Full Order Text
Order 20 · 10 Sept 2024 · CNR DLND020118502021
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF MS. PADMA LADOL, JMFC-04, NEW DELHI, PATIALA HOUSE COURTS, NEW DELHI Ct. Cases 1072/2021 VAIBHAV KUMAR SINGH SCIENTIST, DIVISION OF PLANT PATHOLOGY, ICAR-INDIAN AGRICULTURAL RESEARCH INSTITUTE (IARI), NEW DELHI-110012 Versus 1. DR. M.P THAKUR FORMER PRESIDENT, INDIAN PHYTOPATHOLOGICAL SOCIETY, PLANT PATHOLOGY DIVISION BUILDING, ICAR-IARI NEW DELHI-110012 2. DR. DINESH SINGH FORMER SECRETARY, INDIAN PHYTOPATHOLOGICAL SOCIETY, PLANT PATHOLOGY DIVISION BUILDING, ICAR-IARI NEW DELHI-110012 3. DR. ROBIN GOGOI FORMER JOINT SECRETARY, INDIAN PHYTOPATHOLOGICAL SOCIETY, PLANT PATHOLOGY DIVISION BUILDING, ICAR-IARI NEW DELHI-110012 ORDER ON APPLICATION UNDER SECTION 156(3) Cr.PC. 10.09.2024 -- 1 of 6 -- -2- 1. Complainant has approached this Court alleging offence u/s. 420/406/408/468/469/471/120-B IPC against all the respondents. It is the grievance of the complainant that he was elected as Treasurer of Indian Phytopathological Society (IPS) in February 2017 for a period of three years, however, before completion of the tenure, he was illegally and unauthorizedly removed by the respondents. It is further stated that complainant had been raising voice against cor- ruption, unthical practices and financial irregularities of the above said Society in which all the Respondents were office bearers. However, they conspired to remove the complainant from the Soci- ety and in pursuant to the same, Respondent no. 2, then Secretary of Society sent an e-mail on 26.06.2019 to all Executive Council of the Society informing that complainant has been removed from the position of Treasurer. It is further stated that on 22.10.2019, com- plainant received an e-mail from Respondent no. 2 with a show cause notice asking why he should not be removed from the pri- mary membership of the society. Said show cause notice men- tioned about an inquiry committee who had found the complainant guilty of misconduct. It is alleged that the report of said inquiry committee has been forged by Respondents to remove the com- plainant from primary membership of the Society. It is further al- leged that Respondents, by process of manipulation, forging the records/documents including the electronic/digital record removed -- 2 of 6 -- -3- the complainant from his elected position of Treasurer as well as from primary membership of the Society. Complainant also gave his written complaint to SHO PS Inderpuri as well as DCP dated 08.04.2021 but no action was taken by the police. Hence, com- plainant was constrained to file the present application. 2. Action taken report was called from concerned SHO. SHO filed re- ply in which he submitted that during enquiry into the alleged of- fence it has been found that complainant had filed a Writ Petition bearing No. W.P (C) No. 12675/2019 against his removal from pri- mary membership of the society, however, same was dismissed as withdrawn vide order dated 25.04.2023. It is further stated that no evidence came on record to show the offence of cheating and that complainant did not suffer any unlawful loss. Further, there are only allegations regarding internal issues of Indian Phytopathologi- cal Society (IPS). 3. Ld. Counsel for complainant had argued on the line of allegation made in the complaint, therefore, the same can be safely ommitted in order to maintain brevity. 4. After perusal of case file and hearing arguments, this court is con- scious of the settled law that u/s. 156 (3) Cr.PC the Magistrate has -- 3 of 6 -- -4- not to pass the order mechanically and has to apply his judicial mind. On this point decision of the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi in M/s Skipper Beverages Pvt Ltd vs State, 2001 IV AD (Del) 625 may be referred to in which it was held as under: “7. It is true that Section 156(3) of the Code empow- ers a Magistrate to direct the police to register a case and initiate investigations but this power has to be exercised judiciously on proper grounds and not in a mechanical manner. In those cases where the allega- tions are not very serious and the complainant him- self is in possession of evidence to prove his allega- tions there should be no need to pass orders under Section 156(3) of the Code. The discretion ought to be exercised after proper application of mind and only in those cases where the Magistrate is of the view that the nature of the allegations is such that the complainant himself may not be in a position to col- lect and produce evidence before the Court and inter- ests of justice demand that the police should step in to held the complainant. The police assistance can be taken by a Magistrate even Under Section 202(1) of the Code after taking cognizance and proceeding with the complaint under Chapter XV of the Code as held by Apex Court in 20001 (1) Supreme Page 129 titled " Suresh Chand Jain Vs. State of Madhya Pradesh & Ors." -- 4 of 6 -- -5- 5. Further, the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi in V.P. Sharma v. State of (NCT of Delhi) & Ors. 2009 XAD (Delhi) 709, held that “ the in- sistence to direct the Magistrate to take the other course of exercise of directing registration of FIR by calling for an investigation under Section 156(3) CrPC is putting the entire CrPC on a different pedestal. It is being raised by people who does not want to lead evi- dence or who does not have evidence to substantiate the complaint in accordance with law.” 6. Now, from the bare perusal of the complaint it is clear that the complainant and the respondents were colleagues/office bearers of Indian Phytopathological Society (IPS), ICAR-IARI. Apparently, the parties have internal dispute with respect to the Society and its man- agement. There are no documents to substantiate the allegations of cheating, forgery, criminal breach of trust and criminal conspiracy. Further, there is nothing in the application which requires police in- vestigation or custodial interrogation of the Respondents. Further, all evidence, if any are in possession of the complainant himself. . Therefore, application U/s. 156(3) CrPC stands dismissed on the fol- lowing grounds - i. The identity of the Respondents are already known to the complainant. -- 5 of 6 -- -6- ii. All the incriminating facts are within the knowledge of the complainant. iii. No facts are to be unearthed so as to require aid of police and it is also not the case where the collection of evidence is required. iv. Custodial interrogation of the Respondents are not neces- sary. v. The evidence required in the case is within the reach of the complainant. Announced in Open Court today. (Padma Ladol) JMFC-04, New Delhi, PHC/ND 10.09.2024 -- 6 of 6 --
