Full Order Text
Final Order 13 · 06 May 2025 · CNR DLNT010005232023
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SH. SUNIL KUMAR: PRESIDING OFFICER MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL - 01 NORTH DISTRICT, ROHINI COURTS, DELHI MACT no. 40/23 CNR No. DLNT0100 0523 2023 PS Mahendra Park FIR no.750/21 Babu Ji Dubey (injured / petitioner) S/o Sh. Dadhibal Doobe, R/o Darjin Purwa, Disgit Purwa, Post Gangwal, Prayagpur, Bahraich, UP Versus 1. Sahrukh Khan (driver / respondent no. 1) S/o Ishak Khan R/o Village / PO Mancha, PS / Teh. Kishangarh Bas, District Alwar, Rajasthan. 2. Akbar Khan (owner / respondent no. 2) S/o Khushi Mohammad R/o H. No. 540, Ward No. 1, Hamid Colony Nuh Mewat, Haryana. Also at: R/o Village / PO Mancha, PS / Teh. Kishangarh Bas, District Alwar, Rajasthan. 3. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. (insurer / respondent no. 3). 81, NEB Subhash Nagar, Alwar, Rajasthan. DATE OF INSTITUTION : 17.01.2023 DATE OF JUDGMENT : 06.05.2025 FORM – XVII COMPLIANCE OF THE PROVISIONS OF THE SCHEME TO BE MENTIONED IN THE AWARD, AS PER JUDGMENT PASSED IN RAJESH TYAGI & ORS. VERSUS JAIBIR SINGH & ORS. FAO 842/2003 Page no. 1 MACT no. 40/23 Babu Ji Dubey Vs. Sahrukh Khan & Ors. -- 1 of 13 -- 1. Date of the accident 26.06.2021 2. Date of filing of Form-I First Accident Report (FAR) Not available 3. Date of delivery of Form-II to victim(s) Not available 4. Date of receipt of Form-III from the driver Not available 5. Date of receipt of Form-IV from the owner Not available 6. Date of filing of the Form-V Interim Accident Report(IAR) Not available 7. Date of receipt of Form-VIA and Form VI B from the victim(s) Not available 8. Date of filing of Form-VII Detailed Accident Report(DAR) 17.01.2023 9. Whether there was any delay or deficiency on the part of the Investigating Officer? If so, whether any action/direction warranted? Yes. Notices are being sent to the DCP, ACP and SHO concerned in this regard. 10. Date of appointment of the Designated Officer by the insurance Company. Not appointed. 11. Whether the designated Officer of the Insurance Company submitted his report within 30 days of the DAR? No designated officer has been appointed. 12. Whether there was any delay or deficiency on the part of the Designated Officer of the Insurance Company? If so, whether any action/direction warranted? No designated officer has been appointed. 13. Date of response of the claimant to the offer of the Insurance Company . No offer has been filed. 14. Date of the Award 06.05.2025 15. Whether the claimant(s) was/were directed to open saving bank account near his/her place of residence? Yes 16. Date of order by which claimant(s) was/were directed to open saving bank account near his/her place of residence and produce PAN Card and Aadhar Card and the direction to the bank not issue any cheque book/debit card to the claimant and make an endorsement to this effect on the passbook(s). 06.05.2022 Page no. 2 MACT no. 40/23 Babu Ji Dubey Vs. Sahrukh Khan & Ors. -- 2 of 13 -- 17. Date on which the claimant(s) produced the passbook of their saving bank account near the place of his/her residence along with the endorsement, PAN Card and Aadhar Card? Not produced. 18. PAN Card Number of claimant Not produced 19. Permanent Residential Address of the Claimant(s) As above. 20. Whether the claimant(s) saving bank account(s) is near his/her place of residence? Particulars not furnished. 21. Whether the claimant was examined at the time of passing of the award. Not appeared. AWARD 1. Vide this order I shall dispose off the 'Detailed Accident Report' (hereinafter referred to as 'DAR') filed by the police with regard to the accident occurred on 26.06.2021 in which injured Baby Ji Dubey (hereinafter referred to as 'petitioner') suffered injuries. DAR was treated as claim petition under Section 166 (4) of M.V. Act. Copy of DAR was supplied the petitioner as well as to Sahrukh Khan (hereinafter referred to as 'respondent no. 1'), Akbar Khan (hereinafter referred to as ‘respondent no. 2’) and Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as 'respondent no. 3') i.e. driver, owner and insurance company of vehicle involved in the accident i.e. motorcycle bearing registration no. HR55AK 2093 (hereinafter referred to as 'vehicle in question'). 2. In brief, the facts of the case are that during the investigation, the Investigating Officer has recorded the statement of injured Babu Ji Dubey, which is reproduced us under:- “On 26/06/21 at around 6.15 PM in the evening, I along with my cousin Pawan S/o Kanhaiya went to Shed No. 11 fruits Mandi Azadpur Delhi Shri Vinayak I had come to fruits Shop No. A 1060 to offer mangoes to him. I was standing at Shed No. 11 Shri Vinayak Fruits, Pawan was also standing near me. At this time, the driver of truck No. HR 55 AK-2093 TATA 1512 reversed his truck very fast and carelessly without turning on the horn and lights. The rear axle of which was open and I got injured near the ankle of my right leg and other parts of the body and my leg started bleeding. When I shouted, the driver of truck No. HR 55 Page no. 3 MACT no. 40/23 Babu Ji Dubey Vs. Sahrukh Khan & Ors. -- 3 of 13 -- AK2093 moved his truck forward and parked it near Shed No. 10 and fled from the spot. My cousin Pawan brought me to BIRM Hospital Jahangirpuri Delhi for treatment from where I was referred to Safderjung Hospital for further treatment” 3. Respondents no. 1 and 2 have not filed any reply / written statement despite giving opportunity and stopped appearing. They were proceeded ex-parte and their defence was struck off vide order dated 27.05.2023. 4. Respondent 3 / Ins. Co. in its written statement / reply denied its liability on certain technical grounds but it is admitted that the vehicle in question was duly insured with it as on the date of accident. 5. After completion of pleadings, the following issues were framed vide order dated 27.05.2023, by the Ld. Predecessor: - 1. Whether the injured Sh. Babu Ji Dubey suffered injuries in road traffic accident on 26.06.2021 at about 6:15 PM at Shed No. 11, Shri Vinayak Fruits, Azadpur Mandi, Delhi within the jurisdiction of PS Mahendra Park due to rashness and negligence on the part of Sh. Shahrukh Khan who was driving vehicle i.e. Truck bearing registration no. HR55- AK-2093 owned by Sh. Akbar Khan and insured with the Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd.? OPP. 2. Whether the petitioner / injured is entitled to compensation if so, what amount and from whom of respondents? OPP. 3. Relief. 6. In order to prove the claim, petitioner examined himself as PW1 and filed his affidavit Ex. PW1/A in evidence. Respondents no. 1 and 2 opted not to lead RE and remained ex-parte. Respondent no. 3 examined Ms. Promila its Dy. Manager as R3W1. 7. I have heard Ld. counsel appearing on behalf of petitioner and counsel for respondent no. 3 / Ins. Co. None has appeared on behalf respondents no. 1 & 2 for advancing final arguments. Page no. 4 MACT no. 40/23 Babu Ji Dubey Vs. Sahrukh Khan & Ors. -- 4 of 13 -- 8. Accordingly, my issue-wise findings are as under:- ISSUE NO.1 Whether the injured Sh. Babu Ji Dubey suffered injuries in road traffic accident on 26.06.2021 at about 6:15 PM at Shed No. 11, Shri Vinayak Fruits, Azadpur Mandi, Delhi within the jurisdiction of PS Mahendra Park due to rashness and negligence on the part of Sh. Shahrukh Khan who was driving vehicle i.e. Truck bearing registration no. HR55-AK-2093 owned by Sh. Akbar Khan and insured with the Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd.? OPP. Onus to prove this issue was upon the petitioner and to prove the same, petitioner examined himself as PW1. Petitioner as PW1 has deposed that on 26.06.2021 he along with his cousin Pawan came at Fruits, Shop No. 1060, Shed No.11, Azadpur Fruit Mandi to load Mangoes on truck. He was standing near Sh. Vinayak Fruits, Shed No.11. His cousin Pawan also standing with him. At that time, the truck driver of vehicle bearing No. HR 55 AK 2093 TATA 1512 (vehicle in question) in rash and negligent manner without horn, without light indication drove backward his truck. The dalla of the offending vehicle was opened and the said daala fell on the ankle of his right foot, due to which he sustained grievous injury and some injury on other parts of his body. When he shouted, the driver of the offending vehicle bearing no. HR 55 AK 2093 drove his vehicle forward and parked the same near the Shed No.11 and the driver of the said vehicle ran away from the spot. His cousin brother Pawan put him on hathrehari (hand cart) and took him to BJRM Hospital, Jahangir Puri, Delhi from where he was referred to Safderjung Hospital for treatment. Petitioner / PW1 has not at all been cross examined by respondents no. 1 & 2. Further, neither respondent no. 1 nor respondent no. 2 have have filed their written statement nor examined themselves or any other witness to prove that respondent no. 1 was not rash or negligent or that accident had occurred due to negligence on the part of petitioner nor any written statement / reply filed by them, meaning thereby that they have nothing to say about the rash and negligence on the part of respondent no. 1 and the manner Page no. 5 MACT no. 40/23 Babu Ji Dubey Vs. Sahrukh Khan & Ors. -- 5 of 13 -- in which the accident had occurred as stated by PW1. In cross examination of PW1 / petitioner by respondent no. 3 / Ins. Co. nothing material has come on record to disbelieve the testimony of PW1 / petitioner, as he being injured is natural eye- witness of accident. Further, the DAR collectively Ex. PW1/6 shows that respondent no.1 was charge sheeted by the police for offences punishable under Section 279/338 IPC. Apart from deposition of PW1, the fact that petitioner suffered injuries in the accident is also supported by his medical documents MLC etc. filed along with the DAR collectively Ex. PW1/6. Respondent no. 1 has not placed on record any document to disprove the factum of rash and negligent driving by him. Further, there is nothing on record which shows that respondent no. 1 has ever approached to any higher authority against false his implication in the present case. Relying upon judgment in Pushpabai Purshottam Udeshi & Ors vs Ranjit Ginning & Pressing Co. (P) Ltd. & Anr. 1977 (2) SCC 745 Civil Appeal No. 2071 of 1968, decided on March 25, 1977 by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India wherein it was held as under: - “The general purport of the words res ipsa loquitur is that the accident "speaks for itself" or tell's its own story. There are cases in which the accident speaks for itself so that it is sufficient for the plaintiff to prove the accident and nothing more. It will then be for the defendant to establish that the accident happened due to some other cause than his own negligence. Salmond on the Law of Torts (15th Ed.) at p. 306 states: "The maxim res ipsa loquitur applies whenever it is so improbable that such an accident would have happened without the negligence of the defendant that a reasonable jury could find without further evidence that it was so caused." In Halsbury's Laws of England, 3rd Ed., Vol. 28, at p. 77, the position is stated thus: "An exception to the general rule that the burden of proof of the alleged negligence is in the first instance on the plaintiff occurs wherever the facts already established are such that .the proper and natural inference arising from them is ,that the injury complained of was caused by the defendant's negligence, or where the event charged as negligence "tells its own story' of negligence on the part of the defendant, the story so told being clear and unambiguous." Further, relying upon the judgment of Mahila Dhanvanti and Ors Vs. Phulwant Mahendra Singh, Miscellaneous Appeal no.239/1992 decided by Hon'ble Madhya Pradesh High Court on 29.07.1993 in which it is held as under: - Page no. 6 MACT no. 40/23 Babu Ji Dubey Vs. Sahrukh Khan & Ors. -- 6 of 13 -- “The plaintiff can prove the accident but cannot prove how it happened to establish negligence. This hardship is to be avoided by applying the principle of res ipsa loquitur. The general purport of the words res ipsa loquitur is that the accident speaks for itself or tells its own story”. Thus, Claims Tribunal while dealing with the law of torts in motor accident cases applies the principle of “res ipsa loquitur”. Considering all this, it stands proved that accident in question occurred due to rash and negligent driving of offending vehicle by the respondent no. 1 and petitioner suffered grievous injuries in the said accident The issue no. 1 is accordingly decided in favour of petitioner and against the respondents holding that the accident in question occurred due to rash and negligent driving of offending vehicle by the respondent no. 1 and petitioner suffered injuries in the said accident. ISSUE NO. 2 Whether the petitioner / injured is entitled to compensation if so, what amount and from whom of respondents? OPP. 9. As far as the issue with respect to right to claim compensation is concerned, being injured, petitioner is natural eye-witness of accident and is well within his rights to claim compensation from the respondents. Accordingly, the question of right of the injured for claiming of compensation is decided in favour of the petitioner. Now, the second part of the issue in hand with respect to the quantum of compensation is to be adjudicated and below are the finding: - 10. It is deposed by the petitioner as PW1 that he was earning Rs. 30,000-40,000/- per month and due to this accident he suffered loss of income and claimed a sum of Rs.2 lacs towards loss of earning, Rs. 30,000/- each towards conveyance amount and special diet, Rs. 1 lac each for pain & suffering, enjoyment of life and loss of impairment, Rs. 50,000/- for mental agony, Rs. 1 lac each loss of pleasure and disfigurement, Rs. 30,000/- towards attendant charges and Rs. 1 lac on marriage Page no. 7 MACT no. 40/23 Babu Ji Dubey Vs. Sahrukh Khan & Ors. -- 7 of 13 -- prospects. Medical bills proved and placed on record are of Rs. 58,375/- and during the arguments, Ld. Counsel for petitioner stated at Bar that petitioner was having no mediclaim policy and above sated amount of medical bills has not been got reimbursed from any authority. Accordingly, this amount of Rs. 58,375/- is awarded to the petitioner towards medical expenditure. Though, except deposition of petitioner, there is no evidence to verify that petitioner has spent any amount on special diet and no witness has been examined for proving the conveyance expenditure etc. However, keeping in view the nature of injuries sustained by the petitioner and his long treatment record, this tribunal is of the opinion that the petitioner must have incurred expenses on special diet required for his speedy recovery as well as on travel to hospitals etc. Accordingly, Rs.20,000/- each towards special diet and conveyance. 11. It is a matter of record that a disability certificate issued by the Department of Empowerment of persons with Disabilities, Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment, Government of India Ex. PW1/3 placed and proved on record as per which the petitioner is a case of locomotor disability and has suffered 40% permanent disability in relation to his right foot. No rebuttal evidence has been led by any of the respondents against the said disability certificate. Since the said disability certificate has been issued by the medical board of a government hospital, the Tribunal has no reason to disbelieve the same despite the fact that the said assessment was conducted without any direction of this Tribunal. 12. As far as loss of income during the treatment and loss of income on account of loss of future earning due to disability is concerned, through petitioner as PW1 deposed that he was earning Rs. 30,000-40,000/- per month but admittedly there is no document to prove the contention except deposition of petitioner. Hence, the income of petitioner could not be proved on record and no document with regard to education qualification of petitioner has been filed on record. The contention of respondent no. 3 / Ins. Co. is that the petitioner is resident of UP and hence if any compensation is granted to the petitioner, minimum wages of Uttar Pradesh may be Page no. 8 MACT no. 40/23 Babu Ji Dubey Vs. Sahrukh Khan & Ors. -- 8 of 13 -- considered. No doubt, even petitioner has admitted that he is resident of Uttar Pradesh but petitioner as PW1 has specifically deposed that he was working in Azadpur Mandi and even accident has occurred in Azadpur Mandi, Delhi but despite that Ins. Co. has not brought any rebuttal evidence that petitioner was not working in Delhi at the time of accident. Furthermore, as per DAR filed by the IO, the petitioner was residing at Shop No. D196, Azadpur Sabji Mandi, Delhi at that time. Hence, contention of respondent no. 3 / Ins. Co. is not tenable in this regard and rejected. In such scenario, to calculate the extent of compensation with respect to his loss of income during the period of treatment and loss to future earning, the minimum wages of unskilled labour, at that prevalent time has to be taken, which was Rs.15,908/-, in Delhi and same is taken for purpose of calculating the loss of income during treatment and future loss of income. 13. Considering the testimony of PW1 and long treatment record of petitioner, it is presumed that petitioner could not continue his work during his treatment i.e. about 6 months. Accordingly, a sum of Rs. 95,448/- (15,908x6) for loss of income during the period of his treatment for 6 months and during this period he must have taken the services of an attendant and hence a sum of Rs.30,000/- (5000x6) for 6 months, towards attendant charges are awarded to the petitioner. 14. As per Ex. PW1/1 i.e. Aadhar card of petitioner, his date of birth is 01.01.1994, which inter alias means that petitioner was 27 years and 5 months in age at the time of accident and as stated above, petitioner suffered 40% permanent disability, no doubt, this kind of disability would hamper his day to day activity and work for gain. Hence, his functional disability / percentage of loss of earning capacity in relation to disability is taken as 20% qua whole body. A multiplier of 17 (as per the judgment passed by Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in the case of Sarla Verma vs Delhi Transport Corporation, 2009 ACJ 1298) is taken for calculating his loss to future earnings. Further, as per the judgment in the case of National Insurance Company Limited Vs. Pranay Sethi and others, of Hon'ble Supreme Court, petitioner is also entitled to get 40% of enhancement of salary, as he was below 40 years in age Page no. 9 MACT no. 40/23 Babu Ji Dubey Vs. Sahrukh Khan & Ors. -- 9 of 13 -- at the time of accident. Counting in this way, his loss to future earnings, comes to Rs.6,49,046.4, details of which are well mentioned in the attached proforma. Accordingly, this amount of Rs. 6,49,046.4, is allowed to petitioner, as loss of future earnings, due to permanent disability. No tax is deducted since the said income of petitioner is not taxable. 15. Further, apart from the above mentioned amounts, petitioner is entitled for compensation regarding mental pain and suffering, disfiguration etc. Accordingly, after giving due weight-age to the totality of the facts and circumstances of the case, a sum of Rs.50,000/- for mental pain and physical shock as well as for pain and suffering due to this accident, Rs. 50,000/- towards loss of amenities of life, Rs.50,000/- for disfiguration, Rs. 2,50,000/- for loss of marriage prospects and Rs.50,000/- for loss of inconvenience, hardship disappointment, frustration, mention stress dejectment and unhappiness in future life etc. are also awarded to the petitioner, making a total sum of Rs.13,22,869.4, details of which is mentioned in the attached proforma. In the light of the above discussion, the aspect of liability of the respondents is to be adjudicated and findings are mentioned below: - 16. Admittedly, the vehicle was insured with respondent no. 3, however respondent no. 3 / Ins. Co. in its written statement has taken certain technical pleas and even examined R3W1 Ms. Promila its Dy. Manager to prove that permit of vehicle in question was not valid as on the date of accident. However, R3W1 in her cross examination admitted it correct that permit of the offending vehicle was National Permit at the time of accident. Further, the plea with regard to the permit of vehicle is a technical ground, which does not show in any manner that expiry of permit is the cause of accident. Further, with regard to renewal of permit Section 81 (5) of M.V. Act reads as under: “Where a permit has been renewed under this section after the expiry of the period thereof, such renewal shall have effect from the date of such expiry irrespective of whether or not a temporary permit has been granted under clause(d) of section 87, and where a temporary permit has been Page no. 10 MACT no. 40/23 Babu Ji Dubey Vs. Sahrukh Khan & Ors. -- 10 of 13 -- granted, the fee paid in respect of such temporary permit shall be refunded. In the light of the above, no statutory defence has been brought on record by which the liability of the Ins. Co. would be exonerated. Accordingly, issue no. 1 is decided in favour of petitioner and against the respondent no.2 / Ins. Co. holding that petitioner is entitled to get compensation from respondent no.2 / Ins. Co. ISSUE NO. 3 (RELIEF) 17. Petition is allowed and an award in the sum of Rs. 15,03,000/- (13,22,869.4 + 1,79,910.22 = 15,02,779.62 rounded up to Rs. 15,03,000/-) which includes 18 months & 4 days interest @ 9% per annum from the date of filing the petition till the date of award is passed in favour of petitioner and against the respondent no. 3, details of which are well mentioned in the attached proforma. 18. Accordingly, respondent no. 3 / Ins. Co. is directed to deposit award amount as compensation in this case within the jurisdiction of this Tribunal at SBI, Rohini Court Branch, Delhi within 30 days from today under intimation of deposition of the awarded amount to be given by respondent no. 3 / Ins. Co. to the petitioner and his advocate as well as to this Tribunal failing which it shall be liable to pay further interest @ 9% per annum on the amount of 13,22,869.4 from the date of award till its realization. DISBURSEMENT 19. Petitioner has not given his statement under Clause 29 of MCTAP. Accordingly, the entire award amount would be kept in interest bearing FDR and order with respect to disbursement would only be passed after petitioner comply with the direction of the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi and after recording his statement under Clause 29 of MCTAP. File be consigned to record room. ANNOUNCED IN THE OPEN (SUNIL KUMAR) COURT ON 06.05.2025 PO:MACT-01, NORTH, ROHINI, DELHI Page no. 11 MACT no. 40/23 Babu Ji Dubey Vs. Sahrukh Khan & Ors. -- 11 of 13 -- 1. FORM – IV B SUMMARY OF COMPUTATION OF AWARD AMOUNT 1 Date of accident 26.06.2021 2 Name of injured Baby Ji Dubey 3 Age of the injured 27 years 4 Occupation of the injured Private work 5 Income of the injured 30000-40000/- per month (not proved) 6 Nature of injury Grievous 7 Medical treatment taken by the injured BRJM Hospital and Safderjung Hospital 8 Period of hospitalization 27.06.2021 to 29.06.2021 9 Whether any permanent disability ? If yes, give details Yes, 40% permanent disability in relation to right foot. 10. Computation of Compensation S.No. Heads Awarded by the Tribunal 11. Pecuniary Loss (i) Expenditure on treatment 58,375/- (ii) Expenditure on conveyance 25,000/- (iii) Expenditure on special diet 25,000/- (iv) Cost of nursing/attendant 30,000 (5000x6) (v) Loss of earning capacity 20% qua whole body. (vi) Loss of income during treatment 95,448(15,908x6) (vii) Any other loss which may require any special treatment or aid to the injured for the rest of his life. Nil. 12. Non-Pecuniary Loss: (I) Compensation for mental and physical shock 50,000/- (ii) Pain and suffering (iii) Loss of amenities of life 50,000/- (iv) Disfiguration 50,000/- (v) Loss of marriage prospects 3,00,000/- (vi) Loss of earning, inconvenience, hardships, disappointment, frustration, mental stress, dejectment and 50,000/- Page no. 12 MACT no. 40/23 Babu Ji Dubey Vs. Sahrukh Khan & Ors. -- 12 of 13 -- unhappiness in future life etc. 13. Disability resulting in loss of earning capacity (i) Percentage of disability assessed and nature of disability as permanent or temporary 40% permanent disability in relation to right foot. (ii) Loss of amenities or loss of expectation of life span on account of disability Nil. (iii) Percentage of loss of earning capacity in relation of disability 20% qua whole body (iv) Loss of future income – (Income X%Earning capacity X Multiplier) 6,49,046.4 14. TOTAL COMPENSATION 13,22,869.4 15. INTEREST AWARDED 9% per annum 16. Interest amount up to the date of award 1,79,910.22 i.e. for 18 month 4 days from the date of filing the DAR till passing the award except for the period from 28.03.2024 to 13.01.2025 as the interest for such period was withheld vide order dated 28.03.2024) 17. Total amount including interest 15,02,779.62 rounded up to Rs. 15,03,000/- 18. Award amount released Nil. 19. Award amount kept in FDRs Entire 20. Mode of disbursement of the award amount to the claimant (s) (Clause29) As per clause 29 of MCTAP that too after recording statement of petitioner. 21. Next date for compliance of the award. (Clause 31) 06.06.2025 (SUNIL KUMAR) PO, MACT-1 (North) Rohini Courts, Delhi/06.05.2025 Page no. 13 MACT no. 40/23 Babu Ji Dubey Vs. Sahrukh Khan & Ors. -- 13 of 13 --
