Full Order Text
Order 5 · 10 Oct 2023 · CNR DLNE010026562023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: CNR No. DLNE01-002656-2023 Manish Premji Soni v. Mohd. Vasim Crl. Appeal No.78/23, PS Bhajanpura Order dated 10.10.2023 DLNE010026562023 IN THE COURT OF SH. PULASTYA PRAMACHALA ADDITIONAL SESSIONS JUDGE-03, NORTH-EAST DISTRICT, KARKARDOOMA COURTS: DELHI Criminal Appeal No. : 78/2023 Police Station : Bhajanpura Complaint Case No. : 1048/2019 CNR Nos. : DLNE01-002656-2023 In the matter of: - Sh. Manish Premji Soni S/o. Sh. Premji Soni, R/o. B-403, Padmavathi, CHS Dumping Road, Mulund West, Near Croma, Mulund, Mumbai, Maharashtra. ...Appellant Versus Mohd. Vasim S/o. Mohd. Rais Khan, R/o. H.No. B-1892/1, Near Shishu Niketan Public School, Subhash Mohalla, North Gonda, Delhi-110053. ...Respondent Page 1 of 6 (Pulastya Pramachala) ASJ-03, North-East District, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi -- 1 of 6 -- CNR No. DLNE01-002656-2023 Manish Premji Soni v. Mohd. Vasim Crl. Appeal No.78/23, PS Bhajanpura Order dated 10.10.2023 10.10.2023 ORDER ON CONDONATION OF DELAY Vide this order, I shall decide the application for condonation of delay in filing present criminal appeal preferred against impugned orders dated 12.07.2023 and 10.04.2023. 1. Vide impugned order dated 10.04.2023, trial court issued NBW against applicant herein for his non-appearance. Trial court also forfeited the bail bond and issued directions for registration of FIR against applicant u/s. 229A IPC. Trial court issued warrants of attachment against applicant i.e. appellant herein for recovery of Rs.1 lakh on forfeiture of bail bonds. Trial court also recorded that according to report received from the bank the FDR furnished with surety bond on 25.03.2023, was withdrawn on 26.03.2023 itself. Trial court also issued bailable warrant against his surety. 2. Thereafter, vide order dated 12.07.2023 trial court stayed NBW against applicant till 12.09.2023, subject to deposit of Rs.1 lakh by applicant within seven days i.e. up to 12.09.2023. Trial court also recorded the report sent by SHO PS Farsh Bazar about registration of FIR No.286/23 u/s. 229A IPC. 3. Grounds taken by applicant for condonation of delay, in filing present criminal appeal: - ● That there is no limitation period prescribed under the Limitation Act to file an appeal u/s. 449 Cr.P.C. ● That applicant being resident of Mumbai and a layman only, became aware of the impugned order dated 10.04.2023, on Page 2 of 6 (Pulastya Pramachala) ASJ-03, North-East District, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi -- 2 of 6 -- CNR No. DLNE01-002656-2023 Manish Premji Soni v. Mohd. Vasim Crl. Appeal No.78/23, PS Bhajanpura Order dated 10.10.2023 08.07.2023, when he was informed by his wife that police officials had come to the residential address of applicant with NBW's issued by trial court in Complaint Case No. 1048/2019 titled as “Mohd. Vasim v. Bullish Global LLP”. As per that order, applicant was directed to appear before trial court on 12.07.2023. ● That applicant immediately contacted ld. counsel Mr. Nishchal Joshi, as the previous counsel who appeared on 25.03.2023 had totally misguided him and his non appearance on 10.04.2023 was due to that reason only. That applicant came to know about the order dated 10.04.2023, when his present counsel searched his case status and apprised him about the proceedings that happened on 10.04.2023. ● That on 12.07.2023, when applicant appeared through video conference before the trial court, the trial court imposed penalty of Rs.1 lakh on appellant and Rs.10,000/- on his surety. ● That to file present appeal, applicant immediately applied for the certified copies of all the judicial orders passed in CC No. 1048/2019 and the applicant had received the certified copies of the orders on 21.08.2023. ● That for order dated 12.07.2023 there is no delay to be condoned; however, for the order dated 10.04.2023, if the period of limitation is taken to be 30 days, then there is a delay of 110 days in filing the present appeal. 4. In support of his contentions, ld. counsel for applicant relied upon certain case laws, which are as follows: - Page 3 of 6 (Pulastya Pramachala) ASJ-03, North-East District, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi -- 3 of 6 -- CNR No. DLNE01-002656-2023 Manish Premji Soni v. Mohd. Vasim Crl. Appeal No.78/23, PS Bhajanpura Order dated 10.10.2023 ● Ravinder Lal Airi v. S. Shalu Construction Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. Crl. M.A. 1951/2023 decided on 24.01.2023 by High Court of Delhi. ● Nishu Wadhwa v. Siddharth Wadhwa & Anr. Crl. M.A. No.6591/2016, decided on 10.01.2017 by High Court of Delhi. ● Raheem Shah & Anr. v. Govind Singh & Ors., Civil Appeal No.4628 of 2023, decided on 24.07.2023 by Supreme Court. 5. On the application for condonation of delay, ld. counsel for applicant submitted that normally the period to file appeal is 30 days, but no such provision has been provided for Section 449 Cr.P.C. He further made arguments on the lines of grounds taken in the application to justify the delay in filing this appeal. 6. Per contra, ld. counsel for respondent submitted that in the application it is mentioned that wife of the applicant informed him about NBWs against him, though applicant himself had appeared on execution of NBW on 25.03.2023. He submitted that in the past also when NBWs were issued against applicant, applicant would have been informed by his wife, but he did not appear. He submitted that applicant had been deliberately not appearing before the trial court and he is not a bona fide person. Findings: - 7. The limitation period to prefer an appeal u/s. 449 Cr.P.C. is not provided in Cr.P.C. However, Article 115(b) of the Schedule provided in Limitation Act, 1963, operates in such situation. This provision provides limitation for appeal against any order not being an order of acquittal. If the appeal is being preferred to any court other than High Court, then the period of limitation is 30 days from the date of such order. Thus, the period of limitation in Page 4 of 6 (Pulastya Pramachala) ASJ-03, North-East District, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi -- 4 of 6 -- CNR No. DLNE01-002656-2023 Manish Premji Soni v. Mohd. Vasim Crl. Appeal No.78/23, PS Bhajanpura Order dated 10.10.2023 the present case started from 10.04.2023 and lapsed on 09.05.2023. Though, order dated 12.07.2023 has also been impugned, but during the course of arguments itself, ld. counsel conceded that this order was based on order dated 10.04.2023 and there was no new finding or decision given in order dated 12.07.2023 in respect of subject matter of the appeal i.e. forfeiture of bail bond. Therefore, order dated 12.07.2023 cannot be taken into consideration for extension of limitation period. 8. As far as delay in preferring appeal is concerned, as per applicant itself there is delay of 110 days. Applicant had pleaded that his previous counsel had misguided him on 25.03.2023. Ld. counsel submitted that the previous counsel assured the applicant that the counsel would take care of further proceedings and the applicant need not come. It was argued that this assurance was given on the basis of plea taken by applicant on 25.03.2023 that he had already made payment to the complainant. Thereafter, applicant contacted the present counsel after being aware of NBW against him on 08.07.2023. Ld. counsel, thereafter, applied for certified copies and thereafter, he filed the appeal in question. The certified copies were applied on 14.07.2023 and were delivered on 21.08.2023. Appeal was filed on 31.08.2023. 9. In the case of Collector, Land Acquisition, Anantnag & Anr. v. Mst. Katiji & Ors. (1987) 2 SCC 107, hon'ble Supreme Court observed that: - “Refusing to condone delay can result in a maritorious matter being thrown out at the very threshold and cause of justice being defeated.” Page 5 of 6 (Pulastya Pramachala) ASJ-03, North-East District, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi -- 5 of 6 -- CNR No. DLNE01-002656-2023 Manish Premji Soni v. Mohd. Vasim Crl. Appeal No.78/23, PS Bhajanpura Order dated 10.10.2023 It was further observed that: - “When substantial justice and technical considerations are pitted against each other, cause of substantial justice deserves to be preferred.” It was also observed that: - “There is no presumption that delay is occasioned deliberately, or on account of culpable negligence, or on account of mala fides.” 10. In the present case, there is no doubt that there had been huge delay in preferring this appeal. But at the same time, if the contentions raised by applicant are ture, in that situtation refusing to entertain his appeal would certainly be defeating cause of justice, so as to deny hearing to the applicant on his appeal. Therefore, I deem it fit to condone the delay in preferring this appeal. Application is accordingly allowed. Announced in the open court (PULASTYA PRAMACHALA) today on 10.10.2023 ASJ-03(North East) (This order contains 6 pages) Karkardooma Courts/Delhi Page 6 of 6 (Pulastya Pramachala) ASJ-03, North-East District, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi -- 6 of 6 --
