Full Order Text
Final Order 20 · 19 Feb 2026 · CNR DLNE010013682023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: CS 122/23 REETA AND ORS Vs. SANTOSH AND ORS 19.02.2026 Present: Ms. Priyanka Agarwal, Ld. Counsel for plaintiffs. D-1 in person. None for other defendants. 1. In this suit, a preliminary decree of partition was passed by this Court vide order dated 20.12.2025. The same reads as under:- i. Plaintiffs are held entitled to a preliminary decree of partition with plaintiffs entitled to 1/6th share (in the capacity of LRs of Anil Kumar). The other defendants are entitled to the remaining 5/6th share in the suit property i.e. property bearing No. 271, Gali No. 9, Shastri Park, Bhajan Pura, North-East, Delhi – 110053 measuring 110 sq. yds. (more specifically shown in site plan filed with the plaint Ex. PW1/2). ii. Plaintiffs are also entitled to a decree of permanent injunction whereby defendants or any persons claiming through them are permanently restrained from creating any third party interest in the suit property. 2. Thereafter, an inquiry is being undertaken for passing a final decree in the matter. 3. As per record, it appears that defendants do not want a partition by metes and bounds and want to remain joint. On the other hand, plaintiffs are not residing in the suit property. Therefore, a valuation report was called from SDM concerned qua the suit property. 4. Now, as per report filed by SDM, Seelampur, Delhi, the suit property is measuring 105 sq yards. It is constructed in two portions. One portion is of 23 sq yards (constructed upto 4 floors i.e. ground plus three) and the other of 82 sq yards (constructed upto 3 floors i.e. ground plus two). -- 1 of 5 -- 5. This brings the total area at the site to 105 sq yards and not 110 sq. yards. 6. Counsel for plaintiffs, on instructions, submitted that for the actual area of the property found at the site i.e. 105 sq. yards, partition may be ordered. 7. As per the preliminary decree, plaintiffs are together entitled to 1/6th share of the total property. This would mean that now, plaintiffs are to be given 17.5 sq. yards of land by way of partition. 8. If I consider the site plan Ex.PW1/2, it appears that property is constructed in two portions. This fact is also supported by the report of SDM filed today. This fact is confirmed by the parties appearing in Court. 9. The smaller of the two portions opens towards gali No. 9 as per site plan Ex. PW1/2 and the area of this portion as per report of SDM is 23 sq yards. This portion consists of total 4 floors. If I order physical partition by metes and bounds for this area, it would entail breaking down of physical structure of the property and the area which shall remain after giving the share of plaintiffs (23 sq yards minus 17.5 sq yards) would be of no practical use for the defendants. 10.The larger of the two portions opens towards gali No. 10 as per site plan Ex. PW1/2 and the area of this portion as per report of SDM is 82 sq yards. This portion consists of total 3 floors. If I order physical partition by metes and bounds for this area, it would also entail breaking down of physical structure of the property and the area to be given to the plaintiffs i.e. 17.5 sq. yards cannot be easily cut off from the remaining property. -- 2 of 5 -- 11.I may note that while considering the share of plaintiffs, it has to be kept in mind that the other defendants do not want partition and they want to stay joint. Thus, the remaining property should be left in such a position so that the said defendants can continue enjoying the property. 12.The area to be given to the plaintiffs is only 17.5 sq. yards and if such small area is ordered to be bifurcated from the remaining property, it shall mean severe demolition exercise to be undertaken which may render the entire property inhabitable. Such an approach is not in the interest of the parties. In other words, in my humble opinion, considering the portion/share to be given to the plaintiffs and keeping in mind the nature of construction available at the site and also keeping in mind the peculiar status of construction noted above, a physical partition by metes and bounds is not possible in this case. 13.Now a question arises as to how to satisfy the claim of plaintiffs. 14.In my humble opinion, the only way forward would be to award owelty money in lieu of plaintiffs' share in the property. This amount shall be a charge on the property and the defendants can jointly pay the said amount to the plaintiffs in satisfaction of their claim. 15.As per the report of SDM filed in Court, the total cost of the property is Rs. 72,95,650/-. Despite opportunity, plaintiffs have not placed on record any contemporary sale deeds for this Court to take a view about any other possible fair value of the property. Thus, the report of SDM valuing the suit property at Rs. 72,95,650/- is taken as the fair market value of the suit -- 3 of 5 -- property and on the basis of the said amount, plaintiffs share is assessed at Rs. 12,15,942/- (1/6th of the aforesaid amount). 16.Accordingly, plaintiffs are jointly and severally awarded the aforesaid amount as the owelty sum which defendants are liable to pay jointly to the plaintiffs. In case the said money is not paid, the suit property can be used by the plaintiffs by seeking its sale to recover the said amount and any subsequent purchaser of the suit property or part thereof shall be liable to pay the said amount to the plaintiffs (in case defendants try to sell the property before satisfying the claim of the plaintiffs). 17.Let a final decree sheet of partition be prepared accordingly. 18.Before the final decree of partition is drawn, plaintiffs are directed to place on record the non judicial stamp papers of requisite amount i.e. the amount awarded to them as their share as per Article 45 of Indian Stamp Act 1899. 19.Accordingly, the Final Decree be drawn upon only on the submission of the requisite stamp papers. 20.I may note that while passing the preliminary decree, a decree of permanent injunction was also passed against defendants or any persons claiming through them restraining them from creating any third party interest in the suit property. 21.The said relief is modified to the extent that defendants shall not create any third party interest in the suit property till the payment of owelty sum in the aforesaid manner to the plaintiffs. The said modified relief shall also form part of final decree. 22.With the said directions, nothing remains to be adjudicated in the present matter. -- 4 of 5 -- 23.File be consigned to Record Room. Aashish Gupta DJ-01/NE/KKD/DELHI 19.02.2026 -- 5 of 5 --
