Full Order Text
Final Order 25 · 29 Nov 2025 · CNR DLNE030001832023
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SH. AJAY KUMAR MALIK JSCC-ASCJ-GUARDIAN JUDGE, NORTH-EAST, KARKARDOOMA COURTS, DELHI. Civil Suit 106/23 CNR No. DLNE-03-000183-2023 In the matter of :- Sh. Arun S/o Sh. Raspal R/o H. No. E-69/7, Street No. 3, Near Dhruv Public School, Bhagirathi Vihar, North-East, Delhi-110094. ........Plaintiff V E R S U S 1. The State Through its Secretary, Govt. of NCT of Delhi, New Delhi. 2. To the Commissioner of Police Delhi Police, Police Headquarter, Jai Singh Road, New Delhi. 3. To the SHO PS Gokul Puri, New Delhi. 4. To the Commissioner of MCD Delhi Civic Center, SPM Marg, Minto Road, C.P., New Delhi-110001. ………. Defendants Date of Institution : 06.03.2023 Date of decision : 29.11.2025 CS No.: 106/23 Arun vs. State & Ors. Page no. 1 of 7 -- 1 of 7 -- SUIT FOR DECLARATION AND MANDATORY INJUNCTION J U D G M E N T 1. This is a suit for declaration seeking the relief of declaring Sh. Raspal s/o Sh. Ram Pal as dead and for directions to defendant no. 4 to register death of Sh. Raspal s/o Sh. Ram Pal and issue a death certificate. Plaintiffs’ case 2. The suit of plaintiff is that plaintiff is residing at H. No. E-69/7, Street No. 3, Near Dhruv Public School, Bhagirathi Vihar, North-East, Delhi-110094. It is further stated plaintiff has also filed the suit for declaration before the Ld. Civil Judge, which was dismissed as withdrawn. It is further stated that father of plaintiff namely Sh. Raspal s/o Sh. Ram Pal was living with the plaintiff and his family members at above said address. It is further stated that on 29.07.2014, father of plaintiff left the house and since then he is not traceable. It is further stated that plaintiff reported the matter to PS Gokulpuri on 31.07.2014. It is further stated that public notices regarding missing of Sh. Raspal was published in daily newspaper namely Rashtriya Shahara. It is further stated that all sincere efforts have been made to trace the abovesaid person but he could not be traced so far. Hence, the present case. 3. It is pertinent to mention here that on hearing dated 26.03.2025, it was submitted on behalf of plaintiff that plaintiff wish to implead MCD as party to suit and he moved an application u/o 1 Rule 10 CPC. Vide order dated 14.05.2025, the application u/o 1 Rule 10 CPC of plaintiff was CS No.: 106/23 Arun vs. State & Ors. Page no. 2 of 7 -- 2 of 7 -- allowed and MCD is treated as party to the suit. Defendants’ case 4. WS was filed by defendant/MCD, wherein it is stated that present suit is barred u/s 477/478 of DMC Act, 1957. It is further stated that role of MCD in matters of missing persons is strictly ministerial and contingent upon a decree from a competent court. It is further submitted that death of a missing person could only be registered after obtaining the declaratory decree from the Hon’ble Court of law having competent court. It is pertinent to mention here that defendant no. 1, 2 & 3 were proceeded exparte vide order dated 04.01.2024. Issues 5. After completion of pleadings, vide order dated 25.09.2025, the following issues were framed: 1. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for a decree of declaration, as prayed for?OPP. 2. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for a decree of mandatory injunction, as prayed? OPP. 3. Relief? 6. Plaintiffs’ Evidence Plaintiffs examined two witnesses in his support. (i) The plaintiff stepped into witness box and examined himself as PW-1. In his testimony, PW1 tendered his evidence by way of affidavit Ex.PW1/1 in which he reiterated the contents of the plaint. PW1 also relied CS No.: 106/23 Arun vs. State & Ors. Page no. 3 of 7 -- 3 of 7 -- upon the following documents: (a) Copy of Aadhar Card of deponent is Mark PW-1/A. (b) Copy of order dated 05.12.2022 is Mark B. (c) Copy of missing complaint is Ex. PW-1/C. (d) Copy of newspaper dated 17.01.2023 is Mark A and newspaper dated 18.10.2023 is Ex. PW-1/D. (e) Copy of identity proof of missing person is Ex. PW-1/E. (f) Copy of latest status report/verification report filed by the police is Mark C. (ii) Inspector Umed Singh, SHO, PS Gokulpuri, Delhi was examined as PW-2 and he brought missing report bearing MPR No. 204 dated 31.07.2014 lodged by complainant Arun s/o Raspal regarding missing of his father namely Sh. Raspal. He further deposed that as per record, Sh. Raspal is untraceable so far. The report is Ex. PW-2/A. 7. Plaintiff's evidence was closed on 29.11.2025. Since, defendant not wish to examine any witness in defence, DE was closed on 29.11.2025 and final arguments have been heard. I have gone through the judicial record. Findings 8. Now I shall give my issue-wise findings on the following issues: 1. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for a decree of declaration, as prayed for?OPP. 2. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for a decree of mandatory injunction, as prayed? OPP. CS No.: 106/23 Arun vs. State & Ors. Page no. 4 of 7 -- 4 of 7 -- 3. Relief? (a) Issue no. 1 1. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for a decree of declaration, as prayed for?OPP. The onus to prove the issue no. 1 was on plaintiff. The plaintiff got examined himself as PW-1 and proved his affidavit as Ex. PW-1/1. PW-1 proved his Aadhar card as Mark PW-1/A. PW-1 further relied upon copy of order dated 05.12.2022 as Mark B. PW-1 further relied upon missing complaint as Ex. PW-1/C. PW-1 further relied upon copy of newspaper dated 17.01.2023 as Mark A and copy of newspaper dated 18.10.2023 as Ex. PW-1/D. PW-1 further relied upon identity proof of missing person as Ex. PW-1/E. PW-1 further relied upon copy of latest status report/verification report filed by police as Mark C. PW-1 had stated that he tried his best to trace Sh. Raspal but despite the efforts of plaintiff & his family members, no information was received about Sh. Raspal. PW-1 further relied upon report i.e. Ex. PW-2/A filed by PW-2/SHO Umed Singh. PW-2 stated in his examination that missing complaint of Sh. Raspal was filed by Sh. Arun and as per record, Sh. Raspal is untraceable so far. A period of more than 08 years have passed since the year 2014, Sh. Raspal has not returned to his house or contacted the plaintiff or family members, who should have normally heard from them. The local police has not been able to trace Sh. Raspal despite efforts. Hence, on the basis of evidence led by the plaintiff and presumption drawn under Section 108 of the Indian Evidence Act, the plaintiff has been able to prove that Sh. CS No.: 106/23 Arun vs. State & Ors. Page no. 5 of 7 -- 5 of 7 -- Raspal has not been seen for the last more than 08 years. In case titled as Narbada v. Ram Dayal, AIR 1968 Raj. 48, it was held that under Section 108 of the Indian Evidence Act, presumption about the death of a person is to be drawn when the dispute is brought to the Court and death can be presumed on the date on which the suit was filed and it cannot be given a further retrospective effect. Thus, declaration of civil death of Sh. Raspal shall be effective from the date of filing of the suit in the light of judgment of Narbada v. Ram Dayal (supra). A rebuttable presumption of law has arisen to the effect that Sh. Raspal died sometime within that period and accordingly, it can be presumed that Sh. Raspal is now dead. Accordingly, issue no. 1 is decided in favour of plaintiff and against the defendants. (b) Issue no. 2 2. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for a decree of mandatory injunction, as prayed? OPP. The onus to prove issue no. 2 was on plaintiff. In view of the findings on issue no. 1, issue no. 2 is also decided in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendants. It is directed that defendant no. 4/MCD shall take steps for registration of death of Sh. Raspal s/o Sh. Ram Pal in the birth and death register of defendant no. 4/MCD. Further, defendant no. 4/MCD shall also issue a death certificate of Sh. Raspal s/o Sh. Ram Pal. (c) Issue no. 3 3. Relief? CS No.: 106/23 Arun vs. State & Ors. Page no. 6 of 7 -- 6 of 7 -- 9. In view of the above noted findings, the suit of the plaintiff is decreed. Parties to bear their own cost. Decree sheet be prepared accordingly. File be consigned to the record room after due compliance. Announced in the Open Court on 29.11.2025 Sh. Ajay Kumar Malik JSCC/ASCJ/G. Judge(N/E) Karkardooma Courts, Delhi CS No.: 106/23 Arun vs. State & Ors. Page no. 7 of 7 -- 7 of 7 --
