Skip to main content
Court Order

Order 17

CNR DLND02008639202119 Nov 2022
Back to Case

Full Order Text

Order 17 · 19 Nov 2022 · CNR DLND020086392021

Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT
Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SH. SAHIL KHURMI
METROPOLITAN MAGISTRATE (N.I. ACT) - 02,
ROUSE AVENUE COURTS: NEW DELHI
Case No: 3143/2021
CNR No.DLND020086392021
Sachin Assal
s/o Mr. Ravinder Kumar,
r/o House no.12, Street No.4,
Chander Nagar, West,
New Delhi - 110051
...... Complainant
::Versus::
1. M/s Sampatti Trading and Developers Ltd.
316 (3rd Floor), Competent House,
F-14, Middle Circle, Connaught Place,
New Delhi – 110001.
2. Shanthi Swaroup Satija (Director)
also at
B-52, Pocket-B,
Sarita Vihar, Delhi-110076.
3. Kunwar Pal Singh (Director)
(Not summoned)
G-41, Third Floor, Arya Samaj Road,
Near Sanjivani School,
Uttam Nagar, Delhi-110059.
4. Vishal Tandon
(Not summoned)
s/o Om Prakash Tandon
r/o 776, Dr. Mukherjee Nagar,
Delhi-110009.
5. Janak Rani
(Not summoned)
w/o Sh. S. S. Satija,
r/o B-52, Pocket-B,
Page 1 of 20
-- 1 of 20 --
Sarita Vihar,
New Delhi – 110076.
…....Accused
Offence Complained of: 138 NI Act
Plea of the Accused: Not guilty
Arguments Heard On: 19.10.2022
Date of Judgment: 19.11.2022
Decision: Convicted
JUDGMENT
1. Vide this judgment, I shall decide the present complaint
filed u/s 138 NI Act bearing CC No.3143/2021, against the
dishonor of cheque bearing No.714974, dated 14.02.2021 for a
sum of Rs.30,857/-, drawn on PNB Connaught Circus, New
Delhi in favour of complainant company which on presentation
by the complainant to his banker was returned unpaid with
remarks “Account blocked". (Hereinafter referred to as cheque in
question).
2. Shorn to unnecessary details, the brief facts of the case put
forth by the complainant are that the complainant entered into an
agreement dated 01.11.2016 with the accused company duly
signed by accused no.2 having “down payment plan with money
back scheme”, pursuant to which the complainant was sold a plot
of 100 sq. yards after receiving a consideration of Rs.7,20,000/-
and was issued 21 quarter yearly installments (after deducting /
adjusting the TDS as per the provision of Indian Income Tax) for
which 21 post dated cheques including the present cheque in
Page 2 of 20
-- 2 of 20 --
question was issued. It is further stated that when the said cheque
was presented by the complainant, it was dishonored with the
remarks 'account blocked' vide cheque returning memo. Legal
demand notice was sent to the accused. However, no payment
was made within 15 days and hence, the present complaint.
3. After finding prima facie case against the accused,
summons was issued to accused and on appearance of accused,
notice of accusation u/s 251 Cr.PC was served upon the accused
no.1 and 2, to which the accused pleaded not guilty and claimed
trial. Accused admitted his signatures on the cheque and stated
that he has not received the legal demand notice. He further
stated that he had given the cheque to the complainant for money
back scheme and he has no liability towards the complainant.
4. Thereafter, application u/s 145(2) NI act was moved by the
accused which was allowed by the court. CW-1 was examined in
chief, cross-examined and discharged. Vide separate statement on
behalf of the complainant, CE stood closed.
5. Thereafter, all the incriminating evidence was put before
the accused and the statement of accused u/s 313 Cr.PC was
recorded in which accused took a similar stand as taken by him in
his plea of defence u/s. 251 CrPC. Additionally, he stated that
since no registry of the property in question was done, therefore,
the complainant could not present the cheque in question.
Thereafter, matter was fixed for DE.
6. Thereafter, application u/s 315 Cr.P.C was moved by the
accused to depose as defence witness along with list of witnesses
which was allowed. DW-1 bank witness Sh. Harshit Singhal and
DW-2 accused and DW-3 IO Insp. Ramkesh were examined,
cross-examined and discharged. Thereafter, vide separate
Page 3 of 20
-- 3 of 20 --
statement of accused, DE stood closed and the matter was fixed
for final arguments.
7. Thereafter, final arguments were heard on behalf of both
the parties. I have heard the counsels for both parties at length,
considered the evidence led by them carefully and have perused
the court records thoroughly.
LAW UNDER CONSIDERATION AND SUBMISSIONS OF
THE COUNSELS
8. Before going into the facts of the present case, it would be
apposite to discuss the legal standards required to be met by both
sides. In order to establish the offence under Section 138 of NI
Act, the complainant must fulfil all the essential ingredients of
the offence, as highlighted below:
“1st Ingredient: The cheque was drawn by a
person on an account maintained by him/her for
payment of money and the same is presented for
payment within a period of 3 months from the
date on which it is drawn or within the period of
its validity;
2nd Ingredient: The cheque was drawn by the
drawer for discharge of any legally enforceable
debt or other liability;
3rd Ingredient: The cheque was returned unpaid
by the bank due to either insufficiency of funds in
the account to honour the cheque or that it
exceeds the amount arranged to be paid from that
account on an agreement made with that bank;
4th Ingredient: A demand of the said amount has
been made by the payee or holder in due course of
the cheque by a notice in writing given to the
drawer within thirty days of the receipt of
information of the dishonour of cheque from the
bank;
Page 4 of 20
-- 4 of 20 --
5th Ingredient: The drawer fails to make
payment of the said amount of money within
fifteen days from the date of receipt of notice.”
9. Ld. Counsel for the complainant has submitted that the
accused should be convicted of offence u/s. 138 NI Act because
the complainant has proved the original cheque, which the
accused has not disputed as being drawn on the account of the
accused and the accused has admitted the signature on the
cheque. He has further submitted that the cheque in question
were returned unpaid vide cheque returning memos which are on
record. He has further submitted that the complainant has to
prove that legal demand notice was sent to accused. He has
further submitted that the fact that the payment was not made
within 15 days of the receipt of the legal notice is also not
disputed. Ld. counsel for the complainant has further submitted
that as far as the proof of second ingredient regarding legally
enforceable debt or liability is concerned, since the signatures on
the cheque in question are admitted by accused, accordingly, this
court should raise presumption under section 118(a) r/w. section
139 of NI Act that the cheque in question was issued by the
accused to the complainant in discharge of legally enforceable
debt or liability. He has further submitted that the accused has
already admitted the execution of deed of agreement which is
already placed on record.
10. Per Contra, Ld. counsel for the accused has submitted that
the accused should be acquitted of offence u/s. 138 NI Act as the
accused has not received the legal demand notice from the
complainant, as the cheque in question was issued only for
security purposes, as there is no legally enforceable debt or
Page 5 of 20
-- 5 of 20 --
liability in favour of the complainant and because the account on
which the cheque has been issued was not maintained by the
accused at the relevant point of time.
11. Before examining the defences taken by the accused, it is
pertinent to note that the accused has admitted to the execution of
agreement between the parties and his signatures on the cheque
in question. Accordingly, this court raises presumption under
section 118(a) r/w. section 139 of NI Act that the cheque in
question was issued by the accused to the complainant in
discharge of legally enforceable debt or liability. In order to rebut
the presumptions, the burden of proof shifts to the accused to
prove on a preponderance of probabilities that there was no
liability for the amount of cheque in question. Therefore, in the
present matter, the onus of proof is now upon the accused to raise
a probable defence and to rebut the presumption of the existence
of a legally recoverable debt arisen in favour of the complainant.
DEFENCES OF THE ACCUSED
I. Defence of non-receipt of Legal Demand Notice
12. It is the defence of accused that he had not received the
legal demand notice sent by the complainant as he was in jail. Per
contra, learned counsel for complainant has stated that the legal
demand notice was sent to accused on his admitted e-mail ID.
13. It is pertinent to mention that the email ID on which the
legal demand notice was sent by complainant has been admitted
by accused in his cross examination. Firstly, the accused has not
proved on record that he was in jail at the time when the legal
demand notice was sent to him and no evidence has been
adduced regarding same. Secondly, the accused has also not
Page 6 of 20
-- 6 of 20 --
proved on record that the complainant had the knowledge that the
accused was in jail when the legal demand notice was sent.
14. Thus, the accused is precluded from taking this defence
that he was in jail and he didn’t receive the legal demand notice.
The complainant has done his part diligently by sending the legal
demand notice on email ID of accused which was available with
him and which is duly admitted by accused. Moreover, certificate
u/s 65B of Indian Evidence Act is also on record.
15. The superior courts have time and again held that court
should not adopt an interpretation which helps a dishonest evader
and clips an honest payee as that would defeat the very legislative
object of enacting a beneficial interpretation.
16. Moreover, as per mandate of C.C. Alavi Haji vs Palapetty
Muhammed & Anr. (2007) 6 SCC 555, the accused didn’t make
the payment within 15 days of receipt of the summons from the
Court and thus he cannot contend that there was no proper
service of notice as required under Section 138.
17. The Hon’ble Supreme court of India has very well
discussed this defence in K. Bhaskaran vs Sankaran Vaidhyan
Balan and Anr. (1999) 7 SCC 510, where it was held that if a
strict interpretation is given that the drawer should have actually
received the notice for the period of 15 days to start running no
matter that the payee sent the notice on the correct address, a
trickster cheque drawer would get the premium to avoid
receiving the notice by different strategies and he could escape
from the legal consequences of Section 138 of the NI Act.
18. Thus, for the detailed reasons aforementioned, the plea of
the accused that the legal demand notice was never received is
not tenable and accordingly, rejected.
Page 7 of 20
-- 7 of 20 --
II. Defence of cheque in question being security cheque
19. The accused has taken the defence that the cheque was
given for security purpose, by putting suggestion to the CW1 in
his cross-examination. The said suggestion has been denied by
witness.
20. It is a settled law that mere suggestions do not amount to
proof. No cogent evidence has been led by accused to prove this
defence. The agreement placed on record conclusively proves
that the cheque in question was issued as post-dated cheque.
There is nothing on record to suggest that the cheque in question
were issued for security purposes. Accordingly, there is no merit
in this defence and the same stands not proved and hence, denied.
III. Defence of there being no legally enforceable debt or
liability
21. It is the defence of accused that as per the deed of
agreement the complainant didn’t get the registry done of the
property despite repeated requests by him, therefore, sale was not
completed and thus, the complainant was not entitled to present
the cheque for encashment since no legally enforceable
liability/debt accrued to the accused.
22. Per contra, learned counsel for complainant has stated that
as per the agreement deed it was the duty of owner/promoter (i.e.,
accused) to get the registry of property done and no
communication/efforts were ever made by the accused to the
complainant to get the registry done. He has further stated that
despite several requests of complainant to accused, the accused
didn’t bother to get the registry of property done.
Page 8 of 20
-- 8 of 20 --
23. Learned counsel has drawn the attention of this court on
“Registration” clause of the deed of agreement. The same is
reproduced here for ready reference:
REGISTRATION
The Owner/|Promoter shall get the sale deed
of the plot registered in favor of the allottee(s)
within 90 days of the execution of the present
agreement and for that cause the Owner/
Promoter will call upon the allottee (s) to get
the sale deed registered in his favor as per the
statuary rules and regulations and only subject
to the clearance of all payments and all
outstanding dues payable to the execution,
registration of the sale deed/conveyance deed,
including. the expenditure of stamp duty,
registration fee etc., which shall be borne by the
allottee(s) exclusively.
(Emphasis laid)
24. Thus, a bare perusal of the above-mentioned registration
clause shows that it was the duty of the owner/ promoter (i.e.,
accused) to get the sale deed of the property in favour of
allottee (i.e., complainant) within 90 days of execution of said
agreement. Further, it was duty of the owner/promoter (accused)
to call upon the allottee (complainant) to get the sale deed
registered in his favour.
25. Now, after ascertaining the duty of the accused to get the
registry done, it is to been seen whether the accused is able to
prove that he had called upon the complainant to get the registry
done or not.
26. The relevant extract of cross examination of complainant is
reproduced here for ready reference:
It is correct that the said money back scheme was
applicable only when the residential plot is
Page 9 of 20
-- 9 of 20 --
purchased. Till date I have not done the sale deed
of the said residential plot in my name.
It is wrong to suggest that the accused told
many times to get the sale deed executed, but I
have not done the same. Vol. Despite several
requests on telephone the accused did not
respond and I visited the office of accused
several times, but he didn’t respond.
27. Thus, from the above cross examination of complainant it
transpires that only suggestion was given to complainant that
accused told him to get the sale deed executed. It is settled law
that mere suggestions do not amount to proof. It is also apposite
to mention that the accused had admitted in his cross examination
that, “No written letter was sent to the complainant to get the
registry done.” Further, suggestions were given to the accused in
his cross examination that despite repeated requests of the
complainant the accused failed to get the registry done. The said
suggestions were denied by accused.
28. Now, it is worthy to note that both the complainant and
accused have blamed each other for not getting the registry of
property done.
29. Here, it would be profitable to reproduce Section 103 of
Indian Evidence Act which says that:
103. Burden of proof as to particular fact. —The
burden of proof as to any particular fact lies on that
person who wishes the Court to believe in its
existence, unless it is provided by any law that the
proof of that fact shall lie on any particular person
30. Thus, since it was the duty of the owner/ promoter (i.e.
accused) to get the sale deed of the property in favour of allottee
(i.e. complainant), therefore, as per Section 103 of Indian
Page 10 of 20
-- 10 of 20 --
Evidence Act, the burden of proof was on the accused to prove
that he had asked and informed the complainant to get the
registry done and it was the complainant who didn’t get the same
done. However, the accused has not led any cogent evidence to
prove the same. Thus, the accused has failed to prove, by leading
cogent and clinching evidence, that he made any efforts to get the
registry of property done and his bald averments will not rescue
him to discharge the burden. Accordingly, the accused has failed
to prove the defence that there was no legally enforceable
liability/debt on him towards the complainant. Therefore, this
defence is also rejected.
IV. Defence that the account on which the cheque has been
issued was not maintained by the accused at the
relevant point of time.
31. It is submitted by accused that the cheque in question were
issued for security purpose for paying the agreed future share of
profit as per agreement and thereafter due to demonetization in
November, 2016 the accused suffered losses and asked the
investors not to present the cheque. It is further submitted that
thereafter FIR no. 85/2018, 86/2018 PS EOW, New Delhi was
registered against accused and thereafter the police got the bank
accounts of the accused freezed/blocked by writing a letter to
concerned bank.
32. Ld. Counsel for the accused has submitted that since the
bank accounts of accused were blocked/frozen by police, he was
not able to maintain those bank accounts as he had no control
over his bank account i.e., he was not in a position to withdraw
money from his account to honour the cheque and thus, the
accused has contended that since the account, on which cheque in
Page 11 of 20
-- 11 of 20 --
question was drawn, was not maintained by him, therefore, no
offence u/s 138 NI act is made out. He has placed reliance upon
catena of judgments namely:
i. M/s Ceasefire Industries Ltd vs State 2017 SCC OnLine
Del 8280
ii. Standard Chartered Bank and Anr. vs. State and Anr., 2007
(98) DRJ 71
iii. Vijay Chaudhary vs. Gyan Chand Jain, 2008 VII AD
(Delhi) 293
iv. Rajesh Meena vs State of Haryana and Others 2019 SCC
OnLine P&H 6256,
v. Ashish Parekh v State of Maharashtra decided by Hon’ble
Bombay High Court decided on 22 March, 2011.
33. Before moving forward, it is pertinent to discuss the
meaning of the phrase ‘account maintained by the accused’. In
Rajesh Meena vs State of Haryana and Others 2019 SCC
OnLine P&H 6256 which is himself relied upon by accused it
was held that the expression "account maintained by him" must
necessarily include that the said account is not only alive and
operative, but the account holder is capable of executing
command to govern the financial transactions which include the
clearance of cheque etc. The authority and control of the
account holder upon the account must exist on the effective
date i.e., when the cheque becomes valid for presentation in the
bank.
34. Before dealing with this defence, the testimony of Defence
Witnesses shall be dealt first. DW-1 Bank witness from the bank
account of the accused stated that, “It is correct that even if the
account is dormant, there is no bar to deposit the amount of
money. The only bar is on the withdrawal of money.” The said
Page 12 of 20
-- 12 of 20 --
witness was again put another question by counsel for
complainant namely:
Q. I put to you that even in a freezed account,
money can be deposited but cannot be withdrawn.
Ans. It is correct. In a debit freezed account,
money can be deposited but cannot be withdrawn.
35. Further, DW-3 IO Inspector Ramkesh brought letter dated
20.06.2018, in FIR no. 86/18 dated 17.04.2018 u/s 409/420 IPC,
PS EOW which is Ex. DW-3/1 in which debit freeze direction
was issued by Economic Offence Wing (EOW) to the bank of
accused. He stated in his cross examination that:
“It is correct that there was no prohibition of
depositing the money rather the prohibition was
regarding the withdrawal of money. Vol. Since it
was a debit freeze.”
36. From the testimony of above-mentioned defence
witnesses, it is amply clear, beyond an iota of doubt, that
there was no complete freezing or blocking of the account of
accused, rather there was only ‘debit freeze’ on his account
prohibiting him to withdraw money from his account.
37. Before appreciating the catena of judgments relied upon by
accused, at the very outset, it is apposite to mention that all these
judgements were itself relied upon and discussed by this court at
the initial stage of trial while dismissing the application u/s 143A
of Negotiable Instruments Act for interim compensation moved
by the complainant, due to the reason that the evidence had not
come at that time and the contentions of both parties raised
triable issues which could have been decided only after a full-
blown trial.
Page 13 of 20
-- 13 of 20 --
38. The accused has placed reliance on M/s Ceasefire
Industries Ltd (supra) in which it was held that the complainant
itself was aware that the accounts had been frozen in terms of
directions by some statutory authority. However, in the present
case there is nothing on record to suggest that the complainant
had knowledge that there were instructions of debit freeze from a
statutory authority in respect of the account of the accused. Thus,
the facts of this judgment relied upon by accused, is not
applicable to the present case and is of no help to the accused.
39. Further, the accused has placed reliance on Standard
Chartered Bank and Anr. (supra) in which the recovery officer
of income tax authority had issued warrant of attachment to
attach the bank account of the accused as the accused had not
paid income tax dues. In the said case, the accused had
erroneously issued the cheque whereas the account of accused
was already attached by income tax authority much prior to
issuance of cheque. The accused had even given reply to legal
demand notice mentioning the error on his part to issue the
cheque despite his account being attached by income tax
authority. The facts of the case in hand are distinguishable and
materially different as in the present case in hand the cheque in
question was Post Dated Cheque and the account of accused was
put on debit freeze after the cheque in question was handed over
to the complainant by the accused. Moreover, in the above
mentioned judgment relied upon by accused the account of
accused was attached by income tax authority and accused
ceased to have the control and dominion over his account,
whereas in the present case in hand, there was only debit freeze
put on the account of accused by statutory authority, meaning
Page 14 of 20
-- 14 of 20 --
thereby, that the accused was not able to withdraw the money but
there was no prohibition to deposit the money and accused had
control and dominion of his account except withdrawing money.
Thus, the facts of this judgment relied upon by accused, is not
applicable to the present case and is of no help to the accused.
40. Further, the accused has placed reliance on judgment of
Hon’ble High Court of Bombay in Ashish Parekh (supra), in
which the reason for dishonour was "attachment received from
Crime Branch" and thus cheque was dishonoured because of the
attachment of the said account by the Crime Branch. In the
present case in hand, the reason for dishonour is “Account
Blocked” and the reason for the same was debit freeze put on the
account of accused by EOW. As mentioned above in the last
paragraph, when an account is attached by some statutory
authority the person ceases the control and dominion over his
account, whereas in the present case in hand, the account of
accused was not attached, rather there was only debit freeze put
on the account of accused by statutory authority. Thus, the facts
of this judgment relied upon by accused, is also not applicable to
the present case and is of no help to the accused.
41. Further, the accused has placed reliance on Vijay
Chaudhary vs. Gyan Chand Jain (supra). In the said
judgment, it was held that “For an account to be maintained by an
account holder, it is essential that he is in a position to operate the
said account by either depositing monies there in or by
withdrawing money there from”. Whereas, the present case in
hand is distinguishable as there was prohibition or bar on the
accused to withdraw the money from his account, whereas there
Page 15 of 20
-- 15 of 20 --
was no prohibition or bar to deposit the money in his account.
Therefore, this judgment shall be of no succour to the accused.
42. Further reliance is placed by accused upon judgment of
Rajesh Meena vs State of Haryana (supra) in which the
account of accused was blocked by orders of NCLT and reply
was given by the accused to the legal demand notice sent by
complainant in which it was specifically mentioned by the
accused that because of prohibitory orders by NCLT New Delhi,
the account in question stood blocked and therefore, the request
was made to the complainant to withdraw the legal notice. It was
further requested by accused that as and when the accused would
get the permission to operate the account of the company, the
payment in respect of the cheque in question would be made to
the complainant and request was made to the complainant to not
to present the cheque. Whereas the fact of the case in hand are
different and distinguishable from the above-mentioned judgment
because no reply to legal demand notice has been given by the
accused asking the complainant not to present the cheque and no
communication was ever made by accused to complainant stating
that he would make the payment of cheque once the debit freeze
on his account is lifted. Thus, the facts of this judgment relied
upon by accused, is also not applicable to the present case and is
of no help to the accused.
43. Thus, this court has come to irresistible conclusion that the
facts of the all cases relied upon by the accused in regard to the
defence under consideration are not applicable to the facts of the
present case, since in the instant case, there is only one
prohibition on the account of the accused, i.e., withdrawal of
Page 16 of 20
-- 16 of 20 --
money and the accused had remaining control, authority and
dominion over his account.
44. In the facts of the present case, the service of withdrawal of
money was not provided to the accused due to the prohibition by
the statutory authority in this regard. However, as apparent from
the evidence of DW1 and DW3, the accused could have
deposited any sum of money in his bank account so as to show at
the stage of trial that he had sufficient balance in his account at
the time when the cheque was presented for encashment. Further,
there was no prohibition on the accused to get issued a new
cheque book and issue cheques to third parties, therefrom. There
was also no prohibition on the accused to issue cheques to third
parties from the cheque books already available with him.
Therefore, it is concluded that there was no complete freezing
or blocking of the account of accused, so as to infer that the
accused had no control, authority or dominion on his account
and he didn’t maintain his bank account for the purposes of
Section 138 of NI act.
45. Thus, for the detailed and exhaustive reasons supported by
catena of Judgments of superior courts as mentioned above, the
defence of accused that he didn’t maintain his bank account for
the purposes of Section 138 of NI act is untenable and
accordingly, rejected
46. Lastly, it is apposite to mention the judgment of Rajat
Pharmachem Ltd & Ors. v. State Trading Corporation of
India Ltd 2009 SCC OnLine Del 2134 decided by Hon’ble High
Court of Delhi in which it was held that if the cheque is
dishonoured with the reason “Account Frozen” it falls within
Page 17 of 20
-- 17 of 20 --
the purview of Section 138 of Negotiable Instruments Act,
1881. It was held as follows:
10. Mr. Sandeep Sethi also raised a plea that since
the endorsement on the return memo was “account
frozen”, it did not amount in law to dishonour of
cheque. This submission, in my view, is
untenable. A bare reading of Section 138 of the
N.I. Act will demonstrate the fallacy of this
submission. Once a cheque drawn by a person on
an account maintained by him with a banker for
payment of any amount of money to another
person is returned unpaid, there is a presumption
drawn that it was issued for discharge of a valid
debt or liability even though a rebuttable
presumption. The payee, on receipt of notice from
his banker that the cheque is returned unpaid, is
required to issue a statutory demand notice within
15 days of such notice to the drawer, giving the
drawer 15 days’ time to satisfy the demand from its
communication.
10.1 It is axiomatic that whatever may be the
reasons for return of cheque set out in the
return memo of the bank, if the drawer does not
satisfy the demand within 15 days of its receipt
the offence stands committed in the eyes of law.
In such a situation, presumption will be drawn
against the drawer that the cheque was returned
unpaid either on account of the amount standing to
the credit of the drawer in his account being
insufficient or that the cheque exceeds the amount
arranged to be paid from that account by an
agreement made with the drawer’s bank. If
Section 138 of the N.I. Act is construed
otherwise, it would defeat the entire purpose of
enacting these provisions. A truant drawer
would get his banker to give reasons which will
help him avoid the consequences of a dishonour
of his cheque. An interpretation even in respect
of a legislation which entails penal consequences
which denudes the legislation of its efficacy is to
be abjured.
Page 18 of 20
-- 18 of 20 --
(Emphasis supplied)
47. Therefore, as held by Hon’ble Delhi High Court in Rajat
Pharmachem Ltd (supra) mentioned in preceding paragraph,
that once a cheque is drawn by a person on an account
maintained by him with a banker for payment of any amount of
money to another person is returned unpaid, there is a
presumption drawn that it was issued for discharge of a valid debt
or liability. It is for the accused to rebut the presumptions, which
the accused has miserably failed to do, in the present case.
48. On a consideration of the totality of factors pleaded by the
accused in defence, it becomes clear that the accused has merely
paid lip service to his defence and did not lead any cogent
evidence to establish it or draw any circumstance against the case
of the Complainant which probabilizes his defence. Mere bald
denial of the absence of legally enforceable debt or pleading that
the cheque in question was issued as security would not operate
to absolve the accused of his liability.
FINDINGS OF THE COURT:
49. On the basis of the above discussion, this court arrives at
the following conclusions:
a. The defence of accused that cheque in question was given
to complainant for security purpose is not proved.
b. The defence of accused that legal demand notice was not
received by him is not proved.
c. The accused has failed to prove that there is no legally
enforceable liability or debt on him towards the
complainant.
Page 19 of 20
-- 19 of 20 --
d. The accused has issued the cheque on an account
maintained by him and the defence of accused that the
account on which the cheque was drawn is not maintained
by him is not proved.
50. Therefore, in light of the above reasoning, it is the
considered opinion of this court that the accused has miserably
failed to rebut the presumption u/s 118 and 139 of NI Act which
has arisen in favour of the complainant and has failed to show
that the defence is probable.
51. Therefore, accused no.1 Sampatti Trading and Developers
Ltd. (drawer) and accused no. 2 Shanthi Swaroup Satija
(signatory) are convicted for commission of offence punishable
under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instrument Act, 1881.
52. Lastly, before parting, this court would be failing in its
duty without acknowledging the appreciation for both the parties
along with their respective counsels namely Dr. Ashutosh
(learned counsel for complainant) and Sh. Anil Kumar (learned
counsel for accused) for not taking unnecessary adjournments
and by assisting this court to achieve the milestone of expeditious
disposal of 53 connected matters in timely and speedy manner.
Announced in open court
Note: This judgment contains 20 pages and each page has been
signed by me.
(Sahil Khurmi)
MM (NI)-02/RACC
NDD/ND/19.11.2022
Page 20 of 20
-- 20 of 20 --

TrustJury presents public court-record information for legal discovery and reference. Record availability and detail can vary by source and case.