Full Order Text
Interim Order 16 · 20 Dec 2025 · CNR DLNE010013682023
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF AASHISH GUPTA, DISTRICT JUDGE-01, NORTH-EAST DISTRICT, KARKARDOOMA COURTS, DELHI In the matter of CS No. 122/2023 CNR No: DLNE01-001368-2023 1. REETA W/O LATE ANIL KUMAR 2. PRIYANSHI D/o LATE ANIL KUMAR 3. DIVYANSHI D/O LATE ANIL KUMAR ALL R/O HOUSE NO. E-271, GALI NO. 9, SHASTRI PARK, BHAJANPURA, N.E., DELHI – 110053. PRESENT ADDRESS PLOT NO. 48, KHASRA NO. 72, SUNDAR VIHAR, LONI, GHAZIABAD, UTTAR PRADESH ….. Plaintiffs versus 1. SH. SANTOSH B-126, GALI NO. 2, CHANDU NAGAR, KARAWAL NAGAR, DELHI – 94. 2. SUNIL S/O VIJAY KUMAR R/O HOUSE NO. E-271, GALI NO. 9, SHASTRI PARK, BHAJANPURA, N.E., DELHI – 110053 CS 122/2023 Smt. Reeta and Ors. Vs. Sh. Santosh and Ors. Page 1 of 8 -- 1 of 8 -- 3. SHANTI W/O SH. SUDHIR KUMAR R/O HOUSE NO. E-271, GALI NO. 9, SHASTRI PARK, BHAJANPURA, N.E., DELHI – 110053. 4. RAJINI W/O SUSHIL R/O HOUSE NO. E-271, GALI NO. 9, SHASTRI PARK, BHAJANPURA, (N.E.), DELHI – 110053. 5. SANGEETA W/O VINAY R/O K 6/031, MOHAN GARDEN, GALI NO. 3, UTTAM NAGAR, NEW DELHI – 110059. ….. Defendants Date of filing : 08.05.2023 Reserved on : 03.12.2025 Date of Decision : 20.12.2025 JUDGMENT 1. Plaintiffs have sued defendants inter alia seeking decree of partition and permanent injunction. 2. Plaintiffs and defendants are successors in interest of late Vijay Kumar (died on 28.08.2019) and Jamuna Devi (died on 09.03.2023). 3. Vijay Kumar and Jamuna Devi had six children; three sons and three daughters. One of the sons namely Anil Kumar died on 19.12.2022 and plaintiffs are the class I legal heirs of Anil Kumar (with P1 wife of Anil Kumar; P2 and P3 minor children of Anil Kumar). The CS 122/2023 Smt. Reeta and Ors. Vs. Sh. Santosh and Ors. Page 2 of 8 -- 2 of 8 -- other children of Vijay Kumar and Jamuna Devi are arrayed as defendants. 4. It is plaintiff’s case that Vijay Kumar, who died intestate on 28.09.2019, was the actual owner of property bearing No. 271, Gali No. 9, Shastri Park, Bhajan Pura, North-East, Delhi – 110053 measuring 110 sq. yds. (more specifically shown in site plan filed with the plaint and hereinafter referred to as ‘suit property’). 5. As per plaintiffs, Vijay Kumar had left seven class I legal heirs i.e. his six children and his wife Jamuna Devi. 6. Jamuna Devi also died intestate in 2023. 7. This left six claimants to the suit property. 8. Thus, plaintiffs (in the capacity of class I legal heirs of Anil Kumar/the deceased son of Vijay Kumar and Jamuna Devi) are seeking his 1/6th share in the suit property alongwith a decree of permanent injunction restraining the defendants from creating any third party interest in the suit property. 9. Only D1 and D5 had filed their written statements. Other defendants did not file their Written Statements. 10. D1 and D5 do not dispute the fact that the suit property was of Vijay Kumar; or the relationship between the parties; or that the parties are Hindu by religion; or that plaintiffs are legal heirs of their brother Anil Kumar. CS 122/2023 Smt. Reeta and Ors. Vs. Sh. Santosh and Ors. Page 3 of 8 -- 3 of 8 -- 11. The only defence set up by the said defendants is that Anil Kumar was living separately in Loni, Ghaziazbad and he had already taken his share in the suit property. 12. It is pertinent to note that after filing of written statement by D1 and D5, they stopped appearing in Court and remained ex-parte during trial. The other defendants also remained ex-parte. 13. Based on the pleadings, following issues were framed on 16.02.2024: (i) Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to a decree of partition, as prayed for ? OPP (ii) Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to a decree of permanent injunction, as prayed for ? OPP (iii) Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to a decree of mesne profits, as prayed for ? OPP (iv) Relief. 14. To prove their case, plaintiffs led evidence detailed below: S. No. Particulars of witnesses Nature of witness 1. Reeta/PW1 P-1 herself. She tendered her affidavit in evidence Ex. PW1/A wherein she reiterated her case. She relied upon the following documents: 1. Aadhar Card of Reeta (Ex.PW1/1). 2. Site Plan (Ex. PW1/2). 3. Death certificate of Vijay Kumar (Ex.PW1/3). 4. Death certificate of Anil Kumar (Ex.PW1/4). 2. Vimla Devi/PW2 She is a relative of P1. She tendered her evidence by way of affidavit Ex.PW2/A wherein she reiterated case of plaintiff. She relied upon the aforesaid documents (as relied by PW1) alongwith her Aadhar Card Ex. PW2/1. CS 122/2023 Smt. Reeta and Ors. Vs. Sh. Santosh and Ors. Page 4 of 8 -- 4 of 8 -- 15. PW1/Reeta was cross-examined by Ld. Counsel for defendants. PW2 was not cross-examined by Ld. Counsel for defendants despite opportunity. No other witness was examined by the plaintiffs and thus, PE was closed. 16. Thereafter, matter was listed for DE. However, defendants did not lead any evidence despite opportunity. 17. Arguments heard. Record perused. 18. Based on the evidence led before this court, the issue-wise finding in the matter is as under : Issue No. (i), (ii) & (iii) (i) Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to a decree of partition, as prayed for ? OPP (ii) Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to a decree of permanent injunction, as prayed for ? OPP (ii) Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to a decree of mesne profits as prayed for? OPP 19. All the issues are inter-connected and are thus dealt together. 20. Parties are not in dispute on the fact that Anil Kumar and all the defendants are class-I legal heirs of Vijay Kumar (who died on 28.08.2019) and Jamuna Devi (who died on 09.03.2023). It is also not in dispute that the said individuals died intestate. It is also not in dispute that the suit property was the property of Vijay Kumar. It is also not in dispute that plaintiffs herein are the class I legal heir of Anil Kumar. CS 122/2023 Smt. Reeta and Ors. Vs. Sh. Santosh and Ors. Page 5 of 8 -- 5 of 8 -- 21. Now, the only contention of the defendants against partition was that purportedly Anil Kumar was given his share in the suit property earlier. But, no evidence in this regard was led by the defendants and thus the said contention of the defendants is liable to be rejected. 22. Thus, it has been proved on record that the suit property devolved upon the plaintiffs and original defendant by way of intestate succession. Initially, on the death of Vijay Kumar in 2019, the property devolved in the ratio of 1/7th portion each to his three sons, three daughters and his wife Jamuna Devi. 23. Thereafter, when Anil Kumar died in 2022, his 1/7th share in the property would devolve together on his class I legal heirs i.e. the plaintiffs herein. 24. When Jamuna Devi died in 2023, her 1/7th share in the property would equally get divided between her five surviving children and the sixth portion would then devolve on the LRs of her sixth child i.e. the plaintiffs. 25. Thus, plaintiffs and the defendants would get 1/6th share each in the suit property. 26. Accordingly, plaintiffs are held entitled to a preliminary decree of partition. Plaintiffs would together take 1/6th share in the suit property in the capacity of legal heirs of Anil Kumar. The remaining 5/6th share shall jointly to be share of the defendants. CS 122/2023 Smt. Reeta and Ors. Vs. Sh. Santosh and Ors. Page 6 of 8 -- 6 of 8 -- 27. Considering the fact that plaintiffs have 1/6th share in the property, they are also entitled to a decree of permanent injunction restraining the defendants from creating any third party interest in the suit property to the extent of plaintiffs’ share therein. 28. Thus, in view of the above, issues No. (i) & (ii) are decided in favour of the plaintiffs and against the defendants. 29. As far as Issue No. (iii) is concerned, admittedly defendants are co- owner of the suit property and thus their occupation of the suit property cannot be treated to be illegal. Thus, plaintiffs are not entitled to receive any mesne profits from the defendants. Accordingly, this issue is decided against the plaintiffs and in favour of the defendants. 30. I may note herein that plaintiffs had also prayed for a decree of declaration that they have 1/6th share in the suit property. Since plaintiffs have already been found to be entitled to 1/6th share in the suit property and a decree of partition has been granted on the basis of the same, a separate declaration in this regard is not required to be passed. Relief 31. In view of the findings returned above, plaintiffs are held entitled to the following reliefs: CS 122/2023 Smt. Reeta and Ors. Vs. Sh. Santosh and Ors. Page 7 of 8 -- 7 of 8 -- i. Plaintiffs are held entitled to a preliminary decree of partition with plaintiffs entitled to 1/6th share (in the capacity of LRs of Anil Kumar). The other defendants are entitled to the remaining 5/6th share in the suit property i.e. property bearing No. 271, Gali No. 9, Shastri Park, Bhajan Pura, North-East, Delhi – 110053 measuring 110 sq. yds. (more specifically shown in site plan filed with the plaint Ex. PW1/2). ii. Plaintiffs are also entitled to a decree of permanent injunction whereby defendants or any persons claiming through them are permanently restrained from creating any third party interest in the suit property. 32. Let a decree sheet be prepared accordingly. 33. Site plan Ex.PW1/2 to form part of decree. Announced in the Aashish Gupta open Court on 20.12.2025 District Judge-01, North-East District, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi CS 122/2023 Smt. Reeta and Ors. Vs. Sh. Santosh and Ors. Page 8 of 8 -- 8 of 8 --
