Full Order Text
Final Order 15 · 04 Mar 2024 · CNR DLNE030000162023
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF DEEPAK KUMAR-I, SCJ-cum-RC (NORTH -EAST DISTRICT), KARKARDOOMA COURTS, DELHI. RCA SCJ No. 01/2023 CNR No. DLNE03-000016-2023 In the matter of: (1) SH. PAWAN KUMAR S/o- Late Sh. Premchand, (2) SMT. VARSHA W/o- Sh. Pawan Kumar, Both R/o- H.No. 44, Gali No. 1, Phase-5, Near Ramleela Field, Shiv Vihar, Karawal Nagar, Delhi-110094. ......Appellants Versus (1) RAJKUMAR, S/o- Late Sh. Premchand. (2) PRINCY, W/o- Sh. Rajkumar. (3) KARAN All R/o- 135, 3rd Floor, Gali No. 9, Shankar Nagar Extn., Krishna Nagar, Delhi-51. ......Respondents RCA No. 01/23 Pawan Kumar & Ors Vs. Rajkumar & Ors Page 1/11 -- 1 of 11 -- Date of Institution : 01.09.2022 Date on which judgment was reserved: 04.03.2024 Date of pronouncing judgment: 04.03.2024 JUDGMENT 1. By way of the present appeal, the judgment and decree dated 12.07.2022, of the then Ld. ACJ-CUM-ARC-CUM-CCJ (North East District), Karkardooma Courts, Delhi, has been challenged by the plaintiffs (hereinafter referred as 'Appellants'). By way of impugned judgment and decree dated 12.07.2022, the suit of the appellants was dismissed with costs. BRIEF FACTS OF THE CASE:- 2. The appellants assert that Smt. Sumitra, mother of appellant No. 1, owned the property at 44, Gali No. 1, Phase-5, Near Ramleela Field, Shiv Vihar, Karawal Nagar, Delhi-94 (referred to as 'Suit Property'). During her lifetime, she partitioned the property equally (50-50 sq yards) between appellant No. 1 and respondent No. 1. Through various registered documents dated 29.12.2020, including a family WILL deed, a family GPA, a Notarized Agreement of Gift, an Affidavit, and a Possession letter, 50 sq yards of the property were transferred to the appellants, conferring upon them the right, title, and interest in the property. Following the demise of appellant No. 1's RCA No. 01/23 Pawan Kumar & Ors Vs. Rajkumar & Ors Page 2/11 -- 2 of 11 -- mother, the appellants became the rightful owners of the property, comprising 50 sq yards as delineated in red on the site plan. 3. It is further the case of the appellants that following the marriage of respondent No. 1 and 2, they relocated to rented premises in Krishna Nagar, while the mother of appellant No. 1 resided with appellant No. 1, receiving care and attention. In 2020, during the mother's lifetime, respondent No. 1 purportedly sold his share (50 sq yards) to Smt. Manju, wife of Sh. Kunwarpal Sharma, for a total consideration of Rs. 27 lakhs. Subsequently, Smt. Manju and her family began residing on the property. The respondents allegedly harbor ill intentions towards the suit property and have resorted to threatening the appellants with forceful eviction. That on 26.04.2021 and 21.07.2021, the respondents came to the suit property and created scene. That, despite a call to the police, no action was taken against the respondents, and instead, a false Kalandra was registered under Section 107/151 Cr.P.C against plaintiff No. 1. That, despite a written complaint dated 25.07.2021 to higher police authorities, no action was initiated against the respondents. 4. Accordingly, appellant No. 1 and 2 filed suit for permanent injunction in favour of the appellants and against the RCA No. 01/23 Pawan Kumar & Ors Vs. Rajkumar & Ors Page 3/11 -- 3 of 11 -- respondents, their family members, associates etc, for restraining them permanently from taking forcible possession of the suit property. 5. That summons were issued to the respondents, however, despite service, they did not appear before the Court and vide order dated 22.11.2021, they were proceeded with ex parte. 6. That ex parte evidence was led and appellants No. 1 and 2 tendered their evidence affidavits and relied upon the documents Ex. PW1/1 to PW1/4, Ex.PW1/5, Ex. PW1/7, MARK A to C and Ex. PW2/1. 7. That Trial Court, vide order dated 12.07.2022, dismissed the suit of the appellants with costs with the findings that since the appellants have failed to prove their exclusive possession over the suit property, no relief of permanent injunction, as sought by the plaintiff, can be granted to them. Hence, the present appeal has been filed. GROUNDS OF APPEAL 8. Via the present appeal, appellants have reiterated the averments made by them in the suit filed before the Ld Trial Court thereby seeking permanent injunction, in favour of the RCA No. 01/23 Pawan Kumar & Ors Vs. Rajkumar & Ors Page 4/11 -- 4 of 11 -- appellants and against the respondents, their family members, associates etc, for restraining them permanently from taking forcible possession of the suit property. 9. Appellants have averred that the impugned judgment and decree is based upon own surmises and conjecture of the Ld Trial Court, who has passed the judgment and decree without appreciating the pleadings, documents and the evidence led by the appellants, in its true aspect. That, the Ld. Trial Court has instead of appreciating various documents filed by the appellants, showing their possession, in respect of the suit property, has wrongly reached to conclusion that no document has been filed to prove their current possession, whereas the Aadhar card of the appellants bears the address of the suit property and they are still residing in the suit property. Further, that if the Ld. Trial Court had any doubt to the factum of current possession of the appellants, in respect of the suit property, the Ld Trial Court could have appointed Local Commissioner or had directed the appellants to file other documents to show their current possession, however, no such procedure was followed. That the Ld. Trial Court has not appreciated the testimonies of the appellants in its true spirit, therefore, the impugned judgment and decree is liable to be set aside. RCA No. 01/23 Pawan Kumar & Ors Vs. Rajkumar & Ors Page 5/11 -- 5 of 11 -- ARGUMENTS ON BEHALF OF RESPONDENTS: 10. Record reveals that vide order dated 09.11.2023, the right of the respondents to address arguments, on the instant appeal was closed. 11. Arguments heard on behalf of Ld counsel for appellants. Case file as well as summoned record are perused. COURT'S OBSERVATIONS: 12. Perusal of record reveals that suit of the appellant/ plaintiff was dismissed by the Ld. Trial Court vide order dated 12.07.2022. The observations of Ld. Trial Court is reproduced as below:- “…… In order to prove their possession over the suit property, plaintiffs have led into evidence the registered GPA, family will deed, notorised agreement to gift, affidavit and possession letter, all dated 29.12.2020 (Ex. PW1/3), allegedly executed by the mother of plaintiff No. 1, in his favour. It is pertinent to state here that although the aforesaid documents may be relevant for the purpose of proving the title of plaintiff No. 1 over the suit property, but the same does not prove that the plaintiffs are in possession over the suit property. The aforesaid documents are dated 29.12.2020 whereas the suit in had was filed on 25.08.2021 which is almost 8 months after the execution of the said documents. Plaintiffs have also led into evidence the certified copy of order (Ex. PW1/5) of Special RCA No. 01/23 Pawan Kumar & Ors Vs. Rajkumar & Ors Page 6/11 -- 6 of 11 -- Executive Magistrate (North-East District, Seelampur Court, Delhi), but again the said order is dated 10.01.2020 and moreover, the address of the plaintiffs is not even reflected therein. The other documents i.e Mark A, Mark B and Mark C are simply the copies and the relevant record from the department concerned was never summoned by the plaintiffs in order to prove the same. Apart from the aforesaid documents, no other document has been led into evidence by the plaintiffs to prove their current possession over the suit property and in absence of the same, it cannot be said that plaintiffs are currently in possession of the suit property or were in possession at the time of filing of the suit in hand. Although, the respondents in the case in hand are ex parte, however, it is a settled position of law that plaintiff’s case has to stand on its own legs. In the case in hand, since plaintiffs have failed to prove their exclusive possession over the suit property, therefore, this Court is of the view that plaintiffs have failed to prove their case and so, no relief of permanent injunction, as sought by the plaintiffs, can be granted to them….”. 13. The appellant has challenged the impugned order dated 12.07.2022, passed by the Ld Trial Court by asserting that the Ld. Trial Court's judgment and decree were speculative and failed to duly assess the evidence provided by the appellants, which included documents substantiating their possession of the property. That, despite the appellants' Aadhar card evidencing the suit property's address and their continued residency, the Ld. RCA No. 01/23 Pawan Kumar & Ors Vs. Rajkumar & Ors Page 7/11 -- 7 of 11 -- Trial Court erroneously concluded there was insufficient evidence of current possession. Furthermore, the appellants argue that the Ld. Trial Court inadequately considered their testimonies and could have pursued additional measures, such as appointing a Local Commissioner, to verify the factual circumstances regarding possession. Consequently, the appellants advocate for the reversal of the Trial Court's decision. 14. The Ld. Trial Court dismissed the appellant/plaintiff's suit vide order dated 12.07.2022, citing insufficient evidence of possession over the property. Although documents were presented to establish ownership, none proved current possession. Key documents were dated before the suit was filed, and no additional evidence beyond certain documents, which were copies and lacked authentication from relevant departments, was provided. Despite the respondents being absent, the plaintiff's failure to prove exclusive possession led to the case's dismissal. Consequently, the sought-after relief of permanent injunction was denied. 15. The plaintiffs' failure to substantiate their claim of possession over the subject property resulted in the dismissal of their case by the Ld. Trial Court. The Ld. Trial Court noted that essential documentation predated the initiation of the suit and no RCA No. 01/23 Pawan Kumar & Ors Vs. Rajkumar & Ors Page 8/11 -- 8 of 11 -- supplementary evidence, apart from unauthenticated copies, was presented. Ld. Counsel for the appellants argued that given the chance, they could have summoned pertinent authorities or records to authenticate documents such as Mark A, Mark B, and Mark C i.e. copy of call details, copy of Kalandra and complaint, both dated 21.07.2021 respectively, which are integral for proving the possession. Additionally, it was contended that the plaintiffs possess receipts for electricity and gas connections (copies of which have been submitted alongside the application under Order 41, Rule 17 read with 151 of the Civil Procedure Code, annexed herewith the present appeal), which, if afforded the opportunity, can be proved to demonstrate the actual physical possession of the plaintiffs over the subject property. 16. In the case of Sanjay Kumar Singh vs The State Of Jharkhand, Civil Appeal No. 1760/2022, decided on 10 March 2022, the Hon’ble Apex Court emphasized that if the additional evidence sought to be adduced addresses crucial questions in the case, directly relates to the main issue, and serves the interest of justice, it may be admitted. The appellate court may allow such evidence if it is essential for rendering a judgment or for other significant reasons akin to the circumstances outlined in Order 41 Rule 27 of the Civil Procedure Code. RCA No. 01/23 Pawan Kumar & Ors Vs. Rajkumar & Ors Page 9/11 -- 9 of 11 -- 17. It is evident that the plaintiff failed to exercise due diligence before the Learned Trial Court by not adequately presenting their case and providing evidence to support their claims. Although they had the opportunity to file applications to summon the relevant authority/records to authenticate the documents they relied upon, they did not do so. However, the proposed introduction of evidence to authenticate the documents (Mark A, Mark B, and Mark C), along with the submission of electricity and gas connections receipts, crucially addresses the factual issue of possession of the suit property. This evidence directly pertains to the central issue of the case and promotes the interest of justice by facilitating a comprehensive examination of the factual circumstances. In light of these considerations and in the pursuit of justice, it is appropriate to grant the appellants a single opportunity to substantiate their claims before the Learned Trial Court. This includes allowing the plaintiff the chance to press for the summoning of relevant records to authenticate the aforementioned documents (Mark A, Mark B, and Mark C) and to provide evidence regarding the electricity and gas connections pertaining to the suit property. 18. Upon careful consideration of the arguments presented and in the light of facts and circumstances of the case, it is held that the Ld. Trial Court shall afford one opportunity to the appellants/ RCA No. 01/23 Pawan Kumar & Ors Vs. Rajkumar & Ors Page 10/11 -- 10 of 11 -- plaintiffs to present evidence regarding the authenticity of the documents (Mark A, Mark B, and Mark C) and to lead additional evidence qua electricity and gas connections concerning the suit property. Should the plaintiff successfully provide such evidence, Ld. Trial Court shall decide the matter afresh as per the merit. However, should the appellants/plaintiffs fail to produce the aforementioned evidence, the judgment rendered by the Learned Trial Court shall hold good. The appeal is disposed of as per the terms outlined above. The pending application, attached with the appeal, is also disposed of accordingly Appellants/ plaintiffs are directed to appear before Ld. Trial Court on 12.03.2024 at 2.00 pm. Trial Court Record alongwith copy of this order be sent back to Ld. Trial Court. Appeal file be consigned to Record Room after due compliance. Announced in the open Court on day 04th March, 2024 (DEEPAK KUMARI) SCJcumRC (NORTHEAST) KARKARDOOMA COURTS, DELHI. RCA No. 01/23 Pawan Kumar & Ors Vs. Rajkumar & Ors Page 11/11 -- 11 of 11 --
