Full Order Text
Final Order 17 · 23 Jul 2024 · CNR DLNE030009092023
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF MS. AAKANKSHA VYAS, SCJ-cum-RC (NORTH EAST DISTRICT) KARKARDOOMA COURTS, DELHI Civ Suit No.489/23 CNR No. DLNE03-000909-2023 1. Sh. Praveen Kumar S/o Sh. Mool Chand 2. Sh. Tarun Kumar S/o Sh. Mool Chand 3. Ms. Asha Devi W/o Sh. Mool Chand All residents of : H. No.A-1/66, Gali No.17, Khajoori Khas, Karawal Nagar, Dayalpur, North East, Delhi-110094. 4. Ms. Pooja Devi D/o Sh. Mool Chand W/o Sh. Jagdish Chand R/o Quarter No.27, Second Floor, Type-III, MS Block, Timarpur, Delhi-110054. ...... Plaintiffs Versus 1. State NCT of Delhi Through its Chief Secretary Delhi Secretariat, IP Estate, Delhi. 2. Municipal Corporation of Delhi (“MCD”) Dr. S. P. M. Civic Centre, Minto Road, SKD Basti, Press Enclave, Ajmeri Gate, New Delhi-110002. ..… Defendants Civ Suit No. 489/23 Praveen Kumar vs State of NCT of Delhi Page no. 1/7 -- 1 of 7 -- Date of Institution of the suit : 21.10.2023 Date of reserving Judgment : 11.07.2024 Date of pronouncement of Judgment : 23.07.2024 J U D G M E N T 1. Vide this Judgment, I shall dispose off the present suit for declaration has been filed by the plaintiffs against the defendants. Plaintiff’s Case : 2. It is the case of the plaintiffs that the plaintiffs herein are the surviving legal heirs, being sons, wife and daughter of Mr. Mool Chand S/o Sh. Lochu Ram. It is stated that on 04.08.2016 at about 05:00 PM, Sh. Mool Chand left his house i.e. H. No.A-66, Gali No.17, Khajuri Khas, Delhi without informing anyone and has not yet returned. It is stated that since 04.08.2016, the said Sh. Mool Chand is missing and has not been heard of by the plaintiffs either themselves or through any other person. Therefore, the plaintiff no.1 had lodged a missing person report of his father Sh. Mool Chand on 05.08.2016 at about 10:00 AM vide missing person registration no.125/2016 dated 07.08.2016 at PS Khajuri Khas (North East Delhi). It is further stated that said Sh. Mool Chand continues to be missing and untraced till date, even after a lapse of seven years. It is further stated that vide letter dated 07.08.2023 issued by MHC Kuldeep under the signature of SHO PS Khajuri Khas, the plaintiffs were informed that said Sh. Mool Chand has not been traced so far and continues to be untraced. The plaintiffs have therefore filed the present suit seeking the following reliefs : Civ Suit No. 489/23 Praveen Kumar vs State of NCT of Delhi Page no. 2/7 -- 2 of 7 -- (i) Decree of declaration of death of Sh.Mool Chand. (ii) Directions to MCD/defendant no.2 to issue the death certificate of Sh. Mool Chand. Defendants’ Case : 3. In the Written Statement, the defendant no.1 has stated that the present suit is not maintainable as there is no cause of action in favour of the plaintiffs. Further, the present suit is bad in law as the plaintiffs have not impleaded necessary parties. It is further stated that the present suit is liable to be dismissed as the defendant is not under statutory obligation to register the Births & Deaths and death of a missing person can be registered only by the MCD after obtaining declaratory decree from the Court. Moreover, the plaintiffs never requested the office of the defendant for issuance of the death certificate of Sh. Mool Chand. Lastly, the plaintiffs have not complied with statutory notice period under Section 80 CPC. 4. In its Written Statement, the defendant no.2 has stated that the present suit is barred by Section 477 and 478 of DMC Act for want of service of statutory notice by the plaintiffs. Further, the defendant no.2 can register the death of missing person only on the basis of declaratory decree passed by the Court and therefore, the present suit is not maintainable against the defendant. Issues For Consideration : 5. From the pleadings, the following issues were framed vide order dated 29.05.2024 : Civ Suit No. 489/23 Praveen Kumar vs State of NCT of Delhi Page no. 3/7 -- 3 of 7 -- (i) Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to a decree of declaration, as prayed for? OPP (ii) Relief. Evidence led by the parties : 6. In order to prove their case, the plaintiff no.1 examined himself as PW-1 by way of affidavit in evidence Ex.PW1/1 wherein he reaffirmed and reiterated the contents of the plaint and relied upon the following documents : 1. Copy of Aadhaar Card of the plaintiff no.1 i.e. Ex.PW1/1 (OSR). 2. Copy of Aadhaar Card of the plaintiff no.2 Sh. Tarun Kumar i.e. Mark A. 3. Copy of Aadhaar Card of the plaintiff no.3 Smt. Asha Devi i.e. Ex.PW1/3 (OSR). 4. Copy of Aadhaar Card of the plaintiff no.4 Smt. Pooja Devi i.e. Ex.PW1/4 (OSR). 5. Copy of Aadhaar Card of Sh. Mool Chand i.e. Mark B. 6. Copy of missing report dated 07.08.2016 along with its reply i.e. Ex.PW1/6 (colly) (5 pages). 7. The plaintiffs also examined HC Mohd. Irfan Ali from PS Khajuri Khas, Delhi who proved the missing person report i.e. Ex.PW1/6 (colly. 5 pages) (OSR). He also produced the missing person register for the year 2016 to 2019 wherein the complaint of the plaintiff no.1/Sh. Praveen Kumar regarding the missing of Sh. Mool Chand is recorded vide DD no.10A dated 05.08.2016 at page no. 2 i.e. Ex.PW2/1 (OSR). He also produced the roznamcha register for the period 12.07.2016 to 11.08.2016 wherein the daily Civ Suit No. 489/23 Praveen Kumar vs State of NCT of Delhi Page no. 4/7 -- 4 of 7 -- diary entry at S.No.10 regarding missing of Sh. Mool Chand was got registered by plaintiff no.1 i.e. Ex.PW2/2 (OSR). 8. No defence evidence was led on behalf of the defendants. Appreciation of Evidence and Findings : 9. I have heard the arguments addressed by Ld. Counsels for both the parties and have perused the record carefully. I shall first refer to the relevant legal provisions applicable to this case. 10. Section 108 of the Indian Evidence Act 1872 provides: “ Burden of proving that a person is alive who has not been heard of for seven years. Provided that when the question is whether a man is alive or dead, and it is proved that he has not been heard of for seven years by those who would naturally have heard of him if he had been alive, the burden of proving that he is alive is shifted to the person who affirms it.” 11. In the landmark case titled L.I.C. Of India vs Anuradha (judgment of the hon’ble Supreme Court dated 26/3/2004), it has been held that: “ The presumption as to death by reference to Section 108 would arise only on lapse of seven years and would not by applying any logic or reasoning be permitted to be raised on expiry of 6 years and 364 days or at any time short of it. An occasion for raising the presumption would arise only when the question is raised in a Court, Tribunal or before an authority who is called upon to decide as to whether a person is alive or dead. So long as the dispute is not raised before any forum and in any legal proceedings the occasion for raising the presumption does not arise.” Further a civil suit for such a declaration is maintainable under section 9 of the Civil Procedure Code. Reliance is placed upon the judgment of the Hon’ble Bombay High Court in the case titled Sou. Swati W/O. Abhay Civ Suit No. 489/23 Praveen Kumar vs State of NCT of Delhi Page no. 5/7 -- 5 of 7 -- Deshmukh And Anr. vs Shri. Abhay Deshmukh & Anr. (judgment dated 26 February, 2016) and Sanju Devi vs State 2014 SCC OnLine Del 65. 12. Now in the present case, the plaintiff no.1 who is the son of the missing person namely Sh. Mool Chand has examined himself as PW-1. PW1 has deposed that his father Sh. Mool Chand is missing since 04.08.2016 and till date, neither the plaintiffs nor any person known to the plaintiffs have heard of Sh. Mool Chand. PW-1 as well as the remaining plaintiffs are obviously persons who would have naturally heard of Sh. Mool Chand if he had been alive. The status report from SDM Seelampur is also on record as per which Sh. Mool Chand is still missing. Hence in view of Section 108 of the Evidence Act 1872, on the preponderance of probabilities, it may be presumed that Sh. Mool Chand is dead. 13. I also deem it fit to address the objection raised by defendants no. 1 and 2 to the maintainability of the present suit in view of section 477 and 478 of the DMC Act as well as Section 80 of CPC. As per provisions of the Section 477 and 478 of the DMC Act, the service of notice is mandatory in case the suit is against any act done or purported to have been done in pursuance to the Delhi Municipal Corporation Act, 1957 or any rule, regulation or bye-laws made thereunder. Similarly, Section 80 CPC requires that no suit shall be instituted against the Government or against a Public Officer in respect of any act purporting to be done by him in his official capacity until the expiration of 2 months after service of written notice. However, in the present case, the cause of action for filing the present suit has not been occasioned due to any act of the said defendants. The relief sought by the plaintiff qua declaration of civil death of Sh. Mool Chand can only be Civ Suit No. 489/23 Praveen Kumar vs State of NCT of Delhi Page no. 6/7 -- 6 of 7 -- granted by the Court of law in accordance with Section 108 of the Indian Evidence Act and the defendants cannot grant the aforesaid relief even if the notice is served by the plaintiffs in this regard. Therefore, the relief sought in the present suit cannot be sought by the plaintiffs from the defendants so as to obligate the plaintiffs to serve the notice under Section 477/478 of the DMC Act or Section 80 CPC upon the defendants no.1 and 2. Hence, there was no requirement for the plaintiffs to serve the notice under Section 477 and 478 of the DMC Act or Section 80 CPC upon the defendants no.1 and 2 before filing of the suit. Conclusion : 14. In view of my above said findings, the plaintiffs are entitled to a decree of declaration of civil death of Sh. Mool Chand S/o Sh. Lochu Ram and the defendant no.2 is directed to issue death certificate of Sh. Mool Chand S/o Sh. Lochu Ram to the Plaintiffs. Further the date of declaration of civil death of Sh. Mool Chand S/o Sh. Lochu Ram shall be the date of filing of the present suit. 15. No order as to costs. 16. Decree Sheet be prepared in terms of the Judgment. 17. File be consigned to Record Room after due compliance. Announced in the open Court on day of 23rd July 2024 (AAKANKSHA VYAS) SCJ-cum-RC (North-East) KKD Courts/ 23.07.2024 Civ Suit No. 489/23 Praveen Kumar vs State of NCT of Delhi Page no. 7/7 -- 7 of 7 --
