Full Order Text
Final Order 14 · 15 May 2026 · CNR DLNE030000012025
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: ____________________________________________________________________________________ CS No. 3/2025 Sh. Rahul Tyagi v. Dinesh Kumar Page No. 1/13 IN THE COURT OF PRANAT KUMAR JOSHI ACJ-cum-ARC-cum-CCJ : NORTH EAST: KARKARDOOMA COURTS: DELHI DLNE030000012025 CS No. 3/2025 Sh. Rahul Tyagi S/o Sh. Rajender Tyagi R/o H. No. D-33, Ground Floor, Plot No. 32, Street No. 2, Shanti Nagar, Karawal Nagar, Delhi-110094 Also At:- Ch. No. D-311, 3rd Floor, D-Block, Karkardooma Court Delhi ...Plaintiff Versus Dinesh Kumar S/o Sh. Kanti Prasad R/o H. No. D-7/9, Gali No. 7 Dayalpur, North-East, Delhi-110094 ......Defendant Date of Institution : 24.12.2024 Date of reserving the judgment : 24.04.2026 Date of Judgment : 15.05.2026 Decision : Decreed -- 1 of 13 -- ____________________________________________________________________________________ CS No. 3/2025 Sh. Rahul Tyagi v. Dinesh Kumar Page No. 2/13 SUIT FOR RECOVERY OF Rs. 1,50,000/- ALONGWITH PENDENTE LITE AND FUTURE INTEREST @ 24% P.A. JUDGMENT 1. Present suit is instituted by Mr. Rahul Tyagi (hereinafter ‘plaintiff’) against Mr. Dinesh Kumar (hereinafter ‘defendant’) for recovery of Rs. 1,80,000/- (Rupees one lakh eighty thousand only) along-with pendent lite rate of interest at 24% per annum. Shorn of unnecessary details the facts have been adumbrated in the paragraphs that follow. 2. Plaintiff avers that he and defendant have been friends for a long time. Due to long-standing friendship between them, he had advanced a friendly loan to the defendant in the first week of December 2022 for a sum of Rs. 1,50,000/- (Rupees one lakh and fifty thousand only) for a period of one year. 3. After one-year elapsed, plaintiff requested defendant to return the loan amount upon which latter would express his inability to repay. Defendant would rather assure the plaintiff to return the loan amount later. Holding fast to the promise plaintiff withdrew, only to return in the month of April 2024. This time, defendant would rather issue a cheque bearing no. 156180 dated 20.05.2024 for a sum of Rs. 1,50,000/- (Rupees one lakh fifty thousand only) (hereinafter ‘impugned cheque’) in favour of plaintiff than to repay in cash. This cheque would later get dishonored upon its presentation on 27.05.2024. 4. It is the case of plaintiff that he had extended numerous entreaties to defendant seeking repayment of the loan amount ever since, but his repeated entreaties withered in silence. Eventually being assured of defendant’s intention to grab the loan amount, plaintiff would issue a -- 2 of 13 -- ____________________________________________________________________________________ CS No. 3/2025 Sh. Rahul Tyagi v. Dinesh Kumar Page No. 3/13 legal notice to the defendant which was served on 02.09.2024 and again the same failed to awaken the reciprocation of promised action. 5. By bringing this suit, the plaintiff claims loan amount along with interest at the rate of 24% from 01.01.2024 (date when loan became due) till 31.10.2024, hence the total amount claimed inclusive of interest is Rs. 3,00,000/- (Rupees three lakh only) within the pecuniary jurisdiction of this court. Plaintiff also claims the cause of action is a continuing one and since both parties reside within jurisdiction of this court, this court has territorial jurisdiction to try this case. 6. Upon being summoned, the defendant appeared and filed his Written Statement (hereinafter ‘WS’). Defendant would submit in his WS that the case of plaintiff is nothing but a castle of lies. Although he would admit that he had availed the loan of Rs. 1,50,000/- from the plaintiff - he would aver that he had repaid the entire loan amount as promised. Defendant would rather claim that it was the plaintiff who wrongfully held on to the impugned cheque and refused to return it despite numerous requests. He would also aver that all along the plaintiff’s intention was to misuse the impugned cheque which was given in good faith as a security instrument and never meant to be presented. Defendant would aver that it is the plaintiff who has approached with tainted intention, thus, his suit deserves outright dismissal. 7. Upon filing the WS, the same was kept for consideration but defendant had stopped appearing, in repercussion ex parte proceedings were ordered against him vide order dated 29.10.2025. Since this court had not returned any specific finding to the effect of rejection of WS, for the larger interest of justice and to comprehensively appreciate the matter in controversy, the same is being considered in this judgment. -- 3 of 13 -- ____________________________________________________________________________________ CS No. 3/2025 Sh. Rahul Tyagi v. Dinesh Kumar Page No. 4/13 8. Be that as it may, the ex parte evidence of the plaintiff was recorded vide order dated 08.12.2025. 9. The plaintiff examined himself as PW1 and relied on following documents: 1. Copy of aadhar card of plaintiff. Ex. PW1/1(OSR) 2. Hand Written note of defendant Ex. PW1/2 3. Signed copy of Pass Book of Defendant. Ex. PW1/3 is de-exhibited and now marked as Mark ‘A’ 4. Signed copy of Pan Card Ex. PW1/4 is de-exhibited and now marked as Mark ‘B’ 5. Signed Copy of aadhar card of defendant Ex. PW1/5 is de-exhibited and now marked as Mark ‘C’ 6. Signed copy of Voter Identity Card of defendant. Ex. PW1/6 is de-exhibited and now marked as Mark ‘D’ 7. Signed copy of license of defendant. Ex. PW1/7 is de-exhibited and now marked as Mark ‘E’ 8. Cheque Bearing no 156180 Ex. PW1/8 9. Return Memo Ex. PW1/9 10. Legal notice dated 31.08.2024 Ex. PW1/10 11. Postal receipts of defendant Ex. PW1/11 12. Delivery proof of defendant Ex. PW1/12 is de-exhibited and now marked as Mark ‘F’ -- 4 of 13 -- ____________________________________________________________________________________ CS No. 3/2025 Sh. Rahul Tyagi v. Dinesh Kumar Page No. 5/13 10.Final arguments were heard on behalf of both the parties on 24.04.2026. Closing arguments 11.Mr. Sumit Gupta, Ld. Counsel for plaintiff would submit that plaintiff has proven his case as his testimonies stand unrebutted and defendant could not prove his defence. 12. Per Contra, Mr. Y.S. Panwar, Ld. Counsel for defendant would submit that it is the plaintiff who is saddled with the burden of proving his case, and the defendant need not prove his defence. Ld. Counsel would further submit that even unrebutted evidence of the plaintiff has failed to withstand the scrutiny of preponderance of probabilities. 13.I have bestowed my anxious consideration on the rival submissions and have meticulously pondered over the material placed on record. I would now record my findings in succeeding paragraphs of this judgment. Analysis and Findings 14. The plaintiff relies upon document Ex. PW1/2 which is an acknowledgement of debt of Rs. 1,50,000//- duly signed by the defendant. The defendant does not dispute his signatures in Ex. PW1/2. In fact, he admits his liability of Rs. 1,50,000/- in para no. 5 of his WS. Inter alia plaintiff also relies upon cheque Ex. PW1/8 and return memo of bank which is Ex. PW1/9. The defendant does not question the veracity of these documents in his WS, however, contends that the impugned cheque was given as a security not meant to be presented. Let us now examine the veracity of rival contentions as per law. -- 5 of 13 -- ____________________________________________________________________________________ CS No. 3/2025 Sh. Rahul Tyagi v. Dinesh Kumar Page No. 6/13 15. No longer does the law regarding burden of proof lurks in the corridors of oblivion that primary burden of proof to prove a case lies upon the one who brings the suit. It is now ubiquitously known that it is the plaintiff who must bear the perennial burden to prove its case. As per Section 101 of Indian Evidence Act, burden of proof of any fact lies on the person claiming or asserting that fact. Section 102 of the Indian Evidence Act states that burden of proof lies on that person who would fail if no evidence was given on other side. The elementary rule in Section 101 is inflexible. In terms of Section 102 the initial onus is always on the plaintiff and if such onus is discharged and a case is made out which entitles the plaintiff to a relief, the onus shifts to the defendant to prove those circumstances, if any, which would disentitle the plaintiff to the same. The concept of burden of proof would be explained by Hon’ble Supreme Court in so many words which read thus1: 8. The initial burden of proof would be on the plaintiff in view of Section 101 of the Evidence Act, which reads as under: “101. Burden of proof.—Whoever desires any court to give judgment as to any legal right or liability dependent on the existence of facts which he asserts, must prove that those facts exist. When a person is bound to prove the existence of any fact, it is said that the burden of proof lies on that person.” 9. In terms of the said provision, the burden of proving the fact rests on the party who substantially asserts the affirmative issues and not the party who denies it. The said rule may not be universal in its application and there may be an exception thereto. The learned trial court and the High Court proceeded on the basis that the defendant was in a dominating position and there had been a fiduciary relationship between the parties. The appellant in his written 1 Anil Rishi v. Gurbaksh Singh, (2006) 5 SCC 558 -- 6 of 13 -- ____________________________________________________________________________________ CS No. 3/2025 Sh. Rahul Tyagi v. Dinesh Kumar Page No. 7/13 statement denied and disputed the said averments made in the plaint. 10. Pleading is not evidence, far less proof. Issues are raised on the basis of the pleadings. The defendant-appellant having not admitted or acknowledged the fiduciary relationship between the parties, indisputably, the relationship between the parties itself would be an issue. The suit will fail if both the parties do not adduce any evidence, in view of Section 102 of the Evidence Act. Thus, ordinarily, the burden of proof would be on the party who asserts the affirmative of the issue and it rests, after evidence is gone into, upon the party against whom, at the time the question arises, judgment would be given, if no further evidence were to be adduced by either side. xxx xxx xxx (Emphasis Suppplied) 16.The upshot of the above is that once a party who brings the suit and affirms a fact discharges his burden, the onus shifts on the other side. The reason for the same is that once the initial burden is discharged and no further evidence is led, the judgment could be granted in the favour of party who led the evidence. 17.In the present case, the plaintiff has discharged his burden by showing the acknowledgement of debt in writing duly signed by the defendant; the impugned cheque which is duly signed by the defendant; and the return memo of bank whereby the impugned cheque was dishonored. None of these documents have been challenged or otherwise shown by the defendant to have been blemished by element of deceit or subterfuge. On the contrary, the primary burden of proof to show the existence of debt and dishonor of cheque to discharge the same has been proved by the plaintiff on the parameters of balance of probabilities. The law regarding standard of proof in civil proceedings is ubiquitously known and the same -- 7 of 13 -- ____________________________________________________________________________________ CS No. 3/2025 Sh. Rahul Tyagi v. Dinesh Kumar Page No. 8/13 received the judicial imprimatur from the Hon’ble Supreme Court when it was held that2: 24. The normal rule which governs civil proceedings is that a fact can be said to be established if it is proved by a preponderance of probabilities. This is for the reason that under the Evidence Act, Section 3, a fact is said to be proved when the court either believes it to exist or considers its existence so probable that a prudent man ought, under the circumstances of the particular case, to act upon the supposition that it exists. The belief regarding the existence of a fact may thus be founded on a balance of probabilities. A prudent man faced with conflicting probabilities concerning a fact-situation will act on the supposition that the fact exists, if on weighing the various probabilities he finds that the preponderance is in favour of the existence of the particular fact. As a prudent man, so the court applies this test for finding whether a fact in issue can be said to be proved. The first step in this process is to fix the probabilities, the second to weigh them, though the two may often intermingle. The impossible is weeded out at the first stage, the improbable at the second. Within the wide range of probabilities the court has often a difficult choice to make but it is this choice which ultimately determines where the preponderance of probabilities lies. Important issues like those which affect the status of parties demand a closer scrutiny than those like the loan on a promissory note: “the 2 N.G. Dastane (Dr) v. S. Dastane, (1975) 2 SCC 326 -- 8 of 13 -- ____________________________________________________________________________________ CS No. 3/2025 Sh. Rahul Tyagi v. Dinesh Kumar Page No. 9/13 nature and gravity of an issue necessarily determines the manner of attaining reasonable satisfaction of the truth of the issue [ Per Dixon, J. in Wright v. Wright, (1948) 77 CLR 191, 210] ”; or as said by Lord Denning, “the degree of probability depends on the subject-matter. In proportion as the offence is grave, so ought the proof to be clear [Blyth v. Blyth, (1966) 1 AER 524, 536] ”. But whether the issue is one of cruelty or of a loan on a pronote, the test to apply is whether on a preponderance of probabilities the relevant fact is proved. In civil cases this, normally, is the standard of proof to apply for finding whether the burden of proof is discharged. xxx xxx xxx (Emphasis Supplied) 18. Thus, the civil court would not insist upon proof of a fact beyond reasonable doubt unlike a court trying criminal cases. If, in a civil proceeding, a fact can be supposed to exist after applying the test of prudent person, no higher degree of proof should be insisted upon. 19.In the present matter, therefore, the onus would now inevitably befall upon the defendant to demonstrate that he had repaid the loan amount and the impugned cheque was, as a matter of fact, issued as a security cheque. However, the defendant would rest content with the self-serving statements made in the WS. He would not care to file single documentary evidence to show that the debt which he had admitted ceases to exist anymore. He would remain silent about not insisting upon any undertaking by the plaintiff after the alleged repayment of loan. After all, it would have been nothing but least prudent to insist upon an undertaking -- 9 of 13 -- ____________________________________________________________________________________ CS No. 3/2025 Sh. Rahul Tyagi v. Dinesh Kumar Page No. 10/13 when he himself gave it in writing at the time of availing the loan. The defendant would choose not to explain such indolence on his part. Even if I were to believe - for the sake of argument - that defendant had indeed discharged his debt, it was incumbent upon him to procure a written acknowledgement of the same from the plaintiff. A simple remark signed by the plaintiff on document Ex. PW1/2 would have gone a long way in establishing the defence raised by the defendant. Having failed to do so, the defendant has sabotaged his own defence. The law is clear that oral evidence shall not be permitted to render falsehood to the letter of documents. Best evidence rule enunciates that when documentary evidence is available, it assumes more impeccable character than the words which remain unsubstantiated. The Hon’ble Supreme Court would explain the law thus3: i. It is likewise a general and most inflexible rule that wherever written instruments are appointed, either by the requirement of law, or by the contract of the parties, to be the repositories and memorials of truth, any other evidence is excluded from being used either as a substitute for such instruments, or to contradict or alter them. This is a matter both of principle and policy. It is of principle because such instruments are in their own nature and origin, entitled to a much higher degree of credit than parol evidence. It is of policy because it would be attended with great mischief if those instruments, upon which men's rights depended, were liable to be impeached by loose collateral evidence. (See Starkie on Evidence, p. 648.) 3 Roop Kumar Versus Mohan Thedani, (2003) 6 SCC 595 -- 10 of 13 -- ____________________________________________________________________________________ CS No. 3/2025 Sh. Rahul Tyagi v. Dinesh Kumar Page No. 11/13 xxx xxx xxx (Emphasis Supplied) 20.The upshot of the above is that the luminosity of documentary evidence is so potent that it blinds the court to behold the uncertainties in the oral testimonies that strive to impugn the veracity of such records. Thus, the contention of the defendant that nothing remains due to the plaintiff can only be taken with a pinch of salt. 21. Insofar as the argument that impugned cheque is a security cheque is concerned, the Hon’ble Supreme Court would lucidly explain thus4: 22. When a cheque is issued and is treated as “security” towards repayment of an amount with a time period being stipulated for repayment, all that it ensures is that such cheque which is issued as “security” cannot be presented prior to the loan or the instalment maturing for repayment towards which such cheque is issued as security. Further, the borrower would have the option of repaying the loan amount or such financial liability in any other form and in that manner if the amount of loan due and payable has been discharged within the agreed period, the cheque issued as security cannot thereafter be presented. Therefore, the prior discharge of the loan or there being an altered situation due to which there would be understanding between the parties is a sine qua non to not present the cheque which was issued as security. These are only the defences that would be available to the drawer of the cheque in a proceeding initiated under Section 138 of the NI Act. Therefore, there cannot be a hard- 4 Sripati Singh v. State of Jharkhand, (2022) 18 SCC 614 -- 11 of 13 -- ____________________________________________________________________________________ CS No. 3/2025 Sh. Rahul Tyagi v. Dinesh Kumar Page No. 12/13 and-fast rule that a cheque which is issued as security can never be presented by the drawee of the cheque. If such is the understanding a cheque would also be reduced to an “on demand promissory note” and in all circumstances, it would only be a civil litigation to recover the amount, which is not the intention of the statute. When a cheque is issued even though as “security” the consequence flowing therefrom is also known to the drawer of the cheque and in the circumstance stated above if the cheque is presented and dishonoured, the holder of the cheque/drawee would have the option of initiating the civil proceedings for recovery or the criminal proceedings for punishment in the fact situation, but in any event, it is not for the drawer of the cheque to dictate terms with regard to the nature of litigation. xxx xxx xxx (Emphasis Supplied) 22. Meaning thereby, the security cheque is not a useless piece of paper meant to be torn asunder in all circumstances. The word “security” carries a connotation which renders utility to such cheques when promise to return goes unfulfilled. In the present case, therefore, the plaintiff was well withing his rights to not only present the impugned cheque but also to bring the present suit. The defendant’s claim regarding the impugned cheque being issued as a security flies in the face of settled legal position. 23.After considering both the limbs of defence, I find, with unwavering certainty that the defendant has failed to spark even a tremor of reasonable doubt. His stark complacency towards his own predicament creates an unexplained void, rendering his claims a source of deep -- 12 of 13 -- ____________________________________________________________________________________ CS No. 3/2025 Sh. Rahul Tyagi v. Dinesh Kumar Page No. 13/13 suspicion. The case of plaintiff, on the other hand, stands vindicated anchored by documentary evidence that speak volumes about his credibility. Accordingly, the suit is decided in the favour of plaintiff. 24.The plaintiff is hereby granted the relief to recover a sum of Rs. 1,50,000/- from the defendant. Insofar as rate of interest is concerned, 24% rate of interest is a bit harsh and scales of justice would be balanced if rate of interest at 6% per annum is directed from the date of institution of suit till the decretal amount is paid and the interest at the rate of 6 % per annum from 01.01.2024 till 31.10.2024. 25.Thus, at the cost of repetition but in service of clarity, plaintiff is granted the relief to recover a sum of Rs. 1,50,000/- (Rupees One lakh fifty thousand only) along with the rate of interest at 6% per annum from the date of institution of suit till the decretal amount is paid and the interest at the rate of 6 % per annum from 01.01.2024 till 31.10.2024. 26. The suit is decreed and disposed in above terms. Decree-sheet be prepared accordingly. File be consigned to record room. Pranat Kumar Joshi ACJ-cum-ARC-cum-CCJ North-East/Karkardooma Courts, Delhi/15.05.2026 -- 13 of 13 --
