Skip to main content
Court Order

Order 20

CNR DLNE02002743202307 Mar 2026
Back to Case

Full Order Text

Order 20 · 07 Mar 2026 · CNR DLNE020027432023

Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT
Pdf Text: FIR No. 253/2022 State Vs. Rizwan Ahmad Page 1 of 11
IN THE COURT OF MS. TANYA BAMNIYAL
CHIEF JUDICIAL MAGISTRATE, NORTH
EAST KARKARDOOMA COURTS: DELHI
FIR No. 253/2022
Unique Case ID No. 1474/2023
Police Station Crime Branch NE Delhi
Title State Vs. Rizwan Ahamd
Name of complainant HC Surjeet
Name of accused 1. Rizwan Ahmed
S/o Sh. Israr
R/o H.No. L-252, Gali No. 06,
Gautam Vihar, Khadde Wali
Masjid, 4th Pushta, Kartar
Nagar, Delhi.
Date of institution of challan 18.03.2025
Date of final arguments 07.02.2026
Date of pronouncement 07.03.2026
Date of commission of offence 02.11.2022
Offence complained of U/s 224 IPC
Offence charged with U/s. 224 IPC
Plea of the accused Pleaded not guilty
Final order Convicted
JUDGMENT
BRIEF FACTS:-
01. Briefly stated, the case of the prosecution is that on
02.11.2022 at 06:30 AM at Old PS Welcome, ER-III, Crime Branch,
Delhi, the accused had intentionally escaped from custody in which
-- 1 of 11 --
FIR No. 253/2022 State Vs. Rizwan Ahmad Page 2 of 11
the accused was lawfully detained for an offence. Accordingly the
FIR u/s 224 IPC was registered against the accused.
NOTICE:
02. Notice U/s. 224 IPC was framed against the accused on
07.02.2024 to which he pleaded not guilty and claimed trial.
PROSECUTION EVIDENCE:
03. The prosecution examined 04 witnesses in total to
prove its case.
04. PW1 HC Surjeet deposed that on 01.11.2022, he was
posted at ER-IIIrd, Welcome as HC. On that day, accused was
arrested in e-FIR No. 028975, U/S 379 IPC, PS e-Police Station
Bhajanpura and was kept in IO’s room for enquiry. In the next
morning, at about 6:30 AM, the accused complained about the
stomach pain and told that he wished to go to toilet. PW1 had taken
the accused to toilet at 2nd floor and dropped in the toilet, however,
the accused pushed him due to which, he fell on the ground and
thereafter, the accused ran away from there. He made hue and cry to
apprehend the accused but the accused succeeded in fleeing away
from there. He made efforts to find the accused nearby but the
accused was not found. Thereafter, he informed to his senior about
the incident. IO recorded his statement which is Ex. PW1/A bearing
my signature at point A. IO prepared the site plan which is Ex.
-- 2 of 11 --
FIR No. 253/2022 State Vs. Rizwan Ahmad Page 3 of 11
PW1/B. Thereafter, on 03.11.2022, at about 4:30 PM, the accused
was arrested from Gade Wali Masjid nar Kalindi Kunj Metro Station
vide arrest memo Ex. PW1/C. alongwith a personal search was also
conducted vide personal search memo Ex. PW1/D and disclosure
statement was recorded Ex. PW1/E. The witness has correctly
identified the accused.
05. PW2 HC Vikas Tomar deposed on 01.11.2022. He was
posted at PS ER III Welcome as HC. On that day, he along with ASI
Praveen, HC Deepak and HC Praveen were present in the area of
New Usmanpur. On that day, the accused was found with one stolen
motorcycle make Splendor Pro. Thereafter the accused was arrested
u/S 41 1 (d) Cr.P.C. and he was taken to office in welcome. He
prepared kalandara which is Ex. PW2/A. Thereafter, he had fled
away from there from the custody of HC Deepak and him in the
morning of 02.11.2022. They tried to search the accused but the
accused was not found. On 03.11.2022, the accused was arrested
and FIR No. 253/2022 under section 224 IPC was lodged against the
accused. The witness correctly identified the accused.
06. PW3 SI Praveen Kumar deposed on 02.11.2022, he was
posted at PS ER III Welcome, Crime Branch as ASI and on that day,
one case was marked to him for further action. He had recorded the
statement of HC Surjeet in which he had stated that vide DD No.
165 A kalandara dated 01.11.2022, the accused was apprehended by
HC Vikas in a case related to recovery of stolen bikes. He was under
-- 3 of 11 --
FIR No. 253/2022 State Vs. Rizwan Ahmad Page 4 of 11
the custody of HC Deepak and HC Surjeet at ER-II PS Welcome
office 2nd Floor, Delhi. He had also informed that at about 06:30
AM, the accused told them that the accused was having stomach
pain and had to go to toilet and on the way to the toilet, the accused
pushed HC Surjeet and absconded from the custody. HC Deepak
and HC Surjeet made efforts to trace the accused but he could not be
found despite best efforts. Thereafter, the said statement of HC
surjeet is already Ex. PW1/A. He had made endorsement on the said
complaint and prepared the rukka which is now Ex. PW3/A. After
that, an FIR got registered and the said FIR along with certificate
u/S 65 B of Indian Evidence Act are now Ex. PW3/B (colly). After
that, he prepared the site plan at the instance of HC surjeet the same
is already Ex. PW1/B. On 03.11.2022, he was informed by secret
informer that accused's brother in law has a family function and so
the accused can be apprehended there after which he had prepared
one raiding team consisting of HC Praveen, HC Deepak, HC Surjeet
and another police officials including him. After that they made
departure entry, however, he does not remember the exact DD entry.
After that we had gone to the spot of incident of incident i.e. near
border of Kalandikukj, Madanpur, Khadar, Delhi. After reaching
there they had apprehened the accused. He correctly identified the
accused.
07. PW4 HC Deepak deposed on 02.11.2022, he was
posted at PS ER III, Crime Branch Welcome as HC and he was
present at his office i.e. IO’s room, 2nd Floor. Accused was in the
-- 4 of 11 --
FIR No. 253/2022 State Vs. Rizwan Ahmad Page 5 of 11
custody of HC Surjeet and he was also present there and when HC
Surjeet took the accused for toilet, then he heard the noise of
Bhagya Bhagya. He rushed towards toilet where HC Surjeet told
him that the accused fled from his custody as he was going with the
accused as he wanted to fresh himself and the accused pushed HC
Surjeet and flee from corridor. Thereafter, he along with HC Surjeet
came down through stairs and came at main gate of the office, but
he did not see the accused. Thereafter, HC Surjeet informed other
staff and senior police officials on phone and they also searched the
accused at your friends and relatives house and also possible
hideouts, but the accused could not found by them. On the next day
when they reached at Vijay Park where secret informer met them
and told them that the person who escaped from custody of police
on 02.11.2022 will come at Madanpur Khadr. Thereafter they
reached at Madanpur Khadar and took our position. After sometime,
at about 04:15 PM, the accused came and accused was apprehended
by police team by us. Thereafter, the accused was arrested vide
arrest memo already Ex. PW1/C and personal search was also got
conducted vide memo already Ex. PW1/D. Disclosure statement
was also recorded vide memo Ex. PW1/E. the accused was arrested
in E-FIR No. 28975 u/S 379 IPC of PS E-Police Station Bhajapura.
The correctly identified the accused
08. Thereafter, PE was closed vide order dated 05.12.2025
Statement of accused was recorded under section 313 Cr.P.C (351 of
BNSS, 2023). Accused Rizwan Ahamd opted not to lead evidence in
-- 5 of 11 --
FIR No. 253/2022 State Vs. Rizwan Ahmad Page 6 of 11
his defence and hence, DE was closed. Final arguments were heard
from both the sides.
Admitted Documents Under Section 294 CR.P.C
09. Statement of accused u/s 294 Cr.P.C./330 BNSS was
recorded on 26.11.2025 where he admitted the factum of registration
of FIR and Certificate under Section 65 (B) of Indian Evidence Act
and the same are Ex. A1 and Ex. A-2, respectively.
FINAL ARGUMENTS:
10. Ld. APP for the State has argued that the prosecution
has succeeded in establishing the guilt of the accused beyond
reasonable doubt thereby forming a consistent and compelling chain
of evidence against the accused.
11. Per Contra, it is argued by Ld. Counsel for accused that
prosecution has miserably failed to prove its case as there is nothing
on record to show that the accused escaped from custody. There are
no public witnesses to substantiate the commission of the offence,
and the prosecution has failed to prove the case beyond reasonable
doubt.
ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS:
12. The accused has been charged for the offence
punishable under Section 224 of the Indian Penal Code. The
gravamen of the allegation is that on 02.11.2022 at about 06:30 AM
-- 6 of 11 --
FIR No. 253/2022 State Vs. Rizwan Ahmad Page 7 of 11
at ER-III, Crime Branch Office, Welcome, Delhi, while being in
lawful custody in connection with e-FIR No. 028975 U/s 379 IPC of
PS E-Police Station Bhajanpura, the accused escaped from such
custody by pushing HC Surjeet. The burden lies upon the
prosecution to establish its case beyond reasonable doubt.
13. Section 224 IPC provides punishment for resistance or
obstruction by a person to his lawful apprehension, or for escape or
attempt to escape from lawful custody. To bring home guilt under
Section 224 IPC, the prosecution must establish:
1. That the accused was in lawful custody;
2. That such custody was in connection with a lawful
apprehension;
3. That the accused voluntarily escaped or attempted to
escape from such custody.
14. The expression “lawful custody” implies detention
under authority of law. It is not necessary that such custody must be
pursuant to a judicial remand; even police custody pursuant to a
lawful arrest satisfies the requirement. The term “escape” connotes
voluntary evasion or departure from such custody without lawful
authority.
15. The prosecution has examined PW-1 HC Surjeet, PW-2
HC Vikas Tomar and PW-4 HC Deepak, who have consistently
deposed that the accused had been apprehended in connection with
-- 7 of 11 --
FIR No. 253/2022 State Vs. Rizwan Ahmad Page 8 of 11
recovery of a stolen motorcycle and proceedings under Section
41(1)(d) Cr.P.C. were initiated. PW-2 proved the kalandra (Ex.
PW2/A). It has come on record that the accused was brought to ER-
III Office and remained under custody of police officials.
16. The defence has not seriously disputed the factum of
custody. No suggestion was put that the custody itself was illegal or
unauthorized. There is no material on record to indicate that the
detention of the accused was in contravention of law. In view of the
unrebutted testimonies of prosecution witnesses and documentary
record, this Court is satisfied that the accused was in lawful police
custody on the intervening night of 01/02.11.2022.
17. PW-1 HC Surjeet has deposed that at about 06:30 AM,
the accused complained of stomach pain and requested to go to the
toilet. He took the accused to the toilet situated on the 2nd floor.
After using the toilet, the accused suddenly pushed PW-1, causing
him to fall, and fled from the corridor. PW-1 raised alarm but the
accused succeeded in escaping.
18. PW-4 HC Deepak corroborated this version. He
deposed that upon hearing shouts of “bhag gaya bhag gaya”, he
rushed towards the toilet area where PW-1 informed him that the
accused had fled after pushing him. Both officials searched for the
accused immediately but could not apprehend him.
-- 8 of 11 --
FIR No. 253/2022 State Vs. Rizwan Ahmad Page 9 of 11
19. The testimony of PW-1 is direct evidence of the act of
escape. His presence at the spot is natural and admitted. Nothing
material has been elicited in cross-examination to discredit his core
version. The minor inconsistencies regarding exact timings or non-
mention of certain facts in Section 161 Cr.P.C. statement do not go
to the root of the prosecution case.
20. It is well settled that omissions which are not material
contradictions do not render testimony unreliable. Human memory
is fallible with respect to peripheral details, especially when
witnesses depose after considerable lapse of time. The defence has
emphasized absence of CCTV footage. However, it has come on
record that there were no CCTV cameras installed inside the Crime
Branch office at the relevant time. The absence of electronic
evidence cannot outweigh credible ocular testimony. Law does not
mandate corroboration of trustworthy eye witness account by CCTV
footage.
21. Further, no motive has been suggested as to why police
officials would falsely implicate the accused in an offence under
Section 224 IPC. False implication in such circumstances would
expose officials themselves to departmental consequences, which
renders such suggestion inherently improbable. The act attributed to
the accused is not accidental or involuntary. The prosecution
evidence establishes that the accused intentionally pushed PW-1 and
ran away from the corridor. Such conduct clearly manifests mens
-- 9 of 11 --
FIR No. 253/2022 State Vs. Rizwan Ahmad Page 10 of 11
rea to evade custody. Moreover, Section 224 IPC does not require
elaborate preparation; even sudden flight from custody constitutes
escape if it is voluntary. The fact that the accused remained
absconding until 03.11.2022 further fortifies the inference of
intentional escape.
22. PW-3 SI Praveen Kumar and PW-4 have deposed
regarding re-arrest of the accused on 03.11.2022. Arrest memo and
personal search memo have been proved. The fact that the accused
had to be re-apprehended supports the prosecution version that he
had indeed absconded from lawful custody. The defence has
attempted to point out certain procedural lapses such as non-joining
of public witnesses and non-preparation of site plan at the place of
re-arrest. Even if assumed, such lapses do not demolish the
prosecution case relating to the core incident of escape.
23. It is a settled principle that defects in investigation
cannot enure to the benefit of the accused unless prejudice is shown.
No such prejudice has been demonstrated. The testimonies of PW-1
and PW-4 are consistent, cogent and inspire confidence. Their cross-
examination does not reveal any material contradiction affecting the
substratum of the prosecution case. Merely because the witnesses
are police officials does not render their testimony unreliable. In
absence of animus, their evidence cannot be discarded solely on the
ground of official status.
-- 10 of 11 --
FIR No. 253/2022 State Vs. Rizwan Ahmad Page 11 of 11
24. From the cumulative appreciation of oral and
documentary evidence, this Court finds:
(i) The accused was in lawful police custody.
(ii) He voluntarily pushed the escorting officer and fled from
custody.
(iii) The prosecution has proved the essential ingredients of Section
224 IPC beyond reasonable doubt.
25. The defence has failed to create any reasonable doubt
in the prosecution case. Accordingly, the offence under Section 224
IPC stands proved against the accused Rizwan Ahmad. Therefore,
the accused Rizwan Ahmad convicted for the offence punishable u/s
224 IPC.
Let the parties be heard on the quantum of sentence.
Copy of judgment be given free of cost to the parties.
Announced in the open Court,
on 07.03.2026
(TANYA BAMNIYAL)
Chief Judicial Magistrate
North-East/Karkardooma Courts/Delhi
This judgement contains 11 pages and each page bears my
signature.
-- 11 of 11 --

TrustJury presents public court-record information for legal discovery and reference. Record availability and detail can vary by source and case.