc Convict Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit Offence u/s 392 IPC Rigorous imprisonment for three years and payment of fine of Rs. 10000/. In default of payment of fine, the convict shall undergo a further simple imprisonment for 60 days. Offence u/s 394 IPC Rigorous imprisonment for five years and payment of fine of Rs. 10000/. In default of payment of fine, the convict shall undergo a further simple imprisonment for 60 days. Offence u/s 397 IPC Rigorous imprisonment for seven years. Benefit of Section 428 CrPC shall be granted to the convict. All the sentences shall run concurrently. Conviction warrant be prepared accordingly. 12. Though as per the affidavit submitted by the Ld. Chief PP for the State, an expense of Rs. 2640/ has been incurred by the State on the prosecution of the present case, but keeping in view the financial capacity and the fine already imposed upon the convict, the State is left to bear its own expenses. 13. Compensation : Victim has not been awarded any Order on Sentence : FIR No. 46/2023 page 6 of 7 PS S.P. Badli -- 6 of 7 -- SC No. 322/2023 State Vs. Puneet @ Arjun @ Vinit etc compensation by DLSA or any other government authority. As per report submitted by DLSA, the victim is an exservice man and is getting sufficient pension from his department and is not willing to get any compensation. Accordingly, keeping in view all the facts and circumstances of the case, including the fact that the convicts hails from lower strata of society, and that the victim has refused to get any compensation, no compensation is being awarded to the victim / injured. 14. Copy of the Judgment and Order on Sentence be supplied to the convict. Convict is informed of his right to prefer an appeal against the judgment and Order on Sentence. He has been apprised that if he cannot afford to engage an Advocate, he can approach the Legal Aid Cell, Tihar Jail or write to Secretary, Delhi High Court, Legal Services Committee, 3437, Lawyer Chamber Block, High Court of Delhi. Announced in the open court today i.e. on 08.04.2024 (SEEMA MAINI) Principal District & Sessions Judge (North) Rohini Courts, Delhi. Order on Sentence : FIR No. 46/2023 page 7 of 7 PS S.P. Badli -- 7 of 7 --
