Full Order Text
Interim Order 18 · 25 May 2026 · CNR DLND030000522022
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: CS SCJ 55/22 PREM PRAKASH FRANDSEN Vs. STATE BANK OF INDIA 25.05.2026 Present: None. 1. Matter is pending for order on application under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC filed on behalf of the defendant. 2. Briefly stated, it is the case of the plaintiffs that plaintiffs no 1 & 4 are the brothers of the deceased Asha and plaintiffs no 2, 3 & 5 are the sisters of the deceased Asha. It is further averred that the deceased, who expired on 13.10.2021, was unmarried and therefore, the plaintiffs are entitled to the properties of the deceased. However, it is stated that a person, namely Dilawar S Saini, is wrongfully claiming himself to be the husband of the deceased. Therefore, it is prayed that an injunction may be granted in favour of the plaintiffs, restraining the defendant from releasing the amount in account no. 10819017681 in the name of the deceased, along with any goods, if any, in the locker linked to the account. 3. While the matter was at the stage of PE, defendant filed the present application under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC. It is contended on behalf of the defendant that the plaint is liable to be rejected. It is stated that the plaintiffs have not filed any document to show that they are related to the deceased. It is also stated that the plaintiffs have not mentioned their parentage to show that they are related to the deceased. Further, it is stated that plaintiff no. 1, on 23.04.2025, stated before the court that the plaintiffs are the non-biological siblings of the deceased and, therefore, they are not the brothers and sisters of the deceased. It is also stated that no locker is linked to the The digital key of the undersigned has expired and therefore, order-sheets have been uploaded without digital signatures. -- 1 of 5 -- impugned bank account. It is further stated that the plaintiffs have not disclosed that, as nominees of other accounts of the deceased, they have already received proceeds from those accounts. Hence, it is prayed that the plaintiffs have no locus to file the present suit and therefore, the plaint does not disclose any cause of action. It is also contended that Dilawar has not been impleaded and therefore the suit is bad for non-joinder of a necessary party. 4. Per contra, it is contended that the application is misconceived. It is stated that the plaintiffs have not suppressed any fact and have fairly disclosed on 23.04.2025 that, due to a long-standing familial bond, the deceased treated the plaintiffs as brothers and sisters. Even otherwise, it is stated that the plaintiffs, being the nominees of the said account, have the right to file the present suit. Accordingly, it is prayed that the application be dismissed as not maintainable. 5. I have heard the arguments and perused the record. At the outset, the law about Order 7 Rule 11 as laid down by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the case of “Saleem Bhai & Ors. Vs. State of Maharashtra & Ors.”, in Appeal (Civil) No. 8518 of 2002, is to be noted wherein it was laid down that the relevant facts which need to be investigated for deciding an application under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC are the averments in the plaint. In light of the law mentioned above, only the averments of the petition and the annexed documents are to be considered in deciding any application under Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC. In the light of said principle of law, I proceed to consider the contentions of the parties. 6. In the present matter, plaintiffs have specifically averred that the plaintiffs, being legal heirs of the deceased, are entitled to the amount lying in the impugned bank The digital key of the undersigned has expired and therefore, order-sheets have been uploaded without digital signatures. -- 2 of 5 -- account of the deceased and that, Dilawar is falsely alleging himself to be the husband of the deceased whereas deceased was unmarried. Therefore, bare reading of the plaint shows cause of action in favour of the plaintiffs. As far as contention is concerned that the Dilawar was a necessary party but has not been impleaded, it is pertinent to note that the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Prem Lala Nahata & Anr. vs. Chandi Prasad Sikaria AIR 2007 SC 1247, while clarifying that the defect of misjoinder of parties and cause of action is a defect that can be waived and cannot be a ground for rejection of plaint under Order VII Rule 11 of CPC has held that such misjoinder does not render the suit barred by law. 7. Further, with respect to Order 7 Rule 11(a) CPC, it is trite to state that the cause of action is a bundle of facts which taken with the law applicable to them, gives the plaintiff a right to claim against the defendant. For the purposes of consideration of the issues as to whether the plaint discloses any cause of action or not, all the pleadings in the plaint have to be treated as correct, and the defense has not to be looked into. The plaint had to be read meaningfully. A distinction must always be drawn between a plea that plaint does not disclose a cause of action and the plea that the plaintiff has no cause of action to sue. The grounds on which the plaint can be rejected are enumerated in Clauses (a) to (d) of Rule 11 of Order 7, CPC. The first ground on which plaint can be rejected is that it does not disclose a cause of action. While considering the prayer to reject the plaint on ground (a) of Order 7, Rule 11, CPC that the plaint discloses no cause of action, which is essentially a demurrer, the defendant must be taken to admit for the sake of argument that the allegations of the plaintiff in the plaint are true in manner and form. The power to reject the plaint on this can be exercised only if the Court concludes that even if all the allegations are taken to be proved, the plaintiff would not be entitled to any relief The digital key of the undersigned has expired and therefore, order-sheets have been uploaded without digital signatures. -- 3 of 5 -- whatsoever. A distinction must always be drawn between a case where the plaint on the face of it discloses no cause of action and another in which, after considering the entire material on the record, the Court comes to the conclusion that there is no cause of action. In the first case, the plaint can be rejected, but in the latter case, the plaint cannot be rejected. The suit has to be dismissed. No doubt that where the plaint is based on a document, the Court will be entitled to consider the said document also and ascertain if a cause of action is disclosed in the plaint, but the validity of the document cannot be considered at this stage. To enable a Court to reject a plaint on the ground that it does not disclose a cause of action, it should look at the plaint and documents accompanying the plaint only and nothing else. The Court, however, cannot look at the defence of the defendant or the documents relied upon by the defendant. The effect of dismissal of the suit is altogether different and distinct from the effect of rejection of the plaint. In case the plaint is rejected under Order 7 Rule 11, CPC, filing of a fresh plaint in respect of the same cause of action is specifically permitted under Rule 13 of Order 7, CPC. Altogether different consequences follow in the event of dismissal of the suit, which has the effect of precluding the plaintiff from filing a fresh suit on the same cause of action. Rejection of the plaint takes away the very basis of the suit, rendering it as if there was no suit at all or that no suit was instituted. The order of dismissal of a suit, while recognizing the existence of a suit, indicates its termination. While deciding the application under Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC, the bare allegation made in the plaint and the documents filed therewith are required to be investigated. 8. In the instant case, bare reading of the plaint shows that specific averment has been made that the plaintiffs being legal heirs of the deceased are entitled to amount in the impugned bank account of the deceased and therefore, clearly disclosed at least a cause of action against the defendant for the defendant to be restrained to release the amount to any other person. It would be an altogether different situation if the plaintiffs The digital key of the undersigned has expired and therefore, order-sheets have been uploaded without digital signatures. -- 4 of 5 -- might not ultimately succeed in obtaining a decree against the defendant in view of subsequent statements made on 23.04.2025 that the plaintiffs are not the real brothers and sisters of the deceased. The issues in the present case have already been framed on 24.05.2023. The submission made on 23.04.2025 regarding their non-relation to the deceased is a fact to be considered for the appreciation of evidence for determining whether any right exists in favour of the plaintiffs to claim the equitable relief of an injunction or not. 9. Accordingly, in view of the aforesaid discussion and findings, the application stands dismissed. 10. Relist for PE on 16.09.2026. (Rupinder Singh Dhiman) ACJ/CCJ/ARC, NDD, PHC New Delhi :25.05.2026 The digital key of the undersigned has expired and therefore, order-sheets have been uploaded without digital signatures. -- 5 of 5 --
