Full Order Text
Order 9 · 03 Sept 2024 · CNR DLNT010052322023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: CS DJ 357/23 VIJAY KUMAR JAIN & ANR. VS. VIJAY GARG & ORS. 03.09.2024 Present: Counsel for plaintiffs. Counsel for D-1 to D-5. Sh. G.S. Bhatia and Sh. Anirudh Garg, counsel(s) for D-6/DDA. Heard. Perused. 1. Case is today fixed for orders on an application filed by D-1 and D-3 u/o 7 rule 11 CPC read with Order 7 rule 10 CPC read with Section 151 of CPC, seeking rejection of plaint or in the alternative for return of plaint for want of pecuniary jurisdiction. 2. Arguments on said application were heard. I have perused the record carefully. 3. The facts necessary for disposal of application in hand in brief are that the plaintiffs have filed the present suit for possession as well as permanent injunction. In plaint, plaintiffs have claimed that their grand father had purchased the suit property i.e. agricultural land measuring 9 bigha and 12 biswa comprised in khasra no. 74 (4-16) and 75 (4-16) in village Siras Pur, North District, Delhi, from its erstwhile owner through two registered sale deeds. Mutation of said land was duly sanctioned in the name of grand father of plaintiffs. Grand father of plaintiffs was cultivating crops on said land. The inheritance-mutation in the name of plaintiffs was also sanctioned by ADM (North) on 26.07.2021. Hence, plaintiffs are the recorded _____________________________________________________________ CS DJ 357/23 VIJAY KUMAR JAIN & ANR. VS. VIJAY GARG & ORS. PAGE 1 OF 8 -- 1 of 8 -- owners of said land. The plaintiffs had obtained Fard of said land and after obtaining the same they had visited the suit land on 30.08.2021 and found that some musclemen were sitting on the same and they were claiming to be occupier of said land. D-1 to D-5 are claiming to be Asamis of said land. However, the said claim has become infructuous as the village in question has been urbanized on 17.05.2017 and after urbanization DLR Act, 1954 has ceased to apply on the suit land. Plaintiffs have further claimed that they apprehend that D-1 and D-2 could create third party interest in the suit property and hence they have filed the present suit for possession as well as permanent injunction. 4. Summons of the suit were duly served upon defendants. Defendants have filed their written statement denying the aforesaid claims of plaintiffs. In their written statement defendants have taken various objections and have prayed for dismissal of present suit. 5. D-1 and D-3 have also filed the present application i.e. u/o 7 rule 11 CPC read with Order 7 rule 10 CPC read with Section 151 of CPC, seeking rejection of plaint or in the alternative for return of plaint for want of pecuniary jurisdiction on the ground that the present suit has not been properly valued and proper/appropriate court fees has not been affixed. In said application, it is further mentioned that this court lacks pecuniary jurisdiction to entertain and try the present suit. 6. Sh. S. Chaturvedi, Ld. Counsel for D-1 and D-3/applicants vehemently argued that it is not in dispute _____________________________________________________________ CS DJ 357/23 VIJAY KUMAR JAIN & ANR. VS. VIJAY GARG & ORS. PAGE 2 OF 8 -- 2 of 8 -- that the village in question has been urbanized. After urbanization, the land in question/suit property has ceased to be agricultural land. The value of the suit for the purposes of relief of decree of possession is Rs. 18,84,37,189/- (Rupees Eighteen Crores Eighty Four Lakhs Thirty Seven Thousand One Hundred Eighty Nine only). Ld. Counsel further argued that after urbanization of said land the value of the suit for the relief of possession is to be assessed as per the market value of the same. Hence, the present suit is liable to be rejected or returned to the plaintiff for being presented before the court having pecuniary jurisdiction over the same. Ld. Counsel has also relied upon following judgments :- a) CS (OS) 165/2018, “Sanraj Farms Private Limited Vs. sh. Charan Singh & Another”, of Hon’ble High Court of Delhi, decided on 24.08.2022; and b) C.A. No. 2758/2013 arising out of SLP(C) No. 15094/2011, “Santosh Ramchandra Tadsare Vs. Subhash Ramchandra Gujjar & Ors.” of Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, decided on 18.03.2013. 7. On the other hand, Sh. Abhay Dixit, Ld. Counsel for plaintiffs/non-applicants vehemently argued that the application in hand is without merits and the same is liable to be dismissed with heavy cost. Ld. Counsel argued that merely because the village in question has been urbanized ipso facto does not mean that the agricultural land has lost its nature of being an agricultural land. Ld. Counsel further argued that the sub-registrar concerned is still registering agricultural land of village Siras Pur, Delhi, as _____________________________________________________________ CS DJ 357/23 VIJAY KUMAR JAIN & ANR. VS. VIJAY GARG & ORS. PAGE 3 OF 8 -- 3 of 8 -- agricultural land in Municipal Corporation area at the same uniform circle rate of Rs. 53 Lakh per acre. The owners of private agricultural land in Delhi have option to keep their land as agricultural land in view of DDA Gazette Notification No. S.O.3249 (E), dated 04.04.2018. Ld. Counsel has drawn the attention of this court towards the various grounds mentioned in detailed reply filed by plaintiffs qua the present application. Ld. Counsel has relied upon following judgments :- a) CA No. 5126/2019, “Madhav Prasad Aggarwal & Ors. Vs. Axis Bank Ltd. & Ors.”, decided on 01.07.2019, MANU/SC/0878/2019; b) CA No. 7413/2023, “Geetha Vs. Nanjundaswamy & Ors., decided on 31.10.2023, MANU/SC/1199/2023; c) CA No. 10802/2017, “Sejal Glass Ltd. Vs. Navilan Merchants Pvt. Ltd.” decided on 21.08.2017, MANU/SC/1098/2017; d) CA No. 5077/1998, “Nasiruddin & Ors. Vs. Sita Ram Agarwal”, decided on 28.01.2003, MANU/SC/0100/2003; e) CA Nos. 2552 to 2556 of 1969, :Commissioner of Wealth Tax, Andhra Pradesh Vs. Officer-In-Charge (Court of Wards), Paigah”, decided on 06.08.1976; f) CR No. 7753/2012, “Hardam Singh Vs. Angrej Singh & Ors.”, decided on 22.07.2013; and g) CA Nos. 2811-2813 of 2010 (arising out of SLP (C) Nos. 6745-47/2009) “Suhrid Singh Vs. Randhir Singh & Ors.”, decided on 29.03.2010. 8. I have carefully perused the aforesaid judgments upon which reliance has been placed by Ld. Counsel(s) for _____________________________________________________________ CS DJ 357/23 VIJAY KUMAR JAIN & ANR. VS. VIJAY GARG & ORS. PAGE 4 OF 8 -- 4 of 8 -- the parties. I have also perused the written arguments filed on behalf of plaintiffs. 9. Order 7 rule 10 CPC is being reproduced herein for sake of convenience and ready reference :- 10. Return of plaint. (1) Subject to the provisions of rule 10A, the plaint shall at any stage of the suit be returned to be presented to the Court in which the suit should have been instituted. Explanation- For the removal of doubts, it is hereby declared that a Court of appeal or revision may direct, after setting aside the decree passed in a suit, the return of the plaint under this sub-rule. (2) procedure on returning plaint- On returning a plaint, the Judge shall endorse thereon the date of its presentation and return, the name of the party presenting it, and a brief statement of the reasons for returning it. 10. Order 7 Rule 11 CPC is also being reproduced herein for the sake of convenience and ready reference :- 11. Rejection of plaint. – The plaint shall be rejected in the following cases :- (a) where it does not disclose a cause of action; (b) where the relief claimed is undervalued, and the plaintiff, on being required by the Court to correct the valuation within a time to be fixed by the Court, fails to do so; (c) where the relief claimed is properly valued but the plaint is written upon paper insufficiently stamped, and the plaintiff, on being required by the Court to supply the requisite stamp paper within a time to be fixed by the Court, fails to do so; (d) where the suit appears from the statement in the plaint to be barred by any law; (e) where it is not filed in duplicate; (f) where the plaintiff fails to comply with the provisions of rule 9; _____________________________________________________________ CS DJ 357/23 VIJAY KUMAR JAIN & ANR. VS. VIJAY GARG & ORS. PAGE 5 OF 8 -- 5 of 8 -- Provided that the time fixed by the Court for the correction of the valuation or supplying of requisite stamp-paper shall not be extended unless the Court, for reasons to be recorded, is satisfied that the plaintiff was prevented by any cause of an exceptional nature for correcting the valuation or supplying, the requisite stamp-paper, as the case may be, within the time fixed by the Court and that refusal to extend such time would cause grave injustice to the plaintiff. 11. Para-33 of plaint i.e. pertaining to valuation etc. is also being reproduced herein for sake of convenience and ready reference :- “13. That the value of the suit land for the purposes of Permanent Injunction is assessed as Rs.3,00,000/-. That the value of the suit land for the purposes of possession is assessed as on the land revenue fixed @ Rs. 18.93/- for 68 Bigha 5 Biswa land which comes to Rs. 2.60/- for the suit land as per column 8 of the Khatoni (Collector”s Register), copy of which is annexed herewith as Page 58.” 12. Hon’ble High Court of Delhi in Sanraj Farm’s case (supra) has held as under :- “19. After hearing the arguments on behalf of the parties and perusing the documents on record, it is clear that the land in question already stands urbanized. The law in this regard is very clear that once the land has been urbanized, the Delhi Land Reforms Act ceases to apply to the said area. In view of the aforesaid, the calculation by the SDM, Vasant Vihar on the basis that the land in question is agricultural and applying the circle rates for agricultural land, cannot be accepted. 20. Perusal of the documents on record show that the land in question falls in „H category and the rate for ‟ calculation of stamp duty is Rs.23,280/- per sq. mtr., since the land use of the area is now residential as noted above. _____________________________________________________________ CS DJ 357/23 VIJAY KUMAR JAIN & ANR. VS. VIJAY GARG & ORS. PAGE 6 OF 8 -- 6 of 8 -- 21. In view of the aforesaid, SDM, Vasant Vihar may make the calculations taking the land as falling in “H” category and the calculations be done accordingly, treating the land as residential in nature.” 13. I have carefully perused each and every judgment upon which reliance has been placed by Ld. Counsel for the plaintiffs. There can be no disagreement with the law laid down in the aforesaid judgments, however, the facts and circumstances of said judgments are far different than the facts and circumstances of present case. In the facts and circumstances of present case, the said judgments have no applicability and the said judgments are distinguishable on facts. The facts and circumstances of present case are very similar to the Sanraj Farm’s case (supra) and the judgment pronounced by Hon’ble High Court of Delhi in said case squarely covers/answers the question in hand. 14. It is admitted case of plaintiffs that the land in question and even the village in question has been urbanized. After urbanization, DLR Act 1954 has ceased to apply on the suit land. The suit property has not only been urbanized but the same has been included within the MCD. The land in question falls in ‘H’ category of the circle rates, issued by Govt. of NCT of Delhi and the minimum value for the land falling in ‘H’ Category of municipal area is Rs. 23,280/- per square meter. Thus, according to the circle rate of Govt. of NCT of Delhi the value of suit property comes to more than Rs. 18 Crores. 15. Keeping in view the aforesaid facts, circumstances as well as discussion made herein above, I am of the considered view that the relief claimed has been _____________________________________________________________ CS DJ 357/23 VIJAY KUMAR JAIN & ANR. VS. VIJAY GARG & ORS. PAGE 7 OF 8 -- 7 of 8 -- undervalued. Hence, the plaintiffs are directed to correct the valuation in aforesaid terms and are further directed to pay appropriate/requisite court fees within a period of one month from today, failing which the consequences as envisaged u/o 7 rule 11 CPC shall follow. 16. Now to come up on 08.10.2024 for further proceedings, as per law. (Deepak Dabas) DJ-1(North)/Rohini Courts Delhi/03.09.2024 _____________________________________________________________ CS DJ 357/23 VIJAY KUMAR JAIN & ANR. VS. VIJAY GARG & ORS. PAGE 8 OF 8 -- 8 of 8 --
