Full Order Text
Final Order 26 · 04 Jul 2025 · CNR DLND020066092023
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: CC No. 3437-2023 Page No. 1 of14 IN THE COURT OF JUDICIAL MAGISTRATE (NI ACT DIGITAL COURT- 01), NEW DELHI, DELHI Presided by :- Ms. Shivangi Vyas CNR No. 3437-2023 CC No. DLND020066092023 Sh. Mukesh Kurnar S/o Late Sh. Fakira Singh R/o House NO: 247, Anbedkar Basti, Sector-1, R.K. Purarn, New Delhi- 110022 …………... Complainant Versus 1. Smt. Kiran W/o Raju R/o S- l7 I , Arnbedkar Basti, R.K. Purarn, Sector- 1, New Delhi-110022 Also at: (i) A-28, Shyarn Vihar, Najafgarh, Delhi (ii)6126" Sector- 6 Jharera village Gopinath Bazar, South west Delhi-l 10010 (iii)105, Street No. 6, Vijay Nagar, Mohan Garden, Uttarn Nagar, New Delhi- I 10059 ………. Accused No. I 2. Mr. Pradeep S/o Mahavir @ Raju R/o 8-344, Ambedkar Basti, Sector- l, R.K. Puram, New Delhi- 110022 ……….....Accused No. 2 -- 1 of 14 -- CC No. 3437-2023 Page No. 2 of14 JUDGMENT (1) Offence complained of or proved : 138 N.I. Act (2) Plea of accused : Pleaded not guilty (3) Date of institution of case : 02.03.2023 (4) Date of reserve of order : 12.06.2025 (5) Date of Final Order : 04.07.2025 (6) Final Order : Acquitted BRIEF STATEMENT OF REASONS FOR THE DECISION 1. The present complaint under section 138 of Negotiable Instruments Act (hereinafter referred to as ‘NI Act’) has been filed by Sh. Mukesh Kumar S(hereinafter referred to as ‘complainant’) against Smt. Kiran (hereinafter referred to as ‘accused no. 1’) and Mr. Pradeep (hereinafter referred to as ‘accused no. 2’) for dishonor of cheques bearing number 548258 & 548259 amounting to Rs. 1,00,000/- and Rs. 50,000/- respectively drawn on Canara Bank Branch Uttam Nagar, New Delhi- I10059 (herein after referred to as ‘cheques in question’). FACTUAL MATRIX 2. Facts in brief as stated in the complaint are that the complainant and accused are known to each other since many years and are residents of the same locality. That the accused had approached the complainant due to dire need of money amounting to Rs. 1,50,000/- (Rupees One Lac Fifty Thousand Only) for the marriage of her daughter. That after seeing the genuine need of the accused, the complainant had paid the amount in parts to the accused as Rs. 50,000/- was given by cheque bearing no 236423 in favor of the accused bearing date 20.09.2019 and drawn on Union Bank of India, branch Lodhi Road, New Delhi and the remaining amount of Rs. 1,00,000/- was given in cash from the savings of the complainant. That in discharge of her liability, the accused had issued two cheques -- 2 of 14 -- CC No. 3437-2023 Page No. 3 of14 in question with the assurance that the same would be honoured upon presentation. That the accused executed a notarized affidavit duly signed by her and witnessed by her son accused no. 2. That complainant had presented the aforesaid cheques to his banker i.e., Union Bank of India Branch - New Moti Nagar on 23.12.2022 but the said cheques were returned back with the remarks ‘Payment Stopped by Drawer’ along with cheques return memo dated 26.12.2022. That thereafter, complainant was constrained to send a legal notice through his counsel to the accused persons on dated 19.01.2023 which was deliberately not received by accused. Accused did not make any payment despite issuance of notice and therefore the present complaint was filed. APPEARANCE OF ACCUSED AND PROCEEDINGS 3. Since prima facie offence u/s 138 of Negotiable Instrument Act was made out, the accused no. 1 Kiran was summoned vide order dated 07.12.2023. No summons were issued to accused no. 2 Pradeep. Accused Kiran entered her appearance and notice was served upon her for offence punishable u/s 138 NI Act on 16.03.2024, to which she pleaded not guilty and claimed trial. 4. In her plea of defense, accused has submitted that the she does not have liability of cheques amount towards complainant. She stated that she had taken loan of Rs. 50,000/- from complainant and in lieu of the same, two cheques were given as security cheques. She stated that she had duly returned the amount to the complainant by way of cheque and cheque was duly encashed by complainant. COMPLAINANT EVIDENCE 5. Complainant had tendered his evidence by way of affidavit as CW1/B on 02.05.2024 wherein he has reiterated the facts as mentioned in his complaint. He relied upon following documents in his evidence: -- 3 of 14 -- CC No. 3437-2023 Page No. 4 of14 Ex CW1/1 : Original Cheque bearing no. 548258. Ex CW1/2 : Original Cheque bearing no. 548259. Ex CW1/3 : Bank Return memo pertaining to cheque no. 548258. Ex CW1/4 : Bank Return memo pertaining to cheque no. 548259. Ex CW1/5 : Legal demand notice. Ex. CW1/6 : Speed post receipts Ex. CW1/7 : Tracking report. Ex CW1/8 : Loan agreement dated 20.09.2019. 6. An oral application under section 145(2) NI Act was made on behalf of accused and same was allowed vide order dated 16.03.2024. Complainant/CW1 was cross examined by Ld. Counsel for accused and discharged. 7. No other witness was examined on behalf of complainant and complainant evidence was closed vide order dated 02.05.2024. STATEMENT OF ACCUSED AND DEFENCE EVIDENCE 8. All the incriminating evidence was put to the accused and her statement under section 313 CrPC was recorded on 16.07.2024. In her plea of defence, accused had denied the claim of complainant and stated that she had taken a loan of Rs.50,000/- from the complainant. That no loan was obtained to bear expenses of her daughter's marriage. That her daughter is still unmarried and that she had handed over both the cheques as security. That she had asked the complainant to fill amount of Rs.25,000/- in each cheque and that wrong amount was mentioned by the complainant and that is why she asked the bank to stop the payment. That she signed the loan agreement as she was misinformed by the -- 4 of 14 -- CC No. 3437-2023 Page No. 5 of14 complainant that the loan agreement is being executed to show the transaction of Rs.50,000/-. That the contents of the loan agreement were not read by her. That she has repaid the entire loan amount to the complainant and the complainant has falsely implicated her in the present case. 9. Accused chose to lead DE and examined two witnesses in her defence. Accused examined herself as DW1 and Sh. Pradeep (son of accused) was examined as DW2. 10. DW-1 averred in her affidavit inter-alia that her husband died on 11.01.2021 and that she resided at the address mentioned in affidavit along with her unmarried daughter pooja and her son Pradeep. That she took a friendly loan from her neighbor Mukesh Kumar of Rs. 50,000/- at interest of 20% on 20.09.2019 through cheque bearing number 236423 drawn on Union Bank for renovation of her house for six months and same was received in her account on 23.09.2019. That in lieu of the loan of RS. 50,000/- she issued two blank security cheques bearing number 548258 and 548259. That complainant had made an agreement stating that the same was for the loan amount of RS. 50,000/- and that since she and her husband are illiterate complainant took advantage of same. That complainant made false agreement of RS. 150,000/- instead of Rs. 50,000/- and forged the signature of her son Pradeep. That the loan amount of Rs. 50,000/- was returned by her to Mukesh Kumar on 21.03.2020 as per mutual consent. That after making payment of full amount she asked the complainant for return of security cheques but complainant avoided the same. That when complainant did not return the security cheques she gave instruction of stop payment to her banker sensing malafide intention and the cheque is also dishonoured due to the remarks ‘Payment stopped by drawer.’ That complainant has made false allegation to extort money from her. She was cross examined by Ld. Counsel for complainant and discharged. 11. DW-2 deposed that he is son of accused and is well aware about the present case filed by the complainant. That he is 3" passed out and working as a driver.That complainant -- 5 of 14 -- CC No. 3437-2023 Page No. 6 of14 never approached him to be a witness and he was not aware about the present agreement made between the complainant and the accused and the Complainant had never made present agreement in his presence and he also never singed the present agreement Exhibited before the Court filed by the Complaiant. That in the present agreement his forged signature made in English and he always sign in Hindi. He also Exhibiting his PAN Card bearing no. CZNPP3444B as a proof showing his signature in Hindi as Mark -A. That he is not deposing falsely. He was not cross examined despite opportunity and discharged. FINAL ARGUMENTS 12. Ld. Counsel for complainant has argued that the complainant has successfully established commission of offence U/s 138 NI Act by the accused. It is argued that the cheques in question were issued for repayment of friendly loan taken by accused and the said cheques have been dishonored. Ld. Counsel for complainant has pointed out that the accused has admitted the receipt of loan however has disputed the quantum of loan to be only Rs. 50,000/- however accused failed to prove that the loan was only of Rs. 50,00/- and not Rs. 1,50,000/- It is argued that the loan agreement correctly stipulates the loan amount of Rs. 150,000/- including loan by cheque of RS. 50,000/- and RS. 1,00,000/- in cash. The said agreement admittedly bears the signature of accused and also bears the signature of her son Pradeep as a witness and therefore, the accused cannot deny the loan amount at this stage. Further, it is pointed out the accused herself has admitted her signature upon the cheques in question and there exists presumption of existence of legal liability in favour of complainant which accused has failed to rebut. Ld. Counsel for complainant has further argued that the legal notice has been correctly addressed and sent through post therefore presumed to be served upon accused. 13. Per contra, Ld. Counsel for accused has argued that no offence under section 138 NI act is made out against accused. It is argued that two cheques were given as blank security -- 6 of 14 -- CC No. 3437-2023 Page No. 7 of14 cheques against loan of Rs. 50,000/- taken by accused which has been returned by accused through encashment of cheque issued by accused. It is argued that complainant made fraudulent agreement of Rs. 1,50,000/- taking advantage of illiteracy of complainant and her husband and also forged the signature of her son Pradeep. It is argued that complainant has failed to explain why the cash amount of Rs. 1,00,000/- was given separately to accused when Rs. 50,000/- was given by cheque. Further, the source of cash loan has not been explained and complainant could not have taken loan to in turn give loan to accused. It is further argued that the receipt of amount of Rs. 60,000/- has been admitted by complainant and he has falsely claimed the said money pertaining to other loan transaction however detail of such loan transaction has not been revealed since no such separate transaction existed between the parties. It is argued that the security cheques of accused have been misused which is apparent from the fact that the accused herself issued the instruction for stop payment due to which cheques were dishonoured as accused apprehended misuse of her cheques. LEGAL PROVISION 14. Before adverting to scanning the evidence under the lens of the law pertaining to the lis at hand, let us revisit the legal benchmark to be satisfied as enunciated in Section 138 of the Act. Dishonour of Cheque for insufficiency, etc. of funds in the account: Where any cheque drawn by a person on an account maintained by him with a banker for payment of any amount of money to another person from out of that account for the discharge, in whole or in part, of any debt or other liability, is returned by the bank unpaid, either because of the amount of money standing to the credit of that account is insufficient to honour the cheque or that it exceeds the amount arranged to be paid from that account by an agreement made with that bank, such person shall be deemed to have committed an offence and shall, without prejudice to any other provision of this Act, be punished with imprisonment for a term which may extend to two years, or with fine which may extend to twice -- 7 of 14 -- CC No. 3437-2023 Page No. 8 of14 the amount of the cheque, or with both. Provided that nothing contained in this section shall apply unless— (a) the cheque has been presented to the bank within a period of six months from the date on which it is drawn or within the period of its validity, whichever is earlier; (b) the payee or the holder in due course of the cheque, as the case may be, makes a demand for the payment of the said amount of money by giving a notice in writing, to the drawer of the cheque, [within thirty days] of the receipt of information by him from the bank regarding the return of the cheque as unpaid; and (c) the drawer of such cheque fails to make the payment of the said amount of money to the payee or as the case may be, to the holder in due course of the cheque within fifteen days of the receipt of the said notice. Explanation.—For the purposes of this section, “debt or other liability” means a legally enforceable debt or other liability. ANALYSIS 15. The essential ingredients that can be culled out from the statutory provision are: i) Person must have drawn a cheque on an account maintained by him in a bank for payment of a certain amount of money to another person from out of that account; ii) The cheque should have been issued for the discharge, in whole or in part, of any debt or other liability; iii) That cheque has been presented to the bank within a period of six months from the date on which it is drawn or within the period of its validity whichever is earlier; iv) That cheque is returned by the bank unpaid, either because of the amount of money standing to the credit of the account is insufficient to honour the cheque or that it exceeds the amount arranged to be paid from that account by an agreement made with the bank; v) The payee or the holder in due course of the cheque makes a demand for the payment of the said amount of money by giving a notice in writing, to the drawer of the cheque, within 30 days of the receipt of information by him from the bank regarding the return of the cheque as unpaid; vi) The drawer of such cheque fails to make payment of the said amount of money to the payee or the holder in due course of the cheque within 15 days of the receipt of the said notice. -- 8 of 14 -- CC No. 3437-2023 Page No. 9 of14 16. Being cumulative, it goes without saying that it is only when all the aforementioned ingredients are satisfied, the person who had drawn the cheque can be deemed to have committed an offence under Section 138 of the Act. 17. In the present case, accused has admitted her signature on cheques therefore the issuance of cheque has been established during trial. The complainant has averred that the said cheque was dishonored due to remarks ‘payment stopped by drawer’. Accused herself admitted the issuance of instruction for stop payment of cheque due to which cheques were dishonored. Presentation and dishonor of cheques is also depicted by cheque return memos which states the reason for dishonor ‘payment stopped by drawer’. The testimony of complainant regarding presentation and dishonour of cheques as remained unrebutted and accused has not led any evidence to dispute the presentation and dishonor of cheques in question. Therefore, presentation and dishonour of cheques is also established during trial. 18. Accused has disputed the receipt of legal demand notice. The accused has admitted that the address on legal demand notice is her correct address. The complainant has averred that legal demand notice was sent through post and the same is also reflected from the postal receipts. Although the complainant has also relied upon the tracking report the same is not accompanied buy the necessary certificate for electronic evidence and therefore the same cannot be relied upon by the court. However, even in absence of delivery report there exists presumption of due service of notice sent through post on the correct address of accused. Accused has not led any evidence to prove otherwise. Therefore, the service of legal demand notice is established by complainant. 19. Accused has also disputed her liability to pay the amount of cheques in question. The existence of legal liability for payment of amount of cheques in question is one of the -- 9 of 14 -- CC No. 3437-2023 Page No. 10 of14 necessary ingredients that has to be established by the complainant. In order to correctly appreciate this ingredient in the light of the evidence placed on record by both the parties, it is necessary to revisit the provision under Section 118 and Section 139 of the Act. 20. Section 118 of the Act inter alia provides the presumptions as to negotiable instruments that until the contrary is proved, the the presumptions shall be made that every negotiable instrument was made or drawn for consideration, and that every such instrument, when it has been accepted, endorsed, negotiated or transferred was accepted, endorsed, negotiated or transferred for consideration. Further, section 139 of the Act provides that it shall be presumed, unless the contrary is proved, that the holder of a cheque received the cheque of the nature referred to in Section 138 for the discharge, in whole or in part, of any debt or other liability. 21. It is clear from the conjoint reading of both the provisions that ordinarily in the cheque dishonour cases, what the courts ought to consider is whether the ingredients of the offence enumerated in Section 138 of the Act have been met and if so, whether the accused was able to rebut the statutory presumption contemplated by Section 139 of the Act. 22. Further, the standard of proof required to rebut the presumption raised under S.118 and 139 of the Act is only that of ‘preponderance of probabilities’ and therefore, the accused is required to prove only a probable defence of non-existence of liability and is not required to establish the same beyond reasonable doubt. The accused has to do so by either adducing his own evidence or by punching holes in the case of the complainant. 23. The case of the complainant is that the cheques in question were issued for repayment of friendly loan amount of Rs. 1,50,000/- taken by the accused. Out of the said amount of Rs. 1,50,000/-, there is no dispute regarding the amount of Rs. 50,000/- given -- 10 of 14 -- CC No. 3437-2023 Page No. 11 of14 by cheque. However, the accused has disputed the amount of Rs. 1,00,000/- allegedly given in cash to her by complainant. As far as the cash component of loan is concerned, the entire complaint and the testimony of complainant is bereft of any particular detail regarding the date, time or place when the said amount was given. No independent witness in whose presence the said cash amount was given has been examined. Even the loan agreement relied by complainant is silent about the details of the cash loan transaction. During cross examination, when questioned regarding the source of cash loan, the complainant CW1 has deposed that Rs. 50,000/- was lying with him in cash and he borrowed Rs. 30,000/- from his friend Ajay and another Rs. 20,000/- from his friend Sanjeev. The said persons have not been examined during trial to affirm the transaction. Further, the complainant had monthly income of Rs. 12,000/- to 15,000/- and his monthly income does not seem sufficient to enable him to have cash savings of Rs. 50,000/- readiy available with him to be granted as loan. The complainant does not appear to have financial capacity to grant cash loan of Rs. 1,00,000/- claimed by him. It is pertinent to note that the complainant has claimed to have not charged any interest on loan amount which is stated to have been given as friendly loan. Clearly, complainant did not have any financial incentive to grant loan to accused which was beyond his capacity. Further, no prudent person would himself take loan to be given to another person that too out of goodness of his heart without charging any interest on loan amount. 24. Complainant has relied upon the loan agreement EX CW1/8 to assert the loan amount of Rs. 1,50,000/- given to accused. Clause 1 of the loan agreement Ex CW1/8 states that amount of Rs. 1,00,000 was given in cash and Rs. 50,000/- by way of cheque to accused as borrower by complainant being the lender. The said agreement does not contain any detail regarding the date, time or place where the said cash loan transaction took place. It also does not contain detail of any witnesses in whose presence the said loan transaction took place. The accused has averred as DW1 that the said loan agreement fraudulently -- 11 of 14 -- CC No. 3437-2023 Page No. 12 of14 mentioned Rs. 1,50,000/- when she was led into believing that agreement pertains to the amount of Rs. 50,000/- given as loan to her. During cross examination of DW-1, no question on amount of Rs. 1,50,000/- has been asked and accused has reiterated that loan amount was Rs. 50,000/-(and not Rs. 60,000). It is pertinent to note that the witness has denied her signature on evidence affidavit however the said denial appears to have stemmed from the lack of understanding on her part since the specific signature of witness was not confronted with at the time of her testimony and she herself has relied upon the evidence affidavit in her testimony as DW1. This further points out to her lack of understanding of loan agreement Ex CW1/8 and the possibility of her being lured into signing the same without understanding the contents of the same. 25. The complainant has further averred that the loan agreement Ex CW1/8 was signed by the son of accused namely Pradeep as a witness. Pradeep has been examined as DW2 and he has categorically deposed that he has not signed the agreement Ex CW1/8 and that his signature have been forged. A closer look upon the agreement Ex Cw1/8 would reveal that the details of the said witness containing his name, fathers name and address has been mentioned in the column of witness but the signature appears to be missing and the name mentioned does not appear to be a signature of the said Pradeep. Nevertheless, Pradeep has denied signing the said agreement in toto and has claimed that the said agreement was not made or executed in his presence. He has not been cross examined despite opportunity and therefore his testimony has remained unrebutted and it has been established that the said agreement was not witnessed by Pradeep or executed in his presence. No other witness to the said agreement has been mentioned or cited in the case. Therefore, the due execution of loan agreement Ex CW1/8 also appear to be doubtful. 26. It is further pertinent to note that the accused has claimed return of loan amount of Rs. 50,000/- taken by her through cheque which is allegedly encashed on 21.03.2020. -- 12 of 14 -- CC No. 3437-2023 Page No. 13 of14 During cross examination, CW1 has admitted the receipt of said amount however has maintained that the said amount pertained to another cash loan transaction of Rs. 60,000 given by him on 13.03.2020 and returned on 19.03.2020 which was a separate transaction. The said separate loan transaction has not been mentioned anywhere in complaint or affidavit. It is difficult to believe that before the return of prior loan amount taken six months back, the complainant would grant further loan and that amount would be returned within six days by accused when the prior loan amount is not cleared even after passage of six months! 27. The purpose of grant of loan as enumerated in complaint is to meet the expenses of marriage of the daughter of accused. Accused as DW1 in her affidavit has averred that her daughter is unmarried and stays with her. Accused has clarified that she took amount of Rs. 50,000/- for renovation of her house. The accused has not been cross examined on the aspect of purpose of loan and her testimony has remained unrebutted. Therefore, the purpose of grant of loan as enumerated by complainant also does not appear to be believable considering the testimony of accused as DW1 . 28. The accused has taken the defence that she gave two cheques in question at the time of taking loan of Rs. 50,000/- taken by her from complainant and that she already repaid the said amount. The amount of Rs. 50,000/- is evidenced by the cheque of the said amount admittedly given to accused. Further, the complainant has admitted receiving the amount from accused in march 2020. Although, complainant has stated that Rs. 60,000/- was received by him it is not clear whether the said amount included the interest on loan amount. Nevertheless, the principal amount of Rs. 50,000/- appears to have been repaid at least by accused. The cheques were dishonoured due to the reason ‘payment stopped by drawer’ which gives credence to the defence of accused that cheques were misused therefore the instruction for stop payment was given by him. Considering the above facts -- 13 of 14 -- CC No. 3437-2023 Page No. 14 of14 and circumstances and the testimony of defence witnesses as well as cross examination of CW1, the defence of accused does seem probable. CONCLUSION 29. From the above discussion, it can be concluded that the complainant has failed to prove the necessary ingredient of existence of legal liability in discharge of which the cheques in question were purportedly issued by the accused. Consequently, this court finds the accused Kiran not guilty of the offence under Section 138, Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 and acquits her accordingly. Announced in open court on 04.07.2025 (Shivangi Vyas) JMFC NI Act(DC-01), NDD, Patiala House Courts, Delhi -- 14 of 14 --
