Skip to main content
Court Order

Final Order 10

CNR DLNE01002656202328 Nov 2023
Back to Case

Full Order Text

Final Order 10 · 28 Nov 2023 · CNR DLNE010026562023

Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT
Pdf Text: CNR No. DLNE01-002656-2023
Manish Premji Soni v. Mohd. Vasim
Crl. Appeal No.78/23, PS Bhajanpura
Judgment dated 28.11.2023
DLNE010026562023
IN THE COURT OF SH. PULASTYA PRAMACHALA
ADDITIONAL SESSIONS JUDGE-03,
NORTH-EAST DISTRICT,
KARKARDOOMA COURTS: DELHI
Criminal Appeal No. : 78/2023
Under Section : 449 Cr.P.C.
Police Station : Bhajanpura
Complaint Case No. : 1048/2019
CNR Nos. : DLNE01-002656-2023
In the matter of: -
Sh. Manish Premji Soni
S/o. Sh. Premji Soni,
R/o. B-403, Padmavathi, CHS Dumping Road,
Mulund West, Near Croma,
Mulund, Mumbai, Maharashtra.
...Appellant
Versus
Mohd. Vasim
S/o. Mohd. Rais Khan,
R/o. H.No. B-1892/1,
Near Shishu Niketan Public School,
Subhash Mohalla, North Gonda, Delhi-110053.
...Respondent
Date of Institution : 01.09.2023
Date of reserving order : 09.11.2023
Date of pronouncement : 28.11.2023
Decision : Appeal is allowed.
Page 1 of 7 (Pulastya Pramachala)
ASJ-03, North-East District,
Karkardooma Courts, Delhi
-- 1 of 7 --
CNR No. DLNE01-002656-2023
Manish Premji Soni v. Mohd. Vasim
Crl. Appeal No.78/23, PS Bhajanpura
Judgment dated 28.11.2023
J U D G M E N T
1. Present appeal has been preferred against impugned orders dated
12.07.2023 and 10.04.2023 passed by ld. MM-01, North-East
District, Karkardooma Court, Delhi, in the case titled as Mohd.
Vasim v. Manish Premji Soni, bearing Complaint Case (CT)
No. 1048/19, under Section 138 Negotiable Instruments Act,
1881 (hereinafter referred to as the Act).
2. Vide impugned order dated 10.04.2023, trial court issued NBW
against appellant herein for his non-appearance. Trial court also
forfeited the bail bond and issued directions for registration of
FIR against appellant u/s. 229A IPC. Trial court issued warrants
of attachment against appellant herein for recovery of Rs.1 lakh
on forfeiture of bail bonds. Trial court also recorded that
according to report received from the bank the FDR furnished
with surety bond on 25.03.2023, was withdrawn on 26.03.2023
itself. Trial court also issued bailable warrant against his surety.
3. Thereafter, vide order dated 12.07.2023 trial court stayed NBW
against appellant till 12.09.2023, subject to deposit of Rs.1 lakh
by appellant within seven days from 12.09.2023. Trial court also
recorded the report sent by SHO PS Farsh Bazar about
registration of FIR No.286/23 u/s. 229A IPC.
4. Being aggrieved of the impugned order, appellant has preferred
this appeal on the following grounds :-
● That trial court failed to appreciate that arrest of appellant/
accused was illegal or unlawful and the subsequent proceedings
have also become illegal.
Page 2 of 7 (Pulastya Pramachala)
ASJ-03, North-East District,
Karkardooma Courts, Delhi
-- 2 of 7 --
CNR No. DLNE01-002656-2023
Manish Premji Soni v. Mohd. Vasim
Crl. Appeal No.78/23, PS Bhajanpura
Judgment dated 28.11.2023
● That impugned order dated 10.04.2023 is consolidated order,
whereby due to non-appearance of appellant, trial court forfeited
the bail bonds and sent the same to SHO PS Farsh Bazar for
registration of FIR against appellant u/s. 229A IPC, without
issuing notice as prescribed u/s. 446 Cr.P.C.
● That trial court failed to take judicial notice of the fact that a
show cause notice u/s. 446 Cr.P.C. was mandatory prior to
forfeiting of the bonds and before issuing the recovery warrant.
● That trial court failed to appreciate the law laid down by
Allahabad High Court in Criminal Appeal No.1126 of 2016,
titled as Jamuna Deen and Anr. v. State of U.P. (2016) 03 AHC
CK 0125, wherein court held that: -
“8. First, I would like to produce sub-section 1 of Section 446,
Cr.P.C., which reads as under:-
“446. Procedure when bond has been forfeited.-(1)Where a bond
under this Code is for appearance, or for production of property,
before a Court and it is proved to the satisfaction of that Court or of
any Court to which the case has subsequently been transferred, that
the bond has been forfeited, or where, in respect of any other bond
under this Code, it is proved to the satisfaction of the Court by which
the bond was taken, or of any Court to which the case has
subsequently been transferred, or of the Court of any Magistrate of
the first class, that the bond has been forfeited, the Court shall record
the grounds of such proof, and may call upon any person bound by
such bond to pay the penalty thereof or to show cause why it should
not be paid.”
Explanation: A condition in a bond for appearance, or for production
of property, before a Court shall be construed as including a condition
for appearance, or as the case may be, for production of property,
before any Court to which the case may subsequently be transferred.
9. Afore-quoted sub-section reveals that forfeiture of the bond has to
precede the issue of notice under Section 446, Cr.P.C. ….......
10. From the perusal of the annexure-1 to the Supplementary Affidavit
I also find that notices under Section 446, Cr.P.C. issued to the
appellants were not in proper form. In Schedule 2 of the Cr.P.C. Form
No. 48 has been given, which prescribes the format in which notice is
required to be given to the surety. The notice issued by the learned
trial Judge is not in the proper format, as referred above.
11. Since the order suffers illegality on two score, I am not able to
accept the arguments advanced by the learned AGA and in my
opinion, the appeal has substance and it deserves to be allowed.”
Page 3 of 7 (Pulastya Pramachala)
ASJ-03, North-East District,
Karkardooma Courts, Delhi
-- 3 of 7 --
CNR No. DLNE01-002656-2023
Manish Premji Soni v. Mohd. Vasim
Crl. Appeal No.78/23, PS Bhajanpura
Judgment dated 28.11.2023
● That trial court failed to appreciate the law laid down by
Allahabad High Court in Criminal Appeal No. 2322 of 2011,
titled as Banarasi Lal Vishwakarma and Anr. v. State of U.P.
(2011) 04 AHC CK 0107, wherein court has held that: -
"In such circumstances the sureties cannot be penalised if the
accused appeared subsequently for facing trial. The court below
while separating the proceedings u/s 446 Code of Criminal
Procedure and directing to register a case by an order dated
1.10.2010 has also issued notices for recovery in the same breath.
u/s 446 Code of Criminal Procedure show cause notice is
mandatory prior to forfeiting the bonds and before issuing the
recovery warrant. The order sheet of the case does not indicate that
the bonds have been forfeited. It is the duty of the Court to give a
notice to the person whose bond is or has been forfeited, calling
upon him either to pay the penalty or to show cause why it should
not be paid. If he pays the penalty in pursuance of the notice, the
matter ends. If he does not pay the penalty and offers some
explanation showing reasonable causes of non appearance of the
accused, the Court has to consider the causes and pass a reasoned
order thereon. If the cause shown is not sufficient the amount of the
penalty should be determined remains unpaid, the Court has power
to make recovery of the penalty as fine. Nothing such has happened
as is evident from the order sheet itself and directly an order for
recovery has been issued against the sureties, therefore, the order
passed by the court below is unsustainable and as such cannot be
upheld and is liable to be set aside. The appeal succeeds and is
allowed and the recovery proceedings if any held in pursuance of
the order is set aside."
● That trial court failed to issue any notice to the appellant and
forfeited the bail bonds on only a single date non appearance.
● That trial court in its order dated 10.04.2023 erred in observing
that FDR given by the surety had been withdrawn, whereas the
record clearly showed that the surety had deposited RC of his
vehicle and not the FDR.
● That trial court failed to take into consideration that the appellant
and gave a plausible explanation for his non-appearance on
10.04.2023, still trial court imposed fine of Rs.1,00,000/- on
appellant without recording his submissions. Trial court did not
give an opportunity to be heard, which is against the principle of
natural justice.
Page 4 of 7 (Pulastya Pramachala)
ASJ-03, North-East District,
Karkardooma Courts, Delhi
-- 4 of 7 --
CNR No. DLNE01-002656-2023
Manish Premji Soni v. Mohd. Vasim
Crl. Appeal No.78/23, PS Bhajanpura
Judgment dated 28.11.2023
● That trial court did not appreciate the submissions made by
appellant and their poor financial condition, and passed the
impugned orders in a mechanical manner.
5. In support of his contentions, ld. counsel for appellant relied
upon certain case laws, which are as follows: -
● Ravinder Lal Airi v. S. Shalu Construction Pvt. Ltd. &
Ors. Crl. M.A. 1951/2023 decided on 24.01.2023 by High
Court of Delhi.
● Nishu Wadhwa v. Siddharth Wadhwa & Anr. Crl. M.A.
No.6591/2016, decided on 10.01.2017 by High Court of
Delhi.
● Raheem Shah & Anr. v. Govind Singh & Ors., Civil Appeal
No.4628 of 2023, decided on 24.07.2023 by Supreme Court.
Arguments: -
6. Sh. Nishchal Joshi, ld. counsel for appellant argued on the lines
of plea taken by him in the grounds of appeal. Ld. counsel for
appellant submitted that ld. MM did not follow the mandate of
law and straightaway issued warrant of attachment for recovery
of penalty amount, though he was duty bound to issue show
cause notice to seek explanation from the appellant before
imposing any penalty.
7. Sh. Abid Husain, ld. counsel for respondent argued that
accused/respondent herein had been deliberately delay the
proceedings. It was further argued that ld. MM was justified in
passing the impugned orders as respondent herein was playing
game of hide and seek.
Findings: -
8. Section 446 Cr.P.C. has already been mentioned herein-above. In
the grounds though appellant has taken several grounds, but the
Page 5 of 7 (Pulastya Pramachala)
ASJ-03, North-East District,
Karkardooma Courts, Delhi
-- 5 of 7 --
CNR No. DLNE01-002656-2023
Manish Premji Soni v. Mohd. Vasim
Crl. Appeal No.78/23, PS Bhajanpura
Judgment dated 28.11.2023
issue revolves around compliance of provision u/s 446 Cr.P.C.
Therefore, I shall discuss the relevant proceedings only. As per
record, appellant had not appeared before the trial court and
warrants issued against him were also returned back unexecuted
in the past. Ld. MM gave directions to higher officers of the
police to take sufficient steps and finally appellant was arrested
and produced before Duty MM on 25.03.2023. He was released
on bail on his furnishing bail bond in the sum of Rs. 1 lac. Bail
bond included personal bond of appellant and surety bond of
surety and each bond was furnished in the sum of Rs. 1 lac.
Appellant did not appear before the trial court on the next date
fixed i.e. 10.04.2023.
9. Ld. MM in these circumstances passed the impugned order dt.
10.04.2023. Though, it is apparent that omission of appellant to
appear on very next date after release on bail, was in fact
disturbing especially when appellant had not put in his appreance
before trial court for a long period, before his arrest. But, at the
same time it is also apparent that procedure u/s 446 Cr.P.C. was
not adopted by ld. MM. No notice under Section 446 Cr.P.C. was
given to the appellant herein before imposing the penalty. The
order directing the issuance of warrant of attachment for recovery
of the penalty, was in ignorance to the mandate of law u/s 446
Cr.P.C., hence, impugned order dt. 10.04.2023 cannot be upheld.
Resultantly, the consequent order dt. 12.09.2023 is also not
sustainable. Therefore, both aforesaid orders and other
Page 6 of 7 (Pulastya Pramachala)
ASJ-03, North-East District,
Karkardooma Courts, Delhi
-- 6 of 7 --
CNR No. DLNE01-002656-2023
Manish Premji Soni v. Mohd. Vasim
Crl. Appeal No.78/23, PS Bhajanpura
Judgment dated 28.11.2023
subsequent order for recovery of penalty from appellant, are
hereby set aside. The appeal is, accordingly allowed.
10. Ld. MM shall afford an opportunity to the appellant to show
cause as to why not penalty be imposed on him, on forfeiture of
his personal bond. Ld. MM shall decide afresh the issue of
imposition of penalty upon the appellant, after appreciating his
plea, in accordance with law u/s 446 Cr.P.C. It is further made
clear that since the appellant is now well aware of the
proceedings taken place resulting into forfeiture of bail bond,
there shall not be any need of issuing notice u/s 446 Cr.P.C. The
appellant shall file his explanation within the time given by ld.
MM.
11. Copy of this judgment be sent to the trial court with TCR. File of
appeal be consigned to record room, as per rules.
Announced in the open court (PULASTYA PRAMACHALA)
today on 28.11.2023 ASJ-03(North East)
(Judgment contains 7 pages) Karkardooma Courts/Delhi
Page 7 of 7 (Pulastya Pramachala)
ASJ-03, North-East District,
Karkardooma Courts, Delhi
-- 7 of 7 --

TrustJury presents public court-record information for legal discovery and reference. Record availability and detail can vary by source and case.