Full Order Text
Interim Order 4 · 10 Sept 2021 · CNR DLND030011832021
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF MS. PREETI, CIVIL JUDGE-I, PATIALA HOUSE COURTS, NEW DELHI DISTRICT, NEW DELHI Judge Code DL-00990 CS No. 809/21 1. Sh. C. Cherian S/o late Sh. C. P. Cherian R/o House no. 60, Rajpur Khurd Extn. Near Kidzee School, Maidangarhi PO, New Delhi-110068 2. Sh. Alex Kurien Elected Treasurer of 9th Respondent S/o N. C. Kurien Off: Mar Thoma Centre, 26 Bhai Vir Singh Marg, New Delhi-110001 Res: 201/3, Laxmi Apartment Flat no.3, Upper Ground Floor, Ward No. 2, Near Prince Public School Mehrauli, New Delhi-110030 … Plaintiffs Versus 1. The Most Rev. Dr. Theodosius Mar Thoma Metropolitan The Patron The Northern India Zonal Assembly (NIZA) Mar Thoma Centre, 26, Bhai Veer Singh Marg, Gole Market, New Delhi-110001 Also at;:- Poolatheen Tiruvalla Pathanamthitta Dist. Kerala, India-689101 2. Very Rev. Thomas Cherian (alias Mahesh Achen) CS No. 809/21 Page No. 1/6 -- 1 of 6 -- Defacto Controller and Custodian of the registered office of The Northern India Zonal Assembly (NIZA) of the Mar Thoma Church, Mar Thoma Centre, 26, Bhai Veer Singh Marg, Gole Market, New Delhi-110001 3. Sh. P. T. Mathai Former Treasurer, The Northern India Zonal Assembly (NIZA) of the Mar Thoma Church residing at A-2/137, 1st Floor, Paschim Vihar New Delhi-110063 4. The Synod of the Malankara Mar Thoma Syrian Church Represented by its Secretary Rev. K. G. Joseph Poolatheen Tiruvalla, Pathanamthitta Dist. Kerala, India-689101 5. Rt. Rev. Gregorious Mar Stephanos Episcopa The Former President The Northern India Zonal Assembly (NIZA) Mar Thoma Centre 26, Bhai Veer Singh Marg, Gole Market, New Delhi-110001 6. The Northern India Zonal Assembly (NIZA) of the Mar Thoma Church Mar Thoma Centre, 26, Bhai Veer Singh Marg, Gole Market, New Delhi-110001 7. Rev. Samson Samuel Secretary of the 9th Respondent Vicar, Nasik St. Thomas Mar Thoma Church Mar Thoma Centre, Mangal Murti Nagar, Canal-jail Road, Nasik Road, HO Ponashik, Distt. Maharashtra, India. CS No. 809/21 Page No. 2/6 -- 2 of 6 -- 8. The Registrar of Societies, New Delhi 12/1, Jam Nagar House, New Delhi-110001 … Defendants Date of Arguments : 10.09.2021 Date of Order : 10.09.2021 ORDER ON THE APPLICATION UNDER ORDER XXXIX RULE 1 & 2 R/W SECTION 151 OF THE CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE 1. By this Order, I shall dispose off an application under Order XXXIX Rule 1 and 2 r/w section 151 of Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter referred to as “CPC”) moved on behalf of the plaintiff seeking interim injunction against defendant no.1, 2 and 3 prohibiting them from implementing the circular no. 3 dated 28.08.2021 issued by defendant no.1 pending adjudication of the present suit. 2. Brief facts of the present case as emerging from the plaint are that plaintiffs are members of defendant no. 6. Plaintiff no. 2 is a duly elected treasurer of the society. It is stated that last date for completing the elections of defendant no.6 was 31.08.2020 which was extended due to Covid uptill 31.12.2020. Defendant no.5 approached the Registrar of Society seeking extension of the said time limit. However, the same was not granted but one month more was given to complete the election process. It is further stated that elections were duly conducted as per the bye laws on 27.01.2021 following which the results were announced on the same day and the newly elected officer bearers assumed office on the same day. However, on 27.01.2021, defendant no.1 removed defendant no.5 and kept the elections under suspension without any rhyme and reason. Hence, the present suit. 3. It is stated in the application that elections conducted on 27.01.2021 are legally valid elections. The previous office bearers for the purpose of illegally retaining the power and office, refused to hand over the charges to the new elected CS No. 809/21 Page No. 3/6 -- 3 of 6 -- office bearers and the registered office was retained in their control without any legal scentity. Afterwards plaintiff sent legal notices on 25.06.2021 and 16.08.2021. It is further stated that to defeat the process of law, defendant no.1 illegally and maliciously issued the circular no.3 dated 28.08.2021 in order to reconstitute the general body of defendant no.6 society. It is further stated that for the purpose of creating an artificial majority in their favour, the defendant no.1 in connivance with defendant no.2 and 3 is trying to manipulate the electorate, after the election results are declared. The said circular has been issued without any authority of law and without any sanction from the executive body of the society of the general body. 4. Written submissions were filed by defendants wherein it is stated that present suit is instituted without following procedure under Order 1 Rule 12 CPC. It is further stated that instant application is not complying with Order 6 Rule 14 CPC. It is further stated that election of office bearers of Northern India Zonal Assembly held on 27.01.2021 was set aside by defendant no.1 in accordance with rules of the NIZA society. Such an election could have been conducted only after holding elections of ordinary members from the parishes as required under Rule 5 CPC. It is further stated that the voter list prepared during the impugned elections was defective. It is further stated that defendant no.1 is competent to cancel the elections. It is further stated that once an election process starts, civil court should not interfere in the election process except for extra ordinary circumstances. 5. Arguments heard. Record perused. 6. Plaintiff no.1 was nominated as member as per Rule 9 (a) (iv) of the Rules of NIZA Society. Rule 9 (a) (iv) provides the power to nominate members. Rule 5 (d) of the Rules of NIZA Society provides that nominated members will be referred as honorary members and they shall not have voting CS No. 809/21 Page No. 4/6 -- 4 of 6 -- powers. Rule 7 of the Rules of NIZA Society further reiterates the aforesaid rule. However, as per documents placed on record by plaintiff, the name of plaintiff no.1 was in voter list in the elections held on 27.01.2021. Further, the minutes of meeting dated 27.01.2021 placed in main file is different from the minutes of meeting annexed with the instant application. It is pertinent to note that the minutes of meeting dated 27.01.2021 must have been same. Also, Rule 12 (a) of the Rules of NIZA Society provides that 21 days clear notice in writing shall be given to members about the date of annual elections but in the present case the notice was given on 06.01.2021. In view of Section 9 of General Clauses Act, the day of service of notice and the day of election have to be excluded while counting 21 days. Thus, prime facie it appears that there were certain irregularities in conducting the election dated 27.01.2021. Further, Rule 18 (b) of the Rules of NIZA Society empowers Metropolitan of the Mar Thoma Syrian Church to decide any unresolved dispute, his decision is binding and there cannot be any appeal over such decision. In pursuance of such power the elections conducted on 27.01.2021 were set aside by defendant no.1. 7. Plaintiff has challenged circular/order no.3 dated 28.08.2021 on the ground that elections on 27.01.2021 were duly conducted and defendant no.1 cannot reconstitute the General Body of defendant no.6 society in presence of existing office bearers of the society (defendant no.6). The impugned circular states that the term of NIZA ended on 31.03.2020, each parishes and authorized organization shall elect the members to the NIZA as per the rules of the NIZA society. By way of this notice election process has been initiated by defendant no.1 which cannot be interfered as per various judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme Court. CS No. 809/21 Page No. 5/6 -- 5 of 6 -- 8. Thus, plaintiff has not been able to show prima facie in his favour at this stage. Also balance of convenience lies in favour of defendant no.1 as he has been able to show prima facie that there were material irregularities in conducting of elections dated 27.01.2021 and defendant no.1 is competent to set aside the elections dated 27.01.2021 as per the rules of NIZA. Further, irreparable injury shall be suffered by defendant no.1 as sufficient amount of money and resources have already been invested in issuance of election process. Further, the elections were set aside on 27.01.2021 and the present suit is filed in August, 2021 of which no satisfactory explanation has been given by plaintiff as to why he approached the court so late. 9. In view of above observations, the application under Order XXXIX Rule 1& 2 is dismissed. 10. Nothing in this order shall tantamount to be an expression on the merits of the case. Announced in the open Court (PREETI) on 10.09.2021 Civil Judge-I, New Delhi District New Delhi CS No. 809/21 Page No. 6/6 -- 6 of 6 --
