Full Order Text
Final Order 3 · 14 Aug 2025 · CNR DLNE010016252025
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: 1 CA 97/2025 Rajbiri Vs. Ekta 14.08.2025 ORDER ON APPEAL Present: None. 1. The present appeal has been filed by the appellant challenging an order dt. 08.05.2024, whereby Ld. JMFC, Mahila Court-1, North-East, Karkardooma (hereinafter referred as the trial court) dismissed an application moved on behalf of the appellant/ complainant with a prayer for examining additional witnesses. Impuged order was passed in a case titled as Rajbiri v. Ekta, bearing No. 996/2016, filed by the appellant under section 12 of the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 (herein after referred as the DV Act) against respondent, her daughter in law. 2. During course of arguments, Ld. Counsel for the appellant has submitted that via her application, the appellant had prayed to summon Dr. Rakesh and Irshad alongwith five other relatives of the appellant but ld. trial court dismissed the said application observing that there was delay of five years in moving the said application and it was not elaborated that how the proposed witnesses were connected with the case. Ld. counsel has submitted that ld. trial court did not consider the fact the -- 1 of 4 -- 2 proposed five witnesses could not be summoned earlier because they were not willing to appear before the court to give their evidence. The appellant filed the application without any delay after the five relatives consented to give their evidence. Ld. counsel has also submitted that no prejudice shall be caused to anyone, if a fair opportunity is given to the appellant to examine these witnesses. 3. On the other hand, Ld. counsel for the respondent has submitted that appellant had filed the aforesaid DV petition against the respondent in 2016 but she never pursued the said petition diligently. She has deliberately delayed the proceedings with sole motive of harassing the respondent. Dr. Rakesh, who was sought to be summoned via the application was summoned earlier also. He appeared in the court and stated that he had not prepared the relevant MLC. So there was no purpose to summon him again. Further, opportunity to summon Dr. Irshad was already given but instead of taking steps for summoning him, the appellant moved the application. 4. Ld. counsel has further submitted that appellant was examined in chief in 2019. However, she moved application to summon the five additional witnesses after delay of five years. It was also not elaborated any where that how these witnesses were relevant to the case. With these submissions, ld. counsel has submitted that there is nothing wrong in order which requires to be corrected by this court. -- 2 of 4 -- 3 5. Submissions heard. Record perused. 6. As per record, proposed witness Dr. Rakesh had appeared in the court on 23.08.2024 and had stated that he had not prepared the MLC No. B-545/2016 dated 10.02.2016. Thus, as far as Dr. Rakesh is concerned, matter ends here. There is no reason to summon him again. 7. For examination of Dr. Irshad, ld. trial court had given an opportunity but instead of taking steps for summoning him appellant moved another application with the prayer to summon him. It has not been explained that when Dr. Irshad was permitted to be summoned earlier, why a fresh application was moved instead of taking steps for summoning him. Thus, this court does not find any infirmity in the impugned order as far as rejection of the application for summoning of these two doctors is concerned. 8. Now coming to the summoning of five additional witnesses. The case was filed by the appellant in 2016. The matter had reached stage of complainant’s evidence in 2019. However, the application for calling the additional witnesses was moved after a prolonged delay of five years. Although, the appellant has sought to justify the delay stating that the relatives were not agreed to give evidence in her case, therefore, they were not called earlier. This court would definitely not buy this explanation because if these five additional witnesses were relevant to the case, the appellant was to file their -- 3 of 4 -- 4 names and addresses only. Thereafter, it was job of the court to ensure their presence for their evidence. 9. Moreover, it has not been elaborated any where that how these witnesses are relevant for the case of the appellant. Thus, this court does not see any illegality in the impugned order also whereby ld. trial court declined to summon five additional witnesses. 10. It is apparent that sufficient time has been given to the appellant by the Ld. Trial Court to lead relevant evidence, however, her conduct shows that she is deliberately prolonging the proceedings by moving frivolous application. 11. In view of the above, this court does see any reason to interfere with the impugned order dated 08.05.2025. The appeal is hereby dismissed being devoid of any merit. 12. Appeal file be consigned to record room. 13. Copy of the order be sent to the Ld. Trial Court alongwith TCR, if any. 14. Copy of this order be given dasti to the appellant. (Babru Bhan) ASJ-04/North-East District KKD/Delhi/14.08.2025 -- 4 of 4 --
