Full Order Text
Interim Order 19 · 17 Feb 2026 · CNR DLND030002832022
Order Details: COPY OF JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS Pdf Text: 24 CS SCJ 137/22 RAM AVTAR SHARMA Vs. RAHUL SHARMA 17.02.2026 Present: Sh. Rahul Khanna, Counsel for plaintiff. Sh. Suresh Sisodia, Counsel for defendant no.1 and 2. Perusal of record shows that 03 applications are pending for disposal i.e. (i) application under Order 26 Rule 9 CPC filed on behalf of defendant no.1; (ii) application under Order 39 Rule 4 CPC filed on behalf of defendant no.1 for setting aside interim order dated 14.10.2022; and (iii) application under Section 151 CPC on behalf of the plaintiff for taking on record replies to the aforesaid two applications e-filed on 24.01.2025. Since application u/s 151 CPC pertains to the replies of the previous two applications, the said application is taken up first for disposal. As per para 3 of the application, it has been stated that plaintiff is an old-age person and was in extreme grief after the death of his son and therefore, wants to file the reply. It is also averred in the application that though on 19.09.2024, the associate counsel of the plaintiff stated that the plaintiff does not wish to file reply, on which, right to file reply was closed, the replies were subsequently e-filed on 24.01.2025. Counsel for defendants has opposed the said application stating that mockery of the court is being made and the sole purpose is to delay the proceedings. 19.09.2024, the reply had been filed. Submissions heard. Record perused. Perusal of record shows that the applications had been filed on 13.03.2024. Despite grant of time, on the said date and on 24.05.2024, when no reply had been filed on behalf of the plaintiff on the third date as well, thereafter, query had been made to the counsel for plaintiff who stated in the presence of the plaintiff that the plaintiff does not wish to file any reply. Accordingly, considering the said conduct, as no reply had been filed on three dates, the right to file reply was closed. Subsequently, when the matter was listed for arguments on 25.01.2025, without either seeking the leave of the court nor any intimation that any reply has been e- filed on 24.01.2025, the plaintiff kept mum about it on 25.01.2025, 29.05.2025, 02.09.2025. It was only on the last date of hearing i.e. -- 1 of 2 -- 05.01.2026 when the arguments were to be heard that the plaintiff brought forward the copies of the replies and stated that the reply has already been e- filed despite being aware of the fact that the right to file reply was closed on 19.09.2024. Considering the said conduct, plaintiff is not entitled to the equitable relief u/s 151 CPC as he is guilty of dilatory tactics as well as concealment. Accordingly, application u/s 151 CPC stands dismissed and the replies are not taken on record. At this stage, counsel for defendants has submitted that he would be firstly pressing his application under Order 26 Rule 9 CPC. However, counsel for plaintiff seeks time to take instructions from the main counsel in this regard. Perusal of record shows that the matter was specifically fixed for arguments on the aforesaid applications and despite that, counsel has appeared without any proper instructions to assist the court. Recently, Hon’ble Delhi High Court in Priya Khurana vs Arpit Chadda in its order dated 29.01.2026 bearing CM APPL No. 64072/24 observed that in accordance with the framework of Advocates Act, 1961, a proxy counsel, who is unaware of the facts of the case cannot meaningfully assist the court. A counsel therefore who enters appearance is expected to be aware, at the very least, of the prima facie case and the stage of proceedings. In these circumstances, in the interest of justice, subject to a cost of Rs. 2,000/- to be paid to the defendants, one final opportunity is given to the plaintiff to advance arguments on the aforesaid applications. Since defendant has pressed firstly his application under Order 26 Rule 9 CPC, list for arguments on the said application on 13.03.2026. Sh. Rupinder Singh Dhiman ACJ/CCJ/ARC, NDD, PHC New Delhi :17.02.2026 -- 2 of 2 --
