Skip to main content
Court Order

Final Order 19

CNR DLND03000560202127 Mar 2025
Back to Case

Full Order Text

Final Order 19 · 27 Mar 2025 · CNR DLND030005602021

Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT
Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SH. VINOD JOSHI
JSCC-CUM-ASCJ-GJ, PATIALA HOUSE COURTS,
NEW DELHI
CS No. 409/2021
IN THE MATTER OF:-
Mohd. Danish Faisal,
S/o Late Sh. Shafiq @ Shafiquddin,
134-M-11, C-Block, Connaught Place,
New Delhi. ...Plaintiff
Versus
1. New Delhi Municipal Council
Enforcement Department
Through its Director
Pragati Bhawan,
Jai Singh Road, New Delhi
2. Vinod Kumar
S/o Sh. Mahesh Chand
R/o 25/1, Trilokpuri
New Delhi-110091. ...Defendants
DATE OF INSTITUTION : 02.03.2021
DATE OF RESERVING THE ORDER : 27.03.2025
DATE OF DECISION : 27.03.2025
SUIT FOR DECLARATION, MANDATORY AND
PERMANENT INJUNCTION
JUDGMENT:
1. Vide this judgment, I shall dispose off the present suit filed
by the plaintiff for declaration, mandatory and permanent
injunction against the defendants.
CS No. 409/2021 Page No. 1/13
-- 1 of 13 --
2. For better appreciation, the brief facts of the suit as per the
plaint are summarized as follows:
(i) The plaintiff is the son of late Mohd. Shafiq @
Shafiquddin, who was a Tehbazari licence holder, operating at site
no. 134, M-11, C-block, opposite Singer Machine (now Van
Heusen showroom), inner circle, Connaught Place, New Delhi-01,
measuring 4 ft. x 3 ft (hereinafter referred to as tehbazari site). The
father of the plaintiff expired on 29.11.2019.
(ii) The defendant no.1 issued Tehbazari licence to the
father of the plaintiff and has illegally removed the plaintiff from
the site after the death of his father, despite the protection afforded
by Street Vendors (Protection of Livelihood & Regulation of Street
Vending) Act, 2014.
(iii) The defendant no.2 has allegedly entered into
partnership vide partnership deed dated 23.07.2011, with the father
of the plaintiff and he has been attempting to forcibly take over the
tehbazari site allotted to father of the plaintiff.
(iv) The father of the plaintiff was tehbazari licence
holder, as verified by the Thareja Committee vide order dated
21.10.1992 and has been operating at the tehbazari site since the
year 1992. Subsequently, the father of the plaintiff was allotted a
confirmed space at the tehbazari site vide order of Sh. V.C.
Chaturvedi dated 22.06.1999.
(v) In May, 2016, the defendant no.1 cancelled the
tehbazari licences of several persons, including the father of the
plaintiff and all these persons approached the Hon’ble High Court
of Delhi vide separate writ petitions. The writ petition WP (C) No.
5292/2016, filed by the father of the plaintiff was decided
CS No. 409/2021 Page No. 2/13
-- 2 of 13 --
alongwith the other writ petitions, by way of order dated
06.12.2016, whereby the cancellation orders were set aside and the
petitioners were allowed to continue with their tehbazari sites upon
payment of license fee and adherence to terms and conditions of
the license.
(vi) The father of the plaintiff continued to operate from
the tehbazari site till his demise on 29.11.2019 and the license fee
was deposited with the defendant no.1 till July, 2019, wherein after
the father of the plaintiff fell ill.
(vii) After the death of his father, an application for transfer
of license was made by the plaintiff in November 2019, on behalf
of his mother and a request was submitted on 04.02.2020. As the
mother of the plaintiff was having some health issues, it was
decided between the family members that a request for transfer of
license will be made in favour of the plaintiff. Accordingly, the
plaintiff vide letter dated 28.02.2020, requested defendant no.1 to
transfer the tehbazari license in his favour, as the other legal heirs
of his father had given no objection to the same.
(viii) The plaintiff started sitting at the tehbazari site with
his goods and had requested that he may be allowed to operate
from the tehbazari site pending decision for formal transfer,
however, the plaintiff did not receive any positive response and
instead, his goods were removed from the tehbazari site on
29.01.2020. The plaintiff wrote a letter dated 01.02.2020, seeking
release of his goods and also paid removal charges of Rs.2400/- for
release of the goods. The tehbazari site has remained unoccupied
thereafter. The plaintiff also tried to pay the tehbazari fees for the
site, however, the defendant no.1 refused to accept the same.
CS No. 409/2021 Page No. 3/13
-- 3 of 13 --
(ix) On 18.02.2020, the plaintiff was informed by one of
his neighbours that some unsavory elements had tried to forcibly
take over tehbazari site. The plaintiff immediately reached the site,
where he was threatened by the person with dire consequences and
the plaintiff called upon ‘100’ police helpline. The police
immediately reached the site and helped the plaintiff to deal with
the situation and the said person was removed from the site. The
plaintiff came to know that it was defendant no.2, who tried to take
forcible possession of the tehbazari site. The plaintiff filed the
police complaint dated 18.02.2020.
(x) The defendant no.1 had been permitting other
similarly placed persons (where original tehbazari license holder
has expired) to operate from their respective sites, however, in the
case of the plaintiff, they acted to the contrary. The plaintiff and
his family are completely dependent on the tehbazari site.
(xi) The plaintiff approached the Hon’ble High Court of
Delhi by way of WP (C) 2701/2020, against the defendant no.1,
wherein the defendant no.1 was directed to file status report vide
order dated 11.03.2020. The plaintiff received the affidavit of
defendant no.1 in response to the writ petition.
(xii) The defendant no.1, in the counter-affidavit stated that
the father of the plaintiff had sublet the tehbazari site to Mr. Vinod
Kumar by way of partnership deed, which is a violation of the
terms of tehbazari license.
(xiii) The alleged partnership deed had only surfaced during
the aforesaid proceedings before the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi.
The partnership deed is a forged and fabricated document and does
not bear the signatures of the father of the plaintiff.
CS No. 409/2021 Page No. 4/13
-- 4 of 13 --
(xiv) The Hon’ble High Court of Delhi disposed of the WP
(C) 2701/2020, by way of order dated 19.01.2021, wherein the
following observations were made in para no.6:-
“Even otherwise, in these proceedings, we cannot get into
disputed questions of facts/documents or claims which are founded
thereupon. It would, however, be open to the Petitioner to raise all
such issues before the Town Vending Committee, or any
appropriate forum/Court competent to decide the same”
(xv) The Town Vending Committee for NDMC area is yet
not functional and therefore the plaintiff had approached this court.
(xvi) The plaintiff got the alleged signatures of his father
upon the partnership deed dated 23.07.2011, examined and
compaired with his actual signatures from the handwriting and
fingerprints expert Sh. Deepak Jain, who furnished the report dated
04.02.2021 and opined that the alleged signatures on the
partnership deed are not of the father of the plaintiff, Mohd. Shafiq
@ Shafiquddin.
(xvii) Since the plaintiff is the legal heir of Mohd. Shafiq @
Shafiquddin, he is entitled to vend at the tehbazari site. As
defendant no.1 has been giving permission to similarly placed
persons in respect of tehbazari sites at Connaught Place and
Sarojini Nagar areas, their refusal to allow the same to the plaintiff
is arbitrary and discriminatory. The Town Vending Committee for
NDMC area constituted under Street Vendors (Protection of
Livelihood & Regulation of Street Vending) Act, 2014, is not yet
functional and therefore, the plaintiff has filed the present suit.
(xviii) The plaintiff seeks a declaration that the partnership deed
dated 23.07.2011, is a forged document and that the plaintiff is the
CS No. 409/2021 Page No. 5/13
-- 5 of 13 --
rightful holder/owner of tehbazari site. Plaintiff seeks mandatory
injunction for direction to the defendant no.1 to transfer the
tehbazari license of his father in the name of the plaintiff and to
allow him to squat at the tehbazari site. Plaintiff also seeks
permanent injunction against defendant no.2, thereby restraining
him from interfering with the possession of the tehbazari site.
3. The summons of the suit were issued and duly served upon
the defendants. Defendant no.1 failed to file its WS and the right to
file WS was closed vide order dated 17.11.2021. Defendant no.2
also failed to file WS and he was proceeded ex parte vide order
dated 17.11.2021.
4. Following issues were framed in the present suit vide order
dated 14.09.2022.
Issue No.1- Whether the plaintiff is entitled to decree of
declaration, as prayed for in prayer A? OPP.
Issue No.2- Whether the plaintiff is entitled to decree of
mandatory injunction, as prayed for in prayer B? OPP.
Issue No.3- Whether the plaintiff is entitled to decree of
mandatory injunction, as prayed for in prayer C? OPP.
Issue No.4- Whether the plaintiff is entitled to decree of
permanent injunction, as prayed for in prayer D? OPP.
Relief.
Matter was thereafter, listed for PE.
5. The plaintiff/PW1, tendered his evidence by way of affidavit
Ex. PW1/A and deposed on the same lines as stated in the plaint.
CS No. 409/2021 Page No. 6/13
-- 6 of 13 --
He has also relied upon the following documents:-
a) Copy of death certificate of late Mohd. Shafiq is
Ex.PW1/1 (OSR);
b) Copy of possession slip is Ex.PW1/2 (OSR);
c) Copy of notice dated 10.06.2005 is Ex.PW1/3 (OSR);
d) Copy of judgment dated 06.12.2016 titled as Jagdish Vs.
NDMC & Ors. is Ex.PW1/4 (OSR);
e) Application for transfer of the license on behalf of my
mother Smt. Shahina dated 04.02.2020 is Ex.PW1/5;
f) Copy of letter dated 28.02.2020 is Ex.PW1/6 (OSR);
g) Copy of payment receipt dated 05.02.2020 is Ex.PW1/7
(OSR);
h) Photographs is Ex.PW1/8;
i) Copy of police complaint dated 18.02.2020 is Ex.PW1/9;
j) Copy of handwriting expert report dated 04.02.2021 is
Ex.PW1/10 (OSR);
k) Copy of order dated 21.10.1992 is Ex.PW1/11 (OSR);
1) Copy of order dated 22.06.1999 is Ex.PW1/12 (OSR);
m) Copy of letter dated 01.02.2020 is Mark-A;
n) Copy of counter affiadvit on behalf of NDMC in W.P.(C)
No.2701/2020 filed before Delhi High Court is Mark-B;
o) Copy of Partnership Deed dated 23.07.2011 is Mark-C;
and
p) Copy of order dated 11.03.2020 is Mark-D.
PW-1 was duly cross-examined by Ld. counsel for the
defendant no.1.
CS No. 409/2021 Page No. 7/13
-- 7 of 13 --
6. Sh. Deepak Jain, private handwriting and fingerprint expert,
deposed as PW2 and relied upon his report Ex.PW1/10 (OSR). He
was duly cross-examined by the ld. Counsel for defendant no.1. PE
was thereafter closed and matter was listed for DE/final arguments.
7. Final arguments have been heard. I have perused the entire
record.
8. My issue-wise findings are as under:-
Issue No.1-
Whether the plaintiff is entitled to decree of declaration, as
prayed for in prayer A? OPP.
The onus of proving this issue is upon the plaintiff. The
plaintiff seeks two reliefs by way of prayer (a) in the plaint. He
seeks a declaration that the partnership deed dated
23.07.2011(Mark C), is invalid and forged document. He also
seeks the declaration that he be declared the rightful holder/owner
of the tehbazari site.
9. It is not disputed that the father of the plaintiff was having
the tehbazari license in respect of the tehbazari site till his death on
29.11.2019. The plaintiff thereafter, applied for the transfer of
license in his mother’s name, however, due to health issues of the
mother, it was decided by the family members that the request for
transfer of license in the name of the plaintiff will be applied for.
Accordingly, the plaintiff applied for transfer of the tehbazari
license in his name, with the defendant. The plaintiff states that the
CS No. 409/2021 Page No. 8/13
-- 8 of 13 --
defendant no.1 has been permitting similarly placed persons
(wherein the original license holder has died), to continue with the
tehbazari site, however, in the case of the plaintiff the defendant
no.1 acted to the contrary and therefore, the plaintiff filed the writ
petition WP (C) 2701/2020, titled as
“Danish Faisal Vs. NDMC
and Ors.”, before the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi. The Hon’ble
High Court of Delhi disposed of the petition in the following
terms:-
“Even otherwise, in these proceedings, we cannot get into
disputed questions of facts/documents or claims which are founded
thereupon. It would, however, be open to the Petitioner to raise all
such issues before the Town Vending Committee, or any
appropriate forum/Court competent to decide the same”
10. The plaintiff has stated that the defendant no.1 in the
counter-affidavit, filed before the Ho’ble High Court in the
aforesaid writ petition, has made an averment that the father of the
plaintiff had entered into a partnership deed with the defendant
no.2 on 23.07.2011 and therefore, the father of the plaintiff has
sublet the tehbazari site to defendant no.2. The plaintiff has
challenged the authenticity of the partnership deed dated
23.07.2011, so relied upon by defendant no.1.
11. The plaintiff has duly filed on record the report of
handwriting expert Sh. Deepak Jain, as Ex.PW1/10 (OSR). Sh.
Deepak Jain has also deposed on oath as PW2. As per the report,
the alleged signatures of the father of the plaintiff, namely Mohd.
Shafiq @ Shafiquddin, have been compared with his signatures
CS No. 409/2021 Page No. 9/13
-- 9 of 13 --
appearing on affidavit and Vakalatnama, filed on his behalf in the
WP (C) No. 5292/16, before the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi. The
alleged signatures have also been compared with his signatures
appearing in the challan receipts of the NDMC, issued in respect of
deposition of tehbazari license fees. The handwriting expert has
concluded that the disputed signatures and the comparative
signatures are not of the same person. PW2 has stood the test of
cross-examination and no material contradiction has been brought
out in his testimony during the cross-examination. The plaintiff has
been able to show that the signatures appearing on the alleged
partnership deed dated 27.03.2011 (Mark C), do not pertain to his
father, Mohd. Shafiq @ Shafiquddin. Therefore, the plaintiff is
entitled to the declaration upon the partnership deed (Mark C),
against the defendants. The plaintiff has also sought declaration
that he is the rightful holder/owner of the tehbazari site, however,
in the opinion of the court such relief is not maintainable as the
tehbazari site is allotted on the basis of license and does not confer
any ownership and therefore, the plaintiff cannot claim ownership
upon the same. The issue is partly allowed in favour of the plaintiff
and against the defendants.
Issue No.2 and 3:
Whether the plaintiff is entitled to decree of mandatory
injunction, as prayed for in prayer B? OPP.
Whether the plaintiff is entitled to decree of mandatory
injunction, as prayed for in prayer C? OPP.
12. The onus of proving these issues is upon the plaintiff. The
relief sought in prayer (b) and (c) are similar in nature and prayer
CS No. 409/2021 Page No. 10/13
-- 10 of 13 --
(c) is corollary to prayer (b). It has been proved that the plaintiff
has applied for transfer of license of tehbazari site in his name with
the defendant no.1, after the demise of his father. The application
dated 28.02.2020, for such request is already on record as
Ex.PW1/6.
13. The plaintiff has stated that the Town Vending Committee is
not functional and therefore, the plaintiff has approached this court.
The plaintiff has relied upon section 5 (2) of Street Vendors
(Protection of Livelihood & Regulation of Street Vending) Act,
2014. It is claimed that the tehbazari site is the only source of
income for the family. It is further submitted that the mother of the
plaintiff cannot continue the tehbazari site due to health issues and
therefore, the plaintiff has applied for transfer of license in his own
name and he is entitled to transfer on the basis of section 5 (2) of
Street Vendors (Protection of Livelihood & Regulation of Street
Vending) Act, 2014.
14. Section 5(2) of Street Vendors (Protection of Livelihood &
Regulation of Street Vending) Act, 2014, provides that when a
street vendor having certificate of vending dies, one of the family
members may vend in his place, till the validity of the certificate of
vending. As per the provision, the first priority is to be accorded to
the spouse of the street vendor and the dependent child of the street
vendor comes next. The defendant NDMC have not disputed the
factual position as discussed in preceeding paragraph. Further, no
reply to the request of the plaintiff has been furnished by the
NDMC or the Town Vending Committee. It is an admitted position
CS No. 409/2021 Page No. 11/13
-- 11 of 13 --
that the Town Vending Committee formed under the provisions of
Street Vendors (Protection of Livelihood & Regulation of Street
Vending) Act, 2014, is not functional for NDMC. Therefore, there
is no justification on the part of the defendant NDMC to keep the
application of the plaintiff in abeyance and thereby the plaintiff is
justified in approaching this court. The issues are decided in favour
of the plaintiff and against the defendants.
Issue No.4-
Whether the plaintiff is entitled to decree of permanent
injunction, as prayed for in prayer D? OPP.
15. The onus of proving this issue is upon the plaintiff. The
plaintiff has alleged that the defendant no.2 had tried to forcibly
occupy the tehbazari site and the complaint Ex.PW1/9, has been
filed with the police. The counter-affidavit (Mark C), shows that
the defendant NDMC has also averred before the Hon’ble High
Court that the plaintiff and the defendant no.2 had a fight and
consequently both of them were removed from the tehbazari site
on 14.03.2020, for the time being. The defendant no.2 has not
appeared or contested the present case. The allegations against
defendant no.2 have remained unrebutted. Accordingly, this issue
is decided in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendant no.2.
Relief:-
16. In view of above said discussion, the suit of the plaintiff is
partly decreed. The plaintiff is held entitled to the declaration
against the defendants that the partnership deed (Mark C) dated
23.07.2011, does not bear the signatures of Mohd. Shafiq @
CS No. 409/2021 Page No. 12/13
-- 12 of 13 --
Shafiquddin and is therefore, invalid and forged. The defendant
no.1 is directed to transfer the tehbazari license issued to Mohd.
Shafiq @ Shafiquddin in respect of site no. 134, M-11, C-block,
opposite Singer Machine (now Van Heusen showroom), inner
circle, Connaught Place, New Delhi-01, measuring 4 ft. x 3 ft., in
favour of the plaintiff and further allow the plaintiff to vend at the
said tehbazari site. The defendant no.2 is restrained from vending
at the tehbazari site no. 134, M-11, C-block, opposite Singer
Machine (now Van Heusen showroom), inner circle, Connaught
Place, New Delhi-01, measuring 4 ft. x 3 ft. and is also restrained
from interfering with the possession of the plaintiff of the said
tehbazari site. No order as to costs.
17. Decree-sheet be prepared accordingly.
18. File be consigned to the record room after due compliance.
Announced in open Court VINOD JOSHI
Delhi Dated 27.03.2025 JSCC/ASCJ/GJ/PHC
New Delhi/27.03.2025
CS No. 409/2021 Page No. 13/13
-- 13 of 13 --

TrustJury presents public court-record information for legal discovery and reference. Record availability and detail can vary by source and case.