Full Order Text
Order 10 · 11 Sept 2024 · CNR DLNE010003892023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF MS. MANU VEDWAN, DISTRICT JUDGE-2, NORTH EAST DISTRICT, KARKARDOOMA COURTS, DELHI CS No. 36/2023 Subhash Chand Gupta …..Plaintiff Versus Pankaj Kumar Gupta ….. Defendant 11.09.2024 ORDER ON APPLICATION UNDER ORDER XXXVII RULE 3(4) & (5) READ WITH SECTION 151 OF CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE MOVED ON BEHALF OF DEFENDANT. 1. Vide this order, I shall dispose of an application under Order XXXVII Rule 3(4) & (5) read with section 151 of Code of Civil Procedure moved on behalf of defendant for leave to defend the present suit. 2. This is a suit for recovery of rupees 12,00,000/- alongwith pendente lite and future interest @ 9% per annum. It is the case of plaintiff that the defendant had asked for a friendly loan of rupees 3,00,000/- from the plaintiff in the second week of September 2015. Plaintiff had thus advanced an amount of rupees 3,00,000/- to the CS No. 36/2023 Page No. 1 of 8 -- 1 of 8 -- defendant on 15.09.2015, without interest, through cheque bearing number 787090, dated 15.09.2015 drawn on Syndicate Bank which was duly encashed by the defendant in his bank account. It is further stated that at that time, defendant had also handed over the undated security cheque, bearing number, 084132, amounting to rupees 3,00,000/-, drawn on Central Bank of India, Ghonda, Delhi pertaining to his proprietorship firm, namely, Anand Arts duly signed by the defendant. It is further stated that the defendant had again asked for a friendly loan of rupees 5,00,000/- from the plaintiff in the last week of September 2015 and plaintiff advanced the same to the defendant, on 29.09.2015, without interest, through cheque, bearing number 787091. dated 29.09.2015, drawn on Syndicate Bank, which was duly encashed by the defendant in his bank account. It is further stated that at that time also defendant had handed over the undated cheque, bearing number, 084141, amounting to rupees 5,00,000/-, drawn on Central Bank of India, Ghonda, Delhi of his proprietorship firm, namely, Anand Arts duly signed by defendant. It is further stated that defendant had again asked for a friendly loan of rupees 2,00,000/- from the plaintiff in the first week of November 2015. Plaintiff had advanced the same to the defendant, on 05.11.2015, without interest, through cheque, bearing number 787093, dated 05.11.2015, drawn on Syndicate Bank which was duly encashed by the defendant in his bank account. It is further stated that defendant had handed over the undated, security cheque, bearing number, 084144, amounting to rupees 2,00,000/- drawn on CS No. 36/2023 Page No. 2 of 8 -- 2 of 8 -- Central Bank of India, Ghonda, Delhi of his proprietorship firm, namely, Anand Arts duly signed by the defendant. It is further stated that again in the first week of December, an amount of rupees 2,00,000/- was given to the defendant by the plaintiff as a friendly loan through the cheque, bearing number, 787096, dated 09.12.2015, drawn on Syndicate Bank which was duly encashed by the defendant in his bank account. At that time also, defendant had also handed over the security cheque, bearing number, 084147, amounting to rupees 2,00,000/- drawn on Central Bank of India, Ghonda, Delhi of his proprietorship firm, namely, Anand Arts signed by the defendant. It is further stated that the plaintiff had advanced these amounts to the defendant in good faith and defendant had assured the plaintiff that he would return the loan amounts. On being requested by the plaintiff, defendant finally confirmed that by July 2021, he would repay the entire loan amount of rupees 12,00,000/- and asked the plaintiff to mention the date of 01.07.2021 on all the aforesaid cheques handed over by him to the plaintiff. All the cheques when presented for payment were dishonoured with the remarks “Funds Insufficient” vide cheque return memo, dated 29.07.2021. It is further stated that the plaintiff had sent the legal notice, dated 11.08.2021 to the defendant. Despite that, defendant had failed to make the payment to the plaintiff. It is therefore requested that the defendant is liable to pay a sum of rupees 12,00,000/- alongwith pendente lite and future interest @ 9% per annum. CS No. 36/2023 Page No. 3 of 8 -- 3 of 8 -- 3. Defendant, on the other hand, had filed an application under Order XXXVII Rule 3(4) & (5) read with section 151 of Code of Civil Procedure seeking leave to defend in which it is stated by the defendant that the defendant has a strong case in his favour and the suit of plaintiff is liable to be dismissed on the ground that the plaintiff’s suit is false. It is stated that the contents of the accompanying affidavit be read as part and parcel of the present application. It is stated in the affidavit that the transaction between the plaintiff and the defendant were of commercial in nature as such the present suit is not maintainable. It is also stated that the plaintiff is the neighbour of the defendant and used to work in the Ministry of Finance. Plaintiff had invested his money upto rupees 12,00,000/- in the handicraft business of defendant and plaintiff was the oral/dormant/sleeping partner of the defendant because being in government job, plaintiff could not act and perform his duties as an active partner. It is stated that the aforesaid investment by the plaintiff was never a friendly loan as alleged in the plaint. It is further stated that the defendant never took any friendly loan from the plaintiff. It is further stated that defendant being the partner of the plaintiff supplied the handicraft jewellery to one Sh. Ashok Nagrath total value of rupees 32,00,000/- to 33,00,000/-. It is further stated that however, due to some business dispute defendant was advised by plaintiff to file a Civil Suit bearing number 01/2016 for the recovery of rupees 32,00,000/- against Sh. Ashok Nagrath. Out of the aforesaid sum of rupees 32,00,000/-, a sum of rupees 12,00,000/- was invested by the plaintiff. It is stated CS No. 36/2023 Page No. 4 of 8 -- 4 of 8 -- that the plaintiff in order to legalize his black money had given the cheques in question upto rupees 12,00,000/- to the defendant. On their clearance/credit in the account of defendant, plaintiff immediately took back rupees 10,00,000/- in cash from the defendant and rest of the amount of rupees 2,00,000/- had distributed to the employees and labours of the plaintiff and defendant being the partners. It is further stated that the aforesaid Civil Suit titled as Pankaj Kumar Gupta vs. Ashok Nagrath is still pending before this Hon’ble Court. It is further stated that one Sh. Shakeel Ahmed had also illegally possessed/occupied the factory of defendant in connivance/conspiracy and at the instance of the present plaintiff consequently. It is stated that in the garb of settlement/compromise, the plaintiff had pressurized the defendant to give six cheques of rupees 50,000/- each to Sh. Shakeel Ahmed who filed a case under section 138 NI Act bearing CC No. 2514/2021 titled as Shakeel Ahmed vs. Pankaj Kumar Gupta & Anr, against the defendant which was dismissed. It is further stated that the plaintiff apart from the present suit has also filed a complaint case under section 138 NI Act on the basis of all cheques in question which is pending in the Court of Learned Metropolitan Magistrate (NI Act) wherein the defendant had also deposed and disclosed before the Court concerned that the present plaintiff (complainant in the aforesaid complaint case) had invested his money in the business and the present defendant (accused in the aforesaid complaint case) never took friendly loan from the present plaintiff. It is further stated that the present suit is the abuse of CS No. 36/2023 Page No. 5 of 8 -- 5 of 8 -- process of law. It is further stated that the defendant had never borrowed any amount from the plaintiff instead plaintiff had invested in the business of defendant and plaintiff is now trying to misuse the cheques of the defendant. It is further stated that the present suit is not maintainable as the entire plaint is based upon the fabrication of the documents. The cheques in question are forged and fabricated. 4. Plaintiff has chosen to file reply of the application of defendant. In his reply, apart from reiterating the contents of plaint, the plaintiff has negated all the contentions of the defendant raised by him in his application. It is further stated that the application of defendant is based on false and fabricated facts and are not tenable in the eyes of law. It is stated that the defendant has no ground to defend the present suit and the present application is liable to be dismissed. It is specifically stated that the plaintiff had never invested any amount with the defendant and it is further stated that the plaintiff never became any type of partner with the defendant. It is further stated that the plaintiff had retired from the government job in January 2015 itself and the first loan in question was given by the plaintiff to the defendant on 15.09.2015 and thereafter on 29.09.2015, 05.11.2015 and 09.12.2015 that was almost after eight months of his retirement and this clearly shows that the present defence taken by the defendant is just a false and frivolous one. It is further stated that that the plaintiff had no concern with any Sh. Ashok Nagrath or the business of the defendant. It is further stated CS No. 36/2023 Page No. 6 of 8 -- 6 of 8 -- that the plaintiff had already retired in January 2015 and thus no question of legalization of black money plea/defence as taken by the defendant arises at all and this clearly shows that the present defence taken by the defendant is just a false and frivolous one. It is further stated that the plaintiff had never invested any amount with the defendant. 5. I have heard the arguments advanced on behalf of both the parties and have perused the documents filed on both sides. 6. Now, it is an acceptable legal principle that a leave to defend should not be refused unless the Court is satisfied that the facts disclosed by the defendant do not indicate that he has a substantial defence to raise or that the defence intended to be put by him is frivolous or vexatious. The test whether leave to defend should be granted or not is to see whether the defence raises a real, honest and bonafide dispute and raises a triable issue or not. If the Court is satisfied that the defence has raised a triable issue or a fair dispute has arisen, leave to defend should not be refused. (Ref: Raj Duggal v Ramesh Kumar, 1991 Supp, (1) SCC 191). In the instant case, it is the defence of defendant that plaintiff is not forwarding the friendly loan to the defendant rather he is investing in the business of defendant. Apart from the cheques in question, no other document has been relied upon by the plaintiff to stress his position qua the forwarding of the alleged friendly loan. Despite opportunities given, plaintiff miserably failed to explain his financial status vis-a-vis the CS No. 36/2023 Page No. 7 of 8 -- 7 of 8 -- continuous advancements of money in lakhs made by him and now alleged to be the friendly loan to the defendant. All these facts have to be seen in light that the defendant had specifically stated that the plaintiff was more than a friend in these alleged transactions. There are several triable issues which cannot be understood prima facie without leading relevant piece of evidence. 7. Therefore, in view of the above, the Court is convinced that defendant has disclosed facts constituting substantial defence and raised triable issue which necessitate further trial in the present suit. The grounds taken are sufficient to entitle defendant to defend the present suit unconditionally. The application for leave to defend the suit is therefore, allowed unconditionally. 8. The application is disposed off accordingly. 9. Nothing stated herein above shall amount to expression on merits of the case. (Manu Vedwan) District Judge-02/North-East, KKD Courts, Delhi/11.09.2024 CS No. 36/2023 Page No. 8 of 8 -- 8 of 8 --
