Full Order Text
Final Order 18 · 25 Aug 2026 · CNR DLND030003572024
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: THE COURT OF MR. VAIBHAV PRATAP SINGH CIVIL JUDGE, PATIALA HOUSE COURTS NEW DELHI DISTRICT, DELHI CNR No. DLND030003572024 CS SCJ No. 174/2024 IN THE MATTER OF: RAJINDER SINGH S/o Late Sh. Bhala Singh Rio Property No. 92-J, Pratap Market Munirka, New Delhi-110067 Mob. No. 9313081266 . . . Plaintiff versus RAJ RANI JAIN Proprietor of Vardhman Home Collection Having its office at:- Shop No. 9, Property No. 92-J Pratap Market, Munirka New Delhi - 110067 Mob No.- 9871829910 . . .Defendant Date of Institution : 26.02.2024 Date of Reserving Judgment : 17.08.2026 Date of Judgment : 25.08.2026 Decision : Decreed CS SCJ No. 174/2024 Rajinder Singh vs. Raj Rani Jain Page No. 1 of 18 -- 1 of 18 -- SUIT FOR POSSESSION, ARREARS OF RENT AND MESNE PROFITS/DAMAGES ALONGWITH FUTURE AND PENDELITE INTEREST AND PERMANENT INJUNCTION) JUDGMENT PLAINT 1. The present suit is filed against Defendants, with the following prayers: “a) Pass a decree of possession/ejectment in favour of the Plaintiff and against the Defendant whereby directing the Defendant to vacate the suit property i.e. Shop No. 9, ground floor (including Mezzanine Floor) of the property No. 92-J, Pratap Market Munirka, New Delhi - 67 which is shown red in colour in the site plan, and hand over the vacant possession of the suit property of the Plaintiff. b) Pass a decree of recovery of Rs.1,15,000/- towards the arrears of rent and damage/mesne profit till filing the present suit whereby directing the Defendant to pay the said amount along with pendelite and future interest @ 18% per annum from the date of filing the present suit and till its realization to the Plaintiff and direct the Defendant to clear electricity and water dues. c) Pass a decree of recovery of damages/mesne profits @ Rs. 15,000/- per month w.e.f. 01.02.2024 in favour of the Plaintiff and against the Defendant whereby directing the Defendant to pay the said amount of damage/mesne profits to the Plaintiff till vacation of the suit property by the Defendant and handing over CS SCJ No. 174/2024 Rajinder Singh vs. Raj Rani Jain Page No. 2 of 18 -- 2 of 18 -- the vacant peaceful possession of the suit property to the Plaintiff or assess the said damages/mesne profits by conducting an enquiry under the provisions of Order XX Rule 12 CPC. d) Pass a decree of permanent injunction in favour of the Plaintiff and against the Defendant whereby restraining the Defendant, his agents, servants, etc from creating any third-party interest in the suit property or sublet the suit property. e) Award cost of the suit in favour of the Plaintiff and against the Defendant. f) Pass such other or further relief or order as this Hon'ble Court April deem fit and proper in the facts and circumstances of the present case, in favour of the Plaintiff and against the Defendant.” 2. Brief facts as alleged by the Plaintiff in the plaint are that the Plaintiff is the owner/landlord of property No. 92-J, Pratap Market, Munirka, New Delhi-110067 and the Defendant is a tenant in respect of Shop No. 9 on the ground floor (including Mezzanine Floor) admeasuring 294 sq. ft., forming part of the said property. 3. That the Defendant was inducted as a tenant in the year 1996 without execution of any written or registered lease deed and has been running business under the proprietorship firm M/s Vardhman Home Collection from the suit property. The tenancy was month-to-month commencing on the first day and ending on the last day of CS SCJ No. 174/2024 Rajinder Singh vs. Raj Rani Jain Page No. 3 of 18 -- 3 of 18 -- each English calendar month. 4. That the rent of the suit property was Rs. 6,500/- per month till December, 2018, Rs. 8,500/- per month from 01.01.2019 till December, 2020 and Rs. 11,500/- per month from 01.01.2021 onwards. The rent was regularly deposited by the Defendant directly into the Plaintiff's bank account and the last rent of Rs. 11,500/- was paid for the month of March, 2023. 5. That the Defendant has neither paid nor deposited any rent from April, 2023 onwards and is liable to pay arrears of rent @ Rs. 11,500/- per month for the period from April, 2023 to January, 2024 amounting to Rs. 1,15,000/- besides outstanding water and electricity charges. 6. That the Plaintiff bona fide requires the suit property for himself and his family members and, accordingly, orally terminated the Defendant's tenancy on 16.01.2024, calling upon the Defendant to vacate and hand over peaceful possession within 15 days, i.e., by 31.01.2024, but the Defendant failed to do so. 7. That the Plaintiff also informed the Defendant on 16.01.2024 that in case possession was not handed over within 15 days, the occupation of the suit property would become illegal and unauthorized and the Defendant would CS SCJ No. 174/2024 Rajinder Singh vs. Raj Rani Jain Page No. 4 of 18 -- 4 of 18 -- be liable to pay damages/mesne profits @ Rs. 15,000/- per month with effect from 01.02.2024. 8. That despite termination of the tenancy, the Defendant continues in illegal and unauthorized occupation of the suit property since 31.01.2024 and is liable to pay damages/mesne profits @ Rs. 15,000/- per month from 01.02.2024 till delivery of vacant possession. 9. That the Plaintiff has learnt that after termination of the tenancy, the Defendant is attempting to create third-party interest or sub-let the suit property through local property brokers and, unless restrained, the Plaintiff shall suffer irreparable loss and injury. WRITTEN STATEMENT OF DEFENDANT 10.Defendant filed a WS and took the stand that the suit is based on false, concocted and contradictory facts, filed without clean hands after suppressing material facts with the malafide intention of grabbing the Suit Property through frivolous litigation and is liable to be dismissed with exemplary costs. 11.That the Plaintiff's pleadings and documents are inconsistent and, despite having no ownership over the Suit Property, the Plaintiff has sought possession on the CS SCJ No. 174/2024 Rajinder Singh vs. Raj Rani Jain Page No. 5 of 18 -- 5 of 18 -- alleged ground of bona fide requirement by relying upon false facts and misusing the process of law. 12.That the Suit Property was taken on lease in the year 1966 by Late Sh. Ramniwas Jain, husband of the Defendant, from Late Sh. Pratap Singh Tokas after payment of pagri of Rs. 5,000/-, which was received by Late Sh. Pratap Singh Tokas in the presence and knowledge of his wife Smt. Rampyari. After the death of Late Sh. Pratap Singh Tokas in the year 1971, his legal heirs, including Smt. Rampyari and Sh. Yashveer, became owners of the Suit Property. 13.That after the death of Late Sh. Ramniwas Jain in the year 1982, the Defendant became tenant under Smt. Rampyari and Sh. Yashveer, who collected rent in cash and issued rent receipts. The Defendant has been running her business from the Suit Property, obtained Sales Tax registration in the year 1983 and a telephone connection in the year 1991. In the year 1986, at the request of Smt. Rampyari and Sh. Yashveer, the Defendant converted the tin shed into a concrete lanter and carried out improvements at her own expense, to be adjusted against future rent. 14.That subsequently, due to health issues and other preoccupations, Smt. Rampyari and Sh. Yashveer authorised Sh. Krishan Singh and the Plaintiff, who are brothers of Late Sh. Pratap Singh Tokas and uncles of Sh. CS SCJ No. 174/2024 Rajinder Singh vs. Raj Rani Jain Page No. 6 of 18 -- 6 of 18 -- Yashveer, to collect rent on their behalf. The Defendant accordingly paid rent to them, and the Plaintiff later collected rent by cheque only as an authorised collector and not as owner. 15.That on 10.10.2022 a massive fire damaged the Suit Property and destroyed the Defendant's goods, furniture, documents, bank records and rent receipts. The Plaintiff, on behalf of Smt. Rampyari and Sh. Yashveer, requested the Defendant to undertake repairs at her own expense, assuring adjustment of the expenditure against rent from April 2023. The Defendant spent approximately Rs. 2,03,000/- on repairs and renovation. 16.That in the second week of March 2023, the Plaintiff informed the Defendant that the monthly rent would stand enhanced from Rs. 11,500/- to Rs. 12,650/- with effect from April 2023 and that the repair expenditure would be adjusted against future rent. Accordingly, from April 2023 the Plaintiff adjusted the repair amount against rent at Rs. 12,650/- per month but failed to issue rent receipts despite repeated requests. No notice alleging non-payment of rent was ever served upon the Defendant. 17.That in the first week of March 2024, upon receiving the summons in the present Suit, the Defendant was shocked to learn that the Plaintiff, who is not the owner of the Suit Property, had filed the present Suit seeking possession, CS SCJ No. 174/2024 Rajinder Singh vs. Raj Rani Jain Page No. 7 of 18 -- 7 of 18 -- arrears of rent, mesne profits/damages, pendente lite interest and permanent injunction. 18.That the Plaintiff's allegation of oral termination of tenancy is false as the Plaintiff is neither the owner of the suit property nor authorised to terminate the tenancy, and no such oral termination ever took place. REPLICATION 19.Plaintiff filed replications to the WS of the Defendant wherein it denied the averments of the Defendant and reiterated the averments in the plaint. DECREE OF POSSESSION ON ADMISSIONS DATED 05.07.2025 20.While allowing the application under Order 12 Rule 6 CPC filed by the Plaintiff, this Court granted the decree of possession to the Plaintiff by its judgment dated 05.07.2025 and a part decree was directed to be drawn. The Regular First Appeal bearing no. RCA DJ 37/2025 titled “Raj Rani Jain vs. Rajinder Singh” was dismissed on merits by judgment dated 22.05.2026 by Learned DJ-04, PHC. CS SCJ No. 174/2024 Rajinder Singh vs. Raj Rani Jain Page No. 8 of 18 -- 8 of 18 -- ISSUES 21.On the basis of pleadings, for the remaining prayers, the following issues were framed on 05.07.2025. 21.1. Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to a decree in his favour and against the Defendant for arrears of rent in the amount of Rs. 1,15,000/- with interest @ 18% p.a. from date of filing of suit till realization? OPP 21.2. Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to a decree in his favour and against the Defendant for mesne profits @ Rs 15,000/ per month w.e.f. date of filing of suit till actual handing over of vacant possession of suit property? OPP 21.3. Relief, if any. PLAINTIFF’S EVIDENCE 22.Evidence was recorded by the Learned Local Commissioner. The Plaintiff examined himself as PW-1 and his evidence affidavit was exhibited as Ex.PW-1/A. Following documents have been proved by the said witness: 1. Bank Statements from 01.01.2017 till 31.12.2023 Ex.PW1/1 (colly) (page no. 23 to page no. 52 of the plaint). 23.PW-1 was duly cross-examined by Learned Counsel for Defendant. 24. No other witness was examined by the Plaintiff. CS SCJ No. 174/2024 Rajinder Singh vs. Raj Rani Jain Page No. 9 of 18 -- 9 of 18 -- DEFENCE EVIDENCE 25.Defendant examined herself as DW-01 and filed her evidence by way of affidavit Ex. D2W1/A. She relied on certain Photographs Ex.DW1/1 (colly). 26. DW-01 was cross-examined by Learned Counsel for Plaintiff. There being no other witnesses, DE was closed. FINAL ARGUMENTS 27.Final arguments were heard. I have gone through the record and I have heard Mr. Kartik Dabas, Learned Counsel for the Plaintiff and Mr. Arvind Saraswat, Learned Counsel for the Defendant. FINDINGS OF THE COURT ISSUE NO. 1: WHETHER THE PLAINTIFF IS ENTITLED TO A DECREE IN HIS FAVOUR AND AGAINST THE DEFENDANT FOR ARREARS OF RENT IN THE AMOUNT OF RS. 1,15,000/- WITH INTEREST @ 18% P.A. FROM DATE OF FILING OF SUIT TILL REALIZATION? OPP 28.Plaintiff has averred that the rent of the suit property was Rs. 11,500/- per month from 01.01.2021 onwards. The last rent paid by the Defendant directly into the account of the Plaintiff was for March, 2023. Plaintiff has thus claimed CS SCJ No. 174/2024 Rajinder Singh vs. Raj Rani Jain Page No. 10 of 18 -- 10 of 18 -- Rs.1,15,000/- as arrears of rent for the period April, 2023- January, 2024 till filing of the suit. 29.In the parawise reply, Defendant has denied the same as the Plaintiff is not the owner of the suit property and so the Defendant is not liable to pay arrears of rent or mesne profits. It is further averred that a fire took place in the suit property on 10.10.2022 and so huge damage was caused and the expenditure of Rs. 2,03,000/- to repair the same was incurred by the Defendant on the assurance of the Plaintiff to adjust the same toward future rent. The rest of the paragraph which runs into 4 pages in total again just talks about the Plaintiff not being the owner of the suit property. 30.In the evidence affidavit of DW-01, the same thing has been reiterated and certain photographs showing the damage in the suit property are exhibited as Ex.DW1/1 (colly). 31.In the WS in para-wise reply to para 13 of the plaint, the Defendant herself has admitted the last rent paid to be Rs. 11,500/-, which DW-01 also admits in her cross- examination dated 20.07.2026. 32.Merely filing a few photographs showing some damage due to fire is no proof of any such claim that the Defendant spent money on repairs or that the Plaintiff agreed to adjust CS SCJ No. 174/2024 Rajinder Singh vs. Raj Rani Jain Page No. 11 of 18 -- 11 of 18 -- it toward future rent. Even photographs of the premises after the repair are not filed. No evidence at all has been filed of the expenditure incurred by the Defendant by showing any invoices or other material or even examining the contractor/person who did the repairs. 33.Even if any such thing were done, and the Defendant were desirous of seeking a set-off of the payment, no such set- off has been pleaded within the meaning of Order 8 Rule 6 CPC. 34.In her cross-examination dated 20.07.2026, DW-01 categorically stated that it is correct that she has to pay rent from April, 2023 to February, 2024 @ Rs. 11,500/- per month. 35.In view of the clear admission noted above, the liability of the Defendant to pay arrears of rent is admitted and so this issue is decided in favour of the Plaintiff and against the Defendant. ISSUE NO. 2: WHETHER THE PLAINTIFF IS ENTITLED TO A DECREE IN HIS FAVOUR AND AGAINST THE DEFENDANT FOR MESNE PROFITS @ RS 15,000/- PER MONTH W.E.F. DATE OF FILING OF SUIT TILL ACTUAL HANDING OVER OF VACANT POSSESSION OF SUIT PROPERTY? OPP 36.Learned Counsel for the Plaintiff has argued that the Plaintiff is entitled to mesne profits as Defendant continued in unauthorized occupation of the suit property CS SCJ No. 174/2024 Rajinder Singh vs. Raj Rani Jain Page No. 12 of 18 -- 12 of 18 -- for several years. Reliance has been placed on judgment of Hon’ble Delhi High Court in Lalit Mohan Madhan vs. Life Insurance Corporation of India, 2012 SCC OnLine Del 1159 and Chander Kirti Rani Tandon vs. M/s VXL Lodging N. Boarding Services Pvt. Ltd., 2013 SCC OnLine Del 406 to argue that a Court is entitled to take judicial notice of the standard increase in urban rents and that a 15 % increase in the rent ought to be paid for calculating future mesne profits. 37.PW-1 deposed that the current market rent in the area for a similar property is at least INR 15,000/- per month. No neighboring rent agreements were proved in his own examination as PW-01. However, during cross- examination of DW-01, she was confronted by the Plaintiff with lease agreement dated 01.07.2009 Mark A which is stated to pertain to property bearing no. 92 J, First Floor, Admeasuring 320 sq. feet, situated in the same building as the suit property. It is stated to be fetching a rent of Rs. 15,000/- per month. The document was objected to by Learned Counsel for the Defendant as to mode of proof. 38.The document Mark A lease agreement dated 01.07.2009 is barely readable and appears to be a printout of a photograph clicked of a document. It is neither primary nor secondary evidence nor has been proved by PW-01 in his own evidence. The objection of Defendant is accordingly allowed and lease agreement dated 01.07.2009 Mark A is CS SCJ No. 174/2024 Rajinder Singh vs. Raj Rani Jain Page No. 13 of 18 -- 13 of 18 -- held not to be proved and is eschewed from consideration. 39.Defendant, on the other hand, has, apart from a bald denial that the suit property is not capable of fetching rent of Rs. 15,000/- per month, neither led any evidence to the contrary nor produced any evidence to establish the prevailing rent for similar properties in the locality. 40.In any case, the last rent paid in 2023 admittedly is Rs.11,500/- per month and the Defendant herself in the WS has mentioned that it was increased to Rs. 12,650/- from April, 2023, though not paid by her. 41.Atma Ram Properties (P) Ltd. vs. Federal Motors (P) Ltd., (2005) 1 SCC 705 held that a tenant continuing in possession after termination cannot continue at old rent and must compensate the landlord at market rate. 42.For mesne profits to be awarded, the Hon’ble Delhi High Court in Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd. v. Mohanjit Singh (Deceased) Through Legal Heirs, 2019:DHC:3719 held: “32. . . . A common vein of these judgments is that mesne profits, which a landlord is entitled to receive from a tenant who is continuously in occupation of the lease property despite the termination of the lease, has been laid down to mean the rate of rent which would otherwise accrue on a suit premises during the period of its illegal occupation by a tenant. However, the burden which the Courts are often tasked with is to determine the appropriate amount payable to the landlord/owner CS SCJ No. 174/2024 Rajinder Singh vs. Raj Rani Jain Page No. 14 of 18 -- 14 of 18 -- towards such mesne profits. This process of determination of mesne profits begins with the landlord discharging the onus placed upon him to prove his claim for mesne profits, in accordance with the law. Thereafter, it is for the Court to ascertain the appropriate mesne profits to be awarded to the claimant by adhering to the parameters as set out in Order XX Rule 12 CPC which prescribes that while passing the decree for possession, the Court may either straightaway pass a decree for mesne profits or direct that an inquiry be conducted for assessing the rate of mesne profits payable. If the Court finds that there is sufficient and authentic evidence available on record for determination of the landlord’s claim for mesne profits, the Court may, in its discretion, award the same by relying on such evidence. In the alternative, in situations when the Court finds that the evidence brought on record is not sufficient for such determination, the Court may direct that an inquiry be conducted thereto, in accordance with the provisions of the CPC. 39. In the light of the above discussion, I am unable to appreciate the appellant’s plea that there was no evidence in support of the respondent’s claim for mesne profits. In my view, when evidence of the respondent/witness, in the form of his statement by way of an Affidavit, had been tendered and the same remained uncontroverted, the appellant’s plea that no evidence had been led before the Court to justify the grant of mesne profits at the rate of Rs.2,00,000/- p.m. is without any merit.” 46. I may now turn to the last submission of the appellant that the grant of interest on mesne profits was unjustified. This submission needs to be noted only to be rejected. In the face of the settled proposition of law that interest forms an integral part of the mesne profits and, therefore, once the Court awards mesne profits, the interest accruing thereon has to be allowed in the computation of the mesne profits itself. A tenant cannot be permitted to urge that mesne profits which in fact ought to have been paid years ago, should not bear any interest…. 47. In the present case the trial Court, in its discretion, has awarded simple interest only @ 6% per annum towards the arrears of mesne profits. In the facts of the present case, where the appellant has successfully resisted the respondent’s claim to get possession of his CS SCJ No. 174/2024 Rajinder Singh vs. Raj Rani Jain Page No. 15 of 18 -- 15 of 18 -- property for nineteen years even after filing the suit for possession and that too when the respondent’s title to the same is undisputed, the grant of interest @ 6% per annum can neither be termed as arbitrary nor exorbitant. In my view, such interest upon mesne profits is not only fair and reasonable, but was fully justified to meet the ends of justice. Thus, I do not find any reason to interfere even with this direction of the trial Court.” (emphasis supplied) 43.Thus, rate of rent mentioned by a witness in evidence affidavit, unless countered with contrary evidence, is sufficient to grant mesne profits at that rate, if it does not otherwise seem unreasonable to the Court. 44.Accordingly, as discussed above, there is sufficient evidence on record to award mesne profits and need is not felt for an inquiry under Order 20 Rule 12 CPC. 45.Since even as per the Defendant the rent in April 2023 was Rs. 12,650/- and the Plaintiff has sought Rs.15,000/- per month as mesne profits and the suit has remained pending for two years and possession is still not handed over, there is no reason to deny the Plaintiff mesne profits @ Rs. 15,000/- per month, as prayed for. This is in keeping with Chander Kirti Rani Tandon (supra) as well, as relied on by the Plaintiff. 46.Thus, the Plaintiff is found to be entitled to damages/mesne profits to be paid by the Defendant in the amount of Rs. 15,000/- per month from the date of filing of CS SCJ No. 174/2024 Rajinder Singh vs. Raj Rani Jain Page No. 16 of 18 -- 16 of 18 -- the suit till the date of actually handing over the vacant possession of the suit property to the Plaintiff. 47.This issue is accordingly decided in favour of the Plaintiff and against the Defendant. CONCLUSION 48.In view of the above discussion, the suit of the Plaintiff is decreed as follows: 49.Decree of arrears of rent is passed in favour of the Plaintiff and against the Defendant in the amount of Rs. 1,15,000/- with pendente lite rate of simple interest @ 6% per annum from the date of institution of the suit till the date of decree, and future interest @ 6% per annum from date of decree till the date of realization of the amount. 50.Decree for mesne profits is passed in favour of the Plaintiff and against the Defendant @ Rs. 15,000/- per month from the date of institution of suit i.e. 26.02.2024 till actual handing over of vacant possession of the suit property to the Plaintiff. Simple interest @ 6% per annum shall be paid on the mesne profits from the date of filing of the suit till realization; and 51.The cost of the suit is also awarded in favour of the CS SCJ No. 174/2024 Rajinder Singh vs. Raj Rani Jain Page No. 17 of 18 -- 17 of 18 -- Plaintiff and against the Defendant. Plaintiff is directed to file a memorandum of costs for the decree. 52. Decree sheet be prepared accordingly. 53. File be consigned to Record Room, after due compliance, as per rules. Pronounced by me in the Open Court on 25.08.2026. (VAIBHAV PRATAP SINGH) Civil Judge, Patiala House Courts New Delhi District, Delhi CS SCJ No. 174/2024 Rajinder Singh vs. Raj Rani Jain Page No. 18 of 18 -- 18 of 18 --
