Full Order Text
Interim Order 20 · 30 Jul 2026 · CNR DLND020141332022
Order Details: COPY OF JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS Pdf Text: CC NI ACT 6010/2022, 6011/2022, 6024/2022, 6028/2022, 6029/2022, 6030/2022, 8891/2022, 8893/2022, 11141/2022 30.07.2026 ORDER 1. Vide this common order, I shall decide application filed by the accused under Section 145(2) of the NI Act in connected complaints. 2. Ld. Counsel for the accused made the following submissions- a) The court vide order dated 27.09.2025 framed notice qua the accused persons and recorded that since the settlement and issuance of cheque was admitted, there was no requirement of cross-examination of the Complainant’s witness and that the present case would be tried as a summary case. Matter was subsequently listed for recording substance of evidence. b) Ld. Counsel submits that an application under Section 145(2) never came to be moved by the accused. It isn’t the case that, the right to move an application came to be closed. Consideration of the application would not amount to a review of order dated 27.09.2025. c) Section 145 (2) overrides the procedure applicable to summary trial. d) Reliance was placed upon Second Proviso to Section 143 NI Act, wherein the court at any stage of the trial could recall a witness if it was of the view that the present case was not to be tried summarily. e) He placed reliance upon the judgment of the Hon’ble HC of Delhi in Century Aluminium Manufacturing Company Ltd. and Another v. Hero Fincorp Ltd.1 and Kishor Biradmal Bhandari v. Chandrakant Krishna Gawas2. 3. Ld. Counsel for the complainant made the following submissions- a) The Ld. Predecessor court passed an order under Section 145(1) of the NI Act for recording substance of evidence. The same can now not be read to allow extensive cross-examination of the complainant. 1 2021 SCC Online Del 5538. 2 2023 SCC OnLine Bom 3007. 1 -- 1 of 2 -- b) Once an observation has already been made by the Predecessor court, this court cannot review the order and consider the application of the accused. 4. Heard. Record perused. 5. A perusal of Section 145 NI Act would reveal that the application of the provision is not restricted. It applies irrespective of whether an NI Act prosecution is summary in nature or a summons triable case. 6. The Ld. Predecessor court had merely recorded that the there was no requirement of cross-examination of the Complainant’s witness and that the present case would be tried as a summary case. In a summary trial, evidence is recorded in substance. 6.1 This cannot be interpreted to mean that the right to move an application under Section 145(2) stood closed. 7. Moreover, Second Proviso to Section 143 NI Act stipulates that, at any stage of the trial, if the court is of the opinion that a more severe sentence of imprisonment may have to be passed, a witness may be recalled for examination. This inherently translates to converting a summary trial into a summons triable case. 7.1 In his application under Section 145 (2), the accused at this stage has been able to cull out circumstances which deem it for this court to recall CW-1 to conduct evidence at length as opposed to recording substance of evidence 8. It is settled law that once an application under Section 145 (2) NI Act is moved by the accused, it is obligatory upon the court to allow such an application. 9. Accordingly, for reasons stated aforesaid, the application under Section 145 (2) NI Act moved by the accused is allowed. (Anjali Singh) JMFC (NI Act) – 03/PHC/ND/30.07.2026 2 -- 2 of 2 --
