Full Order Text
Final Order 5 · 13 Mar 2024 · CNR DLNT010009122023
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF VIKRAM BALI, ADDITIONAL DISTRICT JUDGE JUDGE, NORTH DISTRICT, ROHINI COURTS, DELHI CS DJ 83/2023 CNR NO. DLNT01-000912-2023 In the matter title as : AJAY KUMAR SHARMA S/O SH. VIJENDER PAL SHARMA R/O E-935, JAHANGIRPURI, DELHI-110033 ......Plaintiff Versus SH. SANJEEV KUMAR S/O SH. DHARMENDER KUMAR R/O D-BLOCK, H. NO. 1705, JAHANGIPURI, DELHI-110033 Also At : Shop No. D-73, (Mother Dairy), Main DDA Market, D-Block, Jahangirpuri, Delhi-110033 ….....Defendant Date of Institution : 27.01.2023 Date of pronouncing judgment: 13.03.2024 SUIT FOR RECOVERY OF RS. 4,44,000/- (RUPEES FOUR LAC FORTY FOUR THOUSAND ONLY) ALONG WITH PENDENT LITE AND FUTURE INTEREST UNDER ORDER XXXVII EX-PARTE JUDGMENT:- 1. Brief facts of the case as stated in the plaint are as follows : - 2. That the present suit has been filed by the plaintiff against defendant seeking recovery of Rs. 4,44,000/- along with pedente lite interest and future CS DJ 83/2023 Ajay Kumar Shamra Vs. Sanjeev Kumar page no. 1 of 5 -- 1 of 5 -- interest. The case was filed under order 37 CPC vide order dated 27.01.2023 summons for settlement of issues as in ordinary suit were issued. 3. It is the case of the plaintiff that Rs.3 lakhs friendly loan was given to the defendant. A written agreement was executed on the same day i.e. 25.01.2021. Payment of Rs. 1 lakh cash was made on 25.01.2021 by the plaintiff to the defendant. Payment of Rs. 2 lakhs was made by the plaintiff through cheque no. 191115 on 27.01.2021 to defendant in his bank account no. 31710476391. 4. It is further the case of the plaintiff that in February 2022 when the plaintiff asked the defendant for return of the money, the defendant had issued a cheque bearing no. 949650 dated 30.03.2022 (From A/c No. 31710476391) for a sum of Rs. 3,00,000/- (Rupees Three Lac Only), drawn on State Bank of India, A-Block, Jahangirpuri, Delhi. That the defendant assured to the plaintiff that the cheque issued by him/defendant shall honored as and when the plaintiff shall present for encashment to his/plaintiff banker. This cheque Ex.PW1/D was returned with remarks dt. 02.04.2022 “drawer’s signature incomplete/differs”. EX PARTE PROCEEDINGS 5. The defendant was duly served. He failed to appear and was proceeded against ex parte vide order dated 18.04.2023. EX PARTE EVIDENCE 6. PW 1 tendered ex parte evidence on 23.09.2023 and closed his evidence. Following evidence was tendered: 1. Certified copy of the said written agreement dated 25.01.2021 (two pages) (colly) and statement of bank account of plaintiff are Ex.PW1/A and Ex.PW1/B. 2. Certified copy of original cheque bearing No.949650 is Ex.PW1/C. CS DJ 83/2023 Ajay Kumar Shamra Vs. Sanjeev Kumar page no. 2 of 5 -- 2 of 5 -- 3. Certified copy of original return memo dated 02.04.2022 is Ex. PW1/D. 4. Certified copy of the complaint dated 12.04.2022 is Ex.PW1/E (three pages) (colly). 5. Certified copy of the legal notice dated 06.04.2022 alongwith copy of original postal receipt and tracking report are Ex.PW1/F (three pages) (colly), Ex.PW1/G and Ex.PW1/H (four pages) (colly). 7. Thereafter, PE was closed. 8. Final arguments heard. Case file perused. 9. It is argued by counsel for the plaintiff that loan of Rs.3 lakhs was given in January 2021. To return the loan, cheque dated 30.03.2022 of Rs.3 lakhs was issued by the defendant. The same was returned unpaid vide memo dated 02.04.2022. 10. Plaintiff examined himself as PW 1 and reiterated the averments of the plaint, the defendants failed to cross-examine the plaintiff as he was ex parte. Hence, the averments of the plaintiff remained unrebutted and unchallenged. Reliance is placed upon Ex.PW 1/B dt. 28.04.2022, to contend that from account of Ajay Kumar Sharma Rs. 2 lakhs were transferred to Sanjeev Kumar on 27.01.2021. It is the case of the plaintiff that remaining loan of Rs.1 lakh was given cash on 25.01.2021. PECUNIARY AND TERRITORIAL JURISDICTION 11. The case is within the pecuniary jurisdiction of this court as for purpose of court fees and jurisdiction this suit is valued as 4,44,000/-. 12. This court has territorial jurisdiction as well. The defendant is resident of Jahangirpuri Delhi which his within the jurisdiction of this court. The amount CS DJ 83/2023 Ajay Kumar Shamra Vs. Sanjeev Kumar page no. 3 of 5 -- 3 of 5 -- was also transferred from District Court Rohini Branch which is within the territorial jurisdiction of this court. Even Agreement by PW 1/A was executed in Rohini within the jurisdiction of this court. FINDINGS 13. It is the case of the plaintiff that loan of Rs. 3 lakhs was given in January 2021. To return the loan cheque dated 30.03.2022 of Rs. 3 lakhs was issued by the defendant. The same was returned unpaid vide memo dated 02.04.2022. The cheque dated 30.03.2022 is Ex.PW 1/C. Return Memo is Ex. PW 1/D. Plaintiff examined himself as PW 1 and reiterated the averments of the plaint. The defendants failed to cross-examine the plaintiff as he was ex parte. Hence, the averments of the plaintiff remained unrebutted and unchallenged. From perusal of Ex.PW 1/B dt. 28.04.2022 it is clear that, from account of Ajay Kumar Sharma Rs. 2 lakhs were transferred to Sanjeev Kumar on 27.01.2021. It is the case of the plaintiff that remaining loan of Rs.1 lakh was given cash on 25.01.2021. This plea of the plaintiff has also gone unrebutted. INTEREST 14. The counsel for the plaintiff has not been able to point out any agreement of interest between the plaintiff and the defendant for the period prior to the suit. The plaintiff is therefore entitled to interest @ 6% per annum from date of filing of suit till realization. 15. The plaintiff is also entitled to costs. CS DJ 83/2023 Ajay Kumar Shamra Vs. Sanjeev Kumar page no. 4 of 5 -- 4 of 5 -- RELIEF 16. The suit of the plaintiff is decreed for a sum of Rs. 3 lakhs with interest @ 6% per annum from the date of filing of the suit till realization with cost. 17. Decree sheet be prepared accordingly. 18. File be consigned to Record Room. Announced in the open Court (Order contains 5 pages) (Vikram Bali) Addl. District Judge-02, North Rohini Court Complex, Rohini Delhi/13.03.2023 CS DJ 83/2023 Ajay Kumar Shamra Vs. Sanjeev Kumar page no. 5 of 5 -- 5 of 5 --
