Skip to main content
Court Order

Final Order 10

CNR DLNT01000861202405 Sept 2026
Back to Case

Full Order Text

Final Order 10 · 05 Sept 2026 · CNR DLNT010008612024

Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT
Pdf Text: DLNT010008612024
IN THE COURT OF SH. SIDHARTH MATHUR
DISTRICT JUDGE (NORTH-01): ROHINI COURTS : DELHI
LAC No. 1/2024
In the matter of:-
Sh. Ran Vir Singh
Sh. Bharpai
R/o VPO Pehlad Pur Banger,
Delhi.
.... Petitioner
Versus
1. UOI
(Union of India)
2. DDA
(Delhi Development Authority)
....... Respondents
1. Under Section : 18 of the Land Acquisition
Act, 1894.
2. Village Name : Prehlad-Pur Banger, Delhi.
3. Date of Acquisition : 21st March, 2003.
4. LAC Award No. : 06/2005-06/DC(N-W).
5. Date of LAC Award : 12th July, 2005.
LAC No. 1/24 page 1 of 7
-- 1 of 7 --
6. Date of Reference : 22nd January, 2024.
7. Date of Judgment : 05th September, 2026.
8. Final Order : Enhancement ordered.
REFERENCE PETITION UNDER SECTION 18 OF
THE LAND ACQUISITION ACT 1894
AWARD
(BY THE COURT U/S 26 OF THE LAND
ACQUISITION ACT- 1894 ON REFERENCE
PETITION U/S 18 OF THE ACT):
1. This reference under Section 18 of the Land Acquisition
Act, 1894 (hereinafter called as LA Act), was sent to the
reference court by the Land Acquisition Collector (hereinafter
referred as LAC).
2. As per the LAC Award, a large tract of land measuring
‘1969 bigha 18 biswa’, Village Prehladpur Banger, Delhi was
acquired by the Govt. for a public purpose namely “Rohini
Residential Scheme”. Notification under Section 4 of The Land
Acquisition Act, 1894 (hereinafter referred to as 'LA Act') was
issued on 21.03.2003. Declaration under Section 6 was made on
19.03.2004. Thereafter, Award bearing no. 06/2005-06/DC(N-
W) was announced by Land Acquisition Collector (hereinafter
referred to as LAC) on 12.07.2005. The LAC was fixed the
price of Block ‘A’ @ Rs. 15.70 lakhs per acre. The remaining
LAC No. 1/24 page 2 of 7
-- 2 of 7 --
Block ‘B’ allegedly comprising of deep pits etc. was notified @
Rs. 14 Lakhs per acre.
3. The petitioner(s) being dissatisfied with the market value
determined by the LAC, filed the present petition u/s 18 of the
LA Act, seeking reference to this court. The Land Acquisition
Collector forwarded the same to this court, for adjudication.
4. The brief facts of the petitioner's case are that petitioner(s)
was the owner/bhumidar and in cultivatory possession of the
land bearing khasra numbers as mentioned in the statement u/s
19 of the LA Act that was annexed with the present reference
and admitted by the petitioner(s) during the stage of admission-
denial of documents, situated within the Revenue Estate of
Village Prehladpur Banger, Delhi (the said land). The said land
was acquired vide notification dated 21.03.2003.
5. The case of the petitioner(s) can be summed up by stating
that the award was bad due to inadequacy of compensation and
incorrect assessment of market value of land inter-alia due to
non-consideration of relevant factors like potentiality and
fertility of the suit land, the surrounding colonies and developed
areas, the market value of the adjoining areas/villages, the sale
deeds of other lands of the contemporary period, nearness to the
National Highway and industrial areas, the amenities available in
the suit land etc.
LAC No. 1/24 page 3 of 7
-- 3 of 7 --
6. The petitioner(s) has prayed compensation at enhanced
rate besides interest thereon and solatium in addition to the
compensation.
7. The respondent no.1/the Union of India (UOI)/Land
Acquisition Collector and respondent no.2/ DDA contested the
reference petition by filing their respective Written Statements.
8. The petition has been contested mainly on the ground that
the LAC awarded adequate compensation to the petitioner(s)
after taking into consideration all the relevant factors and
therefore, LAC has correctly assessed the market value of the
land after taking into account the market rates prevailing at the
time of notification under Section 4 of LA Act.
9. During the stage of admission-denial of documents,
counsel for the petitioner(s) admitted the statement given u/s 19
of the Act. The following issues were framed:-
i) Whether the petitioner is entitled to enhancement in
compensation, if so, to what amount? OPP.
ii) Relief.
10. In evidence, the counsel for the petitioner(s), on behalf of
the petitioner(s), has relied upon the judgment in a case “ Ashok
Kumar Vs. Union of India & Ors.” LAC No. 19/2018, and also
the evidence led in said case.
11. The respondent no.1/Union of India, in its evidence,
LAC No. 1/24 page 4 of 7
-- 4 of 7 --
tendered the award as Ex. R1. The respondent no. 2/DDA
adopted the evidence led on behalf of the respondent no.1/ Union
of India.
12. I have heard the Ld. Counsels for the parties and have also
carefully considered the record. My issue-wise findings are given
as under:-
FINDINGS ON ISSUE NO. 1 :-
13. Petitioner(s) has contended that valuation of land
determined by LAC is not reasonable as LAC has not adopted
the correct method of valuation. Ld. Counsel for the petitioner(s)
has relied upon the judgment titled as “Ashok Kumar & Anr. Vs.
UOI & Ors.” bearing LAC No. 19/2018 passed by the
undersigned, and conceded that award be passed in terms of the
said judgment and the same enhancement which was granted in
the said judgment be also granted to petitioner(s).
14. In the aforesaid case, this Court had adjudicated the
‘uniform’ market value of the entire land of the petitioner(s)
covered by Award No. 06/2005-06/DC(N-W) as Rs. 19,80,750/-
per acre by setting aside the classification of the lands done by
the LAC in Block A & B. It was thus held therein that the
aforesaid price shall apply uniformly & equally to whole of the
acquired land covered by the Award no. 06/2005-06/DC(N-W)
irrespective of being classified as Block ‘A’ & ‘B’. The
LAC No. 1/24 page 5 of 7
-- 5 of 7 --
petitioner(s) is accordingly entitled to the same compensation for
his land as was awarded in Ashok Kumar’s case. I accordingly
adjudicate the ‘uniform’ market value of the entire land of the
petitioner(s) covered by Award No. 06/2005-06/DC(N-W) as Rs.
19,80,750/- per acre.
15. Besides above, petitioner(s) shall be entitled to other
statutory benefits under the LA Act viz. 12% additional amount
[as per Section 23 (1A)] and 30% solatium [u/s 23 (2)] and will
be entitled to interest under Section 28 of L.A Act on the fair
market value @ 9% per annum for the first year and @ 15% for
subsequent year till the making of payment of enhanced
compensation by LAC as per provision of Section 28 of the Act.
Issue no. 1 is decided accordingly.
Findings on Issue No.2 – RELIEF
In view of the findings on Issue no.1, the petitioner/s are
granted the following reliefs: -
1. Fair market value @ Rs.19,80,750/- per acre uniformly for
the whole of the acquired land as per statement u/s 19 of the LA
Act;
2. Additional amount @ 12% per annum on the fair market
value u/s 23 (1A), LA Act, from the date of notification u/s 4,
LA Act till the date of award or dispossession, whichever is
earlier ;
LAC No. 1/24 page 6 of 7
-- 6 of 7 --
3. Solatium @ 30% on the enhanced amount of market value
u/s 23(2), LA Act; and
4. Interest u/s 28 of L.A Act @ 9% per annum for the first
year from the date of dispossession and, at the rate of 15% per
annum on the difference between the enhanced compensation
awarded by this court and the compensation awarded by the
LAC for the subsequent period till its payment.
16. The share(s) of the petitioner(s) would be determinable as
per the statement u/s 19 of the L.A. Act proved on record and the
said statement shall constitute a part of this award.
17. Reference petition stands answered. Parties to bear their
own costs. A copy of this award be sent to the LAC for
necessary information, action and expeditious compliance for
remittance of the amount. File be consigned to record room.
Announced in the Open Court
Today on 5th Day of September, 2026.
(SIDHARTH MATHUR)
District Judge-01/North District
Rohini Courts/Delhi
LAC No. 1/24 page 7 of 7
-- 7 of 7 --

TrustJury presents public court-record information for legal discovery and reference. Record availability and detail can vary by source and case.