Full Order Text
Final Order 4 · 04 Sept 2025 · CNR DLND030002712025
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: CS SCJ 163/25 SINDHI COUNCIL OF INDIA VS. SHRAVAN KUMAR 04.09.2025 Present: Ms. Swastika, Ld counsel for plaintiff. Ms. Gyanpreet Kaur, Ld. counsel for defendant. No WS has been filed by defendant till date. Further, time for filing the same has already elapsed. Heard both the parties. Record perused. Put up for further proceedings at 03.00 pm. Ashwani Panwar ACJ/CCJ/ARC, NDD, PHC New Delhi :04.09.2025 At 03.00 pm Present: None. ORDER 1. The present suit has been filed by the Plaintiff no.1, Sindhi Council of India, which is a Society registered Under Societies Registration Act, 1860 & the Plaintiff no.2 Sh. Suresh A. Keshwani, who is the founding president as well as the honorary member of the Plaintiff no.1, against the defendant Sh. Shravan Kumar, seeking a decree of permanent & mandatory injunction restraining the defendant from misrepresenting himself as the National President of Plaintiff no.1 organization & from misusing the name/photograph of plaintiff no. 2 in unauthorized communication, publication & meetings. 1 Of 5 -- 1 of 5 -- 2. It is averred that the Defendant was appointed as National President of Plaintiff no.1 on 17.05.2023, however due to his inability to discharge his functions properly & in view of the multiple complaints received against him, the Governing Body of Plaintiff no.1, in its AGM held on 16.06.2024, by way of special resolution removed the defendant from his post & the removal was also conveyed to him on 18.06.2024. 3. It is further stated that despite removal, defendant deliberately continued to misrepresent himself as the National President of Plaintiff no.1 & circulated messages to the members & portrayed himself as the President & also misused name as well as the photograph of Plaintiff no.2, thus misleading members of the community & public at large. Legal notice was sent to the defendant. Same was not replied to, hence the present suit. 4. Summons of the suit were issued, served upon the defendant. Defendant entered appearance on 08.05.2025 through his counsel, Fresh vakalatnama was filed, however no WS was filed. Thereafter again fresh vakalatnama was filed on behalf of the defendant on the NDOH i.e. 24.07.2025, however again no WS was filed and matter was adjourned for today. 4.1 Today again defendant failed to file WS and it was submitted by the Ld. Counsel appearing for the defendant that they have failed to file WS as they have been recently engaged in the present matter. The 2 Of 5 -- 2 of 5 -- said submission made by Ld. Counsel Ms. Gyanpreet Kaur do not inspire the confidence of this Court as her appearance was duly recorded on the previous ordersheet dated 24.07.2025. It appears that the defendant is deliberately delaying the present matter and intentionally not filing the WS. Since no WS has been filed by the defendant & the permissible statutory period has also expired, this Court is proceeding further in the present matter. 5. Order VIII Rule 10 CPC empowers the Court to pronounce judgment where any party fails to present a written statement as required Under Order VIII Rule 1 CPC. 6. The Plaintiffs to prove their case have relied upon Annexure A i.e. Registration Certificate as well as the Memorandum of Association of the plaintiff no. 1 Council, Annexure B i.e. Resolution dated 16.06.2024 showing removal of the Defendant from the office of President of Plaintiff no.1, Annexure C i.e. Communication of removal to the Defendant, legal notice sent to the defendant dated 04.01.2025 & the copies of misleading posters. 7. The pleadings as well as the documents relied upon by the Plaintiffs have not been challenged despite multiple opportunities to the defendant by the Court & the same shows that despite removal of the defendant he is continuing to misrepresent himself as the National 3 Of 5 -- 3 of 5 -- President of Plaintiff no.1, misusing the identity of Plaintiff no.2 as shown in Annexure G relied upon by the Plaintiff & further misleading the public at large as well as the members of the Community in Particular. 8. In exercise of powers U/o 8 Rule 10 CPC, considering the uncontroverted material placed on record, the conduct of the Defendant as well as taking into consideration all the facts & circumstances of the present matter, the present suit deserves to be decreed in favour of the plaintiffs and against the defendant. 8.1 Accordingly, the defendant is permanently restrained from using the title or representing himself as the National President of Plaintiff no.1 Council or misrepresenting himself as holding the position of National President in Plaintiff no.1 Council. 8.2 The defendant is further directed to remove all the misleading posters, social media posts and unauthorised communication claiming himself to be the National President of Plaintiff no.1 Council or where he has used the identity of Plaintiff no.2 without his consent. 8.3 Further, prayer (b) for directing the defendant to issue public apology stands declined, as the purpose of the suit stands served, in view of the reliefs granted to the Plaintiffs. 4 Of 5 -- 4 of 5 -- No order as to costs. Decree sheet be drawn accordingly. 9. File be consigned to record room after due compliance. Announced in open Court today Ashwani Panwar ACJ/CCJ/ARC, NDD, PHC New Delhi :04.09.2025 5 Of 5 -- 5 of 5 --
