Skip to main content
Court Order

Order 1

CNR DLND01010683202323 Dec 2023
Back to Case

Full Order Text

Order 1 · 23 Dec 2023 · CNR DLND010106832023

Order Details: COPY OF ORDER
Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SUMIT DASS : ADJ - 02 & WAKF
TRIBUNAL: PATIALA HOUSE COURTS : NEW DELHI
Arbtn. No.1468/2023
M/s. Mufin Green Finance
Ltd.
Having its office at:-
202, 2nd Floor, Best Sky Tower,
Netaji Subash Place, Pitampura,
New Delhi 110034.
......Petitioner
VERSUS
Dipak Nishad
S/o Sh. Raj Kumar
R/o 137/160, Purabaldi Kyd Ganj,
Allahabad, Uttar Pradesh 211003
….. Respondent
23.12.2023
Petition under Section 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 be
checked and registered.
Present: Mr. N. K. Chaudhary, Counsel for the petitioner.
Arguments on the petition heard.
O R D E R
1. The petitioner has approached this court under Section 9 of the Arbitration
and Conciliation Act, 1996 for interim relief till the arbitration proceedings are
initiated. The petitioner has prayed for ad interim ex-parte appointment of
Page No. 1/5
-- 1 of 5 --
receiver for re-possessing of a vehicle make E-Ricksha, bearing Registration
no. UP70LT0589, Engine no.51363 & Chassis no.51363.
2. I have perused the record.
3. The petitioner is stated to be engaged in the business of finance, loans, hire
purchase etc. It has been stated that petitioner granted a loan in the sum of
Rs.1,38,874/- to the respondent vide a loan cum hypothecation agreement
dated 21.09.2022 for purchase of the above mentioned vehicle. According to
the terms and conditions of the agreement, the respondent was bound to timely
repay the loan by way of EMIs. However, the respondent is stated to have
failed to make the payments as per the agreed schedule and has committed
repeated defaults. The respondent has defaulted in payment of 08 EMIs. The
petitioner was thus constrained to terminate/recall the loan facility vide legal
notice dated 27.11.2023. The respondent did not respond even to the said
notice.
4. The terms and conditions of the agreement require that any dispute arising
out of or in connection with the said agreement shall be referred to and resolved
by Arbitration. The respondent having failed to comply with the terms and
conditions of the agreement and also having failed to respond or comply with
the legal notice, the petitioner is now in the process of initiating Arbitration
proceedings. I have perused the loan cum hypothecation agreement dated
21.09.2022, particularly Article nos.10.14 & 10.15 which bear the
signatures of the parties, as well as para no. 17 & 18 of the petition.
5. Though, the dispute shall be resolved through arbitration, the petitioner has
reasons to believe that the respondent shall malafidely dispose of/sell/transfer
the said vehicle. The petitioner seeks to protect its interest in the vehicle and the
amounts due from the respondent as the vehicle in question is a security with
the petitioner for the amount advanced to the respondent. The petitioner seeks
Page No. 2/5
-- 2 of 5 --
to secure its claim by preventing the respondent from selling the vehicle with a
view to frustrate their claim. The petitioner has submitted that in case, the
interim protection is not granted, the purpose of the Arbitration would be
infructuous.
6. The petitioner has made out a prima facie case for repossession of the
Hypothecated Vehicle. The balance of convenience also lies in the favour of the
petitioner as a substantial loan amount still stands unpaid and the respondent is
using the vehicle. I find force in the submissions of the counsel for the
petitioner that the petitioner would suffer irreparable loss in case, the
respondent dispossess of the hypothecated vehicle.
7. The petitioner has prayed that its representative may be appointed as a
receiver as it would be convenient to cordinate the repossession of the vehicle. I
find no impediment in allowing the said request. Thus, Mr. Vinod Kumar
Tiwari, is hereby appointed receiver with authorization to seize the
hypothecated vehicle E-Ricksha, bearing Registration no. UP70LT0589,
Engine no.51363 & Chassis no.51363 by removing the same from the
possession and custody of respondent or any third person found to be in
possession of the said vehicle, in accordance with law. If required, police aid
may be taken by the receiver. Since the receiver appointed to repossess the
vehicle is a representative of the petitioner company, the petitioner company
shall remunerate the receiver as it deems fit. Further, for the same reason, both
the receiver and the petitioners company shall act as Custodian Legis and shall
keep the vehicle post repossession in safe custody and shall be liable to the
court for the same. The order is subject to following conditions :
(a) The receiver shall remain personally present at the time of seizing the vehicle.
(b) The person from whose custody the vehicle is repossessed shall be permitted to
take his belongings from the vehicle.
Page No. 3/5
-- 3 of 5 --
(c) The receiver shall give a receipt of seizing the vehicle with exact date and an
inventory of the articles found from the vehicle to the respondent or such other
person from whose custody the vehicle is taken. A copy thereof shall be filed
before Ld. Arbitrator if appointed by that time or in alternative before this Court
alongwith the receiver's report of taking possession.
(d) The receiver shall also note the condition of the vehicle in the said receipt.
Preferably, photographs pertaining to the condition of the vehicle shall be taken
and given to the respondent or such other person from whose custody the vehicle is
taken.
(e) The petitioner shall not dispose of the said vehicle without the written
permission of Ld. Arbitrator.
(f) The petitioner shall not sell dismantle or create encumbrance on the vehicle and
shall maintain the vehicle in the same condition as it is when seized, so far as
practically possible. The petitioner shall be held liable for any kind of loss
occurring to the vehicle due to their willful default or gross negligence.
(g) In case the respondent pays up to date dues to the satisfaction of the petitioner
within four weeks of the repossession of the vehicle by the receiver, the vehicle
shall not be alienated and shall be handed back to the respondent upon such
payment.
(h) In case the vehicle is not repossessed within a period of 60 days from the date
of this order, the present order shall cease to be in operation, since the present
proceedings are only interim measures with the dispute being required to be
resolved by the Arbitrator.
(i) Arbitral proceedings shall commence within 90 days of this order in term of
amended Section 9 (2) of Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. For all further
reliefs petitioner would be at liberty to approach Ld. Arbitrator u/Sec 17 of the Act.
Page No. 4/5
-- 4 of 5 --
8. Upon failure of the receiver and/or the petitioner to comply with the above
stated conditions, the order of appointment of the receiver shall cease to be in force
and the vehicle shall be released on terms and conditions deemed fit by Ld.
Arbitrator. The receiver shall submit his report with regard to the repossession
within a week of the said repossession.
9. Notice of the petition be issued against the respondent on filing of PF/RC
returnable on 27.07.2024. Ahlmad is directed to issue copy of the order after
receiving the PF and RC.
(SUMIT DASS)
ADJ–02/WAKF TRIBUNAL/
PHC/NEW DELHI
23.12.2023
Page No. 5/5
-- 5 of 5 --

TrustJury presents public court-record information for legal discovery and reference. Record availability and detail can vary by source and case.