Skip to main content
Court Order

Order 5

CNR DLNE01003715202407 Mar 2025
Back to Case

Full Order Text

Order 5 · 07 Mar 2025 · CNR DLNE010037152024

Order Details: COPY OF ORDER
Pdf Text: 22 MCA DJ 19/24
SABA PARVEEN Vs. BSES YPL
07.03.2025
Present: Sh. A.S. Khan, Ld. counsel for appellant with appellant.
Sh. Akash Swami, Ld. counsel for R-1.
Ld. counsel for R-2 with R-2.
1. In this matter, an application U/O XXXIX Rule 1 & 2 CPC moved
by plaintiff has been dismissed inter-alia on the ground that title and
possession of the plaintiff over the suit property is disputed. During
the course of hearing, it transpired that while plaintiff claims that she
is living in a flat bearing No. C-181/2F, Top floor, Khasra No. 148,
Gali No. 2, Chauhan Bangar, Delhi, this fact is disputed by D-2 (her
husband). It is his case that while plaintiff was living in the aforesaid
flat earlier, he later shifted his wife/plaintiff to another flat bearing
No. C-181/2F, Vth floor, Right side, Khasra No. 148, Gali No. 2,
Chauhan Bangar, Delhi.
2. D-2 claimed before this Court that the aforesaid two properties are
different properties and are located at a distance of 1-2 Kms from
each other and plaintiff wants to take advantage of similarity of
property numbers of the aforesaid two properties.
3. During arguments, parties proposed that the controversy can be put
to an end by appointing a Local Commissioner who can visit the
aforesaid properties and then it will be evident that whether the
aforesaid properties are separate properties or are one and the same
property.
4. Thus, in view of the aforesaid proposal made by the parties and
-- 1 of 3 --
keeping in mind the controversy in hand, with the consent of parties,
Mr. Avinash Chandra Upadhyay, Advocate, Seat No. 10, Hall No. 05,
3rd Floor, Lawyer’s Chamber, District Court, Dwarka, Sec-10, New
Delhi – 110075, Mobile No. 7503363380/8700352833 is appointed
as Local Commissioner to carry out inspection of the above
described property(ies).
5. Since D-2/R-2 namely Hamid S/o Hafizuddin has claimed before this
Court that there are two separate properties bearing No. C-181/2F,
Top floor, Khasra No. 148, Gali No. 2, Chauhan Bangar, Delhi and
C-181/2F, Vth floor, Right side, Khasra No. 148, Gali No. 2,
Chauhan Bangar, Delhi, he shall point out these properties to the
Local Commissioner who shall then prepare a map of the said
property(ies) with the help of a draftsman and shall also get a proper
site plan prepared of the same. The said site plan shall also indicate
the surrounding properties with correct directions thereof so as to
identify the aforesaid two properties. He shall also indicate in his
report as to whether the said properties are two different properties or
they are the same. If they are separate properties, he shall also
indicate the approximate distance between the two. He is at liberty
to take police help from the concerned police station for carrying out
the said inspection.
6. Let the said inspection be carried out on 19.03.2025 at 2:00 PM.
SHO concerned is directed to provide necessary police aid along
with lady police for carrying out the commission.
7. The fee of the Local Commissioner is fixed at Rs.30,000/- to be paid
by R-2. The fee shall be paid in advance to the Ld. Local
Commissioner. This is in view of the fact that R-2 is admittedly the
-- 2 of 3 --
husband of plaintiff/appellant and it is his claim that he shifted his
wife from one property to the other (which is disputed by his
wife/appellant/plaintiff).
8. The fee of the draughtsman shall be paid separately by R-2 as per
actuals. Let the report of Local Commissioner along with the site
plans to be prepared be filed in court on 05.04.2025.
9. Let copy of this order be given dasti to the parties and also to the Ld.
Local Commissioner. Copy of this order be also sent to SHO
concerned for information and necessary compliance.
AASHISH GUPTA
DJ-01/NE/KKD/DELHI
07.03.2025
-- 3 of 3 --

TrustJury presents public court-record information for legal discovery and reference. Record availability and detail can vary by source and case.