Full Order Text
Final Order 7 · 03 Aug 2024 · CNR DLNE030006902023
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SH. RINKU JAIN ACJ-CUM-ARC-CUM-CCJ, NORTH EAST DISTRICT: KARKARDOOMA COURTS, DELHI SC No. 38/2023 CNR No. DLNE03-000690-2023 Sh. Devender Kumar S/o Dharam Chand Kamra, R/o T-17/602, 6th Floor, Tower-17, Paras Tiera GH-01, Secrtor 137, Noida, Gautam Budh Nagar, UP. .............Petitioner. Versus 1. The State 2. Smt. Kamla Ahuja, D/o Dharam Chand Kamra, W/o Madan Lal Ahuja, R/o A-116, Hastsal Road, Uttam Nagar, West Delhi-110059. 3. Smt. Shashi Arora W/o Dharampal Arora, D/o Dharam Chand Kamra, R/o 46/31, Civil Lines, Kalyanai Near Ganesh Mandir, Lal Kurti Bazar, Meerut. 4. Smt. Neelam Kamra W/o Late Sh. Narinder Kamra, R/o C-11/176 Yamuna Vihar, Garhi Mendu, Bhajan Pura, North East, Delhi-110053. 5. Sh. Sunny Kamra S/o Late Sh. Narinder Kamra, SC No. 38/23 Devender Kumar vs. State & Ors. Page No. 1 of 7 -- 1 of 7 -- R/o C-11/176 Yamuna Vihar, Garhi Mendu, Bhajan Pura, North East, Delhi-110053. 6. Sh. Pawan Kamra S/o Late Sh. Narinder Kamra R/o C-11/176 Yamuna Vihar, Garhi Mendu, Bhajan Pura, North East, Delhi-110053. 7. Smt. Shanti Devi Kamra W/o Late Sh. Ashok Kumar Kamra R/o 495, First Floor, Bhai Parmanand Colony, Dr. Mukherjee Nagar, North West Delhi-110009. 8. Ms. Shweta Batheja D/o Late Sh. Ashok Kumar Kamra, W/o Puneet Batheja, R/o F-10/12, Second Floor, Model Town-2, North West Delhi-110009. 9. Ms. Parul Alang, D/o Late Sh. Ashok Kumar Kamra W/o Ashwani Kumar Alang, R/o Su 159, Pitampura, Near City Park, Hotel Pitampura, Saraswati Vihar, North West Delhi-110034. 10. India Post At Yamuna Vihar Post Office, North East Delhi, Delhi-110053. ..............Respondents SC No. 38/23 Devender Kumar vs. State & Ors. Page No. 2 of 7 -- 2 of 7 -- Date of institution of the petition : 05.08.2023 Date on which judgment was reserved : 12.07.2024 Date of pronouncement of judgment : 03.08.2024 Decision : Allowed PETITION FOR GRANT OF SUCCESSION CERTIFICATE UNDER SECTION 372 OF THE INDIAN SUCCESSION ACT. JUDGMENT 1. The present petition has been filed by the petitioner for issuance of succession certificate with respect to debts and securities of deceased Late Smt. Dropati Kamara, who had expired intestate on 07.02.2021. The State, Smt. Kamla Ahuja, Smt. Shashi Arora, Smt. Neelam Kamra, Sh. Sunny Kamra, Sh. Pawan Kamra, Smt. Shanti Devi Kamra, Ms. Shweta Batheja, Ms. Parul Alang & India Post are made respondents in this case. 2. The present petition has been filed with respect to saving account bearing no. 4088911746 maintained with India Post, vide folio no. 091347197 at Yamuna Vihar Post Office, in the name of deceased Late Smt. Dropati Kamara. 3. Service of notice of this petition was also effected upon general public through publication in newspaper i.e. 'The Statesman, dated 11.11.2023. Till date, no objection for grant of certificate in favour of petitioner has been received from general public. 4. Accordingly, an enquiry was conducted and in the SC No. 38/23 Devender Kumar vs. State & Ors. Page No. 3 of 7 -- 3 of 7 -- enquiry, verification report Ex. P-1 (colly. 24 pages) was filed on behalf of respondent no. 1 i.e. SDM, Yamuna Vihar, Delhi regarding the LRs of deceased Late Smt. Dropati Kamara. As per the report, deceased left following surviving legal heirs: i. Sh. Devender Kumar son of deceased ii. Ms. Kamla Ahuja daughter of deceased iii. Shashi Arora daughter of deceased iv. Neelam Kamra daughter-in-law of deceased v. Sunny Kamra grandson vi. Pawan Kamra grandson vii. Shanti Devi Kamra daughter-in-law viii. Shweta Bhateja grand-daughter ix. Parul Alang grand-daughter 5. RW-3 namely Smt. Kamla Ahuja, RW-4 namely Smt. Shashi Arora, RW-5 namely Neelam Kamra, RW-6 namely Sunny Kamra, RW-7 namely Sh. Pawan Kamra, RW-8 namely Smt. Shanti Devi Kamra, RW-9 namely Ms. Shweta Batheja & RW-10 namely Ms. Parul Alang, have given their statement regarding their no objection if the succession certificate is issued in favour of the petitioner. Copy of their Aadhar cards are Ex. RW2/A (OSR), Ex. RW3/A (OSR), Ex. RW4/A (OSR), Ex. RW5/A (OSR), Ex. RW6/A (OSR), Ex. RW7/A (OSR), Ex. RW8/A (OSR), Ex. RW9/A (OSR) & Ex. RW10/A (OSR) respectively. SC No. 38/23 Devender Kumar vs. State & Ors. Page No. 4 of 7 -- 4 of 7 -- 6. Sh. Pramod Kumar Sharma, SPM, Indian Post, Yamuna Vihar, Delhi was examined as RW2, who was again called, however, inadvertently, he was examined as RW11. He brought the details of account no. 4088911746 of Smt. Dropti Kamara, pertaining to Kishan Vikas Patra (KVP). The account was opened by Late Smt. Dropati Kamara and an amount of Rs. 5,59,748.41/- approximately is payable as on date. The nominee of the said account is Ashok Kamara. The said report is Ex.RW11/A (colly. 8 pages). The India post has no objection if succession certificate in respect of aforesaid amount is granted in favour of petitioner Devender Kumar. The department reserved its right to verify that all the conditions for early death benefits are fulfilled and then the post office would release the amount as per succession certificate. 7. Petitioner examined himself as PW-1 and relied upon the following documents to show his entitlement i.e. a. Copy of death certificate of deceased Late Smt. Dropati Kamara Ex. PW1/A. b. Copy of death certificate of father of petitioner’s father Dharam Chand Kamara Ex. PW1/D. c. Copy of death certificate of petitioner’s brother namely Narender Kamara Ex. PW1/E. d. Copy of death certificate of petitioner’s brother namely Ashok Kumar Kamara Ex. PW1/F. SC No. 38/23 Devender Kumar vs. State & Ors. Page No. 5 of 7 -- 5 of 7 -- e. Certificate U/s 63 of Bharatya Sakshya Adhiniyam regarding all death certificates Ex. PW1/B. f. Publication report Ex.PW1/C. g. Necessary report from SDM concerned Ex. P-1. h. Report received from concerned post office Ex. RW11/A. i. Copy of Aadhar card of Petitioner Ex. PW1/G (OSR). 8. That vide separate statement of petitioner dated 12.07.2024, petitioner evidence was closed. 9. I have heard Ld. counsel for the petitioner. Case file perused. 10. A certificate can be granted to an applicant if it is found that the rights in the securities belong to the applicant. As per Section 373(3), even if the Court is not able to decide the right to certificate without determining the question of law or fact which seem to be too intricate and difficult for determination in a summary proceeding, the certificate may nevertheless be granted to the applicant if he appears to be the person having prima-facia the best title therein. 11. Thus, from the averments made in the petition, report of SDM Ex. P-1 (colly. 24 pages) and reports from India SC No. 38/23 Devender Kumar vs. State & Ors. Page No. 6 of 7 -- 6 of 7 -- Post Office Ex. RW2/A & Ex. RW11/A, with respect to debts and securities of deceased in the present petition, I find that there is no legal embargo for issuance of succession certificate in favour of petitioner who is a legal heir of the deceased Late Smt. Dropati Kamara with respect to account no. 4088911746 pertaining to Kishan Vikas Patra in the name of deceased Late Smt. Dropati Kamara for an amount of Rs. 5,59,748.41/- is payable to deceased. 12. Accordingly, petition is allowed and succession certificate be issued in favour of petitioner, for an amount of Rs. 5,59,748.41/- payable to deceased Late Smt. Dropati Kamara, along with interest or any other amount as may be enhanced or reduced till date, on filing of requisite Court Fees in terms of Article 12, Schedule I of the Court Fee Act 1870 as applicable to Delhi along with indemnity bond with one surety in the like amount. 13. File be consigned to Record Room after due compliance. Announced in the open court (RINKU JAIN) on 03rd August, 2024 ACJ-cum-ARC-cum-CCJ North-East District, KKD, Delhi SC No. 38/23 Devender Kumar vs. State & Ors. Page No. 7 of 7 -- 7 of 7 --
