Full Order Text
Final Order 7 · 27 Apr 2022 · CNR DLND030003682021
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF PREETI PAREWA, ACJ/ARC/CCJ NEW DELHI DISTRICT, PATIALA HOUSE COURTS, NEW DELHI SUCCESSION CASE NO. 20/2021 1. Shashi Shobha Khorana W/o Late Sh. Satish Chander Khorana 52, Riverside Avenue Riverside, CT 06878, USA. … Petitioner Versus 1. State 2. Aditi Khorana D/o Late Sh. Satish Khorana 52, Riverside Avenue Riverside, CT 06878, USA. 3. Smitha Khorana D/o Late Sh. Satish Khorana 52, Riverside Avenue Riverside, CT 06878, USA. 4. Citi Bank G & 1st Floor, DLF Capitol Point Baba Kharak Singh Marg Connaught Place, New Delhi110001. … Respondents PETITION FOR GRANT OF SUCCESSION CERTIFICATE UNDER SECTION 372 OF THE INDIAN SUCCESSION ACT, 1925 Date of institution of the petition : 12.02.2021 Date on which judgment was reserved : Not reserved. Date of pronouncement of judgment : 27.04.2022 Final Judgment : Allowed. SC No. 20/2021 Shashi Shobha Khorana Vs State & Ors. Page No. 1 of 6 -- 1 of 6 -- J U D G M E N T 1. Petitioner has applied for succession certificate under Section 372 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 in respect of Savings Bank Account No. 5048382004, Citi Bank, G & 1st Floor, DLF Capitol Point, Baba Kharak Singh Marg, Connaught Place, New Delhi110001 held in the name of her deceased husband Late Sh. Satish Chander Khorana. The petitioner has further sought succession certificate for filing the Income Tax Returns for a property bearing Plot No. 222, BlockD, South City1, Gurugram, Haryana which was sold in the year 2018. 2. It is the case of the petitioner that she is the wife of the deceased Late Sh. Satish Chander Khorana, who died intestate on 12.08.2020 leaving behind the petitioner and the respondent no.2 & 3. That, the respondent no.2 & 3 have no objection for grant of succession certificate in favour of the petitioner in the present case. It is prayed that succession certificate be issued in favour of the petitioner in respect of aforesaid debts / securities of the deceased. 3. The succession petition was filed in this Court on 12.02.2021. Subsequently, besides service of notice of petition upon respondents, this Court also directed for publication of notice of succession petition in the daily newspapers and consequently, the publication was made in newspapers “Veer Arjun” dated 21.09.2021 and “The Statesman” dated 18.09.2021 for inviting objections, if any, from general public. Despite publication, no objection to the grant of succession certificate in favour of petitioner was received from general public. 4. The respondent no.2 & 3 have filed their “no objection” to the instant petition stating that they have no objection if succession certificate in the SC No. 20/2021 Shashi Shobha Khorana Vs State & Ors. Page No. 2 of 6 -- 2 of 6 -- present case is granted in favour of petitioner. 5. Notice was also issued to the concerned SDM / EM verifying the address of the petitioner and details of surviving members of the deceased. As per report of SDM (Dwarka), petitioner and respondent no.2 & 3 were the only surviving members of the deceased. 6. In the petitioner’s evidence, petitioner examined Sh. Ravi M. Macker, SPA holder as PW1, tendered his affidavit Ex.PW1/A and relied upon the following documents : i) SPA executed in his favour by the petitioner Smt. Shashi Shobha Khorana – Ex.CW1/1; ii) Copy of death certificates issued by the Department of Public Health, State of Connecticut, US of deceased Sh. Satish Chander Khorana– Ex.CW1/2; iii) Copy of passport issued at State of Connecticut, US of deceased Sh. Satish Chander Khorana – Ex.CW1/3; iv) Copy of Driving Licence issued at State of Connecticut, US of deceased Sh. Satish Chander Khorana – Ex.CW1/4; v) Copy of saledeed of the property bearing plot no. 22, Block D, South City1, Gurugram, Harayana – Ex.CW1/5; & vi) Copy of bank account statement of deceased – Ex.CW1/6; vii) NOCs of R2 & R3 – Ex.CW1/7 & Ex.CW1/8 respectively. 7. Thereafter, PE was closed vide proceedings held on 28.02.2022. 8. I have heard the final arguments and carefully perused the record. SC No. 20/2021 Shashi Shobha Khorana Vs State & Ors. Page No. 3 of 6 -- 3 of 6 -- 9. Section 373 subsection (3) of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 provides: 'If the Judge cannot decide the right to the certificate without determining questions of law or fact which seem to be too intricate and difficult for determination in a summary proceedings, he may nevertheless grant a certificate to the petitioner if he appears to be the person having prima facie the best title thereto.' 10. Aforesaid provision, therefore, says that succession certificate has to be given by the Court on the basis of “primafacie best title”. Petitioner has to show that she has best title over the debts & Securities in question. Onus of proving the same, therefore, is not on the same platform as that of criminal law or civil law, it is less than that. So much, so even if there is a dispute with regard to the right of petitioner claiming succession certificate, then also it is the broad / primafacie title which has to be seen. This is precisely for the reason the as the rights of the parties are not to be determined by the Court issuing the succession certificate. 11. Section 370 (2) in The Indian Succession Act, 1925 defines the meaning of security, which reads as follows : “For the purposes of this Part, ‘security’ means — (a) any promissory note, debenture, stock or other security of the Central Government or of a State Government; (b) any bond, debenture, or annuity charged by Act of Parliament 1[of the United Kingdom] on the revenues of India; (c) any stock or debenture of, or share in, a company or other incorporated institution; SC No. 20/2021 Shashi Shobha Khorana Vs State & Ors. Page No. 4 of 6 -- 4 of 6 -- (d) any debenture or other security for money issued by, or on behalf of, a local authority; (e) any other security which the 2[State Government] may, by notification in the Official Gazette, declare to be a security for the purposes of this Part. 12. By way of present petition, one of the prayers of the petitioner is for grant of succession certificate for filing the Income Tax Returns for the property bearing Plot No. 222, BlockD, South City1, Gurugram, Haryana which was sold in the year 2018. The aforesaid security does not come within the meaning of Section 370 of Indian Succession Act. Hence, the said prayer is hereby declined for want of jurisdiction. 13. Further, perusal of Section 375 of Indian Succession Act shows that the imposition of a condition of security / surety / indemnity bond is in order to indemnify person (s) or safeguard the interest of such persons who may be entitled to the whole or any part of the debt and security. 14. Respondents / general public / legal representative of deceased in question did not raise any objection pertaining to present application, despite publication in newspapers. The respondent no.2 & 3 have stated in their NOC that they have no objection for issuance of succession certificate in favour of the petitioner. As per report of SDM (Dwarka), petitioner and respondent no.2 & 3 were the only surviving members of the deceased. 15. In view of above discussions, I find that there is no objection to the grant of succession certificate in favour of petitioner (classI legal heir / wife of deceased) in respect of Savings Bank Account No. 5048382004, Citi Bank, G & SC No. 20/2021 Shashi Shobha Khorana Vs State & Ors. Page No. 5 of 6 -- 5 of 6 -- 1st Floor, DLF Capitol Point, Baba Kharak Singh Marg, Connaught Place, New Delhi110001 held in the name of her deceased husband Late Sh. Satish Chander Khorana. Consequently, the present petition is partly allowed and succession certificate be issued to petitioner, on filing of requisite Court Fees of Rs.36,327/ only in terms of Article 12, Schedule I of the Court Fee Act, 1870 as applicable to Delhi along with an indemnity bond of the petitioner in a sum of Rs.18,16,350.89/. Since the petitioner is the ClassI legal heir of the deceased and other surviving members of the deceased i.e. respondent no.2 & 3 have already given their NOC, the condition of furnishing surety bond in the present case is waived in the present case. 15. File be consigned to Record Room after due compliance. Announced in the open Court on 27th day of April, 2022. (PREETI PAREWA) ACJ/CCJ/ARC, NDD, PHC NEW DELHI : 27.04.2022 SC No. 20/2021 Shashi Shobha Khorana Vs State & Ors. Page No. 6 of 6 -- 6 of 6 --
