Full Order Text
Order 15 · 15 Dec 2025 · CNR DLNE010009302023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: CS 77/23 NADEEM AHMED ANSARI AND ANR Vs. KAFEEL AHMED ANSARI 15.12.2025 Present: Ld. counsel for plaintiffs. Ld. counsel for LRs of defendant. 1. On 16.09.2025, following order was passed in this case: “In this case, defendant died on 12.10.2024 and an application to bring on record u/O XXII Rule 4 CPC (naming only one of the LRs of defendant in the application) was moved by plaintiffs on 13.01.2025 (through e-mode). Thereafter, plaintiffs moved another application u/O XXII Rule 4 CPC (naming all the LRs of defendant in the application) on 31.05.2025 (through e-mode). Reply to both the applications already filed. Copy supplied. Counsel for LRs of defendant argued that both the applications filed by plaintiffs are beyond limitation of 90 days in as much as the first application is delayed by 3 days (with limitation considered qua the first application) and 141 days (with limitation considered qua the second application). It is his argument that the LRs of defendant could have been brought on record on or before 10.01.2025 and since either of the two applications are beyond time, the suit abated on the said date and therefore, no LRs of defendant can be brought on record today. Counsel for plaintiffs submitted that this court has ample power to set aside the abatement of suit and also condone any delay in moving an application for seeking of setting aside of abatement also. He seeks time to move appropriate applications in this regard. He is at liberty to do so as per law with copy to the other side. List for further proceedings on 15.12.2025.” 2. In pursuance to the liberty granted on last date, plaintiffs have filed two applications today. The first is u/O XXII Rule 9(2) r/w Sec. 151 CPC seeking setting aside of abatement of the suit. The second is u/s 5 of Limitation Act seeking condonation of delay in filing of the application u/O XXII Rule 4 CPC. Copies already supplied. 3. Arguments on earlier applications moved u/O XXII Rule 4 (referred in order dated 16.09.2025) and the applications moved today heard. -- 1 of 3 -- 4. Record perused. 5. Plaintiffs have sued the defendant inter alia for relief of possession inter alia on the basis of an oral division which is stated to have taken place sometime in 2016 between the family members of the plaintiffs. 6. Now, defendant died on 12.10.2024 and the question of his LRs being impleaded in the suit became necessary. Two applications for the same came to be filed but each one of them is with some delay. Since an objection was taken by LRs of defendant that the LRs cannot be impleaded without the delay being condoned, plaintiffs have come up with an application seeking condonation of delay in moving of the impleadment application and also for recalling of abatement of suit. 7. If I consider the dispute in hand, plaintiffs can institute a fresh suit against the LRs of defendant, even if the present suit is taken to have been abated by operation of law (as the application for impleadment of LRs was beyond time). The delay in moving of the application is attributed partly to illness of father of P-2; partly to marriage of P-2; and partly to the counsel. 8. It is settled law that any dispute should invariably decided on merits and not on technicalities. Thus, in my humble opinion, considering the above, this is a fit case to order setting aside of abatement of the suit and condone the delay in filing of application to bring on record LRs of defendant. Accordingly, both the applications moved today are allowed. 9. The right to sue survives qua the LRs of deceased defendant in this -- 2 of 3 -- case and therefore, the LRs of deceased defendant as described in application moved by plaintiffs filed on 31.05.2025 is allowed. The other application u/O XXII Rule 4 CPC filed on 13.01.2025 is dismissed as it did not name all the LRs of deceased defendant. 10.The amended memo filed with the application dated 31.05.2025 is taken on record. 11.To come up for PE on 27.02.2026. AASHISH GUPTA DJ-01/NE/KKD/DELHI 15.12.2025 -- 3 of 3 --
