Full Order Text
Order 6 · 17 Sept 2026 · CNR DLND030005402026
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: __________________________________________________________________________________________ RC ARC 11/26 Momina Rehman Vs. Praveen Aggarwal Page no. 1 of 15 DLND030005402026 IN THE COURT OF SH. MAYANK GOEL, SCJ-CUM-RC, NEW DELHI DISTRICT, PATIALA HOUSE COURTS, NEW DELHI. RC ARC NO. 11/2026 IN THE MATTER OF: Smt. Momina Rehman W/o Kashif Naqi R/o Z-202, Taj Enclave Geeta Colony, Gandhi Nagar Delhi-110031. ...Petitioner VERSUS Sh. Praveen Aggarwal S/o Sh. Brijlal Aggarwal At Shop No.3, (533 Old), Block 91 Bhagat Singh Lane, Gole Market New Delhi-110001. ...Respondent DATE OF INSTITUTION : 19.03.2026 DATE OF RESERVING THE ORDER : 13.08.2026 DATE OF DECISION : 17.09.2026 FINAL ORDER : ALLOWED -- 1 of 15 -- __________________________________________________________________________________________ RC ARC 11/26 Momina Rehman Vs. Praveen Aggarwal Page no. 2 of 15 ORDER (on application for Leave to defend filed on behalf of respondent) 1. Smt. Momina Rehman (hereinafter referred to as ‘Petitioner’) has filed a petition under Section 14(1)(e) r/w Section 25B of the Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958 (herein after referred to as DRC Act) seeking eviction of respondent Sh. Praveen Aggarwal (hereinafter referred to as ‘Respondent’) from shop bearing no. 3 (533 Old), Block No.91, Bhagat Singh Lane, Gole Market, New Delhi-110001 as shown in red color in the site plan attached with the petition (hereinafter referred to as tenanted suit premises). The said shop was let out to the Respondent and presently the monthly rent of the tenanted premises is Rs. 1,169/- and Rs.210/- on account of service tax i.e. in total Rs.1,379/- excluding all other charges. BRIEF FACTS PLEADED IN THE PETITION 2.1. The petitioner is sole, absolute and exclusive owner of the tenanted suit premises. The tenanted suit premises was originally owned by Late Sh. Mushtaq Ahmed, the maternal grandfather of the petitioner who had executed a Will in favour of his wife Smt. Shamim Mushtaq. That Smt. Shamim Mushtaq, the maternal grandfather of the petitioner expired on 20.12.2024. Till she is alive, the respondent had been paying rent to her regularly being the owner/landlord of the tenanted suit premises by virtue of the Will. That during her lifetime, Smt. Shamim Mushtaq made a valid Hiba (Gift) of the tenanted suit premises in favour of the petitioner. That by virtue of said Hiba, the petitioner becomes the sole and absolute owner of the tenanted suit premises. That the respondent has been duly informed and called upon to attorn in favour of the petitioner vide letter of -- 2 of 15 -- __________________________________________________________________________________________ RC ARC 11/26 Momina Rehman Vs. Praveen Aggarwal Page no. 3 of 15 attornment dated 13.01.2025 and the respondent has attorned in favour of petitioner. 2.2. That the family of the petitioner consists of herself, her husband and her two sons. That the tenanted premises is required bonafide for her husband namely Kashif Naqi, who has been presently carrying out business activities from a tenanted premises bearing no. 11, Second Floor, Kohinoor Building, Katra Baryan, Fatehpuri, Delhi at a monthly rent of Rs.8,000/-. That since the premises is situated at second floor, there is less footfall of customers and business is less profitable to meet the financial requirements of the family. That the petitioner alongwith her husband intends to start and carry on their own independent business from their own premises and the tenanted suit premises is suitable as situated in a prime commercial locality. 2.3. That neither the petitioner nor her family members are having any vacant commercial accommodation at her disposal in Delhi so the need of the petitioner is very urgent and bonafide. 2.4. The petitioner has prayed for passing of an eviction order in respect of the tenanted suit premises as shown and delineated in red colour in the site plan attached with the petition. 2.5. Notice of the petition was served upon the respondent who filed application seeking leave to defend. LEAVE TO DEFEND APPLICATION 3.1. It is stated by respondent that the tenanted suit premises is a -- 3 of 15 -- __________________________________________________________________________________________ RC ARC 11/26 Momina Rehman Vs. Praveen Aggarwal Page no. 4 of 15 Government granted land by L&DO and the tenanted suit premises is a leasehold property and never been converted to a freehold property and therefore, belongs to L&DO (Land and Development Office). Since the land belongs to Government department, therefore, same is not governed by Delhi Rent Control (DRC Act), 1958. 3.2. That the petitioner relies upon an alleged unregistered Hiba in respect of the tenanted suit premises but the same cannot override the lease conditions imposed by L&DO. Therefore, the alleged Hiba is legally ineffective and does not create any ownership or landlord rights in favour of the petitioner. That the conditions of Valid Hiba have also not been fulfilled. 3.3 That as per section 14(6) of the DRC, a landlord who acquires property by transfer cannot file for tenant eviction on bonafide requirement u/s 14(1)(e) DRC until the expiration of five years from the date of acquisition. However, no date of Hiba is mentioned in the said petition by the petitioner. 3.4 That there exists no landlord-tenant relationship between the petitioner and the respondent. That Sh. Mushtaq Ahmed inducted the tenant in the tenanted suit premises in the year 2000 after receiving a Pagdi amount of Rs. 10,00,000/- which was the 75% of the market value of the tenanted suit premises with the condition that Ah. Mushtaq Ahmed would execute the transfer documents after getting the property freehold and that the respondent would keep on paying the nominal rent of Rs. 600/- per month with an increase of 10% after three years. 3.5 That after the demise of Ms. Shamim Mushtaq on 20.12.2024, certain persons claiming themselves to be her legal heirs visited the tenanted suit -- 4 of 15 -- __________________________________________________________________________________________ RC ARC 11/26 Momina Rehman Vs. Praveen Aggarwal Page no. 5 of 15 premises and orally informed the respondent to transfer the rent to the Paytm number of a person, which the respondent later came to know as the petitioner. That no valid, legal or written attornment of tenancy was ever executed between the respondent and the petitioner. REPLY TO LEAVE TO DEFEND APPLICATION 4.1. Reply to the application seeking leave to defend was filed. The petitioner denied the averments made in the application seeking leave to defend and reiterated the facts pleaded in the petition. 4.2. The petitioner averred that the respondent has paid arrears of rent amounting to Rs. 9,653/- to the petitioner on 15.04.2026 through Paytm which falsifies the contention of the respondent. That the respondent has intentionally concealed that he had duly received the attornment communication and therefore continued acknowledging the tenancy in favour of the petitioner. 4.3 That the leave to defend application filed by the respondent is summarily liable to be dismissed as the respondent was served summons in the present case on 10.04.2026 through speed post but the leave to defend application has been filed on 27.04.2026. 4.4 That the petitioner has not purchased or acquired the tenanted suit premises through any sale, transfer or transaction as alleged by the respondent. That the rights in the property came to the petitioner through family arrangement/ hiba from her maternal grandmother during her lifetime and same cannot be treated as transfer within the meaning of Section 14(6) of DRC. -- 5 of 15 -- __________________________________________________________________________________________ RC ARC 11/26 Momina Rehman Vs. Praveen Aggarwal Page no. 6 of 15 5. Respondent in his rejoinder has reiterated the contents of his leave to defend application. 6. I have heard learned counsels for both the parties and have carefully gone through the entire material on record. I have also gone through the written synopsis/arguments filed on behalf of the parties alongwith the judgments relied upon by them. 7. It is settled law that when the questions raised in the leave to contest application can be decided on the basis of affidavits and documents filed in the case, then no triable issue arises requiring evidence, as has been held by the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi in case reported as, “ 2008 RLR 637”, titled as, “ Raghubir Chand Dhawan V/s Vijay Kumar”. 8. It is further settled position in law that the purport of the summary procedure prescribed U/s 25 B of the Rent Control Act is to avoid trial necessarily in cases for eviction, on the ground of personal requirement of premises. The onus has been placed on the tenant to show to the Controller such facts, which if proved in trial would disentitle the landlord to an order of eviction on the said grounds. In a given case, the tenant may, in the application for leave to defend raise pleas disputing the claim of the petitioner. The said pleas may not necessarily require trial. Merely, because pleas have been raised and which if successful may disentitle the landlord from an order of eviction would be no ground to grant leave to contest, if the pleas are such which do not require any trial. The Controller is then required to proceed to decide the said pleas at the stage of considering the application for leave to contest itself. If the Controller -- 6 of 15 -- __________________________________________________________________________________________ RC ARC 11/26 Momina Rehman Vs. Praveen Aggarwal Page no. 7 of 15 grants leave to contest merely because pleas have been raised even though not requiring trial, the same would negate the purpose of summary trial. Section 25 B (5) of DRC Act requires the Controller to give to the tenant leave to contest, if the affidavit of the tenant declares such “facts” as would disentitle the landlord from obtaining an order of eviction U/s 14 (1) (e) of DRC Act. The intent is that “facts” would require to be proved. However, if what is disclosed is a legal defence or a legal plea, not required to be proved, the same has to be adjudicated immediately and decision of such plea is not to be deferred by granting leave to contest to the tenant (Reference case reported as, “166 (2010) DLT 443”, titled as, “Tahira Begum V/s Sumitar Kaur & Anr.”). 9. It is further settled law that the test to determine whether the tenant has raised a triable issue is to examine whether the landlord would fail in his attempt to evict the tenant, if the defence of the tenant, as disclosed is established. Leave to defend cannot be granted to a tenant merely for the asking. When the Controller examines the defence raised by the tenant, in his application seeking leave to defend, it cannot be said that he conducts a pre-trial. Obviously, the Controller is required to value the defences disclosed by the tenant at the time of consideration of the tenant's application. Without such examination, he possibly cannot arrive at the conclusion whether the defence discloses a triable issue or whether the defence is frivolous (Reference case reported as, “ 2008 Vol. 6 AD (Delhi) 103”, titled as, “T.B Jain V/s Savita Ravi & Anr.”). 10. It is further settled law that the test to see whether the tenant has raised triable issues is not of the tenant having controverted/denied the claim of the landlord and thus disputed question of fact arising. The test is to examine -- 7 of 15 -- __________________________________________________________________________________________ RC ARC 11/26 Momina Rehman Vs. Praveen Aggarwal Page no. 8 of 15 pleas of facts and then to determine the impact thereof. A heavy burden lies on the tenant to prove that the requirement of the landlord is not genuine. The tenant is required to give all the necessary facts and particulars supported by documentary evidence, if available, to prove his plea in the affidavit itself, so that the Controller will be in a position to decide the question of genuine or bonafide requirement of the landlord; mere assertion of the tenant would not be sufficient to rebut the strong presumption in the landlord's favour that his requirement of occupation of the premises is real and genuine (ref case reported as, “ 167(2010)DLT80”,titled as,“ Swaran Dass Banerjee V/s Ram Prakash”). 11. In case reported as, “ 1996 (5) SCC 353”, titled as, “ Pratibha Devi V/s T.V Krishnan”, the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India has been pleased to lay down that the landlord is the best judge of his residential requirement and has complete freedom in the matter and it is no concern of the court to dictate to the landlord how and in what manner he should live. The Hon'ble Supreme Court of India deprecated the solicitous approach of the courts below and held that there is no law which deprives the landlord of the beneficial enjoyment of his property. 12. Further, it is settled proposition of law that in order to succeed in a case U/s 14 (1)(e) of DRC Act, the landlord/petitioner is required to prove the following ingredients: (i) Ownership in respect of a tenanted premises; (ii) Relationship of landlord & tenant between the parties; (iii) Petitioner bonafidely requires the tenanted premises for himself or for any member of his family dependent upon him and; (iv) Petitioner does not have any other reasonable suitable -- 8 of 15 -- __________________________________________________________________________________________ RC ARC 11/26 Momina Rehman Vs. Praveen Aggarwal Page no. 9 of 15 accommodation available with him. 13. Petitioner's ownership over the tenanted suit property AND Relationship of landlord & tenant between the parties: Since both these points raised by the respondent are inter- connected and the findings thereupon would be common, so both these points/issues are being taken up together for adjudication. The law with regard to right of tenant to challenge the ownership of his landlord is also fairly settled. Some judgments can be looked into in this regard, which are as under: (i) In case reported as, “ 134 (2006) DLT 298”, titled as, “ Munni Devi V/s Manmohan Verma & Ors.”, Hon'ble High Court of Delhi has been pleased to hold that Rent Controller cannot go into the complete history of the title of the property for centuries, as the same is not permissible under law and the tenant has to satisfy the test of prima facie disclosure of such facts which would disentitle the landlord from eviction order in terms of judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in “ Precision Steel & Engineering Works' case”, reported as, “ 22 (1982) DLT 458”. (ii)In case reported as, “ AIR 1987 SC 2028”, titled as, “ Smt.Shanti Sharma & Ors. V/s Smt.Ved Prabha & Ors.” Hon'ble Supreme Court of India has been pleased to hold that for the purpose of Section 14(1)(e) of DRC Act, the ownership is not to be understood as absolute ownership, but only as a title better than the tenant. So, what has to been seen is whether on the basis of the facts stated by a tenant it can be said that the landlord does not have title to the property, a title better than him. Similar are the observations of Hon'ble High Court of -- 9 of 15 -- __________________________________________________________________________________________ RC ARC 11/26 Momina Rehman Vs. Praveen Aggarwal Page no. 10 of 15 Delhi in case reported as, “ 155 (2008) DLT 383” titled as,“ Rajinder Kumar Sharma & Ors. V/s Leelawati & Ors.”. So, what has to be seen is whether on the basis of aforesaid facts, can it be said that petitioner has a title to the property, a title better than the respondent (reference case reported as, “ AIR 1982 SC 2028”, titled as, “ Smt.Shanti Sharma V/s Ved Prabha”). The aforesaid judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India was also relied by the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi in “ Tahira Begum's” case (supra). The respondent in his leave to defend application disputed the landlord- tenant relationship between the petitioner and the respondent but admitted the landlord-tenant relationship between the him and Smt. Shamim Mustaq. Here, the petitioner is claiming the landlordship on the fact that the tenanted suit premises had been gifted to the petitioner by Smt. Shamim Mushtaq during her lifetime. Furthermore, the respondent has paid the rent to the petitioner by way of Paytm, which also shows that the respondent had accepted the landlordship of the petitioner qua the tenanted suit premises. The stand of the respondent in the leave to defend application that he had paid an amount of Rs. 10,00,000/- as pagdi amount to Sh. Mustaq Ahmed, the then erstwhile owner and maternal grandfather of the petitioner and that the tenanted suit premises belongs to L&DO, holds no water as the respondent admitted that he is the tenant of the petitioner by paying rent to her. The title need not to be proved in eviction petition under section 14(1) (e) DRC Act. Section 116 of the Indian Evidence Act creates estoppel against such a tenant. A tenant can challenge the title of the landlord only after vacating the premises and not when he is occupying the premises. -- 10 of 15 -- __________________________________________________________________________________________ RC ARC 11/26 Momina Rehman Vs. Praveen Aggarwal Page no. 11 of 15 In the present case, the respondent has not disputed the foundational relationship between the parties. Infact, his own case is that he was inducted a tenant in the tenanted suit premises by maternal grandfather of the petitioner at monthly rent of Rs. 600/-. 14. Whether the need of the petitioner to have the tenanted suit premises is bonafide? And Whether suitable alternate accommodation is available with the petitioner? Since both these points raised by the respondent are inter- connected and the findings thereupon would be common, so both these points/issues are being taken up together for adjudication. The stand of the respondent in the leave to defend application has been that the petitioner has already sufficient accommodation under her occupation and the tenanted premises is not required by her for her husband’s bonafide requirements. All these averments made by the respondent is evasive and bald and not supported by any documentary proof. It is the duty of the respondent to place on record the details of the suitable alternate accommodation if any available to the petitioner. It has been argued that petitioner being landlord/owner of tenanted premises in question has all the right and choice to start her own business in the premises more suitable and most convenient to him and the tenant cannot dictate the landlord as to how and in what manner the landlord should use her own property. -- 11 of 15 -- __________________________________________________________________________________________ RC ARC 11/26 Momina Rehman Vs. Praveen Aggarwal Page no. 12 of 15 Moreover, the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Prativa Devi Vs. K. V. Krishnan, 1956 (5) SCC 353, which is a three-judge bench judgment has held that owner/landlord is the best judge of his own requirements and the Courts have no concern to dictate the landlord as to how and in what manner he should live or do business. Thus, considering the facts and circumstances of the present case, the defence/point of “suitable alternate accommodation” and “no bonafide requirement” is also not available to the respondent. 15. Be that as it may, in my opinion the “ bonafide requirement” of a landlord/petitioner qua his property cannot be overlooked and the factum of comparative hardship to the tenants has to take a backstage, as has been held by the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi in, “ 1979 (1) RCR 153”, titled as, “ Ajit Singh V/s Inder Saran. 16. However, the respondent as well as petitioner has taken technical objections in his leave to defend application as well as by way of reply to the leave to defend application respectively. 17. The technical objection raised by the petitioner is that the respondent has been served by speed post on 10.04.2026 and filed leave to defend on 27.04.2026 i.e. after the expiry of 15 days and the petitioner is entitled to the order of eviction against the respondent. It is pertinent to mention that speed post tracking report itself shows that speed post has not been served on 09.04.2026 as ‘no such person in the address’ and on 10.04.2026, it was delivered back to the sender i.e. the petitioner and not the respondent. Moreover, the RC cover also -- 12 of 15 -- __________________________________________________________________________________________ RC ARC 11/26 Momina Rehman Vs. Praveen Aggarwal Page no. 13 of 15 received back with the report ‘no such person in the address’. This shows that the respondent has never been served by the speed post on 10.04.2026 and has been duly served through summons on 15.04.2026 and the respondent has duly filed the leave to defend within 15 days. 18. Another objection has been raised by the respondent which is that the present petition is barred by section 14(6) DRC as in the present petition no valid date of Hiba has been mentioned; Smt. Shamim Mushtaq expired on 20.12.2024; the respondent was giving rent to Smt. Shamim Mushtaq till her death; that the petitioner cannot file the petition u/s 14(1)(e) DRC before the expiry of 5 years from the date of transfer and the date of transfer/hiba is not mentioned. In response to the said objection, it is stated by the petitioner that for applicability of section 14(6) DRC, there must be transfer and the petitioner got the property from Smt. Shamim Mushtaq by way of Hiba/family arrangement which does not amount to transfer in terms of section 14(6) DRC. 19. Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in V. N. Sarin Vs. Major Ajit Kumar Poplai & Anr, 1965 SCC OnLine SC 301, held that while examining the legislative intent behind section 14(6) DRC is to prevent the landlords from circumventing the protection granted to the tenant by transferring the premises to another person who may then seek eviction on the ground of bonafide requirement. The expression ‘acquired by transfer’ contemplates a situation where the transferee acquires rights in the property which did not vest in him prior to such transfer. 20. Hon’ble High Court of Delhi in Preeti Gupta Vs. Madan Mohan -- 13 of 15 -- __________________________________________________________________________________________ RC ARC 11/26 Momina Rehman Vs. Praveen Aggarwal Page no. 14 of 15 Pahwa, held that bar u/s 14(6) DRC was not attracted in the peculiar facts of the case where the petitioner wife had acquired the property from the husband by way of gift deed and already had pre-existing legal right in the property being a Class-I heir. 21. In the present case, the petitioner is Distant Kindred (Dhawu’l- Arham) who inherit only when the prescribed conditions for their inheritance are satisfied and in the absence of Sharers(Quranic Heirs) and Residuaries(Asaba). However, it is not the case here that Smt. Shamim Mushtaq did not have any Sharers(Quranic Heirs) and Residuaries(Asaba) to inherit her property after her demise and the petitioner would inherit her property, therefore, it cannot be said that the petitioner had pre-existing legal right in the tenanted suit premises and consequently, not out of the purview of bar of Section 14(6) of DRC. Here, the petitioner has nowhere mentioned in the petition any date on which the Hiba of the tenanted suit premises has been done by Smt. Shamim Mushtaq in favour of the petitioner and it is also admitted fact that the respondent was making the payment of rent to Smt. Shamim Mushtaq till her demise, therefore, in absence of specific date of Hiba, it raised the triable issue whether the present petition is maintainable or barred by Section 14(6) of the DRC Act. 22. In these circumstances, I find force in the issues raised by the respondent that it requires evidence in order to find out whether the petitioner has got the property by way of Hiba 5 years prior to filing of present petition and it is not possible to take a view that no triable issue arose for consideration. Therefore, the present leave to defend application is hereby allowed only on the limited point of “whether the present petition is barred by Section 14(6) of DRC Act” as the -- 14 of 15 -- __________________________________________________________________________________________ RC ARC 11/26 Momina Rehman Vs. Praveen Aggarwal Page no. 15 of 15 petitioner has already proved all the four essential requirements above-mentioned in para no. 12 of this order. Thus, leave to defend is granted to the respondents to contest the petition only on one issue “whether the present petition is barred by Section 14(6) of DRC Act”. The parties are directed and have to lead evidences only on this specific issue. 23. Put up for petitioner’s evidence on 03.11.2026. MAYANK GOEL Sr. Civil Judge-cum-Rent Controller PHC, New Delhi/17.09.2026 -- 15 of 15 --
