Full Order Text
Order 6 · 25 May 2026 · CNR DLNE030007252025
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: 23 Civ Suit 442/25 MAHINDER SINGH (SR. CITIZEN) Vs. MUNENDER SINGH 25.05.2026 Present: Sh. Ashish Verma, Ld. Counsel for the plaintiff. Ld. Counsel for the defendant. Matter is listed for judgment. An application u/O 9 Rule 7 CPC has been moved to set aside ex parte proceedings in the instant matter. Arguments heard on behalf of both the parties. Put up for orders at 4:00 PM. Pranat Kumar Joshi ACJ-cum-ARC-cum-CCJ North-East/Karkardooma Courts, Delhi/25.05.2026 At 04:00 PM. Present: None. 1. The application u/O 9 Rule 7 CPC has been filed on the ground that on last date of hearing, the ex parte proceedings were ordered against the defendant although he had joined the VC but due to technical glitches he could not be heard by the court. 2. Ld. Counsel for plaintiff has chosen to orally oppose on the ground that no material has been placed on record by the applicant to substantiate his claim that he had attended the court on last date of hearing through VC and his conduct has throughout been questionable and dilatory. 3. I have heard the submissions and carefully perused the record. Contd… -- 1 of 3 -- -2- 4. It is clear from the perusal of order dated 17.04.2026 that defendant had indeed joined the proceedings through VC however, he did not respond despite repeated calls. This is comparable to a situation where a party is present in the court and does not appear despite the matter being called out. If at all there was a technical glitch the same should have been substantiated with relevant material on record which is not the case. Further, on 17.04.2026, the VC was efficiently functional and in no other case was any such issue reported. Thus, the claim of applicant/ defendant remains unsubstantiated and does not inspire confidence of this court. Further, perusal of order dated 19.02.2026 would reveal that last opportunity was granted to defendant to cross-examine PW-1 which the defendant failed to avail. Hence, the opportunity for the same stood closed. Further, mere presence of defendant through VC does not aid the case of defendant and does not prove his bona fides. 5. Additionally, the application u/O 9 Rule 7 CPC is not maintainable for the simple reason that the matter was already reserved for judgment vide order dated 17.04.2026 and the application u/O 9 Rule 7 CPC can only be filed when the case is adjourned for hearing not when the judgment is reserved. It is a settled law that listing the matter for pronouncement of judgment is not the same as matter listed for hearing. The CPC contemplates only two stages (1) When the hearing is adjourned (2) When the hearing is completed. Where the hearing is completed the parties have not further rights or privileges and Contd… -- 2 of 3 -- -3- after the stage contemplated u/O 9 Rule 7 CPC is passed the next stage is only passing of a decree which on the terms of Order 9 Rule 6 CPC the court is competent to pass. Thus, there is no hiatus between the two stages of reservation of judgment and pronouncing the judgment so as to make it necessary for the court to afford to the party the remedy of getting orders passed on the lines of Order 9 Rule 7 CPC (Arjun Singh Vs. Mohindra Kumar and Others 1964 SCR (5) 946, 1964 AIR 993). 6. Thus for the reasons above-mentioned the instant application is disposed off as not maintainable. 7. Matter is already reserved for judgment, the same be listed on [date withheld]. Pranat Kumar Joshi ACJ-cum-ARC-cum-CCJ North-East/Karkardooma Courts, Delhi/25.05.2026 -- 3 of 3 --
