Full Order Text
Final Order 12 · 23 Dec 2025 · CNR DLND020297422024
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF MS. CHARAN SALWAN Judicial Magistrate First Class-01: New Delhi District Patiala House Courts, New Delhi FIR No. 236/2023 P.S.: Vansant Kunj (South) Under Section: 332, 461 & 466A of DMC Act And Section 188 of IPC State Vs. Rajeev Yadav S/o Sh. Ranjeet Yadav R/o Farm No. 7. Grand Westend Green, Rajokari New Delhi-110070. (a) Sr. No. of the case : 3994/2024 (b) The name of the complainant : Deputy Commissioner (c) The plea of the accused : Pleaded not guilty (d) Arguments heard on : 19.12.2025 (e) The date of order : 23.12.2025 (f) The final order : ACQUITTED J U D G M E N T 1. Vide this Judgment, I shall dispose of the case of the prosecution against the accused person, namely, Rajeev Yadav for the commission of offence under Section 332 read with Section 461 of the Delhi Municipal Corporation Act, 1957 (hereinafter referred to as ‘DMC Act’) and offence u/s 188 of the Indian Penal Code’1860 ( hereinafter referred to as ‘IPC’). 2. Briefly stated, it is the case of the prosecution that on 19.01.2023 during official routine inspection within the jurisdiction of Police Station Vasant Kunj (South), it was noticed by the then Junior Engineer, Building Department, South Delhi Municipal Corporation, South Zone, Green Park, New Delhi that the owner/builder/occupier of property/Farm No. 9-A, Grand Western, Rajokari Village, Vasant Kunj, New Delhi, had carried out unauthorized construction work in the shape of First Floor in continuation of previous FIR No.236/2023 State Vs. Rajeev Yadav Page No. 1 of 10 -- 1 of 10 -- booking No. 515/UC/B-II/SZ/22 dated 12.09.2022 and the unauthorized construction has been booked vide File No. 98/UC/B-11/SZ/2023 dated 19.01.2023 as the accused carried out construction without permission of the Commissioner, MCD. Subsequently, the concerned Deputy Commissioner, South Delhi Municipal Corporation, South Zone, Green Park, New Delhi had initiated action under Sections 332, 343 & 344 of the DMC Act. 3. Upon receiving complaint from the concerned Deputy Commissioner, South Delhi Municipal Corporation, the present FIR was registered at P.S. Vasant Kunj (South) as the offence was cognizable in nature. After registration of FIR, investigation was launched and upon completion of investigation charge sheet was filed. Consequently, accused was summoned after taking cognizance of offence. Copy of the chargesheet and accompanying documents were provided to the accused. Thereafter, notice of the offence of was framed upon the accused person for the commission of offences of u/s 332 r/w 461 of DMC Act and u/s 188 of IPC to which the accused pleaded not guilty and claimed trial. 4. Thereafter, the matter was listed for Prosecution Evidence wherein the prosecution examined two witnesses: (i) Raghavendra Pratap Singh, presently posted as JE, at M-1, Civil Lines Zone, Delhi as PW-1 (ii) HC Vishwajeet, presently posted at PS Vasant Kunj South as PW-2 5. PW-1 Sh. Raghavendra Pratap Singh, Junior Engineer at M-1, Civil Lines Zone, Delhi, deposed that on 19.01.2023, he was posted as Junior Engineer in South Zone, Delhi and during an inspection he found out that the alleged property i.e. Farm No. 9A, Grand Western, Village Rajokari, Vasant Kunj, New Delhi, was already constructed in violation of the DMC Act. He prepared the First Information Report (Ex. PW1/A) and forwarded the FIR No.236/2023 State Vs. Rajeev Yadav Page No. 2 of 10 -- 2 of 10 -- complaint to the concerned AE. He further deposed that on 10.04.2024, the IO called him to join the investigation and accordingly, he went to the PS and alongwith the IO visited the alleged property i.e. Farm No. 9A, Grand Westend Village Rajokari, Vasant Kunj, New Delhi. He deposed that site plan was prepared at his instance (Ex. PW1/B) and the IO recorded his statement. 6. In his Cross-examination, he stated that he used to visit the area under his jurisdiction weekly. He stated that prior to 19.01.2023, he did not inspect the concerned area. He stated that he does not remember whether he clicked the photographs of the unauthorized construction. The witness stated that he did not submit the documents of the previous booking made on the property. He stated that he had perused the previous booking file. He stated that he did not remember the extent of the previous unauthorized construction for which earlier offence was registered with the DC. 7. PW-1 was recalled for examination on the prayer of the Ld. APP for the State, whereby PW-1 exhibited the show cause notice (Ex. PW-1/C), demolition notice (Ex. PW-1/D), and unauthorized construction file (Ex. D-1). The Ld. Counsel of the accused has raised objection with respect to non- supplying of the photographs to the accused. The witness was duly cross- examined by the Ld. Counsel for the accused wherein he admitted that in the photographs, particulars of the property are not visible. 8. Thereafter, PW-2 HC Vishwajeet (IO of the case) was examined who deposed that in March, 2024, he was posted as HC in PS Vasant Kunj South and the present file was marked to him for further investigation. He deposed that on 10.04.2024, he alongwith JE went to the spot and prepared the site plan on the instance of JE (Ex. PW-1/A). He further deposed that notice u/s 41-A Cr.P.C was supplied to the accused (Ex. PW-2/A), and Pabandinama (Ex. FIR No.236/2023 State Vs. Rajeev Yadav Page No. 3 of 10 -- 3 of 10 -- PW-2/B) was given to the accused. He deposed that notice u/s 160 Cr.P.C was given to the MCD, South, Green Park for identification of property in question (Ex. PW-2/C). He deposed that Interrogation report (Ex. PW-2/D) was prepared and statement of witnesses were recorded. He deposed that Charge sheet was prepared and filed before the Court. PW-2 has correctly identified the accused. 9. The PW-2 was duly cross-examined by Ld. Counsel for the accused. In his cross-examination, the witness stated that when he got the file no statement u/s 161 Cr.P.C was recorded. He admitted that he did not see the original file pertaining to unauthorized construction or sealing. 10. Thereafter, Statement of accused was recorded under section 294 Cr.P.C vide which he admitted the statements made under section 161 Cr.PC of PWs namely ASI Shri Kishan (Ex. A-1), DC Angel Bhati Chauhan (Ex. A-2), HC Ravinder (Ex. A-3) and HC Anuj Kumar (Ex. A-4). Accordingly, examination of above-mentioned witnesses was dispensed with. 11. On completion of prosecution evidence, statement of accused was recorded u/s 281 Cr.P.C r/w 313 Cr.P.C, wherein all the incriminating evidence was put to the accused, to which he stated that he has been falsely implicated in this case. He stated that the prosecution witnesses have deposed against him as they are official witnesses and with a view to get success in their case, they deposed falsely. Further, the accused has opted not to lead DE. 12. Final arguments heard. Case file perused. 13. Short point for determination before this court is as under: ''Whether on 19.01.2023 the accused initiated/raised/carried out and continued unauthorized construction work in the shape of First Floor in FIR No.236/2023 State Vs. Rajeev Yadav Page No. 4 of 10 -- 4 of 10 -- the property Farm No.9 A, Grand Westend Green, Rajokari, New Delhi in continuation of previous booking No. 515/UC/B-II/SZ/2022 dated 12.09.2022 (structurally completed) without seeking any prior written permission from the concerned Deputy Commissioner, South Delhi Municipal Corporation, South Zone, Green Park, New Delhi.” 14. It is argued by the Ld. APP for the State that the ocular and the documentary evidence on record has proved the prosecution case beyond reasonable doubt. Ld. APP for the state submitted that there is sufficient material available on record to convict the accused and hence prayed for conviction of accused as per the evidence produced by the prosecution witnesses. 15. It is argued by the Ld. Counsel for the accused that the accused is innocent and is falsely implicated in the present matter. The Ld. Counsel for the accused has essentially made two arguments. Firstly, it is argued that the investigation conducted is not proper and has many discrepancies and secondly, the chargesheet was filed beyond the period of limitation and the accused cannot be punished as per provisions of Section 471 of DMC Act and hence, he liable to be acquitted from all charges. 16. Before appreciating the evidence in hand, it is important to go through the relevant provision of the Act: “332. Prohibition of building without sanction: - No person shall erect or commence to erect any building or execute any of the works specified in section 334 except with the previous sanction of the Commissioner, not otherwise than in accordance with the provisions of this Chapter and of the bye-laws made under this Act in relation to the erection of buildings or execution of works.” “461. Punishment for certain offences: (1) Whoever— (a) contravenes any FIR No.236/2023 State Vs. Rajeev Yadav Page No. 5 of 10 -- 5 of 10 -- provision of any of the sections, sub-sections, clauses, provisos, or other provisions of this Act mentioned in the first column of the Table in the Twelfth Schedule; or (b) fails to comply with any order or direction lawfully given to him or any requisition lawfully made upon him under any of the said sections, sub-sections, clauses, provisos or other provisions, shall be punishable— (i) with fine which may extend to the amount, or with imprisonment for a term which may extend to the period, specified in that behalf in the third column of the said Table or with both; and (ii) in the case of a continuing contravention or failure, with an additional fine which may extend to the amount specified in the fourth column of that Table for every day during which such contravention or failure continues after conviction for the first such contravention or failure. (2) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section (1), whoever contravenes the provisions of subsection (1) of section 317 or sub-section (1) of section 320 or sub-section (1) of section 321 or subsection (1) of section 325 or section 339, in relation to any street which is a public street, shall be punishable with simple imprisonment which may extend to six months or with fine which may extend to five thousand rupees or with both.” 17. Section 332 lays down that no person shall erect or commence to erect any building except with the previous sanction of the Commissioner, or otherwise than in accordance with provisions of Chapter XVI and of the bye- law make under the Act in relation to the erection of buildings. The MCD has been empowered to discourage, prevent and stop illegal and unauthorized building and construction activities under Sections 343,344,345,345-A,346 and 347 of the Act to demolish and stop the building work, require alteration or work and seal unauthorized construction. 18. Further, it is clear from a plain reading of Section 332 of the Act that in order that a person may be proved guilty of having committed the offence FIR No.236/2023 State Vs. Rajeev Yadav Page No. 6 of 10 -- 6 of 10 -- mentioned therein, the prosecution will have to prove that such person either “erected” or “commenced to erect” any building or any works without previous sanction or in a manner not authorized by the Act. Further, what is critical is that the person who is sought to be bound guilty should himself have either erected or commenced to erect the unauthorized construction. The mere presence of a person at the spot may not satisfy this requirement. This Court places its reliance on MCD vs Prakash, 148 (2008) Delhi Law Times 587. 19. The case of the prosecution is that the accused Rajeev Yadav, being in the capacity of builder/owner of the property in question i.e. Farm No. 9-A, Grand Westend, Rajokari Village, Vasant Kunj, New Delhi had carried out unauthorized construction in the shape of First Floor in continuance of previous booking No. 515/UC/B-II/SZ/22 without any sanction from concerned Commissioner of DMC. 20. In this regard, the prosecution has examined the investigating officer, PW-2 Sh. Vishwajeet, who deposed that on 10.04.2024, he and the JE went to the spot and prepared site plan on the instance of JE (Ex. PW-1/A). He further deposed that notice was given to the accused u/s 41-A Cr.P.C (Ex. PW-2/A) and Pabandinama was prepared (Ex. PW-2/B). He further deposed that notice u/s 160 Cr.P.C was given to MCD, South, for identification of property (Ex. PW-2/C and Interrogation report was prepared (Ex. PW-2/D). The prosecution has also examined PW-1, Sh. Raghavendra Pratap Singh, who deposed that on 19.01.2023 he found out the alleged property i.e., Farm No. 9 A, Grand Westend, Village Rajokari, Vasant Kunj, New Delhi was already constructed in violation of the DMC Act. He further deposed that he on 10.04.2024, he joined the investigation with the IO and prepared site plan Ex. PW-1/B. 21. It is argued by the Ld. Counsel for the accused that the investigation is FIR No.236/2023 State Vs. Rajeev Yadav Page No. 7 of 10 -- 7 of 10 -- not proper and suffers from several infirmities and inconsistencies. Firstly, it is argued that the as per the version of the prosecution, the property was already booked for unauthorized construction vide 515/UC/B-II/SZ/22 dated 12.09.2022. However, no action was taken with respect to the same. It is argued that the PW-2 had admitted in his cross-examination that he has not seen the file pertaining to unauthorized construction. It is argued that how can any IO investigate without checking all the relevant materials available. Secondly, it is argued that the notice issued u/s 160 Cr.P.C does not indicate when the notice was issued and also does not mention the date and time of joining of the investigation by the JE. It is argued that PW-2 has admitted the same in his cross-examination. Thirdly, it is argued that Ex. PW-2/C, i.e., investigation report bears two different inks. It is argued that PW-2 could not give any explanation for the same. It is stated that Ex. PW-2/ C was not prepared properly and was prepared as an after-thought. Fourthly, it is argued that the photographs relied upon by the State do not mention the particulars of the property. It is argued that the same are not of the property in question and further, the prosecution has failed to prove that the photographs are of the property in question. It is further argued that PW-1 had deposed in his cross-examination that he does not remember if he had taken photographs of the alleged unauthorized construction. Fifthly, it is argued that the prosecution has not proved that the accused has made unauthorized construction. 22. On analysis of the material on record, I am of the considered opinion that the prosecution has failed to prove the guilt of the accused. The Prosecution suffers from several deficiencies. The prosecution has failed to prove that the accused carried out unauthorized construction. No public witness/laborer was examined to prove that the accused carried out FIR No.236/2023 State Vs. Rajeev Yadav Page No. 8 of 10 -- 8 of 10 -- unauthorized construction. The version of the prosecution is that the accused had already constructed the unauthorized construction and was already booked vide No. 515/UC/B-II/SZ/22 dated 12.09.2022. It is appalling that the prosecution did not pursue the previous booking further and rather, again booked the accused for the same alleged unauthorized construction. Further, the prosecution has not produced any evidence on record which shows that there is unauthorized construction. The burden of proof is on the prosecution to show that the accused has raised construction which is unauthorized. Moreover, the Ld. Counsel for the accused has rightly pointed out the deficiencies in the investigation carried out by the prosecution. The Prosecution has miserably failed to prove the guilt of the accused. 23. The accused has also been charged of an offence u/s 188 of IPC. However, the prosecution has failed to the essential ingredients of the offence. The prosecution has failed to prove that the necessary complaint under section 195 Cr.P.C was made. 24. Furthermore, it is imperative to note that, the prosecution is also liable to fail as the MCD has failed to comply with the statutory requirement under Section 471 of the DMC Act. Section 471 of the DMC reads as follows: “Section 471: - No person shall be liable to punishment for any offence against this Act or any rule, regulation or bye-law made thereunder, unless complaint of such offence is made before a Municipal Magistrate within six months next after-- (a) The date of commission of such offence, or (b) the date on which the commission or existence of such offence was first brought to the notice of the complainant.” 25. The mandatory complaint required to be made to the Magistrate was not made in the present case within six months, as required by law. In the present FIR No.236/2023 State Vs. Rajeev Yadav Page No. 9 of 10 -- 9 of 10 -- matter, the property was firstly booked on 12.09.2022 and the chargesheet was filed in Court on 14.05.24. The FIR was registered on 13.04.2023. It is trite that the deficiency in this regard is incurable once the statutory time has lapsed and cannot be corrected in any manner. In the case of MCD vs. Ravinder Kumar Mahindra 42 (1990) DLT 13 Hon’ble Delhi High Court has held as under: "The provision clearly sets out the scope. Even though section 466A does not make certain offences under the DMC Act cognizable and has permitted their investigation to be done as if these offences were cognizable. The offences do not cease to be offences under the DMC Act and section 471 clearly lays down the period of limitation within which action for offences under the DMC Act shall be initiated. It, therefore, clearly bars prosecution beyond a period of six months from the date of the commission of the offence or from the date when the existence of such offence was brought to the notice of the complainant. In our view, therefore, section 468 of the Code of Criminal Procedure is not applicable as the offence under the DMC Act will be covered by the provisions regarding limitation made in the Act itself." 26. Therefore, in the light of the foregoing discussion, I am of the considered opinion that the prosecution has completely failed to discharge its burden and resultantly, the accused person, namely Rajeev Yadav is entitled to the benefit of reasonable doubt and stands Acquitted of the charges levelled upon him. Announced in the open Court on 23.12.2025. It is certified that the present Judgment runs into ten pages and each page bears signature of the undersigned. (CHARAN SALWAN) Judicial Magistrate First Class-01 New Delhi District: Patiala House Courts New Delhi/ 23.12.2025 FIR No.236/2023 State Vs. Rajeev Yadav Page No. 10 of 10 -- 10 of 10 --
